New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Stropping Test *LINK*

Posts

Stropping Test *LINK*

#1

Stropping Test *LINK*

Steve Elliott

After a recent discussion here I started trying to improve the quality of my cutting edges by stropping. My first attempts using leather weren't promising so I made up a piece of boxwood that could be used like the cast iron lap that is my favorite substrate for diamond paste.

The boxwood worked better than my previous choice, cherry, in that it didn't soak up the paste and kept 1/4 micron diamond on the surface enough to cut steel. The 1/4 micron on cherry just sank in and didn't cut.

The test edges became shinier and seemed sharper after stropping on boxwood so I went on to stropping on plain (uncharged) leather. This seemed to degrade the edge somewhat. At each stage I made microscope images which can be seen in the image linked below.

I can't claim this is an exhaustive test of stropping because so much depends on technique and the materials used, but I'm pleased to have found something easy that improves sharpness.


Stropping Test

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#2

Re: Stropping Test

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That's a pretty convincing test. Do you have any thought, other than boxwood, what would be a suitable substrate for a strop? I don't have any good leather - what scraps I do have simply dub the edge. Tempered masonite has worked okay, and corian, of which I have acres, works with Tormek paste but I haven't tried diamond. But then I only have 3 micron diamond so far. Corian's less successful with the green buffing compound.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#3

Re: Stropping Test

David Weaver

Excellent! Fantastic images.

I have found something similar with leather when the edge is very fine to begin with - even fresh new vegetable tanned leather.

One or two light swipes to align the edge is OK, but beyond that and I think the edge is beginning to wear and be abraded (in a not so positive way) by whatever is in the leather.

AS the strop gets used more and more and accumulates little bits of wire edge, it does even less desirable things to whatever is stropped on it.

A hard strop with a fine abrasive just continues the hone to the next step.

What's counter-intuitive is that with a leather strop, you can align the edge and make it shave hair better, but I've never been sure that it's doing anything other than moving the edge around and not necessarily improving it.

When the abrasive is fine enough that the wire edge is already removed for all practical purposes, well...you just showed us what the conclusion is there.

:)

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#4

Alternatives to boxwood

Steve Elliott

The idea to use boxwood came from Dave Barnett in a very informative post which I haven't been able to find using the search function. Boxwood was about fourth on a list of woods he liked and came after pink ivory and lignum vitae, among others. It happened to be the one I had on hand and it sure worked for me.

I haven't tried coarser diamond on it but on cherry 1 micron gave a much shinier finish than the same grit did on cast iron. The cherry absorbed so much paste that I don't recommend it. In the past I've used maple which was better than cherry but not as good as boxwood.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#5

Re: Stropping Test

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Wow! This convinces me to give desert ironwood a try, boxwood is too expensive.

Pam

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#6

Why strop?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

Thank you for a well put together experiment and some superb illustrations - Gad I wish I could take photos like that!

The two main results are the progressive improvement in an edge (what steel out of interest?) using 1/4 micron diamond paste on a hardwood substratum, and that plain leather does not abraid steel (certainly not in a positive way - probably just dubbing the edge?).

Everyone is now going to be looking for that special hardwood to act as a substratum :) I think that they miss the obvious solution ...

The reason for using boxwood - or any other harder hardwood - is that it can be planed flat and diamond paste will bed in the surface, rather than be pushed nelow the surface. A better substratum for a strop using diamond paste is cast iron!

The question is why does one use a strop in the first place?

If it is to break the wire edge after honing, then plain leather is probably less desirable than the honing medium, itself. This brings into the spotlight issuessuch as the hardness/flatness/abrasiveness of the medium/substratum combination. The question that begs itself is what leather did you use. A soft leather is next-to-useless. The Horse Butt strops from Joel are the best I have used.

I used to strop to renew an edge between between honing on my waterstones. The advantage of a strop is that it is handy (could be tucked away and then brought out when needed - no mess, no fuss). A few strokes and the edge is up to speed. Charged with a compound -that is, not plain leather - the strop is capable of abraiding steel in a way similar to a waterstone. Your experiment backs up that uncharged leather is not abraisive in the same manner as a charged leather.

So what about charging the leather? This interested me enough a couple of years ago that I compared the effects of 0.5 micron diamond paste against 0.5 micron Veritas green compound on Joels' Horse Butt leathers ...


This was my pre-microscrope days so I simply compared bringing a dull chilsel back to life ...


Both diamond paste and green compound worked effectively, but my subjective preference was for the green rouge as it seemed to create an edge that pared more easily.

The article is here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/Stroppingwithgreenrougeversesdiamondpaste.html

After all this I rarely use a leather strop these days.

If the aim is the be effective in returning a dull edge to a working sharp one, "stropping" as a technique is valuable. But how valuable a dedicated strop? I do not see the value in a leather strop if my cast iron plates are handy. Before the paste-on-iron I did the same with my Shaptons because my sharpening centre is close at hand. The question that all should ask themselves is whether they are in a similar position to myself, since a dedicated strop may be superfluous.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#7

Ellis Walentine

Excellent post, Steve

Ellis Walentine

I've been using a gnarly old piece of rock maple as a strop for years, with nagura slurry embedded in it instead of diamond paste. Works fine for me.

I wish I had a microscope and a camera adapter. Those photos are wonderful. Thanks for compiling that very clear progression for us.

Ellis

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#8

Re: Why strop?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'm sure that we're all missing the obvious solution. Thanks so much for pointing that out. :)

Pam

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#9

Re: Why strop?

Steve Elliott

Hi Derek

I�ve used the same � micron diamond paste on cast iron but didn�t get the same nearly scratchless result I got from boxwood. It was a very good sharp edge, the best I had achieved except possibly for the time I used a Shapton 30,000x glass stone at a side sharpening class. I put the Shapton edge under my microscope and could see scratches running parallel to the cutting edge, so I think the boxwood stropping possibly was a little finer.

The boxwood was harder to flatten than I had expected. With its grain reversals and pin knots I had to add a significant back bevel to be able to plane it, and then my widest plane (2-1/4�) wasn�t wide enough to do the entire 2-1/2� surface in one pass. I didn�t want to get abrasive grit embedded in the surface for obvious reasons so I used an old piece of coated abrasive belt to take it down the last little bit.

The advantage of boxwood over either maple or cherry was how little the paste soaked in. After a while the surface accumulated some black swarf which I wiped off with mineral spirits. It doesn�t seem like the boxwood will need resurfacing very often.

The leather I used was a very hard cowhide, the closest thing I had to the horse butt strop from Joel. I was using my honing jig to control the angle and the jig only works with stones up to 8-1/2� in length. The horse butt strop is 15� long.

I�ve done this experiment on two blades, A2 and CPM 3V, with nearly identical results. The images I posted were of the 3V. The only difference I noticed was that the 3V took significantly more strokes to eliminate the scratches. I want to test high carbon steel because stropping has traditionally been used in sharpening it, but I expect the results will be similar.

The reason for my experiment was a recent claim that a stropped edge was noticeably sharper and lasted longer, two things I value. My stropped edge was equal to the supersharp edges I�ve gotten before and it may have been quicker to achieve. My next stage of testing will look at whether a supersharp edge lasts longer or quickly loses that extra sharpness and then acts like a regular sharp edge.

As a point of reference, my typical working edges are the 1 micron on cast iron type used as a starting point for my test. They�re pretty quick and are plenty sharp for almost everything I do.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#10

Re: Why strop?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think magnification and photographs are very helpful. But the most important tool in sharpening is the ability to notice subtle differences in performance when the tool is in actual use. And when using the tool, the ability to notice how subtle differences in technique affect the longevity of the edge is a related skill. If we notice a difference between one stone and another or one sharpening technique and another, magnification can be a good tool for explaining why this should be. However, judging an edge purely by pictures is a very hollow test.

I think good stropping technique takes some time to learn because you need the feedback of the performance of the tool. And here again careful discernment over a long period with many repetitions is what makes for good technique.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#11

Re: Why strop?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The reason for my experiment was a recent claim that a stropped edge was noticeably sharper and lasted longer, two things I value. My stropped edge was equal to the supersharp edges I�ve gotten before and it may have been quicker to achieve. My next stage of testing will look at whether a supersharp edge lasts longer or quickly loses that extra sharpness and then acts like a regular sharp edge.

As a point of reference, my typical working edges are the 1 micron on cast iron type used as a starting point for my test. They�re pretty quick and are plenty sharp for almost everything I do.

Hi Steve

I recall Joel writing that he stropped about 50 strokes (or something like that) to obtain his super edges. I do not recall whether this was on a charged or uncharged leather strop. I suspect the latter. If so, I do not see how he does this bearing in mind your results here.

Perhaps we need to define what stropping is, or what it is intended to do. In the context of this study, stropping uses an abrasive medium to refine an edge. In so doing, I wonder why you chose to use 0.25 micron diamond paste here, since you usually use 1 micron paste or a 30K Shapton stone (which would be 0.5 microns)? Surely using the .25 micron paste on boxwood strop here is no different from a 60K Shapton (if there is such a thing). That would be the reason for the sharper edge, not the fact that you used a strop. Have I got that right?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#12

Re: Why strop?

David Weaver

Warren -

How much sub-micron or sub half-micron abrasive have you used on a regular basis?

Can you qualify what the difference would be between a stropped edge that is actually worse under magnification that would make discernment without magnification determine it to be better?

Certainly, if you're contending that the stropping can improve the edge under all conditions, magnification can be described post-determination even if what we see creates a counterintuitive result.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#13

Re: Why strop?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

David, I am not claiming that one way is better than another. What I am saying is that picture comparisons are helpful only so far as they corroborate what we experience in practice. Steve doesn't say anything about the performance of the various edges. If I would buy a high quality natural water stone (which I have no experience with), then use it and take pictures of the edge, I don't think that would be a reasonable test of the stone's usefulness. In actual use, it could be I would get great results right away, or it could be that I would have to work with the stone for quite a while to realize its potential. And it could be that the photograph doesn't look that great.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#14

Re: Why strop?

TomD

"Perhaps we need to define what stropping is, or what it is intended to do. In the context of this study, stropping uses an abrasive medium to refine an edge. In so doing, I wonder why you chose to use 0.25 micron diamond paste here, since you usually use 1 micron paste or a 30K Shapton stone (which would be 0.5 microns)? Surely using the .25 micron paste on boxwood strop here is no different from a 60K Shapton (if there is such a thing). That would be the reason for the sharper edge, not the fact that you used a strop. Have I got that right?"

I probably wouldn't define this as stropping except to the extent that the edge is only being worked in one direction? How is honnning on boxwood different from honing on cast? In say the barbershop context, there are three features to stropping, and these are the ones I tend to associate:

1) The stop is soft, and creates a polish with some convexity to the surface, or could polish an already convex surface, say a drawknife or Bowie.

2) The workpiece is moved in only one direction, as it could otherwise dig in the edge. But this may further refine the edge if no jig is being used since it may be easier to hold a register for final honing while moving in only one direction.

3) The process is essentially dry and loads the medium as time goes by. Some pros and cons to this, but in the day it meant the edge could be refreshed without returning to oil stones and all the stink and mess.

4) One could also add that existing stones As and Ws did not polish to as high a level as strops.

5) And that the sharpening was to both sides and in reverse directions.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#15

Re: Why strop?

Steve Elliott

I wonder why you chose to use 0.25 micron diamond paste here, since you usually use 1 micron paste or a 30K Shapton stone (which would be 0.5 microns)?

I chose � micron diamond because it was the finest abrasive I had. On cherry it had sunk into the wood to the extent that it didn�t seem to have any effect on the blade and I was going to increase the grit of the diamond until I could see an effect. Since the � micron worked I didn�t proceed to coarser grits. For the record, I don�t own a Shapton 30K stone and only used one once in a side sharpening class. I�m not willing to spend that much for a stone or even more for a really good natural Japanese waterstone.

Surely using the .25 micron paste on boxwood strop here is no different from a 60K Shapton (if there is such a thing). That would be the reason for the sharper edge, not the fact that you used a strop. Have I got that right?

I�ve heard different explanations of why stropping works, from �aligning the molecules at the edge� to Beilby flow, a sort of smearing of the steel at the surface that results in a polish. I�m skeptical by nature and don�t put a lot of stock in things I can�t test, though I consider it possible that scratch depth may not be the only factor involved. I�m looking for things that actually give me a better edge in terms of performance in planing wood. I agree with Warren on that point but don�t think that working with a particular stone for years to learn how to coax the very best performance out of it would ever allow me to compare more that a few stones in my lifetime, and even then I wouldn�t know if one stone just seemed better because I hadn�t found the best technique for using another stone. I do know I�ve had significantly better results using some methods and I�ve stuck with what is working well and have looked for ways to make that work even better.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#16

Finally, the statement I've been looking for...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Steve says: "I do know I�ve had significantly better results using some methods and I�ve stuck with what is working well and have looked for ways to make that work even better. "

Sometimes it seems as if I shouldn't even be posting here with the big boys (sorry, Pam) since I can't even begin to afford to do the testing necessary to discern the best possible methods. I will never own a Shapton anything, much less a 30K, since that would be more than I've spent on all my chisels, stones and even my strip sander combined. I don't have a microscope or even a hand-held loupe. When it seems that we get close to a method that produces believable, reproducible results (as opposed to the Journal of Irreproducible Results) then someone comes along to say that everything that preceded that point is wrong. My checkbook has limits, but I can spring for something that's going to work.

So, Steve, what are the "some methods" that produce the "significantly better results"? Your tests and demonstrations make sense to me. I do believe that when you and Warren finally agree on terms, the results will likely satisfy both of you. I don't want to start at the beginning. I want to start at the end of someone else's work. Lazy, I know; cheap, for certain. I have a piece of cast steel, 1" thick, 3" wide and 12" long, soft enough to draw file and scrape with a machinist's scraper (I do know how to do that). Will that get me to the starting gate?

And where is David Barnett? We need you.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#17

What's worked for me

Steve Elliott

So, Steve, what are the "some methods" that produce the "significantly better results"?

Hi Bruce, I hope this will be helpful.

Here�s what seems to work the best for me:

1. When starting with a significantly worn edge, I want to remove most of the metal using a method that is quick but controllable. I like my Tormek wet grinder although it isn�t the fastest at removing metal, but before that I had good results with a half speed grinder and coarse wheels. I produce the edge shape (straight or cambered) on the grinder. On the Tormek I have a tool rest that maintains the chosen angle and I freehand the camber. For straight edges I use the sliding jig that clamps the blade. I generally use a 25 degree main bevel.

2. To produce the cutting edge I want to hone a fairly narrow band of steel right at the edge. This can be done on short, thick blades by resting the bevel on the stone (in this case the main bevel angle produced at the grinder needs to be the desired final angle). For thinner blades I�ve had pretty good results with freehand honing but if you�re a jig person there are some good ones out there. I�m using one I made myself but that�s another story. On chisels I just freehand the angle by resting the main bevel on the stone, lifting the handle a little, and drawing the chisel back toward me a few times. After that I can carefully move the chisel forward and back. This only takes 30 seconds or so and gives me a very sharp edge.

3. Match the honing medium (oilstone, waterstone, diamond on a substrate) to the blade alloy. For carbon steel I like waterstones, for higher alloys like CPM 3V I prefer diamond on cast iron. Your cast steel should work just fine. I use 1 micron diamond as a good compromise that gives me adequate speed and a pretty sharp edge. Although I�m now going directly from the Tormek to 1 micron it�s taken me a lot of practice to get my grinding accurate enough to make that work. A fixed diamond plate or a coarse stone will help refine both the edge shape and the quality of the surface. I like David Charlesworth�s method of increasing the angle slightly each time the honing medium gets finer.

Choosing a method and sticking with it long enough to work out the problems is essential.

A lot of what I just said is pretty standard advice and I don�t mean to talk down to you, but when the basic stuff is working well there isn�t much need for special tricks or secret recipes.

As for what really didn�t work for me, polishing the entire bevel was just too slow and honing a Holtey S53 blade on waterstones was completely ineffective. And slow. And frustrating.

To get supersharp edges I�ve found that using a narrow back bevel really helps. Never on chisels, but especially on wide blades and the higher alloys that hone slowly to begin with.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#18

irrelevant metric?

Bill Tindall

If the edge is so frail that it can be "moved around" with leather what is the likely result of burying such an edge in a piece of maple?

I believe the initial sharpness of a tool edge is irrelevant unless you are in a one pass planing contest. What the edge looks like after 100' of planing is the metric that should be used to judge edge preparation for practical planing application.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#19

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: irrelevant metric?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

"I believe the initial sharpness of a tool edge is irrelevant unless you are in a one pass planing contest. What the edge looks like after 100' of planing is the metric that should be used to judge edge preparation for practical planing application."

I've been saying (something similar to) that for many years. What good is a 'super-sharp' edge if it won't hold up to a normal working environment?

My usual comment is something along the order of "let's both take ten planing strokes on the same board and THEN compare edges. I'm convinced that many of the 'fussy' edges won't be nearly as sharp as a good 'utility' edge after only a few work strokes.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#20

Warren you are spot on in this case

Bill Tindall

A more reflective surface does not ensure the scratches are less deep or the edge is sharper. If the "v's" left from a sharp diamond particle are turned into "u's" the surface will become more reflective. If the steel and carbon particles captured by the v's are scrubbed out by the wood the surface will be more reflective. If the tops of the v's are rounded the surface will be more reflective. In all these cases the edge may provide equivalent performance in practical planing.

It will take an imaging technique better than light microscopy to provide definitive data for this experiment. A light microscope does not have the resolution to see 1 micron scratches and it is a good bet that a 1 micron diamond particle does not make even a 1 micron wide scratch.

Recall that Mr. Lee said they were buying a scanning electron beam microscope for following their wear and sharpening work. With good reason. This is the tool that will be essential to answer the questions raised in this experiment.

I think the focus on sharpness is in any case misplaced. To put it in technical terms the response of the edge to use is what is important. We could in theory plot sharpness vs usage, and call this a "dulling curve". It is the shape of this curve that is important, not the starting point.

Warren is spot on. I have been told that Warren is a carver. Carvers have the tool in wood for extended periods of time with precise feedback for the cutting forces exerted. Cutting force is critical for it affects control. I think that a carver has more feel, and maybe need, for sharpness than other woodworkers. Their tool is removing precise shavings across a spectrum of grain orientation employing minimal force and precise control. And, if they are carving for a living, diddling with sharpening doesn't pay the rent. The carvers I know shape the tool by grinding on some media and hone to sharpen on an abrasive strop of some sort. No doubt there are other means to this end, but this approach works for providing a durable sharp edge that can pay the rent.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#21

Another way of looking at it ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Sometimes it seems as if I shouldn't even be posting here with the big boys (sorry, Pam) since I can't even begin to afford to do the testing necessary to discern the best possible methods. I will never own a Shapton anything, much less a 30K, since that would be more than I've spent on all my chisels, stones and even my strip sander combined. I don't have a microscope or even a hand-held loupe.

Don't give up, Bruce. This type of testing does not cost much.

Although I included microscopic images in the tests I have posted here in recent months, my research designs were based on qualifiable results (for example, testing edges on endgrain after use). In any event, my QX5 microscope cost $50 on eBay.

The cast iron plates for the diamond paste cost nil. I converted three old handplanes.

The diamond paste was about $20 three years ago. It should last about 10 more years.

My layout for the supersteel chisel blades was nil. A bit of sweat in grinding the steel, and some blood spilled in sharpening, but they were sent to me for testing.

I did purchase a couple of Joel's Horse Butt Strops, but these were not primarily intended for experimentation. They are now 3 years old. Steve chose to use hardwood instead of leather.

You don't need Shaptons to do testing. You just need imagination.

These experiments do fire up the interest of many here, even if they are not serious about changing the current sharpening regime. Hell, in spite of my apparent infatuation with diamond paste, I continue to use my waterstones in the main. That old addage of "stick with what works" is still the rule. That we like to experiment does not detract from the rule. It is just human nature.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#22

Re: Every edge can be moved...

David Weaver

... it's a matter of how much movement.

I just chopped a dai out of hard maple last night with a nice old laminated PS&W framer that I guarantee is harder than RC60, and I'll also guarantee that I can move the edge with a strop.

Moving the edge doesn't mean that you're bending a large amount of metal, it means you're moving the very tip one way or another.

To get an idea what i'm talking about, use a stone about 5-8 microns and be aggressive with it on whatever you normally use. When you're done, note that the edge will probably shave hair on one side of the edge, but if you flip it over, not the other.

Take a strop and lightly run the edge over a bare strop (no abrasive), and notice now the second side will shave very easily. go back to the first, you'll note that it is less sharp feeling than it was before stropping.

You are moving the edge back and forth with the leather, not a large amount of it, just the very edge. And the wire edge itself should be long gone when you do this.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#23

Re: Why strop?

David Weaver

We're in agreement, warren, that's what I was hoping to get to. If there is an improvement, then it should be something that can be noticed in use as an improvement, and a preference for a lateral move, but an actual improvement.

That's why I made the comment several months ago that I'd be glad to see someone else volunteer to dull an edge that was stropped after a sub micron finish, and one that is not, and take notes along the way. To do a few iterations would take hours, which is why i'd like to see someone else do it.

If the edge really is better, you can parameterize a use-type test and prove it. If you can't prove it, then it's likely an issue of preference. But it takes a lot of work and some care to accurately assess what's going on.

In my experience (not testing, but my experience just from perception), an edge that comes off of a black or hard trans oilstone is improved by stropping. An edge that comes off of a sub micron aggressive abrasive is not, including those, as you mention, that come off of a very expensive natural waterstone.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#24

Resolving power using visible light

Steve Elliott

A light microscope does not have the resolution to see 1 micron scratches and it is a good bet that a 1 micron diamond particle does not make even a 1 micron wide scratch.

When the boxwood stropping resulted in a microbevel that looked black under the oblique lighting I use with my microscope it made me wonder what the surface was actually like. Why didn�t it scatter light like the original 1 micron surface? I�ve used � micron diamond on cast iron and the surface looked similar to the 1 micron: the entire surface showed scratches parallel to the direction of honing. The resolving power of the microscope wasn�t great enough to show individual scratches, which were probably well less that � micron in width, but the surface scattered light and showed the direction of the scratching. The stropped surface no longer scattered light.

Last night I checked the wavelengths of visible light, which are around 500 nanometers or � micron. My guess is that when the scratches on the honed surface pass a certain threshold of fineness they no longer scatter light. The microbevel that looks black actually has fine scratches, maybe only a little finer than the original scratches visible in the 1 micron edge I started with. The dramatic change in the appearance of the edge under the microscope may be an artifact of the imaging technique rather than a dramatic change in the surface condition of the steel.

I�m absolutely with those who consider the important test to be how the edge performs when it is used. I hope to do some tests that would help determine that.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#25

Re: irrelevant metric?

Sgian Dubh

"I believe the initial sharpness of a tool edge is irrelevant unless you are in a one pass planing contest. What the edge looks like after 100' of planing is the metric that should be used to judge edge preparation for practical planing application."

I wonder about that sort of thing too Bill. My question I suppose is, is there quantifiable benefit to a working furniture maker in aiming for these super sharpened tools? I mean, I suppose, how much longer does it take to go through all these stages of sharpening over my normal few minutes: and is there an improvement in plane performance, eg, time between sharpenings, that makes the business more efficient?

On the other hand, maybe that's the wrong point of view. Perhaps the interest in the subject is primarily and validly academic and really ought to be viewed in that light, ie, interesting for its own sake with some potential trickle down benefits for furniture businesses. Slainte.