New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Oriental woodworking question

Posts

Oriental woodworking question

#1

Oriental woodworking question

Bill Tindall

I know little of Oriental tools and furniture and I have been puzzled about something. There seems to be great interest in and availability of Japanese tools and there also seems to be similar interest in Japanese style of woodworking. What happened to the rest of the of the Orient and India? Surely the Chinese and Indians sat at or on something and stored stuff in wooden furniture and they must have worked wood with metal tools. There was/is great wealth in these countries so the very rich had, and have, the resources to build fine furniture. So why aren't there discussions of Chinese tool makers and Indian cabinet makers and plans for Indian furniture in Popular Woodworkng? I suppose the trivial answer is that these topics are not popular, but why. Are the tools crummy, the designs unappealing, Japanese smiths more photogenic???

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#2

Re: Oriental woodworking question

David Weaver

From what I've seen of other east asian tools, they are generally not as well formed or as well executed as japanese tools, the metallurgy isn't as good and the uniformity isn't there.

The mujis are a fantastic deal if you can get them in a shape and pitch that you want, though. They are maybe a traditional shape but with what feels a lot like M2 in them, though it's never specified.

A lot of the other places (vietnam??) have what look like japanese planes but with less elegance in retaining the iron. Like a wedge and pin.

I have never seen an indian tool, though I've seen a lot of tools that were made in india! (recent tools). Maybe the english were there too early for them to have developed tools in the golden era of our toolmaking in the west (I would think of that as late 18th century and early 19th century, no clue when it was for the japanese, presumably later).

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#3

Re: Oriental woodworking question

roger lance

It seems like there was an article in Fine Woodworking within the past two years that was concern with an ancient and complicated furniture joint found in a Chinese piece....the author was able to take the old joint apart and was able to reproduce it. It also seems that there are various books available that deal with Oriental Furniture (not just Japanese). Its my understanding that there is an extremely high level of craftmanship in ancient high end furniture of both China and India....but these craftsmen made their furniture with a very limited assortment of tools....certainly so limited that these implements would hold little interest for Western tastes. Japan, however, has been more industrial....more elaborate in its manufacture of tools and more open to trade. The recent emergence of the BRIC nations (Brazil, Russia, India, & China) as world economic powers may change their tooling and our perceptions of them. This lack of manufacturing and maintenance of closed societies in some way allowed the Japanese to control China in WWII and 100,000 British soldiers to control 80,000,000 Indians....but times are changing. Most American furniture stores are selling things made in China....and even Stickley is selling Greene & Greene pieces made in Vietnam !!

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Oriental woodworking question

Jesper, Denmark

Bill, I think that all of the principal structure of Korean and Japanese Society, including arts and crafts as well as social systems originated in China. They spread south and west and evolved into distinkt cultures. If you go back 100 years, the written language was the same, and in Japan, that is still so, when the modern simplified Japanes script does not provide a complete meaning, they add some of the older chinese characters.

The architectural designs and the tools to make it also came from China.

The current Japanese design direction is simple and clean, where he Korean and Chinese tends to be a bit overdecorated by western eyes. The industrial revolution started much earlier in Japan that in China, so trade and communication with the west happened at a much earlier time.

The present day issue of copycat and poor quality products from the Chinese market also took place in the eary part of last century with goods from Japan - and in the previous centure� with "N�rnbergerkram" from a recently industrialized Germany.

Chinese craftsmaship goes back not 100's of years, but 1000's. There is a vast collection in the Imperial Museum in Taipei with items of furniture, pottery and carving in wood or jade that simpy blows your mind.

So, I think the simple answer is that we communicate more with the Japanese crafts sphere than with the others, so we know less about them.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#5

blame it on Mao

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

In the discussions of japanese tools all I have read is in refrence to current toolmakers, nothing about toolmakers during the early part of the 20th century. We might be having similar conversations about Chinese toolmakers but there was this little mix up they had in the 1940's and a guy named Mao.

With all the talk about Japanese tools there is very little discussion about Japanese furniture, and for good reason, most regard Japanese temple carpentry as the pinnacle of Japanese woodworking as far as skill and complex joinery. In China during the early Ming and Qing dyanasties the highest level of skil in woodworking was reserved for furniture.

The fairly recent exhibition at the Peabody & Essex highlights the influence that ancient chinese design is still haing on current designers. You may even be familiar with furniture that is derivative of chinese design and not reaized it. Danish Modern designer Hans Wegener designed several iconc chairs that were his version of Ming Dynasiy designs.

I highly recomend "Connisseurship of Chinese Furniture" it is a two volume set that is a pretty extensive over view of Chinese design and joinery, it is lacking in information about Chinese wood working tools.

Robin

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#6

Re: Oriental woodworking question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Andrew Hunter of New York works mostly domestic woods using Chinese joinery and designs. Interestingly he uses a lot of Japanese tools. I think some of the best Chinese craftsmen fled the country along with their patrons. I'm not sure what the status of the craft is in China today.

In 1977 I got a piece of rosewood that was once a part of a piece of Chinese furniture. The joinery is really exceptional, with very clean grooves, precise mortises and tenons hidden in the mitres, and very clean moulding.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#7

Chris Scholz

Overdecorated?

Chris Scholz

I can only confirm what you said.

One not however, "overdecorated" is really true only for Qing-style furniture. Chinese classical furniture is mostly associated with Ming-style furniture. Literati vehemently rejected Qing aesthetics.

For some mysterious reasons we in the West think of Qing furniture with it's excessive carving when we think about Chinese furniture.

Chris

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#8

Chris Scholz

ChineseWoodworker *LINK*

Chris Scholz

Bill,

I started putting together a few thoughts (and pictures) related to Chinese woodworking. This is very much work in progress. Lot more to come whenever I get around to do it.

BTW, I'll stay away form the whole complex of which culture influenced which other one (or bullied into submission). "China: a culture that pretends to be a nation?", "Japanese culture, really a Chinese culture stuck in the Tang dynasty?", I'm not going to touch this with a 10' pole.

Chris


www.ChineseWoodworker.com

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: blame it on Mao

Jesper, Denmark

While we are on the sidetrack of "Danish Modern", let's not forget that it was largely inspired from the Shaker designs - EXCEPT the chairs.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Don't worry about the 10 foot pole......

Jesper, Denmark

There ae very few of us, who can cclaim not to be mongrels of some kind.

Movement of peoples and transfers and adaptations of ideologies is definitely not something new.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#11

some additional thoughts, speculation, & theories

roger lance

perhaps the reasons for the lack of interest in other Oriental woodworking subcultures exists within our American (Western) psyche....I believe its fair to characterize Chinese & Indian traditional furniture as being made on a high level with few things....in other words, these pieces are the result of highly developed skills and not due to some magical collection of advanced tooling....much sweat and toil and few shinning things to do it with....this general formula does not appeal to the average American mind....take golf as an analogy....in golf, the swing is the thing....if you do not develop the physical mechanics to move your body in a certain coordinated fashion that delivers a club head at a specific position when club meets ball, your chances of much success are small....yet every year, golf club manufacturers trot out their latest and greatest $300 driver that will hit the ball farther, straighter, under more control and feel, and all your problems will go away....and golf wannabes buy and change their equipment to keep up with the latest and best....when its the skills....the swing.... that is the thing....but what company wants to tell its potential customers to not buy their magic stick but rather go practice your movement and get more fit and flexible....this is why Lee Trevino became famous for beating and taking money from well heeled, well equipped country club members by playing them using a Coke bottle....the analogies could go on endlessly....but the general idea of avoiding pain and seeking pleasure is well established (as any Freudian knows....hey Derek)....so I think old Chinese & Indian masterpieces demand high skills (pain) and little pleasure if done in the traditional way (no shinning magical stuff) and don't generate much of a Western following as a result.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#12

Re: Don't worry about the 10 foot pole......

Bruce, a MN Galoot

In physical anthropology I was taught that one of the distinguishing characteristics of what used to be called "Mongoloid" genetic stock was a shovel-shaped incisor tooth; that is, the backside of the incisor teeth was slightly hollowed out. I mentioned that to my dentist once (this was in North Dakota), and he said that nearly all his Scandinavian patients had teeth thusly shaped. I did.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#14

Oh, yes, indeed

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My bride, who was told all her life that her ancestry is all but entirely German, has subscribed to one of those DNA/medical risk/ancestry services, and recently got news that she's got DNA traceable to Swedish (we're thinking Viking), Bulgarian, and English populations. The area now considered Germany, of course, is one of those areas that darned near every migration tromped through at one time or another; so it's not surprising, really.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#15

Re: Oriental woodworking question *LINK*

charlie belden

I think the reason for oriental furniture pieces not showing up in woodworking magazines has to do with Complexity AND Do-Ability.

I inherited a fair amount of Chinese furniture - in rosewood. Only after I got into woodworking and had become familar with "western" furniture construction methods did I really start examining the Chinese furniture I had. And what I saw - seemed impossible - based on how I THOUGHT it was constructed.

A six foot long coffee table - with basically 2x2s for legs at the corners - but only a 3/4" thick by 2" wide apron!? OK so there's a piece of 3/4" cove molding between the top of the apron and the bottom of the table top. And there's a 3/8" bead on the bottom edge of the apron. But they CAN'T add enough strength to keep the thing from sagging over a 6' span.

Then I examined things a bit more closely.

The apron wasn't 3/4" thick - it was 1 1/14" thick. And that coved molding and the bottom bead weren't applied molding - they were an integral part of the apron. The apron wasn't 3/4" x 2" - but ACTUALLY

1 1/4" x 3 1/8". And where the aprons met the legs - no simple mortise and tenon - but rather a Triple Miter joint - and a not a simple triple miter either since the apron's height was different than the leg thickness. No 45:45 simple compound miter joint here. Inside THIS triple mitered joint are mitered mortise and tenons - with the legs each having a tenon that extends up above the apron - to fit in a mortise in the underside of the frame of the frame and paneled table top.

Ain't quite as relatively simple as Arts & Crafts / Greene & Greene / Stickley stuff. Relative to Chinese furniture - those seem like IKEA construction. With some power tools and a few hand tools, even I can make A&C furniture - with some basic woodworking skills of course - along with some kiln dried boards I can buy as my starting point.

To make a copy of any of the Chinese furnitutre I have - I'd need not only a lot more skill, mainly hand tool skiilsl - but also the very strong and beautiful rosewood - in uncommon dimensions - as well.

Have a look at the drawings on the attached web page - and follow the link back to the chinese joinery.

Western furniture styles change and the changes come in much shorter time periods than with chinese furniture. A Western style piece that's 20 years old is seen as overdue for replacement - with something NEW.

Chinese furniture designs EVOLVE - and very slowly. You have to look closely to see the differences between a piece done a hundred years ago and pieces done a few years ago. THAT means the designs get refined over time - in small increments. And each refinement adds to the illusions in chinese furniture - the illusions adding to the appearance of delicateness and refinement - while adding structural strength - without that added strength being noticable.


Chinese Side Board Example

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#16

Re: Oriental woodworking question - tools

TomD

The fact of the mater is that when the craft of woodworking, and many other crafts, renewed themselves in the 1970s, China was relatively inaccessible, relatively poor/oppressed, and sorta the bad guy in the background of then ongoing hostilities. Conversely Japan was a friend, had a lot of trade with the US. There was widespread fascination with her martial arts, and other arts, and she had the very best woodworking tools then available in the world.

You can look at this latter statement from a number of perspectives. You could say:

Japanese tools in design etc... are the very best in the world, period. Scholars traveling in Japans many decades earlier were stunned by what they saw in Japanese tools.

Japanese tools in design etc... were the very best in the world in relation to the tasks expected of them. So maybe we don't plane to a finish that much but they do, and their planes are relatively better for that than a Stanley block plane from the 70s was for anything except perhaps a paperweight.

Japanese tools were the best in the world as far as their integration, quality of steel, stones, etc...

What is not all that arguable in the 70s was that Japanese tools were the best in the world at that time, available on the NA market. That explains their penetration that lasts to this day, and their penetration to a lot of folks who really had no reason to adopt them. I worked with them pretty exclusively for decades. I would have had no reason to do so if better tools from my tradition had been available to me. There were people who did not fall for Japanese tools, Frid and klauzs come to mind, since they came from cultures that had continuity with their past, and had available to them tools of professional quality.

I wrote to Leonard Lee in the 90s maybe, and asked him whether LV would be able to do anything about the fact that at the time they were not selling any pro-grade tools from the general troika of chisels, planes, and saws. For a while there they had dropped the Japanese and German stuff, LN was on the way out or in. They had no credible saws, planes or chisels of their own. I remember reading about the Independence saw, the idea that one could just go out and buy a real joinery saw of western make!

One old story I can't verify is the idea that Japanese tools result in part from a closing down of the sword making craft during westernization. Those smiths, whom whatever one thinks of the sword itself were pretty hot, are then said to have been forced into other trades like wood tools and razors etc... Like all that space age materials of the 60s and 70s - Sword age tech! If this actually happened, broadly and with influence, then it would be easy to understand the high quality compared to the output of other country's. Of course, it doesn't specifically argue to the utility of that kind of technology being showered on woodworking.

Chinese woodworking tools have been described for quite a while in the popular press. There were the articles FWW did years back on Chinese and Vietnamese tools and workers. Their tools are pretty western with the exception of the side handles. I have played with these over the years, making a bowsaw in their style. The planes are now widely available, at a decent cost they are the only source for new hollows and rounds. The chisels and gouges look a good deal. The similarity make them both appealing, and less interesting, depending on what one is looking for.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#17

Re: Oriental woodworking question - "projects"

TomD

To me one of the oddities of the interest in Japanese tools is that there is relatively little comparable interest in the stuff these tools exist to make. There is some interest in Shoji. Staircase tansu. But overall very little interest. Where little how to, and not even all that much how to with the tools. To some extent it is perhaps an imaginary world, of small Minkas, shoji screens and the countryside somewhere outside the door. The image is more 19th century than real world today.

I think this separation of the tools from their reality suggests that it isn't for the most part a thing like the martial arts, where people have drunk the whole cultural Kool-aid. One does not see that many people with the rising sun bandanas, the sandal sock, making like a Daiku. It could be fun, but it isn't the large part of the point. People seem to use the tools because they have a fascination in themselves, and they are very well made.

Chinese furniture could have it's place. Of course it is nice in it's way. What makes it appealing to me is that some of it combines a simple look, with very unsimple joinery. There are people who want to make simple, say Shaker, furniture, but from a construction perspective it can be beyond boring. The other choice that seems popular is repro stuff from the more ornate end of our pool and a lot of people don't really want that kind of stuff. But so far, while there have in fact been articles in Popular woodworking, as on the Chinese hoop back chair, there have not been the kind of treatment in depth and video that would be necessary to get me up to speed.

This book looks interesting:

Advanced Book Search

Carpentry and building in late imperial China: a study of the fifteenth...

The article that got me going was A Chinese Woodworker by Jason Beebe, in FWW 37. A good issue that. He did a follow-up article on his own work later.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#18

Re: Oriental woodworking question - "projects"

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

The thing I'll always remember about Chinese furniture is Mark Grable's experience. To wit, he built a gorgeous Chinese cloud chair; but he couldn't sell it to anyone at any price.

Pam

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#19

Re: Oriental woodworking question - tools

charlie belden

The "best" tool, without qualification, is a meaningless term.

A cutting tool that takes the finest edge, and yet is the most durable - becomes less than best - if you need half a generation of learning and special stones to sharpen it to that edge again - without destroying its durability.

Being able to get it back to sharp, really really sharp - again - is probably more important in the long run - since NO cutting tool stays sharp forever - unless it's never used.

Yeung Chan makes his own tools - for specific purposes. And his idea of "sharp" goes way beyond what most of think of when we think of "sharp". And because his cutting tools are made for a specific purpose AND he can show you how to get each REALLY sharp - without a $500 machine and $200 worth of special sharpening jigs - they're sharpend - to a finer edge - more often. He uses tradtional chinese joinery in his works - and to make those joints you MUST have very very sharp tools - that don't have to be from Japan.

The Japanese cutting tools are laminates softer iron mainly, with a much harder steel laminated on the cutting end - but only for a short distance back up the tool. The tradition developed out of necessity. Japan didn't have much iron ore, or access to special addatives - chrome, vanadium, cobalt, etc., nor sophisticated blast furnaces. I've read that sword makers really like links from old ship anchor chains. They optimized what they had and kept refining their methods to a degree that only the Japanese seem to do (Tea Ceremony, Bonsai, Gardens, Temples, Archery . . .)

I've seen EverLast chisels that had only an inch left on them - after 20+ years of use. I've never seen or heard of a japanese chisel that's been sharpened down to less than 7/8th the original length- probably because the iron back that far won't take and hold an edge.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#20

Re: Oriental woodworking question - "projects"

charlie belden

Dover Publications has a book on Chinese Furniture first published in the late 20s/early 30s, by a German. The photos are all black and white and the printed images aren't that great but good enough to show the piece if not the fine details. There is a section on the joinery and some plans with dimensions. Paper back - it's under $20. It's the only book I've found that has some plans and some details of how some of the pieces are constructed.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#21

Chris Scholz

That would be Prof. Gustav Ecke...

Chris Scholz

...AFAIK he was American though, at least he taught at the University of Hawaii after he was expelled from China during the crazy times, which BTW hosts a few remaining pieces of his collection.

Prof. Ecke and a group of friends started collection and documenting "Chinese domestic furniture". I guess things that are extraordinary for us were quite ordinary for Chinese and rather unspectacular in the eyes of the Chinese of the late Qing and Republican period.

I have been told that there is quite a bit of Chinese literature on imperial furniture, temples, etc. (including detailed instructions on how to build them). The Lu Ban Jing might be the most important book. The imperial works themselves cranked out stuff in a "proto-industrial" fashion and also set standards for good taste in furniture design.

Clearly some of our own greats (notably Chippendale and G&G) shamelessly copied/were inspired by (your point of view will depend on what side of the table you sit at of course) Chinese furniture, and one could argue that the Baroque and Rococo style was a cheap copy of Qing style aesthetics, or, well, inspired by such.

Nevertheless, with all these well documented and researched facts and authentic antique pieces of zitan furniture fetching astronomical prices at the rare occasions that the are auctioned off, it behoove me that as good as nothing is know about Chinese tools. Maybe, like someone already stated, Chinese furniture that a village carpenter cranks out using old rusty tools of his own make are just to hard to make for spoiled westerners.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#22

Chris Scholz

Re: blame it on Mao

Chris Scholz

All my experience and the sole two interviews I had the pleasure of conducting with traditional Chinese woodworkers indicates that tools were typically made by the woodworker themselves. China went through many episodes of war and peace and had a large weapons industries that flourished and perished. Never heard of swordsmiths turn into woodworkers.

[...] In China during the early Ming and Qing dyanasties the highest level of skill in woodworking was reserved for furniture.



I never heard that but love to learn more. All I know is that carpenters were at the very bottom of the social scale (social hierarchy was largely arranged according Confucian principles). Buildings were pretty much constructed like furniture and vice versa. Amazing temples and official buildings were constructed in wood (ever been to the gugong "Forbidden City" in Bejing?), 9-level pagodas with characteristic roofs around a stone core. Many of the ancient Budhist and Thaoist wooden temples still exist in mailand China.

I highly recommend "Connesseurship of Chinese Furniture" it is a two volume set that is a pretty extensive over view of Chinese design and joinery, it is lacking in information about Chinese wood working tools.

Yes, indeed. Literature geared towards collectors of Classical (and more recently not so classical, aka. vernacular) Furniture is vast and overwhelming. If you are lucky they show a photograph of a few tools. There is as good as no literature on Chinese tools per see (with exception of a few chapters in Hommel's "China at Work").

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#23

disagree with premise

Bill Tindall

"Spoiled Westerners" ? While this pejorative assessment might apply to some, the quality and complexity of pieces of 18th century American and English reproduction furniture being made now days suggests that it is not lack of skill or determination that limits the interest in Chinese reproductions. If modern American furniture makers eschewed the challenge the Society of American Period Furniture Makers (SAPFM)would not have hundreds of members making stuff.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#24

Re: disagree with premise

charlie belden

I think Chris was referring to Week End Warrior Woodworkers, the ones most woodworking magazines are after. And those folks want projects that can be built in a weekend - or two - start to finish - out of wood they can get easily and as inexpensively as possible.

In every culture there are avid enthusiast amateurs and some dedicated professionals who will spend the time and energy - and some money - to make high end, challenging pieces. But they're a very small minority in the woodworkers population

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#25

I'm with Bill

John in NM

There's no lack of skill amongst us spoiled westerners, more likely it's nothing more than differing aesthetics. Most people (not just westerners) tend to prefer something familiar in their furniture, art, architecture, etc. This is why innovators like G&G and Chippendale (amongst others) shamelessly copied details and forms but also copied contemporaneous features. Some would even say they came up with something new as a result.