New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Oriental woodworking question

Posts

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#26

Chris Scholz

Re: disagree with premise

Chris Scholz

Bill, no offense, please.

Of course there are wonderful woodworker all around the world. Our needs and methods, materials and markets are quite different than the ones of the traditional Chinese village carpenter. This is neither good nor bad, it is just what it is.

I like to see "spoiled" as something positive, we just celebrated July 4th in the US, we have achieved a high standard of living after over many generations of hard work. It's something to be proud of!

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#27

Re: Oriental woodworking question - tools

TomD

"The "best" tool, without qualification, is a meaningless term."

Sure but I did qualify it as those tools available (meaning available in the usual places people of the day bought woodworking tools) during the woodworking revival of the 70s-early 80s.

"A cutting tool that takes the finest edge, and yet is the most durable - becomes less than best - if you need half a generation of learning and special stones to sharpen it to that edge again - without destroying its durability."

Yeah, but none of that is truly indicated. There are many ways to get a hair popping edge on a Japanese tool on a learning curve far shorter than most people around here have spent talking about it. I spent a good deal of my first year in "serious" woodwork learning to sharpen tools, which is probably not all that different from the time the average american has spent watching Simon Cowell productions.

I sorta agree with Scott Nearing who is quoted as having said he won't teach people who will not learn to sharpen, because they aren't going anywhere. In the stuff I have managed to do, that has turned out to be true because everything seems to come down to sharpening. There is no more basic skill, whether I am TIG welding a bicycle frame, making a knife, or hand sharpening a chisel, etc...

"Being able to get it back to sharp, really really sharp - again - is probably more important in the long run - since NO cutting tool stays sharp forever - unless it's never used."

Well the tools of that period didn't come sharp, or even relatively near the point where sharp starts to be a question, so anybody who had them sharp was well on their way. The relative value of edge durability varies I would agree. There are situations where it is paramount. The list that goes into what made Japanese tools of the day the best, is a very long one and would not be edge durability alone. I should say the saws came ready to use.

"Yeung Chan makes his own tools - for specific purposes. And his idea of "sharp" goes way beyond what most of think of when we think of "sharp". And because his cutting tools are made for a specific purpose AND he can show you how to get each REALLY sharp - without a $500 machine and $200 worth of special sharpening jigs - they're sharpend - to a finer edge - more often. He uses tradtional chinese joinery in his works - and to make those joints you MUST have very very sharp tools - that don't have to be from Japan."

YC came onto the woodworking scene in the US possibly about 20 + years after the period in question. He is a graduate of the College of the Redwoods program, that Krenov started, and Krenov would have at the time I addressed been saying much the same things I mentioned in my post, relative to Japanese tools, where he used both the saws and the chisels.

"The Japanese cutting tools are laminates softer iron mainly, with a much harder steel laminated on the cutting end - but only for a short distance back up the tool. The tradition developed out of necessity."

Maybe. Who really knows. Japanese tools of the type we speak are a relatively recent invention. In theory the 1876 (?) ban of the manufacture of the swords led to the woodworking tool style we revere today. That is the story, one wonders. So the tools are less than 200 years old, in their current perfection and metallurgy. Well within a period in which Japan had wide access to trade goods. All Japanese swords had the same bimetal construction to them. The Yin and Yang aspect alone, the temper line are enough in themselves. I do not believe they were made using iron because iron is cheap. I don't doubt they may have evolved from those roots.

" Japan didn't have much iron ore, or access to special addatives - chrome, vanadium, cobalt, etc., nor sophisticated blast furnaces."

That seems to have been an advantage. Those countries with industrialization drove the quality of their hand woodworking tools largely into the ground. You can vary the means if you retain the goal. But then hand made suits degenerated into sweats and t-shirts.

"I've read that sword makers really like links from old ship anchor chains. They optimized what they had and kept refining their methods to a degree that only the Japanese seem to do (Tea Ceremony, Bonsai, Gardens, Temples, Archery . . .)"

Yeah, in theory those chains have impurities that not only look interesting, but help clean the stones. That said, I was on a US knife board at one point, and a guy had scored some nice wrought iron and was selling off stuff he wasn't using. It was old anchor chains from the scrap yard. It takes 720 feet to anchor with normal scope in 40 fathoms, so maybe there is just a lot of the stuff around...

"I've seen EverLast chisels that had only an inch left on them - after 20+ years of use. I've never seen or heard of a japanese chisel that's been sharpened down to less than 7/8th the original length- probably because the iron back that far won't take and hold an edge."

You obviously haven't spent much time on Ebay. :) In theory Japanese users are proud of their very short Japanese chisels. You can use the chisels pretty much right down to the end, so there is only the shoulder left. You could use that if you didn't mind loosing the full width dimension. The whole chisel has a hardened back.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#28

Re: Oriental woodworking question - tools

Sam Takeuchi

""I've seen EverLast chisels that had only an inch left on them - after 20+ years of use. I've never seen or heard of a japanese chisel that's been sharpened down to less than 7/8th the original length- probably because the iron back that far won't take and hold an edge."

You obviously haven't spent much time on Ebay. :) In theory Japanese users are proud of their very short Japanese chisels. You can use the chisels pretty much right down to the end, so there is only the shoulder left. You could use that if you didn't mind loosing the full width dimension. The whole chisel has a hardened back. "

I don't think Charlie has much experience with Japanese tools or use them. If he spent a few minutes with Japanese chisels, he would know that the hard steel pretty much forms the entire non-bevel side all the way to the shoulder. Even just by looking at the picture, it's not hard to tell. If he hasn't seen Japanese chisels used nearly to the shoulder, he hasn't even looked for old or well used Japanese chisels. It's not even a rarity. Maybe not so common outside of Japan, but in Japan, they are pretty common.

Do you know why they keep laminated construction even now? Because it helps with sharpening. Boat anchors and other old irons are quite well suited for chisel and plane blades backing iron for their sharpening quality and structural property. And yes, ease of sharpening is a very important quality in Japanese tools and blacksmiths incorporates different irons to achieve different sharpening qualities. Not all soft irons behave the same way and more often than not, certain soft iron are paired up with certain edge steel in order to achieve good balance of sharpening.

If you think it takes such a long time to learn to sharpen or need special stones to achieve the kind of sharpness that make Japanese tools worthwhile, I don't know what to say to you. All I can say is that your "guess" is totally off the mark. Anyone can learn to sharpen and achieve good edge in a reasonable period of time not unlike non-Japanese tools. Just because it's Japanese doesn't change the fact it is still a blade and it doesn't require special process to achieve a very good edge. However you can't mindlessly just rub the blade over the stone and hope it'll come out ok, so you do have to acquire skill in sharpening, but that goes for any edge tools.

While I think enthusiastic discussion is good, but so far, there's a lot of misinformation peddled around. I'm not here to say "oh Japanese tools are the best". I don't even use them for variety of reasons, but my background is with Japanese tools. Normally I don't care to chime in, but really, it's getting bit ridiculous.

http://www7b.biglobe.ne.jp/~kodawaridaiku/nomi/IMG_1032.jpg

http://www.tsune36.co.jp/repair.html

Scroll down 3/4 of the way for the plane blade picture (from Tsunesaburo)

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#29

Re: Oriental woodworking question

James Watriss

I think the reason you're looking for is implied in your question. Of course Popular woodworking won't get into it. Neither will FWW, much... though I found this image on the FWW forums.

These publications have currently defined themselves around beginners. PWW has stretched a bit, and seems to be aiming for the 'doing it for a year or two,' group, but they still cover the basics with regularity. If you want a real head scratcher, you need to look through old issues of FWW, when they talked about making and tempering your own tools, building wooden clocks, or anything else that was pretty much NOT doable with off-the-shelf technology.

I know the following statement will make me unpopular. But I think that a demographic that still feels the need to rehash the dovetail joint on a regular basis will be inspired and intimidated by joinery like this... but their experience in making it will likely be disheartening, and possibly even enough to send them looking for a new hobby. Not exactly the way to sell a magazine. Same goes for making a shoji door with the traditional joint that laps on the back, and miters in the front. Cutting *one* of those joints, is challenging enough. Cutting a bunch of them, spaced evenly enough to make a nice-looking door, is going to be doable for most woodworkers who have grown beyond what they read in a mag that they buy at Home Depot.

I'm sure when they figure out a way to make stuff like this in a weekend, with a Domino tool and a L-N shooting board plane, we'll be sure to hear more about it.


img

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#30

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Interesting Question *LINK*

Jim in Burlington ON

My thoughts are that steel made by Japanese blacksmiths was so advanced that high end tools were far more plentiful. Some would debate this point. I have looked at Indian antiques and they are few and far between. China has some very fine pieces indeed. Given the size of most living quarters in these countries a condiserable number of fine boxes were made instead of larger pieces of furnture. In Toronto there is quite a large antique market to view. Five O Seven antiques has more european ultra high end stuff than you could look at in a lifetime.

http://www.507antiques.com/


http://www.greenteadesign.com/asian-furniture.html

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#31

Chris Scholz

Yup, that's how they do it...

Chris Scholz

...and if you are very lucky you find a traditional master who takes you to his shop in a back alley.


And sure enough, that's how the build them:


The assembled table:


Some crude machinery is involved these days (more on this later). For example, making a screen like this without any power tools takes a skilled Chinese woodworker 1-2 month, with the aid of power tools they can do it in 2-3 weeks.


Re: Oriental woodworking question

#32

OK - so please educate me

charlie belden

The following photos are on an Iyoroi 24mm chisel I picked up at Dick Fine Tools in Metten, Germany.

Image 1 is about actual size - a shot of the back.


Image 2 is a detail shot of the back of the chisel showing what appears to be a hollow grind on the back - as I purchased it - and put there presumably by the chisel's maker


Image 3 is a detail shot showing the top and bevel with what appears to me to be evidence of steel laminated over the chisels base body.


Here's my question - illustrated


I've been told that the hollow grind on the bottom was to make it easier to "lap" the bottom of the chisel - less metal to remove therefore quicker and easier to lap.

Because the cutting edge is the intersection of two planes - the bevel AND the back/bottom of the chisel - to get a straight cutting edge - both must be FLAT - at list for the first 1/16" to 1/8" behind the edge. To get that intersection of two FLAT planes - the bottom/back of the chisel must be flat - for 1/16" to 1/8" behind the cutting edge. But because of the hollow grind on the back/bottom - when the chisel is ground back into it - after many sharpenings - the arc of the hollow grind would put an arc on the cutting edge where you want a straight line.

If you relap the back/bottom to restore a straight line at the cutting edge one of two things seems as though must happen

- either you'd think the harder laminated steel on the bottom/back

or

- some of the cutting edge would be the harder laminated steel - and more and more in the middle of the cutting edge would be the softer steel of the body.

So which parts of my understanding of Japanese chisels is wrong - and why? I'm always up for leaening - so educate me please.

As for seeing stubby Japanese chisels - I assumed they were made that way - analogous to shorter "blade" and shorter handled "butt chisels" - done for better control when using a mallet (the steel ring on the top of my two Japanese chisels are then to prevent the hornbean handles from mushrooming when struck by a mallet - or hammer.

(I need to find my copy of Odate's book - and reread it! It's been 8 to 10 years since I last read it.)

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#33

Re: OK - so please educate me *LINK*

wilbur

Simple answer: the hollow on the back of a Japanese chisel is relatively shallow towards the cutting edge and gets deeper as you go towards the handle. Couple that with working the back of the chisel as you sharpen, and you'll maintain the flat behind the cutting edge and keep the hollow as you wear away the chisel. As you move back, the hard steel layer may be a bit thinner, but not enough to make a real difference in the performance of the chisel. The depth of the hollow is only about 1/64-1/32" at most.

Your diagram has a few points that need to be corrected. First, the hollow remains in the hard layer and does not touch the soft layer. Second, the hard layer is only at the bottom and does not come all the way around the top as you have in your diagram.

I have a more detailed explanation in my blog, linked below.


Hollows in Japanese chisels

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#34

Re: OK - so please educate me

TomD

- The core is Iron, not lower grade steel, like a mild steel

- Backs are ground, but they are also forged in, so the material thickness is not compromised. The hwole chisel is both forged and ground more or less on all it's surfaces. This is typical forging technique/post-forging technique.

- "'ve been told that the hollow grind on the bottom was to make it easier to "lap" the bottom of the chisel less metal to remove therefore quicker and easier to lap."

This is often given as an explanation. I don't really buy if for several reasons. First the technology level, and pride level are such that they could pre-grind the backs flat if they felt like it, an there are a few chisels that don't come with the hollows and are pre-ground.

Second the hollow might make it faster to level the back manually, but over the lifetime of the chisel it makes maters much worse, because there is a big honking divot in the chisel that needs to be ground out.

The sensible reason for the hollow, is that it makes the surface area of the back and bevel closer in area, to a point where working both surfaces with each sharpening yields a relatively more equal surface area of hard steel. This allows both surfaces to be polished more perfectly and for a sharper edge to be formed. The hollow is a hassle over the lifetime of the chisel prep wise, but and advantage performance wise.

- "the arc of the hollow grind would put an arc on the cutting edge where you want a straight line."

You have two options, tapping out the edge, which is the process of deflecting it downward from the bevel side. This pushes more material into the aft edge area. This is possible to do, since the majority of material in the blade is soft iron. This is the preferred method on plane blades and works on chisels also. With chisels though, one can also just grind the back down through sharpening. Odate mentions this as the preferred method with chisels. Both work.

"

- some of the cutting edge would be the harder laminated steel - and more and more in the middle of the cutting edge would be the softer steel of the body."

Not a problem because the hollow is partially forged in. so steel thickness is thicker than you might imagine, and also because steel thickness is sufficient that even if it weren't forged in there is enough there.

"As for seeing stubby Japanese chisels - I assumed they were made that way - analogous to shorter "blade" and shorter handled "butt chisels" - done for better control when using a mallet"

There are different aspect ration blades, like the butts and the temple carpenter chisels, etc.. But I am talking about a far more radical alteration than that. Look at your image two. move up the parallel section of the blade to the shoulder where the rounding commences. Draw a staight line across there. That is the kind of reduction I am talking about. It isn't just a proportionally smaller chisel. I think the Kodansha book on Nakashima shows an example of a worn set. But either way, they do show up on ebay, in totally consumed state.

(the steel ring on the top of my two Japanese chisels are then to prevent the hornbean handles from mushrooming when struck by a mallet - or hammer.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#35

Re: OK - so please educate me

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

At a certian point in the wear of a japanese chisel the flat at the leading edge disapears and needs to be re-established by skillfully tapping the bevel with a hammer while the back is on an anvil. I believe there is a special hammer that is used for this as well as a special stake anvil.

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#36

Re: OK - so please educate me

TomD

That's the distinction with the chisels, normally they aren't tapped out. I don't know why, but it could be that hammering away on a 1/16" chisel to deflect it is too risky. I have tapped out big blades and the whole thing was a lot eaier than I expected. The machines to do it, also wouldn't tap out the small blades,, for the same kind of reason there might be difficulty getting tem held in a sharpening jig.

Here is an auction on ebay for a chisel that is half worn, aand one can see th hollow has been ground down: 230646567919

And another: 270783668944

Re: Oriental woodworking question

#37

Re: OK - so please educate me

wilbur

Although you can tap out a wide Japanese chisel, you don't have to, even on the wide chisels. As I mentioned above, the hollow of a Japanese chisel gets deeper as you move further back towards the handle. If the cutting edge gets close to the hollow, then working the back of the chisel reestablishes the land in back of the edge, and the fact that the hollow is deeper towards the handle prevents the entire hollow from being worn away.