Re: Not compared to calipers, etc...
TomD
It is certainly less accurate than a caliper. I use calipers a lot. It is sorta like digital watches, when they first came out people wondered what one needed that level of accuracy for, and they were right, but we are used to it today. I think one can argue that the measures you have are sorta useless, not accurate enough to tell you what parts of the tenon is tight, but not useful for all the stuff that ought not to be measured in the first place. Woodworking is a fit-to business. I would far rather size something to available stock (with adherence to sound design), that piece on a sliver to make up to my width to some nominal number. So my eyes/patterns, story stick, etc... tell me major layout. And if my method does not lead to perfect joinery results, or whatever, I want some real numbers that mater, and that is to thous. Calipers do both, you can set them like a go-bar to a measurement, accurate to sub thous and walk around with it, no numbers, or you can take a "real" measurement.
With your stuff, as mentioned there is the parallax issue. The rule may be accurate, but what maters is how you read it, and how you make marks from it.
I also don't like a measureing tool that can't take a measure from the middle of a surface. I would have to reach for a different tool.
There is the method of pattern layout where one uses guages, patterns, ticks etc... These lack the inaccuracy of measuring in the first place.
There is the method of laying out from a side reference point. Your measurement is fundamentally determined by your stock's current state of accuracy, and crumbs. This is why certain techniques use layout in reference to secondary surfaces, or CLs, etc... Increasingly I do some parts layed out from CAD transgers.
Obviously if what you are doing works then it works, but it doesn't appeal to me at all. I have to say after years of scorning score marks on most squares, I was surprised to discover the Starret combo square is a machinists' tool, or so I now believe it to be. That blew me away. I had been tought to disparedge it as inaccurate, so what gives there. I do have one though.
I have to say the only metal square I like are the Japanese ones. As with many such ideals, they are not perfect. They are not available to me yet with inches on both sides, or even MMs on both sides, and I don't plan to buy new ones should that change. I believe inches are superior, but I was brought up in mms, I don't really care, inches are just the most logical default for the universe I actually work in. It is one thing to argue superior systems, but it is pointless because what actually exists out there are blends
What do I like about Japaese rules:
- Bigger and lighter, which is a toofer.
- Not as cold to the touch, a winter issue around here.
- LIghter, so I don't have to worry about them damaging themselves, or other stuff
- built in parallax compensation system
- User configurable if they get out of set
- No drag marks if using felt tips or bamboo brushes (another "good thing")
- The biggie, is that they do not shift after being laid on a surface, which is a traditional hate for any metal rule
- Works just as well on a plane, or hooked on an edge
- Built in finger locators when using knives.
- Etc...
So reeks of never having been touched by a marketing person, or engineer... As I say, I don't like metal rules, but this one just works if one is into that kind of thing. I actually like wooden squares, but I won't get into any more mind expanding here.