New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Stropping Test *LINK*

Posts

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#51

Re: What is being imaged by the microscope

Rob Lee

Hi Bill,

We have the SEM in house, and are getting it set up...

Very costly to run though, but not for the reason one would think....the images are captured using Polaroid film....hard to find, and very expensive. Will have to test some other instant films, or convert the image capture method....

Our digital microscope is still our primary device... 500x optical zoom, I believe... It was about 40k to buy....

Cheers,

Rob

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#52

An interesting distinction

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Since we can't see anything solid unless it reflects light, I'm interested by his statement; although, as I think about it*, I understand what he's saying. I imagine it's kind of like being able to see light reflecting off the window of a house in the trees, even when you can see the house or the windows.

*OK, I can't stand it: I considered saying, "...on reflection..." So here I am looking for pun points (which I know are worth more on the main board, where the Colonel sets the standard).

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#53

Let us all place an order......

Bill Tindall

so LV can buy digital imaging capture software with the increased profits. Running one of these things on film is limiting the capability.

Wish I lived near-by, well actually wished you lived near by as I had my fill of MN and Potsdam winters, and I would come beg to be your summer intern on this project.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#54

Re: There is a bit of a different intent here..

TomD

"Nobody that I know of has ever asked if I planed or sanded a surface, and they're more interested in the finish on the wood than the quality of the surface on the wood itself."

I am sure that is true. I am reminded of all the Red Oak interiors, restaurants and such that were popular in the 70s and 80s, and were clear coated right over the top of highly visible planer marks.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#55

Re: Let us all place an order......

TomD

Just a quick tip on those Ottawa summers... Not as bad as Minesota winters!

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#56

More data to support your case

Bill Tindall

See saw horse post for context.......Finck sharpens with 1000 grit water stone followed by 8000 on all steels from O1, Japanese, to M2. When the objective is to get stuff out the door"good enough" can be the standard.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#57

Re: Let us all place an order......

Bill Tindall

and better than TN summers- too hot and humid here.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#58

Re: What is being imaged by the microscope

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I don't know what size film your system requires, but Fuji makes great 4X5 instant film, slightly different color shift (but then, nothing comes close to Kodachrome). I've switched to Fuji for large format photography since Polaroid went crazy.

Pam

PS Not that you're likely to need it, but if you do, Jack and I would be glad to help you program image capture and/or other stuff.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#59

Re: There is a bit of a different intent here..

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I suspect there are those out in the mighty unwashed public who do indeed recognize and appreciate the wonderful chatoyance possible with planed but not sanded wood.

Pam

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#60

Myth?

Frank D. in Montreal

The tests I've done (a few) as well as others I've seen show little or no difference between sanded and planed wood once a finish is applied. I've also seen some wood with crazy chatoyance obtained by sanding through the grits to superfine (2000, even finer).

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#61

I don't think so

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

But I'm not likely to do these tests. And for unfinished projects it's there, and the pieces feel better, a lot better. The saw dust clogs things up, which may be hidden by a finish. And, yes, I sometimes sand regardless.

As for magazine comparison testing, it's all nonsense, too much money at stake, always.

Pam

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#62

Re: Myth?

wilbur

So if I understand this correctly:

Planed surface --> chatoyance.

Sanded surface to crazy high grits (2000) --> chatoyance.

Implies that a sanded surface to more normal grits (220-320-ish) --> no chatoyance.

Planed surface with finish = sanded surface with finish.

Which kind of begs the question: can you tell the difference between finish applied to a surface sanded to 220-320 grit or so and finish applied to a surface sanded to 2000 grit?

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#63

Re: I don't think so

bugbear

As for magazine comparison testing, it's all nonsense, too much money at stake, always.

Are you aware of how many (well respected) people you just accused of acting in bad faith?

BugBear

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#64

There is a lot of optics going on here

Bill Tindall

The observer is detecting the light reflected and scattered from the wood and finish surfacs being examined. Some of the variables that will affect the observation are observation angle, lighting angle, refractive index of finish, depth of finish, surface texture of finish, surface texture of wood, refractive index of wood relative to that of finish. Further variables in the texture of the wood surface are factors like pores, particles(saw dust), fibers and the scratch pattern on the solid part of the wood.

It would not be surprising for different people finishing different woods prepared in different ways and finished with different materials to come to different conclusions. As a general rule, the thicker the finish and higher refractive index the finish has the less important the wood surface will become. There is a reason nitrocellulose lacquer is popular. Minimalist applications of shellac demand a refined wood surface.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#65

Re: I don't think so

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I don't think they acted in bad faith. They did what they were told to do by their employers.

And I think there's no other explanation for FWW's various comparison reviews, such as chisels (I mean really, any self-respecting Japanese chisel user would choose those chisels to test?) and finishes, etc.

Pam

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#66

*chuckle*

David Weaver

I don't read the magazine tests, either. Even if I'm not being a cynic, I would still think that the articles are written to meet a quota, and the tests are the kinds of tests I'd want to see. I would rather hear warren's experience or someone else with 40 years under their belt than pay to see the result of a test that can be done in a day or two.

Or in the case of japanese chisels, hear from people who have used a few.

I'm sure there were scads of matsumura chisels sold because of the FWW "tests", and scads of LN chisels made of A2 sold because of the same. I haven't exactly gone and bought off of the test list, but several friends have bought matsumura chisels because of the "reviews".

The matsumura chisels are OK. But "OK" describes them very well. Still don't know what they actually are, and did buy two parers on price quite a while ago (never the bench chisels). They are also OK, they are at least shaped correctly, and I do have other parers that are not that were about the same price. I would certainly be buying a different brand of parers if I had to do it over again.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#67

Re: More data to support your case

TomD

Properly sharpened to 8K will give a very good edge, with my body it passes the test, where the hair jumps of the skin as shaven which is kinda funny to see. Thanks for the data point.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#68

Re: Myth?

TomD

It could be argued that planes, etc... are just an efficient means of transferring with bedding angle degradation, the finish achievable with sanding. Sharpening is just sanding, and it is more efficient to sharpen a metal edge, than it is to sharpen/sand a really big piece of furniture, except when it isn't.

Turning is an example of a process where forming through to finishing can be done under power, and one can efficiently use even very fine papers, with the results you mention.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#69

Re: Myth?

TomD

Or you can go all Eugene Clarky on it and French polish it with heavy pumise so the cross grain scratches create the impression of Bear Claw - Chatoyance!

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#70

Re: I don't think so

TomD

"I don't think they acted in bad faith. They did what they were told to do by their employers."

Good point, they didn't have bad faith with the employers!

"And I think there's no other explanation for FWW's various comparison reviews, such as chisels (I mean really, any self-respecting Japanese chisel user would choose those chisels to test?) and finishes, etc.

Pam"

I think the problem there is the assumption that they are trying to replicate tests from the perspective of a self-respecting Japanese tool user. There are various ways of being stupid when running a business, one of which in this case would be to review tools for people who already own them, and from suppliers who don't advertise with you, that way you can guarantee you didn't help anyone, including yourself. :)

I have some cheap Japanese tools, as well as some good ones. They all vastly outperform western tools, format allowing. This leads me to believe when comparing the results that there is some kind of underlying eror in their test. My theory with one of their tests was that they had a linear chart for an exponential result. They had a range of 1-6 say, when the real range was more like 1-36. A convenient conceptual eror.

I tend to believe people are stupid or clever before downright venal. I may be wrong of course. Normally equipment type tests are not fully corrupted, they are more a mater of conveniently biased. If you set up the test, you can create objective conditions that stratify the tests in your favour.

I remember when an association I worked for wanted to argue tax policy in favour of lower taxes on capital gains (fancy that). We created numbers in the Canada vs. US that indicated we were much more dependant on dept in our financial structures. We did this by removing whole industries from the numbers that had more favourable capital structures. The results were pretty dramatic. Our rationale was that we were simply creating a comparable base to US numbers since the industry mix was not comparable otherwise. There are always ways of making a good, seviceable, honest, tests.

Another favorite of mine are tests where golf drivers are compared as played by robots, like Iron Byron. Since shafts can be optimized for a given swing speed or other launch condition, it is easy to create entirely "fair" tests where your driver out-drives and hits the center of the fairway, while the competitions' fair much less well.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#71

Re: Let us all place an order......

TomD

Doctor Zhivago was on TCM last night. I have never seen it, and only caught a bit of it last night. Of course Russian can be cold, but I pointed out how bad it could be to my kids when they were showing pictures of beautiful fields full of bees and wild flowers, yet the actors were dressed in double great coats and Balaclavas. "As yes, it was a 2 Balaclava summer that year..."

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#72

Re: Stropping Test

Charles

You're not stropping. You've simply built a proxy for the fine stone you apparently don't have in your arsenal and are continuing the honing and polishing process on the proxy stone.

Edges honed on very fine media (the equivalent of 2000 grit sandpaper and finer) do not require stropping - there is no rag left to remove.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#73

Re: Myth?

Frank D. in Montreal

"So if I understand this correctly:

Planed surface --> chatoyance.

Sanded surface to crazy high grits (2000) --> chatoyance.

Implies that a sanded surface to more normal grits (220-320-ish) --> no chatoyance.

Planed surface with finish = sanded surface with finish.

Which kind of begs the question: can you tell the difference between finish applied to a surface sanded to 220-320 grit or so and finish applied to a surface sanded to 2000 grit?"

A planed surface with no finish has limited chatoyance compared to the same surface with a finish, so I disagree with your statement that planed surface=chatoyance (At least that's not quite what I said). I do think (have seen) that once a finish is applied, it becomes impossible for most people to tell the difference between planed and sanded if both are done correctly. On the tests that I did with shellac, the sanded surface came out consistently smoother than the planed surface. And when there were slight differences in chatoyance, the planed surface was not always the most chatoyant.

As far as superfine grits go, I can't compare since I've only seen pieces that had been sanded, and with no finish applied they were spectacular.

Could have been the wood, bu the chatoyance certainly came through.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#74

Re: Myth?

Frank D. in Montreal

That's an interesting way of seeing it; it can certainly account for a lot. There's probably some differences in burnishing going on between sanding and cutting, which could be either beneficial or detrimental To the final result depending on the finish.

Re: Stropping Test *LINK*

#75

Fine Stones v. Stropping

Steve Elliott

The purpose of my test was to explore whether stropping on uncharged leather would improve an already sharp edge. I'll grant you that using 1/4 micron diamond on boxwood is essentially the same as using a VERY fine stone. My finest stone is a 15,000 grit Shapton which is very good and produces edges on carbon steel and A2 that are plenty good enough for even the most demanding smooth planing I do.

The Shapton doesn't cut M2 or CPM 3V nearly as effectively as diamond does. I'm able to use diamond on cast iron to get edges that are plenty sharp enough and essentially free of a wire edge (that 540x microscope always finds something on the edge, but that's overkill). If stropping or whatever you want to call it will result in a more durable edge I'd like to know that, and will be doing some planing tests to find out.