Re: Another question
TomD
I think it is like everything else, brands win out. At at some point even stuff that isn't really a brand can achieve that status. O1 has also become popular in a range of fields, for backyard toolmaking, and knifemaking, and also among the pro makers. So you can run into it over and over, and it tends to add to it's acceptability.
While O1 is not so likely to turn up free, it is relatively cheaply available in just about any metal store. It comes clean, accurate like feeler stock, in just about any practical thickness or width. It makes a nice knife or tool, and while no metal has all the advantages, it is second to none in a community of advantages. There is a huge amount of info available on how to use it, which certainly helps those who are new to heat treating.
So you can like it or not, but it is never second rate. I think it is fair to say it is an easy steel to work with, but in many professional cutting fields, that actually wins out over other characteristics, even among ultimate pros. You have to have a degree of edge holding that is exponentially better than lesser steels, just to come out ahead. Then you have to consider the tools required to sharpen, their availability in all venues, whether it is a good deal to face these edges when routine damage occurs, whatever. There are actually a range of tools that require constant sharpening, and edge thinning, where ultimate edge holding is not the key. So O1 may not be the best but it has a little something for everyone, and has become well known.
In woodworking we have probably Ron Hock to thank as much as anyone, since he pushed O1 out there as a superior replacement steel, and stuck with it when other pretenders showed up. More recently LV has been staunch.
I remember reading about the pleasures of W1 steel back a while, like the 80s, I think even some comparisons saying it was like white steel. In the knife biz it is still popular because one thing O1 does not do is show a hamon very well. W1 is not terribly easy to get, and does not tend to come clean. I sometime call O1 "brown paper steel", because it comes neatly wrapped in a rust proof paper, with instructions, and with the contents dimensional and ready to go, just like the white a blue paper steels. 