Re: NEWS FLASH... laughable!
Bob Hackett
Your email address here appears to be invalid.If you`ll email me at bihackett@roadrunner.com I`ll be glad to reply to your comments off list.
I tried to contact you but it keeps coming back as undeliverable.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: NEWS FLASH... laughable!
Bob Hackett
Your email address here appears to be invalid.If you`ll email me at bihackett@roadrunner.com I`ll be glad to reply to your comments off list.
I tried to contact you but it keeps coming back as undeliverable.
Re: Not "show me" but "sunshine"
David Weaver
White #2 warren. It's as good as anything ever made of cast steel, just as sharp, and it's not that hard (though probably harder than old cast steel stuff).
Any extra hardness it has over cast steel will be rewarded by extra edge holding, and it fails and wears the same way.
That`s just cheating
Bob Hackett
Those guys have been making that stuff the same way for generations!You can`t count that as modern steel!They don`t even make it in factories!
Besides,they`re using recycled wrought iron to back their steel and that ain`t fair!
How can you trust people who laminate in order to save steel and then waste a bunch of it by grinding a hollow in it!It just ain`t right!
For those who may be humorically challenged,the above post was typed in satire format.It`s not my fault if your computer cannot read satire or sarcasm.I suggest you either upgrade your software or put your 3D glasses back on.
Re: Not "show me" but "sunshine"
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I don't think we are on the same page, David. You might be thinking of abrasion resistance, not hardness. Hardness has to do with carbon content and tempering temperature, not so much steel type.
What I am interested in is a nice thin laminated and tapered chisel with a delicate bolster and a nice thin tapered tang. A chisel that, like David Barnett says hones like butter, has extremely fine grain and easily achieves a fine edge.
Talk to a toolmaker or historian
Bob Hackett
Speaking strictly from a metalworkers point of view and seriously now this comes up rather often up here where you can still find laminated chisels and irons without too much trouble.I had discussed the nuances of "cast steel" with folks like Cecil Pierce and Leon from Crown Planes as they were both within easy driving distance and Cecil was a friend who I visited and talked to rather often.
Their general opinion was the closest thing to the old laminated steel was in fact Japanese steel.Wiley and I even batted this around in some of the posts and an email or two.
For a metalworker the shape of the steel is rather unimportant the analysis and quality is everything.If you know what you have in your hand you can then find out how to harden and temper it to do what you want.Many of the tools my friends thought were sub-par came to life after being properly reshaped and heat treated.
For those who are interested in finding out about early steels and tool makers one of the best sources of info that I`ve found is Skip at the Davistown Museum in Liberty Maine.They have published many very informative books on the subject and you can contact them thru their website.Skip has devoted his life to old tools and their history as well as art involving tools.
For WWers the different tool steels may seem like voodoo but for serious metalworkers,bladesmiths and toolmakers it`s everyday stuff.
iforgeiron.com and anvilfire are two excellent places to get started learning.Once you absorb most of what`s available there you can hit some links to the knifemaking forums and see that there`s still folks making things like blister steel and Wootz as well as incredible pattern welded blades.There really is little mystery out there if you know where to look.
Horse, meet Tom
John in NM
Dude, no offense, but this horse died ages ago 
The question was:
"...why would anyone (unless ignorant of such improvements) recommend such methods to beginners? "
My answer was:
"Sells magazines, polishes the ego, etc, etc....."
We were not discussing the sales of sharpening materials, rather why an author in a WW magazine would recommend, either directly or by implication, a complicated and rather arcane routine.
Oh no!It`s the ZOMBIE HORSE!!!
Bob Hackett
Pick up your shaman stones and run while you still can!
Your magic can not protect you here voodoo man! 
Re: Horse, meet Tom
TomD
Well if you are going to go back to some long distant and forgotten OP, there is no talking to you...