Not "show me" but "sunshine"
David Barnett
"Missouri is real close, it's a local call to the border. Come on down."
Yeah, I'm no longer quite so close, Larry, but thanks, nonetheless.
"It doesn't take any longer to dress an oil stone than a grinding wheel and it makes just as big a difference."
I wholly agree, although I prefer diamond for this, these days. In addition to dressing, I've cut and lapped hones from novaculite* and other recrystallized chert -- even cryptocrystalline quartz. In fact, jasper with diamond is my go-to final stone for polishing gravers.
"One thing I see is that most sharpening discussions on the web assume a straight iron. What if one wants to progress beyond the most basic rectilinear wood working?"
Much of my work involves carving tools, although nowadays, not often for wood. But restoring sixty or so moulders, some in fairly needy condition, gave me lots of practice with not-so-rectinear tools. You learn a lot re-profiling complex irons to match shrunken boxing, and for moulders that've lost their irons, learning opportunities abound.
Early on I acquired two sets of Norton stone files and a pile of much older stone files from a gunsmith's estate. These did yeoman's work on my first batch of moulders. I have no complaints with those files but do like the speed of more modern abrasives to get me close to the scribed line. I will also say that often the softer Arkansas stones did a much nicer job than their india equivalents.
Another thing I do is make shaped strops. I explained this in a recent WC post:
http://tinyurl.com/ShapedStrops
"Traditional sharpening methods, i.e. oil stones, evolved with the tools and what's needed is readily available."
Absolutely, but steels keep evolving. Novaculite, not so much. Furthermore, the sharpening technologies adapted to modern challenges can sharpen the old tools as well as the new, perhaps even better as recent research in Japan asserts. Diamond and other modern abrasives, such as CBN (cubic boron nitride) can address the hardest superalloys, powder technologies and ceramics, and still do an unexcelled job on my oldest plane irons.
"How would you sharpen these two #11 veiners and this "V" tool with diamonds? The little 1/16" veiner is difficult even though I have the slips to fit it. Old eyes, I guess."
Tiny veiners are always fun. Lots of ways to do it with diamonds, these days. There are diamond films, PSA and otherwise, from 3M and other manufacturers that are ideal, with grits into the ultrafine ranges. Of course, one can cover a conveniently shaped substrate in diamond compound and get it done. There are small diamond files, diamond lapping sticks, and diamond combined with fiber for die polishing. So diamond again for me.
In addition, there are other modern abrasive solutions: Gesswein polishing sticks, microabrasive film wrapped on a round escapement file will hone inside a veiner, as will a light touch with a shaped rotary point. Strips of steel with abrasive paper or film for the V-tool, a maple strip with diamond paste -- all work fine. But if you have oilstone slips or files in the right shape and size, those are useful on all but the harder steels, of course.
As for presbyopic eyes, I hear you. The last ten years, I've used a stereomicroscope on an articulated boom for engraving, stone setting, jewelry fabrication, gem carving, and sharpening. It's an absolute must-have for my aging diabetic eyes. It's also nice to have dual cold halogen fiberoptics on goosenecks to get the light just so. That's overkill for most folks, of course, but a Magnavisor will help a lot.
"On edit: BTW, it's traditional to have a 5� inside bevel on carving tools."
A lot easier to steer a gouge with the inside bevel, most definitely.
"If you go beyond the basics in woodworking, you're most likely going to end up using oil stones. They can be incredibly efficient, you know. Why accumulate multiple sharpening systems that won't go the distance and will end up just cluttering your work space while adding unnecessary expense?"
I started on oilstones, actually, and they served me well for nearly two decades. Later, I took my sharpening skills as a hand bookbinder to woodworking and only migrated to waterstones when I took classes after moving to Western Massachusetts. I added diamond soon after and now prefer it to both oilstones and waterstones.
Perhaps I'm just not following you on ending up using oilstones. Since abrasive papers and films can conform to almost any shape they're wrapped around or otherwise applied to, and since polishing sticks and strops can be shaped and charged with various abrasives, I don't see why someone who started with waterstones or diamond would likely or eventually settle on oilstones.
Had I started with diamond, I seriously doubt I'd ever have switched to or acquired either waterstones or oilstones, so I would've avoided the clutter and added expense of multiple equipment and supplies. I'm not saying that I regret using waterstones or oilstones -- they worked well and got me most of the distance -- but I find modern abrasive products so versatile, affordable, and often superior to either that for me it'd be a painful and limiting regression.
Also, for me, probably moreso than for others here, diamond offers a complete abrasives continuum. My mixed media interests span woodworking, ferrous/nonferrous and precious metals, faceting and carving gems, and glass casting, so diamond is a very natural choice.
But when you finally get down to it, to each his own, different strokes for different folks, whatever floats your boat, and vive la diff�rence!
*I was fortunate to get some nice material from a lapidary whose grandfather had kept boxes labeled Sutton, 1000 Year, and so on. I've heard Magnet Cove still allow folks to dig their own, but with all the knappers these days, that may have ended.

:D:D


