New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Requesting a chisel comparison of....

Posts

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#26

Wilbur, would you be so kind as to

Bruce, a MN Galoot

post the link to the video showing the Japanese woodworker producing the blind dovetails on that superb case? That demonstrates just about everything you explained.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#27

Re: Wilbur, would you be so kind as to  *LINK*

wilbur

Hi Bruce,

Is this the guy you were thinking of? He finishes off a long secret mitered dovetail about halfway through the video.

I also like this video because he is clearly working on a workbench, sitting on a stool. Which gives the lie to the idea that Japanese woodworking has to be done sitting on the floor. ;)


http://youtu.be/rx0HDZMjuOY

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#28

Re: Wilbur, would you be so kind as to

Bruce, a MN Galoot

This isn't the one I had in mind, but it's probably a better one. It shows the dovetailing better.

The one I originally thought of was the one where the guy is sitting on the floor :) and he's making the little case with the piston-fit drawers.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#29

Re: Wilbur, would you be so kind as to

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Here's the series starting with #1 (it's very hard to follow directly because the series seems to be many woodworkers):

1) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=85GrCHbdaJ4&feature=BFp&list=WL5D8A2859F0DDF1DD&index=2

2) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hwzeONtOAFg&feature=BFa&list=WL5D8A2859F0DDF1DD&index=3

3) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U98YYBeG7NI&feature=BFa&list=WL5D8A2859F0DDF1DD&index=4

4) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQNyA0SBoVA&feature=BFa&list=WL5D8A2859F0DDF1DD&index=5

5) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EIEIaZFOCaU&feature=BFa&list=WL5D8A2859F0DDF1DD&index=6

6) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NVZXYh_b-34&feature=BFa&list=WL5D8A2859F0DDF1DD&index=7

The hidden dovetail is in #3. I think this will work; but they're numbered in the url according to their place in my queue. His name is Tadashi Kimura.

Pam

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#30

That's it!  Thanks, Pam.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#31

Re: Dovetails in Japanese woodworking

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wilbur

Thanks for the post. Lots of good detail.

It strikes me how different the Japanese school of "hide the joinery" from that of Greene and Greene, where exhibiting - glorifying - joinery was/is the go. And then there is the traditional English school, which is somewhere in the middle.

When it comes to Japanese dovetails, I can understand why the modern dovetail chisel was not "invented" in Japan. The simple reason is that their dovetails are large and do not require chisels to get into small spaces. There is no reason why these joints require anything more than a firmer chisel. These Japanese dovetails are quite different from the slender London dovetails.

To those who argue that all London dovetails require is straight sawing, my response is poppycock. All dovetails require straight sawing. London-type dovetails additionally need more care taking in marking (if you make Tail first), and delicacy in chiseling. I just cannot see how it can be done without the latter.

What I would like to hear about are the methods of those who actually do make use London dovetails in their work.

I would also like to find out more about the history of London-type dovetails. Can someone point me to a reference source?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#32

When a craftsman gets to a certain level...

Bob Hackett

He stops building strictly for utility/function or to the client`s specs and starts doing things that he thinks will impress his peers. Much of what we do is actually aimed at either the "look at the beautiful wood I found" or "Look at what I can do" line of thought. In other words you`re either showing off the wood or your skills. Joinery is one of the premier ways to show off skills. The rest is history.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#33

Re: Dovetails in Japanese woodworking

kees

I am a little shy to reply in this forum full of seasoned woodworkers. My experience is pretty limited. But I did have some "insights" on my latest dovetail project. Maybe it was tainted because of the horrible crumbly woodtypes I used.

About the original question, I can only answer that the Koyamaichi's are very well made. Mine are a lot tougher and hold their edge way longer then any vintage chisel from England, Sweden or The Netherlands that I have. It is possible to chip the edge when I wait too long with touching up the edge and especially when I pry too much. When I just touch up the edge on my 8000 stone from time to time, the chisels just keep on trucking.

Regarding cutting dovetails. I don't like to remove the waste with a coping saw. I like to cut a triangle on the show side. Then turn over the wood and remove the rest of the waste layer for layer. For this purpose the chisel must fit inbetween the converging sides of the tails, and this also limits the size of my dovetails, the pins shouldn't be thinner then 3mm on their smallest aspect. I wonder how you chop these London dovetails Derek?

And finally the halfblind dovetails. These pesky corners in the tail pockets are difficult to reach. I can see the advantages of some skewed chisels here. But until now I made do with a utility knife. Because I can't sharpen a knife, not even to safe my life, I use these Stanley break-off blades, I really should get some knife sharpening practice.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#34

Re: Dovetails in Japanese woodworking

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Kees

To answer your question about how I clear the waste from the tails of a London-style dovetail, I first use a fretsaw, then a chisel.

However I do not remove the waste before first marking out the tails. I wrote a pictorial of this on my website for building a drawer using traditional design (which is my preference for most drawers):

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/Londonhalf-blinddovetaileddrawer.html


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#35

On hiding the joinery.....

roger lance

Other cultures that were proponents of hiding the joinery include the American Shaker community that objected to the display of finely crafted exposed joinery as a form of boasting/showmanship and was discourage along moral/religious lines. It would be nice to have Christian Beecksvort enter the conversation at this point. It is interesting to note the difference in how the Japanese and Shakers hid their joinery...the Japanese with a beveled edge and the Shakers with an additional covering board in some cases....maybe there was more available/inexpensive wood in America and less in Japan ?? Since the Shakers had European roots, there are probably other woodworking cultures there that had similar practices.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#36

joinery as a design element

Bill Tindall

I think flauntable dovetails may be a recent phenomena. I don't see much exposed joinery in period furniture. The Federal and Chester County, PA pieces I have reproduced, or been inspired by, invariably covered the dovetailed drawer blade joints, and everything else that held the case together. On half blinds inside the case and the drawers it was common to extend the saw cut to make removing the waste easier, which demonstrates clearly that joints weren't where these people flaunted their skills. Joints were functional, not a design element. The expression of skill was made in the overall design and ornamentation.

I am skeptical that the motivation to hide joinery was motivated by modesty. These utilitarian joints were made to hold something together and function was the goal, which led to bread (maybe even meat) on the table. The metric for quality was whether the joint was sufficiently strong, not whether all joinery looked as though it had grown together.

Someone said previously that the "craftsman" could show off with wood or joinery. I would add two more important opportunities- design and ornamentation(carving, inlay, etc). Alternatively one might just be trying to make something to hold his socks.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#37

Re: Dovetails in Japanese woodworking

kees

Thanks for the link Derek. I think I've seen it before, but it was good to read it again.

Some observations. I think you mixed up the names for pinboard and tail board in the beginning of the text. I suppose the pine boards are the tail boards?

A pitty you don't show how you remove the waste on the front of the pine boards where you have these very narrow pockets between the tails. You use the fret saw here too?

The fretsaw approach wasn't a huge succes in my case. First my fretsaw is a floppy disaster. Second, I had trouble paring the very soft western red cedar when the wood wasn't fully supported on both sides of the chisel. Despite sharpening a chisel to 20 degrees, the wood would tend to bend away and rip out instead of being cut. With the traditional method of removing just a triangle of wood on one side and then work from the other side I had a lot more control. Maybe my sharpening skils are just not good enough.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#38

Re: Dovetails in Japanese woodworking

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

To those who argue that all London dovetails require is straight sawing, my response is poppycock. All dovetails require straight sawing. London-type dovetails additionally need more care taking in marking (if you make Tail first), and delicacy in chiseling. I just cannot see how it can be done without the latter.

Derek, I didn't say "straight" sawing, but sawing to a line. By that I meant an accurate termination point, the base of the dovetails, not following a line the length of the sawing effort.

I also talked about following the base line with a chisel, chopping, and trimming any corner problems with a pen knife or some other chisel that one has laying in the shop.

I know for a fact that I cut perfect dovetails for 26 years with nary a dovetail chisel in sight.

Pam

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#39

London dovetails

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have seen London dovetails most often on English drawer sides. They were common 200 years ago. Usually the sides are very thin so that after sawing it is easy to chop out the waste with the chisel only, coming in from both sides. I think they were made this way because they are quick to make; it takes about a minute to make three tails. I don't think these dovetails were the "pride" of cabinetmakers of old; they were just doing a workman like job. As I mentioned earlier there are no dovetail chisels in 19th or early 20th century catalogues. The earliest use of the term "dovetail chisel" that I know is in a 1984 Garrett Wade catalogue. And it is much more recent that there has been such a thing as a "western dovetail chisel".

For more robust dovetails, I use a coping saw to remove waste. I think it is even more recent that fret saws have been used for dovetails. I have some fret saws, but I use them for fretwork. As a "design element", fretwork has a lot more possibilities than dovetails.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#40

Re: London dovetails

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"I think they were made this way because they are quick to make..."

The sides might have been quicker to make - would the matching larger areas of waste on the drawer front have been easier to make? Seems to me you wind up having to remove roughly the same amount of waste wood in any case - it's just a question of ratio between the two pieces.

Bill, asking ignorant questions because that's what I am on the subject

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#41

mahogany vs white oak

Bill Tindall

The sides were traditionally white oak, the fronts mahogany. Faster to remove large amount of mahogany, especially in a half blind.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#42

skeptical about motivation....

roger lance

as difficult as it is to believe that some people were influenced by their moral/religious principles to the point that these values were even reflected in the things they made, it's true of the Shakers....but they are down to only one community and the rest of us are safe from this unusual way of thinking.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#43

Re: Dovetails in Japanese woodworking

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek, I didn't say "straight" sawing, but sawing to a line. By that I meant an accurate termination point, the base of the dovetails, not following a line the length of the sawing effort.

I also talked about following the base line with a chisel, chopping, and trimming any corner problems with a pen knife or some other chisel that one has laying in the shop.

I know for a fact that I cut perfect dovetails for 26 years with nary a dovetail chisel in sight.

Hi Pam

I hope you didn't take my comment personally. Actually Warren wrote this before you did.

The fact is that in London-type dovetails (i.e. skinny) there is not likely to be wiggle room for a knife.

More importantly, sawing to the "base of the dovetails" will compound the difficulty! I had this discussion with a few others not so long ago, and David Charsworth emphasised the point this way ...

Just to add to the d/t corner discussion, let us assume the bottom of the saw kerf is square?

If it is, stopping on the line is not really practicable, even if one had that skill level.

Either the inner corner stops on the line and corner is not complete,

or the outer corner stops on the line and the inner is cut just past the shoulder line.

best wishes,

David Charlesworth

So if you think that you are stopping at the line it is likely that you are actually stopping a tiny fraction short. Now you have to remove the wood fibres that lie there - and that is the dilemma.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#44

Re: Dovetails in Japanese woodworking

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Of course Warren said this first in this forum on this day. I replied to his message confirming what he'd said as being true from my experience.

However, just because I replied to Warren doesn't mean I didn't originate my experience. Same with the Japanese dovetail chisels are called dovetail because of shape, not function. I think I was actually the first person to say that in the Australian Japanese Hand tool Forum, a couple of years ago; but that doesn't mean that everyone who says that now is copying me. And I'd worked that out for myself. Surely other people can work it out for themselves, too.

I know a bunch of people on the Old Tools forum have been on my back for years about taking what they say and pretending to be smart on other forums by supposedly repeating their advice. But they're wrong, very wrong. I never do that, always speak from personal experience or not at all. And I haven't even read the Old Tools Forum for years, because I more or less disdain the participants (except for bugbear), a mob who group together in horror anytime someone different makes an appearance or says something they haven't anticipated.

And now you've raised this issue again. Gee, thanks so much. Guess it's impossible that I'd know anything that I haven't been told by one of the boys.

Pam

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#45

This illustrates a point I`ve been trying to make

Bob Hackett

There are two schools of thought when it comes to any craft or trade. There are those who look at the tools that are available and think "I know what I want to do,now lets find the tools to do it" .This type of thinking brings crossover of tools from one trade or craft to another.

The second school of thought says, "I want to make this but it`s beyond the scope of the tools available. I`ll have to make what I need". These folks then go out and make the tools to make whatever they envision.

I`m sure you can see while the first approach can be liberating the second makes possibilities almost limitless. The first may take a lot of cash,the second just requires mastering a new skill set (or having a friend who has already done so and likes your work enough to trade skills).

All this to say if you have the skills and the time you can make whatever you please as well as the tools to do it any way you please.

That`s how my brother got me hooked on woodturning,but that`s another story. :)

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#46

Square saw kerf

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Did I read this right? Now we are worried that the square saw kerf is going to leave an uneven surface on the bottom because the saw is slightly angled? Is this something you have seen yourself or just learned from someone else? I studied trigonometry when I was 15, but I can still calculate that the "fraction" you are talking about is 0.003 inches. Are you going to claim that the side walls you cut with your saw are flat and smooth to within this tolerance? Square to within this tolerance? That with your little dovetail chisel you are sneaking into these tiny dovetails and cleaning the corner to this tolerance? That if it weren't for the square cut you could otherwise saw to the line within 0.003?

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#47

Re: Square saw kerf

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Warren

This is a common issue, one I've encountered innumerable times

First saw to the line. Now the kerf will either line up with the baseline on one side, and overshoot it on the other. Or, the kerf will either line up with the baseline on one side, and undershoot it on the other. Your choice.

If you go with the undershoot, and then chisel to the line, you will leave a filet in the corner of the dovetail. This is easy enough to remove on wide dovetails, but on narrow ones it really helps to have a chisel that can get into this corner.

Modern toolmakers, such as Lie-Nielsen, Blue Spruce and Ashley Iles, have spent their time developing chisels to deal with this. David Charlesworth is a woodworker with an analytical bent, he recognises this issue and writes about it.

It is only a non-issue if you do not build narrow dovetails.

Edit: I recall that several months ago someone wrote in to the forum asking how he could fashion a "thin chisel" (one recommendation was a scraper blade) into a tool that may remove the filet by chopping it away via the dovetail opening. It exists.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#48

Re: Square saw kerf

David Weaver

Does the interpretation of what is visually OK as "perfect" or "OK" differ between contesting parties here?

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#49

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

Schtoo

Hi Roger,

The quality of these two tools in not in question, only how they feel and balance in your hands.

So simply put, we can't tell you! Nobody can, except yourself.

Maybe the only thing I can suggest is that because the Koyamaichi chisels are very much based on a standard Japanese pattern 'oire-nomi' that if you can pick up a generic Japanese chisel, see what it feels like in your hands and maybe make a tentative decision based on that. If the Japanese chisel feels like it will work, then I think you'll be safe. If the Japanese chisel feels poor, then perhaps the Blue Spruce would be a superior choice.

While I'm here, the Koyamaichi chisels should not be 'whacked', but tapping gently with a hammer or mallet won't hurt them too much. In the smaller sizes, I don't think you'd need to be reminded that there isn't much metal there, so they are not superlatively tough and can be damaged. Goes for any smaller tool, especially those trimmed down in dimensions for fitting into tighter areas.

(I'll add here, I only have Koyamaichi chisels in this 'dovetail' style. In fact, they're the only chisel I'll actually buy nowadays for my own personal use. Blame that on selling them and knowing Mr. Koyama(ichi) personally. I suppose that affects how I wrote the above, but not the message. If you need chisels in this style, you have to get the ones you will use most effectively regardless of who made them or where they were made...)

Skew and fishtail chisels.

Hmm...

The last half blind dovetails I did, I made up a pair of left and right skew chisels to get those pesky little bits of wood out of the corners. The chisels worked well, but it was a little annoying to me to have to use two distinctly different chisels on each socket. I'd have much preferred to have had a proper flared tip chisel to do the job and I'll be as honest as I can here, I've never seen one that I'd be completely happy with.

Not sure why that is, and I'll not speculate on it.

But, I'll go back to the little caveat mentioned above about knowing a chisel maker personally and simply say "I'm working on it".

On the other question of "are dovetails used in Japanese joinery?" the answer is yes as in flared pins/sockets, but I think Wilbur covered it pretty well. I've rarely seen dovetails used in drawers and such that are on display. Most everything is either covered up, subdued or strictly utilitarian and how well the joint was covered up or subdued was the measure of the craftsman. Obvious corrections of poor work are not tolerated at all, nor is wasted material. If you couldn't get it right, then you found a less demanding line of work. Maybe as a sword tester?

And yes, as Wilbur mentioned (clever fellow, isn't he?), wood movement is, at least where I live, severe. I cannot use conventional joinery or conventional Western methods in anything I make without it tearing itself to pieces. Sometimes it takes a few years, sometimes it take a few days, but it always happens. Reinforce the joint however, execute the gluing properly and make sure the joint will be stable, and it'll hold.

On the other side of the coin, choose the right woods and you can get away with anything. Absolutely horrific risks such as glued in panels, simply end grain butt gluing and similar abhorrent tricks, done in the right material, no trouble whatsoever.

Just thought I'd pop my head in here and offer some thoughts is all.

I hope they helped.

Stu.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#50

why else to buy such a chisel......

Bill Tindall

While the focus here is on dealing with tiny dovetails I doubt this is the market Blue Spruce is addressing with these chisels. For this application all one would need would be one tiny chisel, easily home fabricated from a variety of starting materials. I have seen a triangular file employed to good effect.

Rather, the most distinguishing attribute of the Blue Spruce chisel is its short length and comfy handle. The thin blade and beveled sides are just a bonus for dovetailing. I have heard several professional cabinet makers comment favorably on Japanese chisels, not for all the reasons I have heard here, but simply because they were short and light and wonderfully balanced for tapping dovetailing operations. When tapping out waste I hold the chisel between thumb and forefinger near its bevel. Any short, light chisel excels in this position. Often there is also some paring involved. The comfy handle of the Blue Spruce means one isn't encouraged to fetch another chisel pattern for the paring. One tool does it all for what ever comes up in making a dovetail.

So, bottom line, the reason to own a Blue Spruce "dovetailing" chisel is because for some folks it is the most comfy pattern to use for this application. One does not need to be making dinky dovetails to realize its benefits, which is why it is available in substantial widths. Personally, if I was limited to only one chisel pattern this would be my choice because it is the most versatile.