New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

New Steel from Lee Valley

Posts

New Steel from Lee Valley

#1

New Steel from Lee Valley

Bill Tindall

The editorial from Mr. Lee in the January catalog supplement discusses a new line of edged tools to be fabricated from a high performance steel, which is both tougher and more wear resistant than current woodworking tool steels. The advantages of diamond abrasives are also discussed. Data on the performance of this steel is promised in future supplements.

One thing puzzled me about the information provided. The new tools are expected to be tougher and more wear resistant, yet sharpen as easily as A2. It is not clear how one can have a more wear resistant tool that abrades(sharpens) easily, unless the researchers at LV have discovered that the wear experienced by plane irons and chisels is not primarily abrasive wear. I believe this is indeed the case with chisels, hence the quest for a tougher chisel steel, but I would find it an unexpected result for plane irons.

It was reported to me that a corrosion resistant coating on high speed cutters for wood increases edge life. Could the same be true for a plane iron?

It will be exciting to see how the fruits of modern research into steel for woodworking tools develops in the market place. More exciting still to see data from this research.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#2

I will be watching this thread closely..

david weaver

...to see who changes their opinion once the smoke clears :b

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#3

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

James Watriss

I'm not a metallurgist. But I can say from experience that M2 and M4 sharpen MUCH more easily than D2, which it pretty tough stuff, but a bear to sharpen.

I was surprised at how much easier, too, given how well HSS holds up.

So, I'll be interested to hear how this works our, but I don't think it's going to be a game changer for me.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#4

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I have not seen the January Supplement, but Rob has mentioned the new PM steel on several forums in recent months. Indeed, I have been testing a plane blade made of this steel for some while. All I can say at this time is that Rob's comments that the blade sharpens as easily as A2, yet lasts twice as long, is absolutely true! My ow results demonstrate this time and again. Remarkable. Interesting times ahead.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#5

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

TomD

I can think of at least two reasons that this could be the case Bill, not sure they are correct in general or this case.

1) Better fit to abrassive. You can simply have a better fit to the abrassive, or process any time you are looking at sharpening and steels, it takes two to get the job done.

2) One thing one finds a lot with stainless is that some of the steels are just nasty to sharpen. The tool part of the steel is one thing. Other stuff gets thrown in there that has nothing to do with that, or has to do with what happens when turning steel or something. And the component is almost like an impurity in the metal, relative to what one wants it to do. D2 is a little like that, and also somewhat stain resistant.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#6

game changer?

Bill Tindall

I only use a plane for fitting and as a result I rarely, if ever, dull a plane during one planing session. I expect this situation is more typical than not. I just don't remember when I last sharpened any of my planes. In this environment it will be difficult to detect differences in edge retention for a plane iron.

Chisels used for chopping, dovetails for example, are another case. I usually need to touch up an edge during a dovetailing session. I think I could detect even a modest improvement in edge retention and would pay more for this improvement. On the other hand, the shape of a chisel is so personal that shape could easily trump steel.

By my observation chisels dull either by micro deformations or micro chipping at the cutting edge and not abrasive wear. This dulling would be improved by a tougher harder steel. A more sturdy edge would mean the chisel could be sharpened at at steeper angle for improved penetration.

In the case where someone would be buying their first chisel, for example, a new steel would be an easier sell if the sales was backed by data, which it appears this steel will be. A2 was a game changer in this market. Many new sales were captured by this steel even though it was not such an improvement that it rendered traditional steels obsolete. (It would not be hard to beat A2 for a chisel steel.)

In any case, I expect the marketing muscle of Lee Valley to set off an investigation of steel by other companies, large and small. In this sense this steel will be a game changer.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#7

How come we got left out?

Bill Tindall

"Rob has mentioned the new PM steel on several forum"

Is there a forum where steels has been discussed more than on this one?

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#8

Re: game changer?

david weaver

I can think of only two chisels that are made of A2 steel - LN and blue spruce. I don't know why blue spruce used A2, but I wouldn't consider it an improvement for chisels. The best steel for chisels for general use, as far as I can tell from all of mine, is plain carbon steel.

LN eventually released O1 chisels, so it's not like their A2 chisels were solve-all chisels.

A2 is an improvement in plane irons if you're dimensioning lumber and you want the edge to last as long as possible, maybe with the exception of smoothing (though a good A2 iron should make a surface just the same and not release carbides and create tiny lines all over everything - all of them aren't that good, but some are very good).

It's probably an improvement in mortise chisels, too, especially for people who might be hard on their mortise chisesl.

As far as HSS goes, if someone over here would carry the entire line of mujingfang planes, I'd have access to all of the HSS I'd ever want.

For chisels, though, it's just not that hard to get a chisel to the stones and back. 30 seconds maximum 3 out of 4 times, and maybe a minute total the 1 of 4 times that you need to grind the chisel.

I am, curious, though, to see if the powdered steels will hold up well around 30 degrees or so in a plane iron, and not release any parts of their edge, consequently fouling up the work.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#9

Re: game changer?

James Watriss

I think you and I may be exactly backwards on this one Bill.

I have some planes that are ridiculous meticulous, and some that are beaten down workhorses. I sharpen those planes more often, in part because some of the surfaces that I have to use them for are inglorious and pretty brutal, ie glue spots, or plywood, etc. I like A2 because it stays sharp enough to put up with some pretty indignant stuff. It's not a fine edge, but it's durable. Other planes are a mix of HC/ W1 and exotics. (D2, M2, S53)

Chopping performance for chisels? Use a bigger hammer. Yes, chisels dull faster when you chop with them. Grind to a higher bevel, worry less about edge performance, and get what you need from them, whether they're willing or not. The only stroke that matters is the last one. (shoulder) Keep a clean paring chisel for that. Waste removal is simple brutality, and as long as you color within the lines, it's good enough.

In three years of woodworking retail, I only ever recommended one brand of chisel to newcomers: Marples (Irwin) blue chip. Most new guys don't know how to sharpen, and it's a critical skill. So I recommend something that they'll have to sharpen regularly, so they get regular practice: You can buy new tools, you can't buy skill. After years of sharpening Irwin, and then Pfeil, I moved onto something better. But I know how to sharpen very well now.

Thinking about the Marples, I think there's a balance that needs to be struck between sharpens easily and stays that way, that the new steels haven't hit yet. They stay sharp, but it's not typically easy to get them that way. If the new steel is easier to sharpen, as Derek says, then I think it might be suitable to learn with. If they're only easy to sharpen with fancy/expensive stuff, then never mind. With the Marples, it takes half a minute to resharpen a tool made of what is rapidly being viewed as 'substandard' steel, but they still take an edge well enough to do good work. In some cases, a few strokes on a strop was all it took to maintain and bring them back. In the grand scheme, that's pretty time efficient. I knew a lot of guys at NBSS that used the Marples/Irwin for the full 2 years. Their work was immaculate.

I also knew guys who used Lie-Nielsen the whole time, and couldn't sharpen worth a damn, because they didn't do it very often.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#10

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

Chuck Kettler

Did they provide the assay of this new steel?

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#12

Lee Valley chisel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I spent time looking at the new chisel in October and talked with several LV representatives. Here is my impression.

First, the chisels are very thick, similar to what carpenters and millwrights used 100 years ago. They are even more robust than chisels I have used for 2x6 and 3x8 mortises in heavy timber framing. Altogether heavier than I could recommend for furniture joinery.

The handle (maple) is short. I like five inches (or more) of wood showing so you can grip the handle with your left hand without gripping the ferrule and also have some leeway to avoid bruising knuckles with the mallet. I think the Veritas was 4 1/2, too short for my average hands. Also at roughly 1 3/16 thick, a much fatter handle than I would recommend.

The tang was the biggest disappointment. It is a turned cylindrical tang with a few slanted notches cut in to prevent the handle from coming loose, and I think fixed with epoxy as well. No traditional four sided taper. I asked how you would get the handle off and it seemed that they had never heard of such an idea. They did suggest that you could destroy the handle to remove it. The idea that a chisel could be sold unhandled also seemed foreign to the representatives I spoke with.

I asked what the composition of the steel was and was told it was a secret. So it could be the same as somebody else's chisel. Who knows?

Just the outward dimensions of the chisel suggested to me that they did not consult professionals who use chisels at a high level. This is not what you see in fine shops. Technicians and photographs can only go so far. To evaluate a steel for fine work, you need discerning craftsmen with lots of experience.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#13

agree almost entirely

Bill Tindall

From its properties one would think that A2 would not be the metal of choice for a chisel. It is just not tough at the high hardness desired for a chisel edge that will be used to chopping. The properties of O-1 type steels would suggest it to be an excellent chisel steel. However, there is potential for improvement, something that we think 3V delivers.

I would like to understand more about your carbide release theory. I have not seen any microscopic evidence of voids left at a worn edge that could have been the result of carbide particles detaching from an edge.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#15

Re: Lee Valley chisel

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

First, the chisels are very thick, similar to what carpenters and millwrights used 100 years ago. They are even more robust than chisels I have used for 2x6 and 3x8 mortises in heavy timber framing. Altogether heavier than I could recommend for furniture joinery.

The handle (maple) is short. I like five inches (or more) of wood showing so you can grip the handle with your left hand without gripping the ferrule and also have some leeway to avoid bruising knuckles with the mallet. I think the Veritas was 4 1/2, too short for my average hands. Also at roughly 1 3/16 thick, a much fatter handle than I would recommend.

Hi Warren

Some of your observations are similar to mine, but there are factors you report that are incorrect, probably a result of relying on your memory.

I have had pre-production LV chisels for several months. I must emphasise that these are pre-production and I know that changes have been made. However these are the same chisels that were viewed at WIA, so there is nothing secret about them now. My involvement was to comment on the steel, its shape, and the overall balance.

I will comment here on the handle you saw, and again emphasise that this is not the handle that will reach production.


What we have here is the LV in the centre, flanked below by a Blue Spruce and above by one of my re-handled Stanley 750s.

Note that the LV is longer than the BS.

In turn, the BS is longer than an original Stanley 750 (which is the same length as the LN) ...


When I rebuilt the Stanley set I have, I purposely made handles longer than the originals, longer than the LN .... interestingly, the LV turned out as long as mine!

The tang was the biggest disappointment. It is a turned cylindrical tang with a few slanted notches cut in to prevent the handle from coming loose, and I think fixed with epoxy as well. No traditional four sided taper.

What you have is a handle-blade connection that is essentially the same as the Japanese chisel design, that is, a combined tang-and-socket.

Treat this design according to its own merits, not on a pre-conceived notion that 18th Century design was the ultimate design.

I asked how you would get the handle off and it seemed that they had never heard of such an idea. They did suggest that you could destroy the handle to remove it. The idea that a chisel could be sold unhandled also seemed foreign to the representatives I spoke with.

What chisel maker, outside of the LN 750 offer this as part of their design? Many users complain they the handles come off when they do not choose them to do so! I do not expect buyers of chisels today to be doing so on the basis that they have the choice of re-making handles. I find your reasoning strange.

I asked what the composition of the steel was and was told it was a secret. So it could be the same as somebody else's chisel. Who knows?

Indeed.

Just the outward dimensions of the chisel suggested to me that they did not consult professionals who use chisels at a high level. This is not what you see in fine shops. Technicians and photographs can only go so far. To evaluate a steel for fine work, you need discerning craftsmen with lots of experience.

As Rob has stated, there will be a range of chisels. Personally, I prefer a thinner blade, ones along the lines of the BS. The LV blade above is, for information, the same thickness as the Stanley 750. It weighed the same (longer blade being balanced by the socket design), had the same balance point. OK, it is not a paring chisel. But then neither is the LN or Stanley a dedicated paring chisel. These are bench chisels. It will be interesting to see what other designs are coming along in the future.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#16

I'm crushed

Bill Tindall

I could not agree more that once a minimum level of steel performance is achieved then it's mostly about ergonomics. Considering this fact and LV's market savoy with planes I would have thought that unhandled chisels would have been an obvious product.

Now that I have started noticing, I see that most of the professionals I encounter use a short chisel for dovetail fabrication. I suspect the popularity of the typical Japanese chisel is largely due to its nimbleness and not the Oriental steel.

The only place I see for significant improvement over traditional steel for chisels is in a chisel used for chopping - dovetail or mortise. If the ergonomics of the chisel doesn't address these uses then the steel becomes less important.

But we can hope that if the steel proves beneficial then it will not be long before others explore steel options. Even if there is only one steel known to man that has the claimed properties, it is not possible to keep this steel secret from a motivated competitor. Literally, in the span of 1 minute its composition can be determined in a lab equipped for steel analysis. Microscopic analysis will reveal much about its physical structure. It is a short trip from this knowledge to a similar or identical product. If the steel has promise for knives there are enough motivated and equipped knife makers that the steel will soon be revealed.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#17

Re: agree almost entirely

david weaver

Whatever the chipout is, I don't notice it in an O1 iron that is not over-hardened. I notice it in A2 and in the HSS on the mujis (I use those for the once or twice a year that I plane something out of cocobolo - I could get by with other irons, but thicknessing a 12x18 piece of cocobolo filled with little silica bits glinting from the light overhead makes makes carbon steel and a2 irons short lived. It is the only process where I really like the HSS over carbon or A2)

I don't really care too much if it's carbides or what, i care that it leaves lines in the surface of my work. I wouldn't think of sanding a surface to remove them, especially when a carbon steel iron will do the task perfectly well.

I have a couple of irons from LN that never seem to chipout like that in hardwood, but that's not universally true. I appreciate an iron that leaves a surface that shows nothing at all in raking light. A2 is hit or miss for that.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#18

Re: Lee Valley chisel

david weaver

Warren, I know you prefer chisels with long handles.

I don't think a lot of people these days do.

I think a lot of people prefer a chisel that has balance toward the cutting edge so that it can be placed easily (holding the steel) in a marking line or next to a marking line and struck.

That's just my guess. I don't mind handles a little bit longer, but they do need to be made of something light enough such that if I decide to grip the chisel near the edge, it isn't an arthritis-inducing act.

I don't recall, even when grasping the handle, that I've often malleted my hand.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#19

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

Rob Lee

Nope.

You'll just have to judge it on performance... not specs... :D

Cheers -

Rob

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#20

Re: Lee Valley chisel

Bob Hackett

I much prefer a chisel with too much bulk that I can grind down or otherwise modify myself over one that is so light and thin there is no metal for me to work with.

This is just my take on things, but I prefer larger potions over snappy presentation any day.

My aging hands also prefer larger handles. The one thing that wasn`t pointed out bt Warren was that when you have some bulk forward it really does need to be balanced by a stout handle. The LV philosophy toward tool design seems to favor ergonomics over visual appeal so I`m guessing that balance and ergonomics were why they went with the larger than standard handles.

I have to smile because I had thought the days of criticisms like too much steel, too much wood, or too much of anything besides hype for that matter were gone for good in this day and age.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#21

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

Rob Lee

Hi Bill -

Glad someone's reading those letters... :D

We'll be publishing a lot about our testing methods, and the general results. As we tested more than a dozen steels with different heat treatments - there's a lot of data to sort through. There are more than 5500 photos alone.

We literally looked at more than 100 candidates before selecting our steel. We evaluated each for wear, impact resistance, and sharpenability - and normalised and plotted the results. We made 100's of chisels and blades to do the testing...

Failure modes are all documented - and we'll be drawing some conclusions there too.

I expect we'll be publishing information once we actually have some product here to offer. With the lead times on PM steels at 6-12 months - we're still a month or two away from receiving ours. We're actually preparing our second mill run order now...before even seeing the first!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#22

Warren, I'm curious

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Who in the late 19th/early 20th century was making chisels of the thinness you advocate? Was there anyone? I'm no expert, but I have purchased more garage sale chisels than makes rational sense, with a predilection toward old on my part*, and very few of them would have met your test. Two of the four that spring immediately to mind were German-made (and the Germans seem still to favor thinner chisels, based on the offerings from Hirsch and Two Cherries); the other two are a sweet pair of Buck Bros. short chisels clearly intended for paring. Did the cabinet/furniture makers' families hold onto them, or were there just fewer sold than to carpenters and joiners?

*Understand: the European settlement of this area didn't start in earnest until the first third or so of the 19th century, and didn't really take off until after the Civil War. I also find Stanley planes following me home, and I've only ever found one pre-Sweetheart plane (that I know of). So my sample base is skewed toward early 20th century; and you have tended to speak of that period in the same way that many use when speaking of the period after World War II - that is, deterioration of standards from an earlier period.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#23

Re: game changer?

Charles

Yours is simply one of the best and most sensible posts I've read on this forum in a long time. The bit about waste removal and 'coloring between the lines' is aptly put and so true.

What a gem.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#24

Thanks 


Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#25

I saw Superman.....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

.....walking out of the back door of the super secret LV testing facility. He told me he was asked to test some new tools. I couldn't help but notice he was wearing several bandages. I think it bodes well for the new tools.

T.