New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Squares

Posts

Squares

#1

Squares

Bill Tindall

I don't own any squares that aren't ruled. The reason, I use a square for measuring length many times more often than I use one for measuring 90 degrees. It makes little sense to me to own one square for measure 90 degrees and a different one for measuring length.

Re: Squares

#2

Re: Squares

roger lance

I do own squares for measuring 90 degrees only and a Stanley square which also measures length....and this makes sense to me. You're at it early, Bill.

Re: Squares

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Squares *LINK*

Moses Yoder

If I used a square to measure something, my old high school shop teacher would probably Gibbs slap me upside the head.


Gibbs Slap

Re: Squares

#4

Re: Squares

Schtoo

I own a few squares that have no measurements on them at all.


But I don't own that one. Not any more...

Stu.

Re: Squares

#5

Combination and Double Squares, me

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

While some try squares have come to stay in my shop, I find the flexibility of a combination and/or double square fits my working style better*; and, of course, the rules on combination and double squares have measurements.

I use the measurements a lot, too. Combination and double squares are particularly nice for repetitive measurements from an edge: set the rule to the measurement needed, hold the head against the edge, mark off the corner of the rule. This applies, of course, only where the edge can be trusted - that is, it's straight and related to the layout desired.

I do have one wee engineer's fixed square, with a beam 2" long, that I use when I need to check square in small work (I own an adjustable square in that size range, but reserve it for highly fussy measurements).

*As with so many other "this feels right" tool decisions, this may well be at least partly a product of my early exposure to tools. My dad used a combination square, and it was the first squaring tool I acquired when I started to ruin perfectly good pieces of wood.

Re: Squares

#6

Re: Squares

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I must use different methods of work. One of my squares has markings, maybe eighths, but I haven't looked at the markings for over 30 years.

Re: Squares

#7

Combo square for me....

John in NM

I find them very versatile, so much so that I have a couple and use them a lot, and most of the old try squares stay in the tool chest. I don't find graduated try squares especially useful, so if I didn't have a combination square, I'd probably use whatever try square was at hand and a tape measure.

Re: Squares

#8

Square measurement

Bill Tindall

Anything I need to measure that is shorter than the length of what ever square is at hand will be measured by the ruled square. I can't think of a more convenient or more precise way to accomplish the task.

My most often used square/measure is a Starrett 4" "double square" . It lives on the bench and is used to measure and mark anything less that about 3". With the sliding bar set at 1" it for me is the fastest and most precise means of measuring smaller distances, or with the sliding bar set at a specified distance it is my handiest means of marking a distance with scribe or pencil, depending on accuracy required. It is certainly more convenient than setting a marking gauge.

My most cherished set of squares is a set made in India and sold by Manney's in Lexington KY. They are precisely ruled, rust proof, and easy to read. Indeed a square ruled in 1/8ths would be near useless for measurement. Slap one on an 8" wide board and with one tool at hand the precise width, and, squareness of the end can be established. I can't think of a better way of making these two routine measurements. But, I am open to alternative suggestions.

Re: Squares

#9

Why?

Bill Tindall

What reason could the be for eschewing measuring with a square, unless it was the one Warren has with 1/8th inch rulings?

Re: Squares

#10

Yet another why?

Bill Tindall

Why don't the fabricators of these elegant squares make them from stainless steel? It seems to me to be a superior material for the tool. Brushed to a satin finish it is attractive and this luster would remain attractive forever, unlike brass or steel.

Re: Squares

#11

Moses Yoder

Re: Why?

Moses Yoder

Woodworking is a religion to most woodworkers. It doesn't really matter why you do it that way, that's just how you do it. Take the Stanley bench plane. They and their copies were manufactured exactly the same way for almost 150 years until Lee Valley came along and said "Why?" And now there are still people who won't use a Lee Valley plane because "It looks funny."

Re: Squares

#12

Re: Squares

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I use three types on a regular basis.

A bunch of years ago I bought an aluminum c-man 8 X 12" framing square that was pretty close to being square. I went at it with a file until it is as close to right as I can make it. There is also a full sized framing square that gets used only to true up big cabinets.

Then I have a Freud try square that is right on, and a little machinist's square that was given to me as a joke, but that cheap little bugger is perfectly square.

What I use mostly, though, are my combination squares, all three graduated to at least 1/32". I have three: the standard sized Starrett, a 4" double square from LV and a teeny little 2" Starrett.

Re: Squares

#14

Marking gauge

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I can't imagine that anyone familiar with a marking gauge and a panel gauge would do things as you describe, Bill. We gauge to eight inches, saw and plane to the line, and thereafter don't need to measure the width. And with a marking gauge we can hold the work with one hand and gauge with the other; it sounds like you need two hands to hold the combination square and the pencil, so you have to secure every piece before marking. There is a reason traditional woodworkers have used plain squares.

Re: Squares

#15

Clint Searl

Re: Squares

Clint Searl

Measuring squares are subject to the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle.

Clint

Re: Squares

#16

parallax and squares

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

As a patternmakers apprentice I was taught that the most accurate way of measuring was to place the rule on edge. The reason any rule is more accurate when placed on edge is because you eliminate any parallax error. Since most squares with graduated blades use thicker stock than a simple rule the parallax error will be greater with a square than a rule when it is not used on edge. Parrallax is the reason why when you are driving you can be doing 70mph and the person sitting in the passenger seat will look at the dash and it will look like the speedometer shows 65 to them.

When I was buying tools as an apprentice the first tool I bought was a Starrett combination square. I used the blade as a rule when doing layout but I would remove it from the head so I could place it on edge to get accurate results. The next tool I bought was a Starrett rule so I could save time by not having to remove the blade from my square every time I needed to measure something.

The first tool I made was a panel gauge with a marking wheel. In use it is much more accurate than using a square and a knife as a panel gauge because with the wheel attached to the panel gauge the wheel actually pulls the gauge snug to the board rather than allowing the grain to cause a knife blade to wander.

Once I learned these work habits there was little need for a square with a graduated blade. There is nothing wrong with the way you are working but now you know why unmarked rules are often prefered.

Re: Squares

#17

Squares inventory....

roger lance

I did an inventory of my squares. I have a total of 10 squares including a combination square, a Japanese Shinwa square (with 45 and 90 degree sides), a framing square, and a saddle square. Four squares are graduated for measuring and six are plain. I do use the Stanley graduated square the most and do measure with it when I don't need to be very precise. When accuracy counts, its the steel rules that get used and for repeatability, a story stick. This does not count the various clamps and other devices in the shop that are intended to help get a glue up square etc.....and still I sometimes fail to achieve that goal of 90.

Re: Squares

#18

Re: Yet another why?

Schtoo

Well, aside from the difficulty of working with stainless vs. bronze, brass or even steel, there's the concern that dragging a knife along the edge of bearing metal versus a known work hardening steel.

In short, SS can tear up stuff, brass or bronze is less likely to.

And besides, brass on wood looks nice and warm. Stainless on wood can look good but is usually cold and looks 'meh'.

FWIW, that's Muntz metal, not exactly 'brass'.

Next incarnation will likely be made by someone else. I don't have the time to crank them out for fun or profit.

Stu.

Re: Squares

#19

Re: But.....do you measure length with them?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I do if that's what is handy. Plus, it makes the handiest scribe for a fixed distance from the edge of something. Just set the length on the blade, tighten the set screw on the handle and let 'er buck.

Plus #2, they (the Starretts) work extremely well for transferring measurements without reading the rule scale, very much akin to how I like to use calipers.

Re: Squares

#20

Re: Yet another why?

David Weaver

gahhh!! tacky! I hope they don't start making everything out of stainless steel, polished or not. Everything will look like an inlaid muffler tip.

I'd much rather have brass or bronze.

Re: Squares

#21

Good form and function

Bill Tindall


This square is one of a set I bought from Manny's in Lexington, KY some years ago. Actually I got it at their booth at IWF in Atlanta. The set was about $80 at the time. The squares are ruled in 32nd. The blades are brushed stainless steel, probably a 400 series. They are as accurate as my Starretts. Because they are stainless with black ruling they are easy to read. They will never get any less easy to read due to corrosion/oxidation. I don't see how they are any less accurate for measuring than any alternative ruled instrument. Bottom line, when I need to determine 90 degrees and/or measure a short length these are my go to tools when the 4" combination square doesn't do the job (or I can't locate it).

Re: Squares

#22

Re: Not compared to calipers, etc...

TomD

It is certainly less accurate than a caliper. I use calipers a lot. It is sorta like digital watches, when they first came out people wondered what one needed that level of accuracy for, and they were right, but we are used to it today. I think one can argue that the measures you have are sorta useless, not accurate enough to tell you what parts of the tenon is tight, but not useful for all the stuff that ought not to be measured in the first place. Woodworking is a fit-to business. I would far rather size something to available stock (with adherence to sound design), that piece on a sliver to make up to my width to some nominal number. So my eyes/patterns, story stick, etc... tell me major layout. And if my method does not lead to perfect joinery results, or whatever, I want some real numbers that mater, and that is to thous. Calipers do both, you can set them like a go-bar to a measurement, accurate to sub thous and walk around with it, no numbers, or you can take a "real" measurement.

With your stuff, as mentioned there is the parallax issue. The rule may be accurate, but what maters is how you read it, and how you make marks from it.

I also don't like a measureing tool that can't take a measure from the middle of a surface. I would have to reach for a different tool.

There is the method of pattern layout where one uses guages, patterns, ticks etc... These lack the inaccuracy of measuring in the first place.

There is the method of laying out from a side reference point. Your measurement is fundamentally determined by your stock's current state of accuracy, and crumbs. This is why certain techniques use layout in reference to secondary surfaces, or CLs, etc... Increasingly I do some parts layed out from CAD transgers.

Obviously if what you are doing works then it works, but it doesn't appeal to me at all. I have to say after years of scorning score marks on most squares, I was surprised to discover the Starret combo square is a machinists' tool, or so I now believe it to be. That blew me away. I had been tought to disparedge it as inaccurate, so what gives there. I do have one though.

I have to say the only metal square I like are the Japanese ones. As with many such ideals, they are not perfect. They are not available to me yet with inches on both sides, or even MMs on both sides, and I don't plan to buy new ones should that change. I believe inches are superior, but I was brought up in mms, I don't really care, inches are just the most logical default for the universe I actually work in. It is one thing to argue superior systems, but it is pointless because what actually exists out there are blends

What do I like about Japaese rules:

- Bigger and lighter, which is a toofer.

- Not as cold to the touch, a winter issue around here.

- LIghter, so I don't have to worry about them damaging themselves, or other stuff

- built in parallax compensation system

- User configurable if they get out of set

- No drag marks if using felt tips or bamboo brushes (another "good thing")

- The biggie, is that they do not shift after being laid on a surface, which is a traditional hate for any metal rule

- Works just as well on a plane, or hooked on an edge

- Built in finger locators when using knives.

- Etc...

So reeks of never having been touched by a marketing person, or engineer... As I say, I don't like metal rules, but this one just works if one is into that kind of thing. I actually like wooden squares, but I won't get into any more mind expanding here.

Re: Squares

#23

Re: Why?

TomD

Perfecting a stanley is like optimizing teats on a goose...

Re: Squares

#24

Re: Good form and function

David Weaver

I probably read something and jumped to conclusions assuming the whole thing would be stainless steel. That one doesn't look too bad, though I've never used a try square with graduations on it.

As warren mentions, I'm going to end up having to mark the board with a marking gauge, anyway, so the measurement is made there - in setting the gauge.

Re: Squares

#25

Clarification

Bill Tindall

I rarely mark from this kind of square but I do mark frequently from a small combination square (the square with a sliding part on a ruled blade). But slapped against an edge or pushed against an inside corner the square in the picture is a handy way to measure distance in addition to its function at measuring 90 degrees or establishing a 90 degree line. A hooked ruler would be largely equivalent except I dropped mine and wrecked the hook part and I am too cheap to pay $30+ to replace it.