Re: irrelevant metric?
David Weaver
If you do it right, it takes no longer. For cambered plane irons, grind the iron however you would normally grind it, then for maintenance honing, one or two passes across a 1200 grit belt and then same on a 1/2 micron moving leather strop, and a quick lap of the back on a finish stone.
Actually, I'll guarantee that nobody with stones only will do the job as fast, and the cost of the belt grinder is about $150.
With a smoother, manage the size of the flats on a hollow grind with a bench grinder (or use a flat grind and microbevels, whatever is wanted), and again, two stones - one in the 1000 grit range and then whatever the finish stone may be. For me, a 1 micron stone. There is no need to play around with a strop then.
Same with a chisel, two stones and a grinder, no strop.
The claim that you can't go to a fine edge and do it quickly is false.
One of the other posts that said something about what the durability of the edge may be? If the geometry is the same as the "utility edge" (whatever that's supposed to be), then the more finely honed edge will last longer. It will be smoother at stroke one and smoother at stroke 100.
plan on using .25 micron paste on a home-brewed-lansky-type jig and if it holds up ok, as a fine hone too.



