New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

New Steel from Lee Valley

Posts

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#26

Re: Warren, I'm curious

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you look at Gary Robert's toolemera site there is a selection of catalogs from the era you mention. Most have both heavy and light chisels. I think one late 19th century catalog says something like "We have listed the socket chisels first because that is our greatest trade, but a survey of our best class of workman finds they prefer the tang chisels." It is shocking how many more chisels were available then.

When I was a boy we had two chisels in the house, the big one and the little one. They were Greenlee chisels (might have been made by someone else) and my father got them for Christmas in 1930. That year they were $6.40 a dozen. Since they taper down to the bevel, they are a little thicker now, after maybe 15,000 sharpenings, but were less than 1/8 thick when new. Very nice steel; I was lucky.

I like Butcher chisels, but there are many good brands.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#27

Re: Lee Valley chisel

Dean J in MN

Well then, they guys in the LV booth at WIA heard from at least two people that we were disappointed how thick these new offering were. It was my first comment when they handed me one.

I can only hope that this is just the start of a series of offerings? We can hope the small, but growing chorus for thin nimble chisels are heard.

-Dean

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#28

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

Pam Niedermayer

So, Rob, given the expense of the PM steel, do you think you'll come out with a laminated line? :)

Pam

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#29

Re: Lee Valley chisel

Rob Lee

Dean -

We listen more closely to those that are critical, than to those that are laudatory...

The table at WIA was full of prototypes - many of which were designed to be abused during testing - and were waaay beefier than what we're making. There were only two smaller "real" chisels there...

Cheers -

Rob

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#30

Re: Lee Valley chisel

Pam Niedermayer

I prefer different length handles/blades for different tasks. I have to admit though that I love the look and feel of my 6" long overall Japanese, just wouldn't use them for chopping mortises.

Pam

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#31

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

Rob Lee

Hi Pam -

Right after we open the Austin store..... ;) :b

Cheers -

Rob

(who actually wouldn`t mind being in Austin....)

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#32

Thanks

Bill Tindall

that paints a considerably different picture of the chisels than Warren's post. Curious this information never got posted on this forum where we have been discussing "improved steel" (or at least the possibility of) for the past 10 years.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#33

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

Pam Niedermayer

Now that's some serious attitude.

Pam, who's been basking all week in the 60's and 70's

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#34

another vote for small and nimble

Bill Tindall

especially for dovetails....the chiseling operation that consumes most of the time I have a chisel in my hands.

I can live with anything for the occasional paring.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#35

I am anxious to learn.....

Bill Tindall

how it is that wear resistance does not correlate with ease of sharpening (the statement that this metal "wears" (presumably in planing) better than, say A2, but sharpens as easily.

Also, I would like to learn what your more detailed research found was the dulling mechanism for "struck" chisels (dovetailing for example). I found it to be deformation or chipping but I have not had a tsunami of support for this conclusion.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#36

discussion of your observation

Bill Tindall

I am not disagreeing with your observation. I don't agree with the explanation for its cause.

The following is the results of observation of edge failure. If the metal does not possess sufficient toughness after the heat treating schedule it will micro chip at the edge. This is a bulk metal failure, on a small scale. It is not a result of carbide particles being shed. Many of the tool steels are not very tough at high hardness, which is why we selected 3V for our tools. It has exceptional toughness to resist chipping. I made a chisel from M2 and it shows the failure you describe. A2 is similarly deficient in toughness.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#37

Kriptonite?

Bill Tindall

Dang....the one element we can't detect in a steel alloy. Only Superman can detect it with his X-ray fluorescence vision so it will remain hidden from analysis. It must be the Kriptonite carbides that impart superior wear while at the same time abrading with Arkansas stones with relative ease.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#38

Chisel Thickness

Warren in Lancaster, PA

So you are suggesting that the chisel I looked at was not a real model, even though two clerks at two different times told me otherwise? How about the plastic model I looked at? Was that the wrong thickness also? What is the current projection for the thickness of the chisel?

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#39

They hammered them out of a U-lock?


Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#40

Don't forget: good music, too; and chili


Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#41

Re: Don't forget: good music, too; and chili

Pam Niedermayer

Yep, but I make my own great chilli and music (mediocre, but fun).

Pam

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#42

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

Pam Niedermayer

It has come to my attention that I left out the smiley on that, so it should have said: "...serious attitude. :)" Offending Rob is about the last thing I'd want to do.

Sorry about that.

Pam

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#43

Re: Lee Valley chisel - thickness

TomD

So if these have been shopped around, are there pictures? Is this the final form? I don't see anything to be concerned with here:

http://i271.photobucket.com/albums/jj136/ToddHyman/WIA%202011/1317525883.jpg

I don't mind thick at all.

I hate chisels that have a narrow waist and buzz when one hits them. There should not really be a waist.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#44

Re: I'm crushed

TomD

"I suspect the popularity of the typical Japanese chisel is largely due to its nimbleness and not the Oriental steel."

Wrong again. :)

But then you can't apparently have excellence in one without the other. They don't do ugly or crap.

I do agree the length is pretty perfect, and I was recently chopping dovetails with my mini chisels, and they were even handier. 3/4" birch plywood no less.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#45

Re: game changer?

TomD

"In the case where someone would be buying their first chisel, for example, a new steel would be an easier sell if the sales was backed by data, which it appears this steel will be."

It is a good idea if it passes the smell test and isn't a series of irrelevant tests that don't hold up in the real world. LV always has my full confidence. That said I think it is more a shield against sniping from other less well funded techheads. They have done a ton on stones, and as you know, that pretty much settled the question... :) People don't buy from numbers, wallstreet is pretty much proof of that. But they like to believe they could.

"A2 was a game changer in this market. Many new sales were captured by this steel even though it was not such an improvement that it rendered traditional steels obsolete. (It would not be hard to beat A2 for a chisel steel.)"

Better steels by almost any criterion, from HSS to disposables have been around for my 30+ years as a buyer. Never changes nothing after the Shapton effect wears off and the herd gets restless. The very first cabinet chisels I ever bought were Japanese HSS and I have never seen anything better, back around 1979 from masterpiece tools, and not very expensive. Changed the world as we know it... :)

"In any case, I expect the marketing muscle of Lee Valley to set off an investigation of steel by other companies, large and small. In this sense this steel will be a game changer."

You have a good point about muscle. But one thing that muscle has suggested in the past is that the leader prefers his O1 to his A2. May this change? One release mentioned O1 will be the first release of these chisels, not PM. No current info from me. But it does raise a question as to which will sell more, which is more desired, and what the gnomes of Ottawa know about us, that we do not know about ourselves. Sometimes all the everything is just there so yo can feel good about buying, in this case, the O1. Feeling good about the fact that a technical perfection of sorts is encompassed in the same envelope, for those outliers who actually want it. Meanwhile one can slink back to the shop with the brown paper package containing the O1 chisels one knows actually work best. Or not, but that is as much marketing as many other strategies.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#46

Re: Lee Valley chisel - to Derek

TomD

""I asked how you would get the handle off and it seemed that they had never heard of such an idea. They did suggest that you could destroy the handle to remove it. The idea that a chisel could be sold unhandled also seemed foreign to the representatives I spoke with.""

"What chisel maker, outside of the LN 750 offer this as part of their design? Many users complain they the handles come off when they do not choose them to do so! I do not expect buyers of chisels today to be doing so on the basis that they have the choice of re-making handles. I find your reasoning strange."

I think this is probably a marginal ask. LV, though, has offered many unhandeled tools over the years. Back in the 70s I bought a Greenlee starter turner set at LV, and almost felt dirty that it did have handles on it. Of course, strange reasoning or not, LV currently sells many tools with some happy talk about customizing handles. Having grown up with socketed chisels my Dad had, where the handles always come off, I am taken with my Barrs, that I have had 15 years, and the sockets never move. One socket even split, and the handle is on there seemingly for life. A socket with a retailing screw would suit me. There should be more screws.

Another point Derek, Japanese handles are removable.

""Just the outward dimensions of the chisel suggested to me that they did not consult professionals who use chisels at a high level. This is not what you see in fine shops. Technicians and photographs can only go so far. To evaluate a steel for fine work, you need discerning craftsmen with lots of experience.""

Or the same guys who want to make their own handles can hit the belt sander with this chunk and "have it their way".

"As Rob has stated, there will be a range of chisels. Personally, I prefer a thinner blade, ones along the lines of the BS. The LV blade above is, for information, the same thickness as the Stanley 750. It weighed the same (longer blade being balanced by the socket design), had the same balance point. OK, it is not a paring chisel. But then neither is the LN or Stanley a dedicated paring chisel. These are bench chisels. It will be interesting to see what other designs are coming along in the future."

I like it, it looks muscular. One can have muscular pretty as with the Japanese, or Muscular, utilitarian, and with this and the Barr. But give me some guts.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#47

Re: We need a proper review...

TomD

Let's get this guy to test these new chisels if it's numbers you want:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1roIicDkmn4&feature=related

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#48

Re: I am anxious to learn.....

TomD

"Also, I would like to learn what your more detailed research found was the dulling mechanism for "struck" chisels (dovetailing for example). I found it to be deformation or chipping but I have not had a tsunami of support for this conclusion."

I think it is mostly the dude on the other end going "dang! it's stuck again, let me lever that chunk out"

The loads and mileage are far lower than on a plane so I don't get the idea that a chisel cutting is worse off than a plane scraping. Because of the special condition of a plane, the shaving gets cut, but the blade is scraping (no bevel support in the cut, and the load is at an angle to the edge.

Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#49

Heh, heh ....


Re: New Steel from Lee Valley

#50

Re: Chisel Thickness

Rob Lee

Hi Warren -

What we had at WIA, were prototypes, and very early pre-production. What we are making is different from all of those - there have certainly been design changes since then.

We have put a lot of focus on where the balance point for these chisel will be - striving to have it at, or just below, the ferrule. as we change the handle - we work with the blade etc.

Our first release of chisels wil be bench chisels... utility all-round users. we will quickly be adding Butt, Mortise, Paring, and specialty chisels to that range. There will be lots of choice - in both design, and material.

Cheers -

Rob