New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Stropping Test *LINK*

Posts

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#76

Re: I don't think so

Frank D. in Montreal

For sure for unfinished pieces a planed surface is superior. I'm not so sure it's so much the dust (although I'm not claiming to know) as the difference in reflection of light on the surface. Most if not all of the dust can be removed from a sanded surface.

I remember the test in FWW and that wasn't the basis of my conviction, although it did confirm a few things. I too abhor most of their tests on tools or finishes or rust prevention or joint strength. This said, to say that they are dishonest (rigging a test is dishonest even if the orders to do so came from the employer) with no proof is...not the most honest form of argument. The fact that they make money from the magazine doesn't necessarily make a bad test a dishonest one.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#77

Re: *chuckle*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, Matsumura are sold by Japan Woodworker, who I'm sure were the ones advertising in FWW.

Pam

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#78

Re: I don't think so

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, well I have no desire to continue reading FWW, therefore no dog in this hunt. A once fine inspiration gone to seed.

Pam

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#79

Re: I don't think so

David Weaver

How often are the tools not from their advertisers?

I'm not accusing them of anything specific, but I thought it kind of odd they chose matsumura chisels when iyoroi chisels were more well known.

That itself was a lack of diligence in work, I think, to not try to find out what japanese chisels were actually good. I would imagine if they called JWW, they would've gotten the matsumuras, and maybe that's what they did.

Presumably JWW advertises in FWW? But maybe they don't.

Does Hida?

Maybe everyone who makes tools basically does, it's been several years since I got an issue of FWW. They send me postcards from time to time to tell me what a special deal they're going to give me - regular subscriber's price (wow, who could resist a 0% discount?) - or to tell me how my skills have been diminishing without their publication.

That said, if the person doing the article tests went to any japanese tool forum online and said "what's a good moderately priced japanese chisel" when that article was written, the tone of the responses would've led the reviewer to imai chisels at the time and not matsumura.

A lot of the rest of the tests seem aimed at pushing their high volume products, like sanders and 14 inch bandsaws. Maybe that's their duty to talk about that stuff since it will attract new subscribers, but it sure wasn't stimulating to someone who has no interest in a 14 inch bandsaw or more sanders.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#80

Re: I don't think so

TomD

"How often are the tools not from their advertisers?"

It can certainly happen, but the reality is people want to be marketed to. The tone around here amps up quite a bit when there is a new toy on offer. People like consumerism. It makes sense to review tools that support long term advertisers, and also from manufacturers and suppliers that can handle the demand an article may generate. They may sprinkle in a few cool tools but people will pressumably gravitate to the better represented products.

"That itself was a lack of diligence in work, I think, to not try to find out what japanese chisels were actually good. I would imagine if they called JWW, they would've gotten the matsumuras, and maybe that's what they did."

What little business dealings I have had with FWW were very satisfactory, among the best long term out there. In some magazine segments it is all about selling products through placement. They won't mention the sky unless god gives them a kickback. Often non-core products, like cars, airline, etc... are all pre-contacted, and sold before a word hits the paper. I think FWW has made statements about their tests saying they are impartial, and that is good enough for me. But there are lots of ways to skew tests. One is to get a complete tyro to write the copy. "I have never owned any quality chisels before, and I was really looking forward to the chance to put down the router and try my hand at sharpening..." So you give the writer a few samples from known advertisers, and turn him loose. You can rely on his not getting too off base, and maybe he will call the supplier for a few tips and quotes. This also works with the average tyro reader, who doesn't like being talked down to. I have read a few of those.

"Presumably JWW advertises in FWW? But maybe they don't.

Does Hida?"

Yup. For a long, long time. Which is a good thing, people know they will be there, and that they are supporting the segment. Given the stability in prices they are a virtual market maker.

"That said, if the person doing the article tests went to any japanese tool forum online and said "what's a good moderately priced japanese chisel" when that article was written, the tone of the responses would've led the reviewer to imai chisels at the time and not matsumura."

That isn't necesarilly all that representative either. JWW has been at it for over 30 years. People on forums come and go, and tend to be all abuzz about the lattest and greatest. I remember the great Shaptons bubble. They don't get the returns, etc... Anyway, a wise editor won't ask a question he doesn't already know the answer to...

"A lot of the rest of the tests seem aimed at pushing their high volume products, like sanders and 14 inch bandsaws. Maybe that's their duty to talk about that stuff since it will attract new subscribers, but it sure wasn't stimulating to someone who has no interest in a 14 inch bandsaw or more sanders."

Interesting metric is to know how long the average reader sticks with a publication. The early FWW was a potential lifetime subscription. Today I would be surprised if it's longer than 3 years. The money is in turning people and selling them all the stuff they need when they start up, then moving on to the next person. Bride mag is a good example of that. The best long term mag I have personally been exposed to is Wooden Boat. It has stayed relevant to it's readers for decades, but that is rare. Most of the esoteric stuff will not pay the bills, and exists to build the magazine's profile so that the people buying the bandsaws will have high confidence that FWW s actually reliable.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#81

Re: I don't think so

David Weaver

I think once they pick the tools, their review is fair and impartial. Hopefully, I didn't make it seem like I thought the results were predetermined.

I just don't like what they pick, but they aren't out looking for the best when they pick, I guess, they're looking for what's popular and what's commonly known.

I found myself too often saying to myself "but what about this brand?" when it didn't show up in the reviews. I can't remember what really made me let the subscription lapse, but it was probably a combination of things.

I would probably have renewed one round of the magazine if they'd have had any offer, but still would've probably let it lapse after that. What didn't help at all was the tone of their renewal offers "you're so lucky, we'll let you renew for full price, we know you forgot our wonderful magazine, you're lucky we're reminding you", and "your skills are already diminishing because you're not getting our magazines".

I do think, though, that they run a professional operation, and they're as accurate as they can be, that's my opinion. I just get the sense that they think they're a lot better than they really are, and maybe that's because the magazine was better in the past, and they haven't really had the attitude adjustment that they need. PWW, I suppose gave it to them for a little bit, but I don't get enough out of that now that they jumped the price, and also let that lapse.

They are not close to as obnoxious as music magazines and guitar magazines, though. Everything they ever review is "an awesome deal that deserves to be bought right away!!!".

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#82

Re: I don't think so

TomD

"I think once they pick the tools, their review is fair and impartial. Hopefully, I didn't make it seem like I thought the results were predetermined."

It's like the Pepsi taste test campaign. They knew people preferred the sweeter Pepsi in taste tests, but not as an every day drink. So Pepsi did the taste test thing. Why lie or cheat when you can get where you want to go with no impropriety at all. And it does mean something that people preferred Pepsi, even if it didn't mean they preferred it overall.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#83

Re: I don't think so

wilbur

Historically, Japan Woodworker, Hida Tool, and the late great Misugi Designs consistently placed ads in Fine Woodworking.

Back in the day, Fine Woodworking covered Japanese tools quite well, at least in explaining methods and technique. Lately they've done a poor job, as evidenced by Garrett Hack's recent articles on the FWW website on his trip to Japan. Besides getting some facts wrong, he doesn't even mention the names of the Japanese woodworkers and tool makers that he visited. From reading between the lines, ("a father and son pair of blacksmiths") it appears that he met with Akio and Michio Tasai on this trip. To visit them and not identify them by name is like being given a tour of the Lie-Nielsen facility and referring to "the skinny guy with gray hair and mustache wearing a vest".

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#84

Re: I don't think so

David Weaver

I felt the same way about that one, I liked coke better, but given the two, your initial preference will always be to go with the one with the stronger sweetness.

Reminds me of guitar shopping. A long time ago when Taylor just started getting big, it seemed to me that their guitars always sounded brighter and more fundamental. At least brighter and louder. Someone told me that they made guitars with thinner tops than the traditional makers.

Well, when you go into an enclosed room, you play two guitars, a new one of another with lots of overtones and less outright punch and brightness will sound a little sick. It is, to my ears, a better tone, but it is hard to convince you brain of that when your brain is just saying "well, that other one is a lot louder, go with the louder one".

So, you end up getting a guitar with loud strong tone that after you've had it a while, is kind of grating, and that doesn't record like you'd want, anyway, where you want a tone and not a volume.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#85

Re: I don't think so

David Weaver

I can imagine seeing TLN as an unwashed and saying "hey, that guy looks sort of like roy, but a little different".

My subscriptions all lapsed before hack's article, but that's Ok, i would've had the same questions you're mentioning - "who is that guy? who is the other guy?", because if nobody gives you details, how do you look further when you're done with the article?

I saw some of the video clips online and if the article was anything like the clips, it would have only been remotely interesting to people who never used japanese tools.

For quite a long time (when I first started woodworking, and was using mostly power tools), I thought from reading JWW and FWW that there was reform grade, matsumura, iyoroi and tasai. I didn't kid myself about buying any tasai chisels, but who'd have known about all of these other guys out there?

Only when I lucked into an inukubi nakano plane for cheap did I have the inclination to start trying to find out who else was making tools and what makes good ones. And it's not easy, because nothing is in english on the web or on youtube.

Unfortunately, misugi designs was long gone, but most of the stuff they sold might've been above my cost threshhold.

I have had some luck finding things on youtube and on google now by going to google translate, guessing at random phrases, and then taking whatever comes out of the other end and putting it in the search box on youtube or google. Sometimes you get what you expect, and sometimes you get nothing related, but it's a good way to find subscription material on youtube.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#86

Re: I don't think so

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Unfortunately, misugi designs was long gone, but most of the stuff they sold might've been above my cost threshhold.

Maybe, really can't guess about "most" without a catalog; but Kayoko was always more cost conscious than I was, pushing cheaper saws and planes, reminding me $500 was a lot of money for a saw, and similar stuff.

Pam

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#87

Re: I don't think so

David Weaver

I would agree - $500 is a lot for a saw.

i don't like using softwoods that much, so the higher end saws have not gotten along with me that well, and I'm headed out of them to western saws, anyway.

The first taper ground non-impulse hardened saw I ever got, I pinged two teeth off of it the first day I had it.

I recall folks relaying some of the advice they got, being that people should expect to pay about $750 for a good natural stone to get the most out of their tools. There is definitely truth that the best natural stones are really nice to use, but I'd consider that to be over the top for amateurs unless those amateurs were doing really really fine work.

I would like to have been able to pick and choose tools when the exchange rate was 120:1, though. I've been limited mostly to used tools or NOS for the last two years because of that. I did get an imai chisel in the mail yesterday, though - a firmer with white steel. We'll see how it does.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#88

Couple questions/ideas

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

Great thread, lots of ideas here.

Couple questions:

- Could it be possible that the 1/4 micron on CI results are due to the fact that the CI surface is not smooth enough? I'm picturing a Blanchard ground surface to which diamonds are embedded in. The diamonds on the "peaks" of the surface would be the only ones doing the work, therefore resulting in little difference in scratch pattern with the 1 micron paste. What if the CI surface was polished to a mirror? Seems to me that the smaller the abrasive the smoother the substrate has to be...

- From what I read here, stropping is as much "shaping" the edge as anything else. Have you tried stropping with just plain boxwood (i.e. no diamond paste)? Just curious...

DC

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#89

Couple of sorta answers

Steve Elliott

The Blanchard ground surface has had so much use that most of the circular witness marks from the grinding are gone. It's become shinier and slightly dished with lots of use. Yesterday I put it on an 800x waterstone and then some w/d sandpaper to get it flat again, so now it has various non-diamond abrasive grits on it. The last time I did this I was doing thread-cutting tests for sharpness and found that it took a little bit of use before the sharpness of the edges was back to where they had been before the plate was flattened.

Since the cast iron plate was the one I normally used for 1 micron diamond I'm sure there were some larger grits embedded, but this test was done after repeated honings with 1/4 micron and the appearance of the edge under the microscope was the same as every other 1/4 micron edge I've done using cast iron.

I tried both uncharged boxwood and uncharged leather on the 1/4 micron diamond honed edge and saw no effect from either. That was when I added 1/4 micron diamond to the boxwood and saw the scratch pattern disappear under the microscope. I tried the uncharged leather to see what effect that would have (the few scratches that appeared in the images I posted) and then charged the leather with 1/4 micron diamond and got edges that were similar to the diamond-on-boxwood ones except with a few deeper scratches that increased as I continued to strop.

Overall the leather charged with fine diamond almost equaled the boxwood charged with diamond and the leather conformed to the shape of the edge in a way the boxwood didn�t. I can understand why leather stropping is a useful technique but it�s my guess that the �plain leather� strops that work well have accumulated some kind of grit over the years.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#90

Re: I don't think so

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I expect top quality hand made tools to be expensive and a pleasure to use.

Pam