Observations and Questions
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia) Rather, the most distinguishing attribute of the Blue Spruce chisel is its short length and comfy handle. The thin blade and beveled sides are just a bonus for dovetailing. I have heard several professional cabinet makers comment favorably on Japanese chisels, not for all the reasons I have heard here, but simply because they were short and light and wonderfully balanced for tapping dovetailing operations. When tapping out waste I hold the chisel between thumb and forefinger near its bevel. Any short, light chisel excels in this position. Often there is also some paring involved. The comfy handle of the Blue Spruce means one isn't encouraged to fetch another chisel pattern for the paring. One tool does it all for what ever comes up in making a dovetail. So, bottom line, the reason to own a Blue Spruce "dovetailing" chisel is because for some folks it is the most comfy pattern to use for this application. One does not need to be making dinky dovetails to realize its benefits, which is why it is available in substantial widths. Personally, if I was limited to only one chisel pattern this would be my choice because it is the most versatile.
While the focus here is on dealing with tiny dovetails I doubt this is the market Blue Spruce is addressing with these chisels. For this application all one would need would be one tiny chisel, easily home fabricated from a variety of starting materials. I have seen a triangular file employed to good effect.
Hi Bill
I'm not going to disagree with your comments about using a short blade as this is my preference as well. I also agree that making a dedicated chisel for cleaning the waste in narrow tails is also something I would do (and have done). I doubt, however, that many woodworkers would follow suit. They would prefer to purchase a ready-made tool.
For the record, the wider BS chisels (e.g. 3/4") came later. I know - I had the second 3/4" made, and had a little part in the design that followed. There are a few outstanding features on the BS chisels, not just the short blades. The handles are quite wonderful - not only looking, but ergonomically. I like the stretched #750 profile. The blades are thin (at 1/8") and then the shoulder are hollow ground to be minimal. These small chisels are reserved for pushing and not hitting (my African Blackwood handles would not like it
).
Were these designed with "dinky" dovetails in mind? I don't know. However this raises a related question: How many forum members routinely make London-style dovetails for drawers? And the corollary is, If you do, what strategy do you use to remove the waste from the slim tails?
In the background to these questions is the impression I get from some of the replies in this thread (and others) that there is a fundamental difference in the way that the "British/Australian" school go about designing and building drawers compared to the "American" school (if I may be that reductionistic about these groups). I posed a similar question on a UK forum and no one there used the term "London dovetail". The respondents however all considered that slim style of dovetail to be the norm (as examplified in the work of Alan Peters).
Regards from Perth
Derek



