New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Requesting a chisel comparison of....

Posts

Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#1

Requesting a chisel comparison of....

roger lance

Koymaichi (LV spelling) dovetail chisels and Blue Spruce dovetail chisels. From the tool comparison below by Derek Cohen, I will be purchasing a small set of chisels for dovetail work...6,9,and 12 mm. In checking prices, I find that similar dovetail chisels from Blue Spruce are fairly close in cost. So now I ask for your expertise in assessing the quality and functionality between these two. To my inexperienced eye, the Japanese tool appears made to be struck with a mallet (lovingly) while I question if the beautiful handles of the Blue Spruce should be used this way (hand paring perhaps). Hopefully we can continue the discussion...I'm a little concerned about sensitivity of subject here....but I guess I'm ignoring that little voice and proposing the question. And if possible, please share your views on skew and fishtail chisels as well in making dovetails. Thanks in advance.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#2

buy one of each and do it yourself

Bill Tindall

As proven by the multitude of persons professionally making drawers in stuff, with a great variety of chisels, any quality chisel will be adequate in North American woods. The main deciding factor will not be the steel properties but how the chisel fits in your hand and your woodworking style. However, as someone said, if you pay 2X more for some chisel it should deliver some value for this premium-looks, fashion or performance.

The two chisels you chose are vastly different. For my style of woodworking I would pick the Blue Spruce, not for steel, but for shape. I made chisels very similar to these and I use them for everything. I bang on them and pare with them. Well, I don't open paint cans with them or cut nails. My other styles and lengths never get used in furniture construction. No doubt the Japanese developed their style of chisel to match they style of woodworking and woods. Hence, it follows that others would come to an entirely different conclusion.

Another non-obvious factor is how much total you can spend. To take an extreme example to make the point, it might be better to have 2 sizes of $100 chisels rather than one -$200 chisel. For my style of woodworking I find chisels spaced in 1/16" increments to be handy in the small sizes as well as one large one, and a few in between these. This consideration promptly led me to chisels that were less $$ per chisel. There are 4 chisels I use a lot, others less. but I don't know how I would have known what I needed until I settled more on how I was going to work to make the things I make.

The bottom line is that comparisons of near identical styles and price are useful. Comparisons among quite different styles are more limited value for making a personal decision.

Chisels are the most often used hand tool on my bench. Choose wisely.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#3

How about a loaner?

Bob Hackett

For anyone considering chisels comparisons I`d like to make an offer.

I have a rather large (some would say huge) and eclectic collection of old chisels with various well known and now defunct maker`s names on them. If someone wants to take the time to compare a wide variety of chisels I am willing to make a loan (in the spirit of Wiley Horne`s Japanese plane) of some "old iron" for comparison purposes. I`ll even turn either a paring or striking handle in appropriate wood for the test.

Any takers?

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#4

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

It's late at night, so I will just say a little, and maybe come back again to add more. Also I'm sure that there are many here who could offer more experienced advice.

I should preface my remarks with the admission that I have more chisels than I need. Chisels are my favourite tools. Nothing else gets close to providing the level of feedback in a handtool.

That said, the first thing I should point out about hooped Japanese chisels, ones that are used with a gennou, is that this is not about power (i.e. hammering the blade through the wood) but about precision. It is possible to extract more accuracy from a tap of a gennou than pushing a chisel by hand.

Of course I appreciate pushing a paring chisel as well, and here one benefits from a light blade, which means a thin blade, as this offers great feedback. You can keep your chisels with those great heftly blades (unless they are meant to power through, such as mortice chisels. I also have some rather hefty firmers for coarse work). The Kiyohisa parers have these thin blades, and feel a part of your hand ..


This is where Dave Jeske's Blue Spruce chisels shine. The blades of the detail/dovetail chisels I have are 1/8" thick.

Several years ago, when Dave began offering his dovetail chisels, I was the second person to request a 3/4" wide version. At that time the largest size was 1/2". I contacted Dave and he mentioned that he had a spare available, having made 2 when the first order came in. He sent it to me .. and I sent it back. At that time Dave was of the mind that the blade should get thicker as they got wider. The 3/4" was 3/16" thick. In my hand it felt lifeless, a blob. I asked him to keep the chisels 1/8" thick. Dave listens, and a new 3/4" duly arrived. It was perfect. I have Blue Spruce chisels in sizes from 1/8" upward to 3/4". They are just beautifully designed on a number of levels.


Another of the attractions of the Blue Spruce is the handle. It is longer than the Stanley/LN 750, and this was also important for me. The longer handles balance the blade very well, and this balance was the major reason I chose the BS over the LNs when I was looking for a set of dedicated dovetail chisels. I have a set of Stanley 750s that I modified (ground away the shoulders and turned new handles). These, too, have longer handles, ones that are modelled on a set designed by Dave for LNs. I really enjoy this set of 750s, which travel with me when I demonstrate at shows ...


Keep in mind that Dave also makes a bench chisel that is designed to be struck. I gather that they also have minimal shoulders and make fine dovetail chisels.

And, of course, there are the LN. They are excellent chisels, perhaps one of the best all-rounders around at this time, excelling in both heavy and delicate work.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#5

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

TD

"Koymaichi (LV spelling) dovetail chisels and Blue Spruce dovetail chisels. From the tool comparison below by Derek Cohen, I will be purchasing a small set of chisels for dovetail work...6,9,and 12 mm. In checking prices, I find that similar dovetail chisels from Blue Spruce are fairly close in cost. So now I ask for your expertise in assessing the quality and functionality between these two."

Quality is probably relatively equal, but I don't think the Blue Spruce chisels are as sophisticated. There is a long standing experience based bias again the kind of tang construction used in the Blue Spruce chisels. And while they may have very specific reasons for embrassing that construction, it is generally pursued because it is easier/cheaper to do. Serious people buy BS chisels, but I just can't get by it myself. A variety of other chisels people like are made the same way. Like 3 cherries, and some LV. I just won't pay a premium price for them. Japanese chisels are in general better thought out than the competition, not to mention the steel quality.

"To my inexperienced eye, the Japanese tool appears made to be struck with a mallet (lovingly) while I question if the beautiful handles of the Blue Spruce should be used this way (hand paring perhaps)."

Japanese chisel handles are made to be struck by a metal hammer. This works really well, but despite my love of those metal hammers, when I discovered the urethane carving mallet I never looked back. Saves the ears, feels good in use. Probably safe with either handle. Fancy woods are not always the right choice, they can feel stiff or brittle in use.

"Hopefully we can continue the discussion...I'm a little concerned about sensitivity of subject here....but I guess I'm ignoring that little voice and proposing the question. And if possible, please share your views on skew and fishtail chisels as well in making dovetails. Thanks in advance.""

I own tons of high end chisels, mostly Japanese. One of the things I really prefer in any chisel that is to be struck is a thick transition from handle to blade. I do not like the whole chisel to buzz when I hit it. Japanese chisels are good that way, and so are some western socket chisels like the Barrs. You can do a visual check for how thick they are and whether there are narrows that serve no purpose.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#6

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

wilbur

The main difference between Koyamaichi chisels and the Blue Spruce dovetail chisels will be (1) for the most part, you can pound away on a Japanese chisel with a hammer if you want to, (b) the feel of the chisel in your hand, and (iii) I think that Japanese chisels are easier to sharpen overall than A2 steel, but that there's not much difference in edge retention between the two.

If you look at the Blue Spruce and Japanese chisels, the blade of the Blue Spruce is longer than the blade on a Japanese chisel. This will make the balance of the chisel feel different. I like the balance and feel of Japanese chisels for chopping and paring dovetails, myself. Others will prefer the feel of a western chisel, which is fine. That's just personal preference.

The only way to tell is to pick up one of each, and see which one you like better. An alternative is to just go with one or the other. Either one will be nice to use, and if you go with either type of chisel, you'll be able to do high quality woodworking. Having a chisel is better than having no chisel.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#7

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The two types of chisels that you mention, Roger, are very different in feel and somewhat different in steel. If one style does not jump out at you, I would recommend holding back and not buying a set right away. Perhaps you could buy one and see how you like it, or even wait until you have experience making dovetails before buying one of these chisels.

It may surprise you, but these are not traditional tools for making dovetails. I was making dovetails for perhaps ten years before the term "dovetail chisel" appeared in print. Maybe these chisels are nice for the guy who has everything, but they certainly would not make my list for the first 300 tools one might buy.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#8

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yes, it wasn't until about two years ago that I bought any chisels that one could say the purchases were driven by dovetail concerns; and that wasn't for through dovetails, but hidden/mitered.

Pam

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#9

What makes the perfect dovetail chisel?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The question raised could instead ask, "is a dedicated dovetail chisel necessary?". In my understanding, the answer is a definitive "maybe".

Warren pointed out that he does not use anything special. I know of many who are happy using thin firmer-type (square sided) paring chisels. And I can see where this would be perfectly adequate. I can also anticipate where this would make life uncomfortable, and a bevel edges shape would definitely be preferred.

As I mentioned in my post above, you can use any chisel type for removing the waste on dovetail pins. Pins are square sided and there are no awkward angles with which to deal. Removing the waste from the angled sidewall of a tail is trickier since you want to avoid bruising the corners (as this will affect the way they look once completed). The question is, "does one require a chisel with non-existant sidewalls to do this?". Chisels such as the Blue Spruce and the LN.

The short answer is that it is quite possible to remove the waste from tails without a non-shouldered chisel. I can understand the critical looks of some when these "newfangled shoulderless chisels" are trotted out as the Be-all-to-end-all. There are conditions, however, in using high shouldered chisels. The main condition is that there is room to skew a narrower chisel to work away the waste at the corner of the sidewall. So the wider the dovetail, the easier it is to find a chisel to fit when skewed this way.

But what if you do not have room to maneuver like this? For example, skinny London dovetails that are but 1/8" wide at the base. Warren, do you make dovetails like this, and if so, what technique do you use? What did the Cabinetmakers of Olde do, or are narrow shouldered bevel edged chisels not just a modern invention as some suggest? I suspect that at least one chisel was ground down for this purpose. I simply cannot otherwise see how else this style of dovetail could be made ...

For myself - an amateur woodworker who cares not a whit about the number of chisels I own, as long as I have a place to store them (and at the risk of getting flamed for saying this: there seems to be some machismo strutting when some suggest that 'one does not need anything but the most basic of basic chisel to do everything') - it helps a great deal to have a chisel that makes life easier because it is designed to do a specific task.

LN improved on the Stanley 750 by offering a shoulderless version. Blue Spruce came along and did the same, although their design is quite different. Socket versus Tang is a personal choice (The balance is different. Tanged chisels are lighter, more along the linges of traditional paring chisels. Sockets are designed for heavy duty and probably survive heavy blows better). Japanese "dovetail" chisels are not called this because of their apparent intended purpose, but because of their profile - they all have shoulders. This is the reason I went the extra yard to ensure that mine are shaped without shoulders. Is the dovetail a joint used in Japan? I suspect that it is not traditional joint there. Anyone? Wilbur?

Your thoughts ...

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#10

for Roger...chisel construction

Bill Tindall

(the rest already know this). Many (historically maybe all) chisels are forged with a handle set into the socket of the forging. This operation is beyond the scope of many small manufacturing operations. It could be argued, without merit for your application, that a forged chisel will be more robust.


Alternatively, a chisel can be simply cut from bar stock, shaped, heat treated and stuck in a handle. No glamorous pictures of period dressed fabricators can be derived from these mundane operations. The picture shows my minimalist application of this technique, while Blue Spruce illustrates a most refined application. This technique can be practiced by anyone with a hack saw, so the product has less appeal to some. But does this approach yield a sufficiently robust chisel? Yes, indeed.

For purposes of setting the handle I have bashed the handles of some recalcitrant chisels with frightening forces from a 2 pound hammer while the blade was captured in the vice. Never broke a handle. For paring and the gentle tapping required for dovetails you will never challenge the durability of this style.

Indeed, as the above posts have so clearly illustrated, chisels are all about style. Anything you pay at least $20 for will function make drawers. It is up to you to determine the style you want. The best advice you got is to buy one before you buy a set.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#11

Amen to dovetailing pattern

Bill Tindall

Dovetailing chisels are versatile. I have no need for a skew chisel for half blinds. My multitasking "dovetailing" chisels fit in there and slice off this waste just handily. One, or two less skew chisels to own and occupy space. What ever the advantage is for having straight sides on a chisel, or a thick blade, I have yet to discover. And I find I don' t like long chisels even for paring. And I definitely don't like top heavy chisels for chopping where I hold the chisel near it bevel. A long heavy handle gives me hand cramps.

Multitasking "floats my boat" and multitasking dovetailing chisels do it all. I have a set of traditional western chisels and I haven't picked one up in years. Ditto for the occasional Japanese and antique chisel that used to occupy bench space.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#13

Re: What makes the perfect dovetail chisel?

Warren in Lancaster, Pa

In his Japanese Woodworking Tools (1984) Toshio Odate pictures what we now call a "dovetail chisel" and says they were used for getting into tight places like a sliding dovetail. He says Japanese craftsman rarely used dovetails on box corners like we do. My memory is that these chisels were first marketed to Americans as dovetail chisels in the 1980s. I would be somewhat surprised to see one of these chisels in the shop of a long time professional. I do have a Butcher chisel with very slightly relieved edges (maybe 6 degrees), probably done by the previous owner who died in 1982.

I have made very delicate pins at times, but rarely. I have had to repair drawers where excessively thin pins have broken off, so making this type of pin would make me uneasy.

I thought Roger should hold off buying a set because 1. He didn't really know what kind he wanted, 2 he gave the impression that money was an issue, 3 they were certainly not necessary. I think he would have a better idea with more experience.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#14

Re: What makes the perfect dovetail chisel?

Bill Tindall

"I would be somewhat surprised to see one of these chisels in the shop of a long time professional."

I have never seen a $75 chisel in any professional shop. The ones I know couldn't afford a set at this price. The tool they already own is most often "perfect enough". (No doubt there are exceptions to this observation.)

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#15

One thing many people overlook

Bob Hackett

When we are talking historically we`re talking about a time when most people carried at least a pen knife in their pocket and used that simple tool as an extension of their hand. Remember when it was common to sit and pick up a twig or scrap of wood and whittle something without even thinking about it? That was because you first started doing that as a right of passage when you were given your first knife as a pre-teen.

You`d be surprised how many of the old boat builders rely on a pocket knife to do what no other store bought tool will do. The ones with 3 different blades were especially popular up here and would get into places nothing else would,like the corners of dovetails.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#16

Re: What makes the perfect dovetail chisel?

Bob Hackett

People who came into the shop of one of the boatyards I worked at would always remark on how I had a Snap-on toolbox that cost $5000 yet most of the tools (outside of wrenches and air tools) in it were hand made. I told them I blew the budget on the box. :D

The real reason was that boat building requires very specialized tools and the few folks who produce them make them in rather small production runs so the price is usually astronomical. The thought pattern in many of the yards seems to be that if you want to be able to build a yacht then you better be prepared to start out building the tools needed to make a boat.

Showing up with nothing but new store bought tools is a sure sign of a "newbie" who "Let his wind fill the sails" rather than letting his work do the talking for him.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#17

David Barnett

You're so right.

David Barnett

The knife is so basic, so versatile, it was the very basis of Sloyd education for the youngest child. I recently reread Wille Sundqvist's Swedish Carving Techniques, which emphasizes this so thoroughly.

Boston's North Bennet Street School was originally founded as a Sloyd institution. From their site:

The Philosophy of Sloyd

Pauline Agassiz Shaw, NBSS's founder, was a visionary educator and proponent of the Swedish system of manual training known as �sloyd� which means �craft� or �hand skills.� The sloyd method focused on the development of character and intellectual capacity, as well as technical skills. This method encourages students to systematically develop their hand skills, along with an understanding of tools, materials, processes, and a sense of care and commitment to excellence in their craft. Shaw saw the NBSS�s mission as teaching the �whole person� not only how to make a living, but how to live.

In England, they departed from this intimacy with the knife, fearing to allow children unsupervised use of sharp objects. Instead, they adopted the chisel, handing them out and taking them back after each use. Scandinavians taught and allowed knife use from the time an child could reasonably hold and manipulate one.

I use an old whittler pattern three-blade knife for all manner of cleanup and tweaking, scraping, scoring, marking. It lives on my bench when it isn't in my hand. I kind of 'think' with it in my hand, fiddling about whatever I've just done until I'm ready for the the next task. Another pocketknife stays next to my Taig lathe and yet another on my jeweler's bench.

I always used a pocketknife for dovetail layout, marking, and cleanup. I've made a couple traditional marking knives, but most always reach for the pocketknife.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#18

Re: You're so right.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

Do you really believe that those London dovetails that are the pride of Ye Olde English cabinetmaker as well as more modern ones, such as Alan Peters, were cut with a pocket knife?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#19

David Barnett

Now that's a thought

David Barnett

From Luthiers Mercantile International (LMI):

"Classical guitar builder Eugene Clark was trained in Mexico and claims that a guitar can be built with nothing but a cuchillo (a specially shaped knife commonly used in Mexico for building guitars). This includes the perfectly circular tuning post holes!"

But no, Alan Peters didn't whittle no dovetails with no pocketknife, much less a Sloyd, but I'm not sayin' he couldn't have if he'd wanted to. And I wasn't exactly saying, either, that he had to DT with a chisel because they wouldn't give him no damned pocketknife when he was toddler, but now that I think about it... :)

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#20

Re: Now that's a thought

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

If you learn to saw to a line properly and learn to chop to the line properly, you really don't need special chisels to make dovetails. Any cleanup is minor, and could easily be done with a knife, even for those skinny pinned versions.

Pam

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#21

David Barnett

You're exactly right

David Barnett

The joys of tweaking.

Aside from the small, thin blade on my 'peanut' pocketknife, another tool I've used for very narrow DTs are barrette and knife needle files in '0' cut. These really do the trick, cut clean and smooth in the tightest corners. The barrette is a flat triangle with two 'safe' sides, the knife is an elongated triangle with the short side 'safe'. They're affordable, so buy Grobet, Pferd, or F. Dick.

I had to make a miniature chest where I even used a 55mm escapement barrette. Another thing, files work well in ebony, box, ivory, bone, and so on. Hints: good light, magnification, ease up on the coffee.

Now if you know a maxillofacial surgeon, they have these really neat little saws that are only 11mm cutting length. Grind a recess in the back, epoxy on a flat handle, and see what that can do for you. :)

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#22

Learn to saw

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I agree with Pam: saw to the line. That is the best way to clean out corners. No need for special chisels, files, knives, lasers or dental picks.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#23

Reading too deep into it.

Bob Hackett

What I was trying to convey was the pocket knife was many times used for clean up duties where we might today either regrind a chisel for a particular purpose or those of us with cash just burning to jump into someone else`s pockets might actually pay as much as 4 times the going price of a high quality pen knife for a fancy tool that is nowhere near as versatile.

Don`t tell me they chop,whittle,carve,mark out or otherwise fashion dovetails with only a skew chisel or one of those more triangular than rectangular fishtail chisels down in OZ. :D

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#24

Dovetails in Japanese woodworking

wilbur

"Japanese "dovetail" chisels are not called this because of their apparent intended purpose, but because of their profile - they all have shoulders. This is the reason I went the extra yard to ensure that mine are shaped without shoulders. Is the dovetail a joint used in Japan? I suspect that it is not traditional joint there."

Dovetails are used in a lot of Japanese joinery. You can find dovetail joints, or complex joints that incorporate a dovetail as part of the joint, in many examples of Japanese woodworking. Dovetails are found in joints that would probably not have them in the western woodworking tradition, such as incorporating a dovetail in a joint to connect two boards together end to end, or as part of a joint that would serve the same purpose as a mortise and tenon joint.

What you don't find are through dovetail joints being used to hold together the corners of a box or drawer. If dovetails were used for this purpose, they would often be what Frank Klausz calls the secret mitered dovetail joint. For drawers in a tansu, oftentimes the front, sides, and back of drawers in the tansu would be constructed with a 3 or 5 fingered box joint that was pegged with a thin wooden dowel, or a lock rabbet joint, which would also be pegged in a similar manner.

There are three reasons that I can find that explain why through dovetails weren't used at box corners to the same degree as in western furniture making. The first is aesthetic. In Japan, it wasn't considered seemly to show off your joinery, so if you made a dovetail joint, it was considered part of decorum to hide the joinery in some fashion. They would have been aghast to see super skinny pins, taking it as showing off. One can only imagine what they would have done if they saw London pattern houndstooth dovetails. ;)

Second, it was considered to be useful to hide endgrain as much as possible to minimize wood movement due to changes in humidity. A through dovetail joint exposes quite a bit of endgrain. It was felt that for tansu drawers, a pegged lock rabbet joint was the best choice to deal with the humidity issue. The flexibility of the wooden dowel peg would allow the boards of the drawer to move without splitting or having the joint come apart. I don't have data on the humidity swings in Japan, but since it's an island nation, it wouldn't surprise me if Japanese woodworkers had to deal with humidity swings that were larger than their American or European counterparts.

Third, many times the finish of choice for smaller wooden objects, like small boxes, would be an opaque lacquer, with the goal of having a smooth flawless surface, like what you might see on a piano. If a small box was made with through dovetails at the corners, eventually the wood movement would telegraph the dovetails through the lacquer finish, which Japanese woodworkers wanted to avoid. This would be another reason to use a secret mitered dovetail joint, where telegraphing would be much less of an issue.

As far as Japanese "dovetail" chisels go, they do bear a resemblance to western dovetail chisels, but they still have a small vertical component to the sides, as can be seen here:


"Shinogi" actually comes from the term used for the ridgeline of a Japanese sword, which the triangular profile of these chisels resemble, so it has nothing to do with dovetails.

Re: Requesting a chisel comparison of....

#25

thanks for the insights

Bill Tindall

that was a pleasant read.