Why strop?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Steve
Thank you for a well put together experiment and some superb illustrations - Gad I wish I could take photos like that!
The two main results are the progressive improvement in an edge (what steel out of interest?) using 1/4 micron diamond paste on a hardwood substratum, and that plain leather does not abraid steel (certainly not in a positive way - probably just dubbing the edge?).
Everyone is now going to be looking for that special hardwood to act as a substratum
I think that they miss the obvious solution ...
The reason for using boxwood - or any other harder hardwood - is that it can be planed flat and diamond paste will bed in the surface, rather than be pushed nelow the surface. A better substratum for a strop using diamond paste is cast iron!
The question is why does one use a strop in the first place?
If it is to break the wire edge after honing, then plain leather is probably less desirable than the honing medium, itself. This brings into the spotlight issuessuch as the hardness/flatness/abrasiveness of the medium/substratum combination. The question that begs itself is what leather did you use. A soft leather is next-to-useless. The Horse Butt strops from Joel are the best I have used.
I used to strop to renew an edge between between honing on my waterstones. The advantage of a strop is that it is handy (could be tucked away and then brought out when needed - no mess, no fuss). A few strokes and the edge is up to speed. Charged with a compound -that is, not plain leather - the strop is capable of abraiding steel in a way similar to a waterstone. Your experiment backs up that uncharged leather is not abraisive in the same manner as a charged leather.
So what about charging the leather? This interested me enough a couple of years ago that I compared the effects of 0.5 micron diamond paste against 0.5 micron Veritas green compound on Joels' Horse Butt leathers ...

This was my pre-microscrope days so I simply compared bringing a dull chilsel back to life ...

Both diamond paste and green compound worked effectively, but my subjective preference was for the green rouge as it seemed to create an edge that pared more easily.
The article is here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/Stroppingwithgreenrougeversesdiamondpaste.html
After all this I rarely use a leather strop these days.
If the aim is the be effective in returning a dull edge to a working sharp one, "stropping" as a technique is valuable. But how valuable a dedicated strop? I do not see the value in a leather strop if my cast iron plates are handy. Before the paste-on-iron I did the same with my Shaptons because my sharpening centre is close at hand. The question that all should ask themselves is whether they are in a similar position to myself, since a dedicated strop may be superfluous.
Regards from Perth
Derek