Re: Oriental woodworking question - tools
TomD
The fact of the mater is that when the craft of woodworking, and many other crafts, renewed themselves in the 1970s, China was relatively inaccessible, relatively poor/oppressed, and sorta the bad guy in the background of then ongoing hostilities. Conversely Japan was a friend, had a lot of trade with the US. There was widespread fascination with her martial arts, and other arts, and she had the very best woodworking tools then available in the world.
You can look at this latter statement from a number of perspectives. You could say:
Japanese tools in design etc... are the very best in the world, period. Scholars traveling in Japans many decades earlier were stunned by what they saw in Japanese tools.
Japanese tools in design etc... were the very best in the world in relation to the tasks expected of them. So maybe we don't plane to a finish that much but they do, and their planes are relatively better for that than a Stanley block plane from the 70s was for anything except perhaps a paperweight.
Japanese tools were the best in the world as far as their integration, quality of steel, stones, etc...
What is not all that arguable in the 70s was that Japanese tools were the best in the world at that time, available on the NA market. That explains their penetration that lasts to this day, and their penetration to a lot of folks who really had no reason to adopt them. I worked with them pretty exclusively for decades. I would have had no reason to do so if better tools from my tradition had been available to me. There were people who did not fall for Japanese tools, Frid and klauzs come to mind, since they came from cultures that had continuity with their past, and had available to them tools of professional quality.
I wrote to Leonard Lee in the 90s maybe, and asked him whether LV would be able to do anything about the fact that at the time they were not selling any pro-grade tools from the general troika of chisels, planes, and saws. For a while there they had dropped the Japanese and German stuff, LN was on the way out or in. They had no credible saws, planes or chisels of their own. I remember reading about the Independence saw, the idea that one could just go out and buy a real joinery saw of western make!
One old story I can't verify is the idea that Japanese tools result in part from a closing down of the sword making craft during westernization. Those smiths, whom whatever one thinks of the sword itself were pretty hot, are then said to have been forced into other trades like wood tools and razors etc... Like all that space age materials of the 60s and 70s - Sword age tech! If this actually happened, broadly and with influence, then it would be easy to understand the high quality compared to the output of other country's. Of course, it doesn't specifically argue to the utility of that kind of technology being showered on woodworking.
Chinese woodworking tools have been described for quite a while in the popular press. There were the articles FWW did years back on Chinese and Vietnamese tools and workers. Their tools are pretty western with the exception of the side handles. I have played with these over the years, making a bowsaw in their style. The planes are now widely available, at a decent cost they are the only source for new hollows and rounds. The chisels and gouges look a good deal. The similarity make them both appealing, and less interesting, depending on what one is looking for.