Re: Lee Valley chisel
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
First, the chisels are very thick, similar to what carpenters and millwrights used 100 years ago. They are even more robust than chisels I have used for 2x6 and 3x8 mortises in heavy timber framing. Altogether heavier than I could recommend for furniture joinery.
The handle (maple) is short. I like five inches (or more) of wood showing so you can grip the handle with your left hand without gripping the ferrule and also have some leeway to avoid bruising knuckles with the mallet. I think the Veritas was 4 1/2, too short for my average hands. Also at roughly 1 3/16 thick, a much fatter handle than I would recommend.
Hi Warren
Some of your observations are similar to mine, but there are factors you report that are incorrect, probably a result of relying on your memory.
I have had pre-production LV chisels for several months. I must emphasise that these are pre-production and I know that changes have been made. However these are the same chisels that were viewed at WIA, so there is nothing secret about them now. My involvement was to comment on the steel, its shape, and the overall balance.
I will comment here on the handle you saw, and again emphasise that this is not the handle that will reach production.

What we have here is the LV in the centre, flanked below by a Blue Spruce and above by one of my re-handled Stanley 750s.
Note that the LV is longer than the BS.
In turn, the BS is longer than an original Stanley 750 (which is the same length as the LN) ...

When I rebuilt the Stanley set I have, I purposely made handles longer than the originals, longer than the LN .... interestingly, the LV turned out as long as mine!
The tang was the biggest disappointment. It is a turned cylindrical tang with a few slanted notches cut in to prevent the handle from coming loose, and I think fixed with epoxy as well. No traditional four sided taper.
What you have is a handle-blade connection that is essentially the same as the Japanese chisel design, that is, a combined tang-and-socket.
Treat this design according to its own merits, not on a pre-conceived notion that 18th Century design was the ultimate design.
I asked how you would get the handle off and it seemed that they had never heard of such an idea. They did suggest that you could destroy the handle to remove it. The idea that a chisel could be sold unhandled also seemed foreign to the representatives I spoke with.
What chisel maker, outside of the LN 750 offer this as part of their design? Many users complain they the handles come off when they do not choose them to do so! I do not expect buyers of chisels today to be doing so on the basis that they have the choice of re-making handles. I find your reasoning strange.
I asked what the composition of the steel was and was told it was a secret. So it could be the same as somebody else's chisel. Who knows?
Indeed.
Just the outward dimensions of the chisel suggested to me that they did not consult professionals who use chisels at a high level. This is not what you see in fine shops. Technicians and photographs can only go so far. To evaluate a steel for fine work, you need discerning craftsmen with lots of experience.
As Rob has stated, there will be a range of chisels. Personally, I prefer a thinner blade, ones along the lines of the BS. The LV blade above is, for information, the same thickness as the Stanley 750. It weighed the same (longer blade being balanced by the socket design), had the same balance point. OK, it is not a paring chisel. But then neither is the LN or Stanley a dedicated paring chisel. These are bench chisels. It will be interesting to see what other designs are coming along in the future.
Regards from Perth
Derek