Re: Lee Valley chisel - to Derek
TomD
""I asked how you would get the handle off and it seemed that they had never heard of such an idea. They did suggest that you could destroy the handle to remove it. The idea that a chisel could be sold unhandled also seemed foreign to the representatives I spoke with.""
"What chisel maker, outside of the LN 750 offer this as part of their design? Many users complain they the handles come off when they do not choose them to do so! I do not expect buyers of chisels today to be doing so on the basis that they have the choice of re-making handles. I find your reasoning strange."
I think this is probably a marginal ask. LV, though, has offered many unhandeled tools over the years. Back in the 70s I bought a Greenlee starter turner set at LV, and almost felt dirty that it did have handles on it. Of course, strange reasoning or not, LV currently sells many tools with some happy talk about customizing handles. Having grown up with socketed chisels my Dad had, where the handles always come off, I am taken with my Barrs, that I have had 15 years, and the sockets never move. One socket even split, and the handle is on there seemingly for life. A socket with a retailing screw would suit me. There should be more screws.
Another point Derek, Japanese handles are removable.
""Just the outward dimensions of the chisel suggested to me that they did not consult professionals who use chisels at a high level. This is not what you see in fine shops. Technicians and photographs can only go so far. To evaluate a steel for fine work, you need discerning craftsmen with lots of experience.""
Or the same guys who want to make their own handles can hit the belt sander with this chunk and "have it their way".
"As Rob has stated, there will be a range of chisels. Personally, I prefer a thinner blade, ones along the lines of the BS. The LV blade above is, for information, the same thickness as the Stanley 750. It weighed the same (longer blade being balanced by the socket design), had the same balance point. OK, it is not a paring chisel. But then neither is the LN or Stanley a dedicated paring chisel. These are bench chisels. It will be interesting to see what other designs are coming along in the future."
I like it, it looks muscular. One can have muscular pretty as with the Japanese, or Muscular, utilitarian, and with this and the Barr. But give me some guts.
Regards from Perth
Derek