Re: I don't think so
TomD
"I don't think they acted in bad faith. They did what they were told to do by their employers."
Good point, they didn't have bad faith with the employers!
"And I think there's no other explanation for FWW's various comparison reviews, such as chisels (I mean really, any self-respecting Japanese chisel user would choose those chisels to test?) and finishes, etc.
Pam"
I think the problem there is the assumption that they are trying to replicate tests from the perspective of a self-respecting Japanese tool user. There are various ways of being stupid when running a business, one of which in this case would be to review tools for people who already own them, and from suppliers who don't advertise with you, that way you can guarantee you didn't help anyone, including yourself. 
I have some cheap Japanese tools, as well as some good ones. They all vastly outperform western tools, format allowing. This leads me to believe when comparing the results that there is some kind of underlying eror in their test. My theory with one of their tests was that they had a linear chart for an exponential result. They had a range of 1-6 say, when the real range was more like 1-36. A convenient conceptual eror.
I tend to believe people are stupid or clever before downright venal. I may be wrong of course. Normally equipment type tests are not fully corrupted, they are more a mater of conveniently biased. If you set up the test, you can create objective conditions that stratify the tests in your favour.
I remember when an association I worked for wanted to argue tax policy in favour of lower taxes on capital gains (fancy that). We created numbers in the Canada vs. US that indicated we were much more dependant on dept in our financial structures. We did this by removing whole industries from the numbers that had more favourable capital structures. The results were pretty dramatic. Our rationale was that we were simply creating a comparable base to US numbers since the industry mix was not comparable otherwise. There are always ways of making a good, seviceable, honest, tests.
Another favorite of mine are tests where golf drivers are compared as played by robots, like Iron Byron. Since shafts can be optimized for a given swing speed or other launch condition, it is easy to create entirely "fair" tests where your driver out-drives and hits the center of the fairway, while the competitions' fair much less well.