New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

New Steel from Lee Valley

Posts

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#51

Re: game changer?

Rob Lee

Tom -

Excellent post!

Will I personally change from O1? No, not likely. O1 for me is a preference - it's something I'm used to, comfortable with, and have confidence using - and maintaining. Yes - I'll buy some of the tools with the PM steel - but I'll still use my Berg's, my Mifers, and the other odd chisels I have around.

Personal preference when it comes to hand tools is unassailable. All a manufacturer can do is offer choice, and rationale... the consumer ultimately has to make the decision. And it can only be a correct decision for themself.

I really believe that the constant desire to designate a "best" or an "ultimate" in any design or tool is counterproductive, and limiting. In fact - a spectrum of high quality choices is enabling for beginning woodworkers and experts alike.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#52

Do you regularly make dovetails for furniture?

Bill Tindall

If not, you may not have experienced the fundamental difference in wear that a chisel chopping across grain experiences vs a hand plane which is essentially splitting apart wood fibers. Because we made the tools I have both plane irons and chisels made with steel of identical properties. Used as a plane iron this metal goes away/disappears/abrades as a result of wood rubbing on the back and wood chips sliding up the bevel. I have never observed a plane iron edge that was chipped or deformed from my typical planing domestic hardwoods.

On the other hand I have never seen this metal abrade away at a chisel edge. The failure is always deformation of the frail edge, I suppose because the loading on this edge is greater when it is being tapped with a mallet cross grain. (this type of failure suggests we could have heat treated this steel to a greater hardness than what we specified, a presumption confirmed by others making chisels from this steel) Steels with less toughness, for example the one hard M2 chisel I made, micro chipped at the edge and I never saw deformation. I have numerous micro-photographs to support these conclusions which I have, and would be willing, to share.

I think I prefer a deformation failure to micro-chipping. An edge modestly dulled by this mode can often be straightened, and hence rendered sharp for penetration, by simply rubbing on a hard ARK stone, a sharpening device I once considered useless. (I have a flat piece of ceramic under evaluation that may prove superior.)

All these data lead to the straightforward conclusion that there could be a game changing steel lurking out there for chisels used for chopping dovetails and mortises. I can predict its attributes. Wear resistance will be of marginal importance. It will have exceptional toughness(to resist chipping) at high hardness(stiffness). As a result its edge will hold up at smaller bevel angles that aid ease of penetration.

When someone decided to make lathe tools from M2 the improvement was so obvious that they captured the market in short order, to be followed by even higher performance lathe tool steels such as M4. I think the key was that M2 tools were cheap enough that many people were willing to give them a try and the improvement was sufficiently great that most that tried saw a favorable result. There is an opportunity to repeat this result with chisels.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#53

Balance Point

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Is there a rationale for having the balance point at the ferrule? When we use a chisel it gets shorter and the balance point changes considerably. I have three chisels that I put longer handles on when I wore them down to the point that they were no longer optimum length. And if a narrow chisel needs a short handle or a thick blade just to balance right, or if a wide chisel needs a fat handle, it seems as if these are poor trade offs.

I checked my carving tools. Predictably the wide tools balanced at or near the ferrule, the narrow tools back on the handle. We have tools that are 1/8 wide or so. We can't worry about balance on tools like this.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#54

Re: I am anxious to learn.....

david weaver

Well, I'll make a small wave. I've not seen a lot of plane iron type wear on any of my chisels, it's always deformation/chipping right at the edge that sends me back to the stones.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#55

Rob....about that cover....

roger lance

This morning, I was sitting in the local Panera"s enjoying my morning coffee and reading your recent catalog supplement when I began to notice that people at other tables were looking at me with suspicion and a little fear in some cases....then, I realized that it was the cover with the knives on it that was giving people pause....so I announced that it was only a tool catalog (and hopefully they would not think me to be a psycho)....just a little feedback for your art department.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#56

Re: Rob....about that cover....

david weaver

Par for the course at panera, though, I'd think.

next time, take an issue of shooting times and see if you get different looks.

And then after that, maybe one of those steroid magazines with barely human looking scantily clad folks on the cover.

Most folks who frequent paneras could probably use a little jolt, anyway. (no WC members would qualify for that stereotype, of course) :b

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#57

Re: I am anxious to learn.....

Rob Lee

Hi Bill -

We saw both deformation and chipping as the primary causes of dulling of chisels. Of the two - chipping is "preferable"...

For plane blades, it was primarily abrasive wear... though blades could also deform and chip..

To be substantiated at a later date ....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#58

Thanks

Bill Tindall

One does not know their research is valid till it is independently confirmed.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#59

Re: Thanks

Rob Lee

Hi Bill -

I guess that's where we differ a bit (in a good way, I mean).

You see - we do research to guide our internal development, and to support decisions. We really have no interest in publishing the majority of what we do, or "defending" our conclusions...our goal is to satisfy ourselves that we're doing the right things.

From a business perspective - the R&D is viewed as an asset for us - and we need to get a return on it. It's a rather large expense that manufacturers who just copy products don't have. Keeping some results and conclusions to ourselves means that a corporate asset doesn't turn into competitive liability.

I understand the public policy benefits of shared research - which is why a lot of research is publicly funded. There is also support for the types of research that we do, as it creates domestic employment when tied to domestic manufacture. That increase in employment however, does not materialize when the fruit of the effort goes offshore...

Just another perspective... and a bit of insight as to why we do/don't participate in some discussions....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#60

Re: Thanks

Pam Niedermayer

It still astounds me how cheaply most of our North American executives have sold off our technology, as in given away. I hold them in deep disdain.

Pam

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#61

Re: Do you regularly make dt - not buying it

TomD

Sure, been cutting dovetails with chisels since the 70s. Keep in mind that planes do cut across grains when hitting knots, working endgrain, working at diagonals to prep boards, working up and down a run of grain, an extreme case being something like planing tiger stripe.

The rule with DTs is that one has to cut the full width of the board to make a set. Each dovetail set is like a single crosscut. In prep for that single cut, a person might shoot the end to make it square. This would require repeated plane cuts across the endgrain as one approaches square. So each shooting would involve many times more crosscuts than each set of DTs cut.

Also, production oriented folks often use some methods to saw or pre-saw the endgrain. So imagine you use a fretsaw to remove all but the last mm of endgrain. You are now making a single pass, paring with the chisels. This is no more than a single pass with a plane wood be. The edge is aligned, unlike the plane that scrapes. The plane in the shooting phase would be doing a lot more work.

I don't think you have thought this through.

I think a big factor with lathe tools is that they are dry ground and sometimes not even sharpened beyond that point. I frankly can't tell the difference in sharpening the carbon tools vs. the HSS, speed of sharpening wise. In fact it might even feel better since the HSS seems to be less prone to clogging my wheels. I can get a shinning surface on wood direct off the tools with a dry coarse grind only. And as you say edge wear is vastly improved. Carbon tools are not great for lathe work. I rejected them pretty nearly day one, the only real exception in my kit being skews where a few of my favorites are carbon, but it isn't that they wouldn't be better if they were HSS they just felt right, and I put up with the fact they wear a little faster.

Metal lathe work makes even better use of hard tools, even carbide.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#62

Re: game changer?

TomD

I'm glad I didn't offend. I feel a major role of "marketing" is to not only trigger a buy, but to allow the purchaser to have long term confidence and pleasure in the product bought. Sometimes commentators criticize larger market participants for spending more money on marketing than smaller players. But not everyone is able to make purchases from first principles. In their hay days, companies like Callaway in Golf, whatever the technical merits, allowed players to have confidence that they hadn't at the very least made a tragic mistake in brand, and could just relax and enjoy their play.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#63

Re: game changer?

Rob Lee

Of course.... what I say about O1 doesn't hold for you folks down under....

Your tough abrasive woods *require* a PM steel....

:D :D

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#64

Like Merle Haggard....I'm basically an

roger lance

Okie from Muskogee and will not be showing some magazine with briefly clad steroid induced humanoids on the cover to the other customers at Panera's......not that there is anything wrong with it.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#65

You`re not alone Pam

Bob Hackett

They not only sold off the technology and exported the jobs they also many times sold off the machinery and tooling needed to produce the products as "scrap" and by the pound only to have that "scrap" show up as working machinery in the plants producing product for them. The sale and export of many of the larger machines we used to establish the US as a major manufacturing leader, things like huge steam hammers, large presses, rollers and mills is what allowed China and India, as well as other countries to gear up and take over the production of most of what used to be made in America with such speed.

The blatant piracy of products that others had to spend years developing and perfecting is one thing. Supplying the machinery and tooling directly to those same pirates at the price of scrap is something else entirely.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#66

Re: You`re not alone Pam

Pam Niedermayer

I'm sure a lot of it was sold as scrap to avoid export restrictions. These men knew who was buying it and why, probably they also encouraged it. And all for a few million more a year.

This is a riff on the privatize-the-profits, socialize-the-losses mode of behavior. It's been said that they have a lot more in common with the gun slingers of old than with any of us.

Pam

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#67

Reminds me of seeing Schwartz break old planes


Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#68

Another question

Patrick Gibbons

I always understood water-hardening steels to be the first choice for chisels over oil-hardening. This was, of course, before A2, etc. Besides ease of production, water-hardening steels can warp more than oil-hardening during hardening/tempering and thus require more grinding, why have more manufacturers gone to O1 rather than W1 for chisel manufacture?

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#69

Re: Another question

TomD

I think it is like everything else, brands win out. At at some point even stuff that isn't really a brand can achieve that status. O1 has also become popular in a range of fields, for backyard toolmaking, and knifemaking, and also among the pro makers. So you can run into it over and over, and it tends to add to it's acceptability.

While O1 is not so likely to turn up free, it is relatively cheaply available in just about any metal store. It comes clean, accurate like feeler stock, in just about any practical thickness or width. It makes a nice knife or tool, and while no metal has all the advantages, it is second to none in a community of advantages. There is a huge amount of info available on how to use it, which certainly helps those who are new to heat treating.

So you can like it or not, but it is never second rate. I think it is fair to say it is an easy steel to work with, but in many professional cutting fields, that actually wins out over other characteristics, even among ultimate pros. You have to have a degree of edge holding that is exponentially better than lesser steels, just to come out ahead. Then you have to consider the tools required to sharpen, their availability in all venues, whether it is a good deal to face these edges when routine damage occurs, whatever. There are actually a range of tools that require constant sharpening, and edge thinning, where ultimate edge holding is not the key. So O1 may not be the best but it has a little something for everyone, and has become well known.

In woodworking we have probably Ron Hock to thank as much as anyone, since he pushed O1 out there as a superior replacement steel, and stuck with it when other pretenders showed up. More recently LV has been staunch.

I remember reading about the pleasures of W1 steel back a while, like the 80s, I think even some comparisons saying it was like white steel. In the knife biz it is still popular because one thing O1 does not do is show a hamon very well. W1 is not terribly easy to get, and does not tend to come clean. I sometime call O1 "brown paper steel", because it comes neatly wrapped in a rust proof paper, with instructions, and with the contents dimensional and ready to go, just like the white a blue paper steels. :)

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#70

Re: Another answer

TomD

W1 is basically a fairly simple carbon steel, and performs as do others. The O1 can be water hardened no problem in correct sections. These recommendations about quenching are mainly for the benefit of industry, relative to conventional projects and conventional approaches. For instance laminated steels can take faster quenches like water and brine due to the iron reserve. O1 is prized for it's dimensional properties, for gauge block, dies, etc... So they recommend it be hardened in a fashion that would retain the dimensions it is delivered with. Just so happens guy like it too, because they can make a knife and apply the handle scales to the dimensional section with great ease, or get it to snug up to a plane ramp. So we are tweaking it, and one should not expect the best/only results to come from what is suggested by those who have a different application in mind.