New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Stropping Test *LINK*

Posts

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#26

Re: irrelevant metric?

David Weaver

If you do it right, it takes no longer. For cambered plane irons, grind the iron however you would normally grind it, then for maintenance honing, one or two passes across a 1200 grit belt and then same on a 1/2 micron moving leather strop, and a quick lap of the back on a finish stone.

Actually, I'll guarantee that nobody with stones only will do the job as fast, and the cost of the belt grinder is about $150.

With a smoother, manage the size of the flats on a hollow grind with a bench grinder (or use a flat grind and microbevels, whatever is wanted), and again, two stones - one in the 1000 grit range and then whatever the finish stone may be. For me, a 1 micron stone. There is no need to play around with a strop then.

Same with a chisel, two stones and a grinder, no strop.

The claim that you can't go to a fine edge and do it quickly is false.

One of the other posts that said something about what the durability of the edge may be? If the geometry is the same as the "utility edge" (whatever that's supposed to be), then the more finely honed edge will last longer. It will be smoother at stroke one and smoother at stroke 100.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#27

Both are relevant objectives

Bill Tindall

I will be that the razor blade companies know all there is to know about sharpening for the objective of ultimate sharpness. Some day I will see if I can crack into that literature.

Another field that demands ultimate sharpness is microtoning (this doesn't look like it is spelled right?) for the preparation of thin sections of specimens for microscopy. If you think planing end grain is demanding.....! I'll see what I can dig up on microtoning technology. Carbon steel blades are used. I have one.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#28

Re: irrelevant metric?

TomD

While I don't doubt there are cases where a super sharp edge is less durable, or beside the point. In most of my experience, you get extra edge durability from super sharp edges. And in a standard cost benefit analysis it would win out. But I am sure one could conspire to be disappointed also.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#29

Re: Both are relevant objectives

TomD

I remember once reading in PM that Gillette simply sharpened their blade to the next level, when they went through the whole add a blade, add a strip thing. That most of the improvement was in sharpening.

On the other hand, if they all understand it so well, one would wonder why they never make blades to the Merkur level, etc...

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#30

Re: irrelevant metric?

TomD

"I wonder about that sort of thing too Bill. My question I suppose is, is there quantifiable benefit to a working furniture maker in aiming for these super sharpened tools?"

Everyone's idea of super sharp might vary, but very very sharp, super good, does last longer. One way to look at it is as a smother edge that attracts less drag. There is some kind of proportionality between the low resistance in the cut, and the low wear to the edge. BUt it is also probably something with a lot of variables.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#31

Re: Warren you are spot on in this case

TomD

I am not so sure the carving example is apt, except obviously for carvers. They often work soft wood. The are often making cuts with very little scraping component, as in planing. They do not work to the fine dimensions that some of us do. The work they do can be of the highest order, but rarely because they lifted off a shaving that was a few tens thick. The shape of the tool needs to be appropriate, but it can vary within some significant margin, for instance be the product of hand forging. Of course a lot of cabinet type work does not require those dimensions either. But it can.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#32

Re: Finally, the statement I've been looking for..

TomD

"Sometimes it seems as if I shouldn't even be posting here with the big boys (sorry, Pam) since I can't even begin to afford to do the testing necessary to discern the best possible methods."

Post about something else, please god! This place, and the traffic may reflect it, is the zone of deminishing returns. There seems to be some underlying myth that there aren't already ways of sharpening tools, sharp enough.

It's just one of those things. If you start a thread about planing fly rods, you might find 1% trully interested. But a thread on how to sharpen the planes that someone happens to use to plane rods, is near universal. That is as much because it is banal, as anything else.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#33

Posting with the big boys

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

No offense, I can't keep up with these guys either. All I want to do is make some chisels without forging (cpm 3v) and some way to adequately sharpen it (diamonds). This discussion about flat media is very interesting, but not critical for my needs (diamonds and cast iron have been specified and bought, not likely to buy anything else until I've tried what I have. Nice to think that if the cast iron doesn't turn out to be optimal, perhaps a very hard wood is a reasonable substitute.

Pam

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#34

Re: Both are relevant objectives

darin

Razor blades are sharpened to 1000 grit with a diamond wheel. At least that was the state of the art in the 80s when Gillet updated its manufacturing.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#35

Re: Stropping Test

joel moskowitz

Steve,

what kind of steel was the iron? Did you work both sides evenly? The point of stropping is to remove what is left of the wire edge without significantly altering the bevel. Carvers and barbers use charged leather hones (and they call it stropping but it actually isn't) because the leather is forgiving and follows the contour of the tool - but it is a form of honing not removing the burr.

joel

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#36

Re: Both are relevant objectives

David Weaver

They are honed much further than that.. that may be what they're ground with.

check Brent Beach's pictures.

If you've ever attempted to get the same initial sharpness as a feather blade or a disposable razor, you'll probably have had experience with a razor blade that went to the strop too early (and the corresponding razor burn).

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#37

Re: Stropping Test

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used a straight razor for 42 years and have never dressed the strop. Some barbers put abrasive paste on a special strop to avoid honing, but the barbers I have talked to use another, a clean strop for stropping.

I also use a clean strop for carving tools. It was kind of interesting reading speculations about my carving habits in posts above. I carve almost exclusively hardwoods. I have the most trade in white oak and black walnut. In 33 years, none of my carving tools have seen a grinder or a grindstone.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#38

Re: Stropping Test

TomD

"In 33 years, none of my carving tools have seen a grinder or a grindstone."

That sounds about right, but 33.5 years ago...

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#39

Well,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

the finest diamond I can find locally (and having a limited amount of patience) is 1 micron, so after my sojourn to Mpls and Woodcraft Saturday, I flattened a chunk of maple and applied that diamond paste. Uffda! did that make short work of that A2 blade from my LV shoulder plane!

Thanks! That's just exactly what I needed to know.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#40

Re: Stropping Test

joel moskowitz

Exactly. A strop with compound for honing on a forgiving soft substrate. A clean strop for final removal of the wire edge for the best edge.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#41

Re: Stropping Test

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Sure, all the tools were nicely ground at the factory by skilled workers. Some still show the straw color from tempering. They still need hand work to be usable, and once in good shape, it would kind of barbaric to put them to a grinder.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#42

Re: Stropping Test

Steve Elliott

I've done this test on two blades, A2 and CPM 3V, with identical results except for the number of strokes needed to eliminate the last of the scratches. The 3V took at least 3 times the number of strokes.

The images I posted were of 3V. Yesterday I rehoned that blade using � micron diamond on cast iron (lots of scratches) and stropped on leather loaded with � micron diamond. The result was similar to the boxwood test except that there were always some scratches, as if new ones were being made while older ones were being removed. It could just be that the particular piece of leather I'm using has been contaminated at some point so I don't want to generalize too much based on one strop.

I worked both surfaces equally, so 20 strokes means 20 on the bevel and 20 on the back. I alternated 5 strokes at a time.

One advantage of the leather was that it conformed to the shape of the edge. The boxwood had a slight crown and the blade ended up with areas near the corners that weren't fully stropped.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#43

Speculation would be quelled if.....

Bill Tindall

you would post pictures of some of your work.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#44

Re: irrelevant metric?

Sgian Dubh

David, generally speaking with all my cutting tools such as bench chisels and plane irons, I grind them on a standard grinder giving me a hollow grind. After that I sharpen a honing angle with an 800 grit ceramic stone and finish off by doing a bit of flipping (stropping) of the tool edge on the palm of my hand.

I don't often do any more than that for bench chisels and planes-- for 95% of work undertaken that's always been satisfactory. Resharpening itself takes anything from about 20 seconds to maybe a couple of minutes. If I feel the need for a more refined edge (almost exclusively on smoothing planes and block plane irons) I move on from the 800 grit stone to a 2000 grit ceramic stone, followed again by a bit of palm flipping of the sharpened edge before reuse of the tool or reassembly of the tool before use.

The description of my most often employed routine above seems perhaps just slightly less involved than the steps you described. Anyway, it works effectively enough. I usually seem to spend about as much time, or a bit more, on the flat side of the blade as I do on the bevelled side. Slainte.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#45

Re: irrelevant metric?

Sgian Dubh

You may well be right Tom; there are likely to be a lot of variables. I suppose one of the main drivers for me has always been do whatever is needed to get the job done and out of the door. It's often the case that a planed surface, eg a table top, doesn't need to be perfect straight off the plane anyway because there are always scrapers and abrasives solutions.

I know of almost no working furniture makers that put polish or finish straight over a planed surface as almost without exception there's some scraping and sanding done after planing and before finishing. The only exceptions to that I know of are those manufacturers that generally produce a certain country style of furniture. These products are mostly oak, elm, ash, chestnut, etc and prepped using things like adzes, and excessively cambered blades in smoothing planes, block planes and spokeshaves. Here the makers are are usually after that undulating slightly torn out grain look. Slainte.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#46

Re: Stropping Test

joel moskowitz

The wire edge of A2 is more brittle than o1 so the effect of stropping is less. I have never worked with 3V but my guess is that it is so tough that your burr cannot be turned by plain leather. It's possible one photo shows leather being caught on the residual burr and the burr isn't being removed.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#47

Re: Stropping Test

anotherBob

I only have/had one little block of pink ivory, so I sliced it up a while back, stickered then thickness sanded. Finished epoxying the strips to some alum and ply I had prepped earlier... gonna give it a day to finish curing then flatten/level with the router skiis. Thanks for the motivation to get it off the back burner... :) plan on using .25 micron paste on a home-brewed-lansky-type jig and if it holds up ok, as a fine hone too.


Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#48

Re: Stropping Test

Steve Elliott

My boxwood is 1/8" thick strips glued to both sides of a 1/4" piece of plywood. I didn't want to waste a big chunk of wood on something that might not work out.

I've found the surface to last a long time, unlike maple or cherry. I've cleaned it off multiple times using a paper towel moistened with mineral spirits, which takes off almost all of the black gunk.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#49

What is being imaged by the microscope

Bill Tindall

So I go to the fireworks last night and I am looking for a spot to sit and I hear a voice. It is the guy from the microscopy lab. I ask, "can you see 1 micron scratches"? "No, can't resolve something that small", was the reply.

However, he went on to say that reflections from points much smaller than the resolution of the microscope can be seen/detected. So, if the surface of the metal has scratches of less than a few microns, such as what would result from submicron sized abrasive particles, then what is being imaged are reflections from some part of the scratch that reflects a point source of light. What appears as scratches in the photos result from scratches, but the scratch itself is not being seen. He went on to say that such images may not represent the topography of the surface because the actual surface structure is not being resolved, just bits and pieces of it that reflect light toward the objective of the microscope.

When asked why the "scratch image" disappears after the wood abrasion he could not speculate except to say that what ever was reflecting in the "scratch images" was gone or altered. Clearly the scratch pattern is different from the wood substrate but it remains unknown how it is different, or what potential benefit might result from the alteration.

Recall that Mr. Lee is buying a scanning electron microscope to support their work. This device has greater resolving power as well as greater depth of field. No doubt his group ran into this same limitation of optical microscopy for supporting their sharpening/dulling studies.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#50

There is a bit of a different intent here..

David Weaver

..I hear you on the medium stone and the hand strop. My 1000 stone and your 800 stone are probably identical in grit size.

Instead of hand strop, I swipe the iron on a 1 micron stone, but not because that needs to be done for everything - more because I do not sand or scrape if I don't have to. I'm not doing this for a living, so my goals are different than they would be were that the case. If I were, I would plane, scrape, sand. Actually, I probably would do very little planing were that the case.

Nobody that I know of has ever asked if I planed or sanded a surface, and they're more interested in the finish on the wood than the quality of the surface on the wood itself.

i can't speak to what other folks do on here, but there can't be many who work with only hand tools who spend too much time sharpening, it gets to be a drag in the middle of good workflow.