New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

EZE Lap Plate

Posts

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#51

David Barnett

Not "show me" but "sunshine"

David Barnett

"Missouri is real close, it's a local call to the border. Come on down."

Yeah, I'm no longer quite so close, Larry, but thanks, nonetheless.

"It doesn't take any longer to dress an oil stone than a grinding wheel and it makes just as big a difference."

I wholly agree, although I prefer diamond for this, these days. In addition to dressing, I've cut and lapped hones from novaculite* and other recrystallized chert -- even cryptocrystalline quartz. In fact, jasper with diamond is my go-to final stone for polishing gravers.

"One thing I see is that most sharpening discussions on the web assume a straight iron. What if one wants to progress beyond the most basic rectilinear wood working?"

Much of my work involves carving tools, although nowadays, not often for wood. But restoring sixty or so moulders, some in fairly needy condition, gave me lots of practice with not-so-rectinear tools. You learn a lot re-profiling complex irons to match shrunken boxing, and for moulders that've lost their irons, learning opportunities abound.

Early on I acquired two sets of Norton stone files and a pile of much older stone files from a gunsmith's estate. These did yeoman's work on my first batch of moulders. I have no complaints with those files but do like the speed of more modern abrasives to get me close to the scribed line. I will also say that often the softer Arkansas stones did a much nicer job than their india equivalents.

Another thing I do is make shaped strops. I explained this in a recent WC post:

http://tinyurl.com/ShapedStrops

"Traditional sharpening methods, i.e. oil stones, evolved with the tools and what's needed is readily available."

Absolutely, but steels keep evolving. Novaculite, not so much. Furthermore, the sharpening technologies adapted to modern challenges can sharpen the old tools as well as the new, perhaps even better as recent research in Japan asserts. Diamond and other modern abrasives, such as CBN (cubic boron nitride) can address the hardest superalloys, powder technologies and ceramics, and still do an unexcelled job on my oldest plane irons.

"How would you sharpen these two #11 veiners and this "V" tool with diamonds? The little 1/16" veiner is difficult even though I have the slips to fit it. Old eyes, I guess."

Tiny veiners are always fun. Lots of ways to do it with diamonds, these days. There are diamond films, PSA and otherwise, from 3M and other manufacturers that are ideal, with grits into the ultrafine ranges. Of course, one can cover a conveniently shaped substrate in diamond compound and get it done. There are small diamond files, diamond lapping sticks, and diamond combined with fiber for die polishing. So diamond again for me.

In addition, there are other modern abrasive solutions: Gesswein polishing sticks, microabrasive film wrapped on a round escapement file will hone inside a veiner, as will a light touch with a shaped rotary point. Strips of steel with abrasive paper or film for the V-tool, a maple strip with diamond paste -- all work fine. But if you have oilstone slips or files in the right shape and size, those are useful on all but the harder steels, of course.

As for presbyopic eyes, I hear you. The last ten years, I've used a stereomicroscope on an articulated boom for engraving, stone setting, jewelry fabrication, gem carving, and sharpening. It's an absolute must-have for my aging diabetic eyes. It's also nice to have dual cold halogen fiberoptics on goosenecks to get the light just so. That's overkill for most folks, of course, but a Magnavisor will help a lot.

"On edit: BTW, it's traditional to have a 5� inside bevel on carving tools."

A lot easier to steer a gouge with the inside bevel, most definitely.

"If you go beyond the basics in woodworking, you're most likely going to end up using oil stones. They can be incredibly efficient, you know. Why accumulate multiple sharpening systems that won't go the distance and will end up just cluttering your work space while adding unnecessary expense?"

I started on oilstones, actually, and they served me well for nearly two decades. Later, I took my sharpening skills as a hand bookbinder to woodworking and only migrated to waterstones when I took classes after moving to Western Massachusetts. I added diamond soon after and now prefer it to both oilstones and waterstones.

Perhaps I'm just not following you on ending up using oilstones. Since abrasive papers and films can conform to almost any shape they're wrapped around or otherwise applied to, and since polishing sticks and strops can be shaped and charged with various abrasives, I don't see why someone who started with waterstones or diamond would likely or eventually settle on oilstones.

Had I started with diamond, I seriously doubt I'd ever have switched to or acquired either waterstones or oilstones, so I would've avoided the clutter and added expense of multiple equipment and supplies. I'm not saying that I regret using waterstones or oilstones -- they worked well and got me most of the distance -- but I find modern abrasive products so versatile, affordable, and often superior to either that for me it'd be a painful and limiting regression.

Also, for me, probably moreso than for others here, diamond offers a complete abrasives continuum. My mixed media interests span woodworking, ferrous/nonferrous and precious metals, faceting and carving gems, and glass casting, so diamond is a very natural choice.

But when you finally get down to it, to each his own, different strokes for different folks, whatever floats your boat, and vive la diff�rence!

*I was fortunate to get some nice material from a lapidary whose grandfather had kept boxes labeled Sutton, 1000 Year, and so on. I've heard Magnet Cove still allow folks to dig their own, but with all the knappers these days, that may have ended.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#52

David Barnett

Well, when you put it that way *LINK*

David Barnett

"Would an old pro with a good set of oil stones have more down time on them. I doubt it. How many less cabinets did James Krenov deliver because he decided not to shift to waterstones or scary sharp?"

I doubt that an experienced oil stone user would ever feel limited. No, my main point when arguing for diamond was the initial cost to beginners and the elimination of unnecessary steps. I still do not see how Arkansas stones or water stones offer any advantages over diamond.

"There is also the whole small tool thing. Diamond over soft iron is not a very durable surface, if highly abrasive. I might not choose to use them on small gravers and chisels, and would reach for ceramic stones, or oils stones. It is too easy to catch a corner."

Which is why I still use oilstones and ceramics for gravers and other small tools with high sectional density when sharpening freehand. I do, however, use diamond on these stones for HSS. For most graver shaping, sharpening and polishing, especially when facing M42 and CarbaltXD�, it's diamond plates, whether static or rotary, which is the pretty much the standard, these days.

"Think of the long promoted DMT stones. Not a nice surface for small tools."

I have several of those DMT stones and have never been fond of them. Not only are they annoying to use, all but impossible on small tools, as you note, but they're monocrystalline, which is not my preference. Even the new continuous DMT plates are still monocrystalline, so they don't get my vote.

As Allied High Tech puts it:

MONOCRYSTALLINE DIAMOND provides a cost effective means for good stock removal and finish. It has a slightly irregular shape with multiple cutting edges, and is recommended for general applications where polycrystalline's features are not required.

POLYCRYSTALLINE DIAMOND has many more cutting surfaces per particle, resulting in higher removal rates. As it cuts, it breaks down in its original shape, allowing for finer finishes in less time than when using monocrystalline diamond. Because polycrystalline has no cleavage planes, it cannot crack or splinter like monocrystalline diamond. It causes less sub-deformation, and is excellent when polishing samples composed of different materials/hardness.


IMO, you can pretty much get by with one diamond stone for everything, including small, pointy tools; the polycrystalline EZE-lap fine (600 grit) 2-1/2" x 11-3/8" x 3/8, which can be had for $49.95 US (when it's in stock, which is sporadic). For chisels and planes, go right to the 14000 grit lap. For gravers, finish up on a ceramic.


EZE-lap fine stone - 2-1/2" x 11-3/8" x 3/8"

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#53

Re: Not "show me" but "sunshine"

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Steels keep evolving, yes, but but the best tools I have used were made 200 years ago. These tools seem extremely soft when sharpening and can be quickly renewed. Yet they have extremely fine texture which allows for a fantastic edge which has good longevity. I sorely wish we had tools like this today available in catalogues.

I don't see straight razor users lining up to buy chrome steels. Nor do I see razor users foregoing stropping. Maybe woodworkers are not so discriminating, but your face can feel the difference.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#54

David Barnett

Old, no-name steels

David Barnett

"Steels keep evolving, yes, but but the best tools I have used were made 200 years ago. These tools seem extremely soft when sharpening and can be quickly renewed. Yet they have extremely fine texture which allows for a fantastic edge which has good longevity. I sorely wish we had tools like this today available in catalogues."

I have a few of those irons, too, and you are so right. I've described them as buttery. To quote myself from a previous thread:

"Those buttery-honing high-carbon fine-grained water-quenched simple tool steels of yesteryear."

And for those irons, I do agree that Arkansas stones are a superb match and a joy to use. Tools like those also take a very sharp edge with minimal effort. Sure, you'll go back to your stone a bit sooner, but it's a fast turnaround. A lot of understanding went into those steels, both in alloying and the heat treat. A lot more skill with a lot less technology and instrumentation, too.

"I don't see straight razor users lining up to buy chrome steels. Nor do I see razor users foregoing stropping. Maybe woodworkers are not so discriminating, but your face can feel the difference."

Fie on that first batch of chromium steel, ineluctable though it undoubtedly was.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#55

Re: From the peanut gallery

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

That does leave me wondering Derek, how you got off the stones with a dull tool in the first place. I am most indebted to the razor crowd for the wet fingernail, wet fingertip thing.

Hi Tom

There is a point of interest here, that is, do you test each blade for sharpness after sharpening?

I don't. I do what I believe should get a sharp edge, believe that it will be sharp, and just use it.

With a hollow ground 3V blade, I am able to achieve a wire edge on a micro secondary bevel with just a few strokes on a Pro Shapton 1000. The issue is not with the coarser stone. The issue is at the polishing end of the regime. The polishing needed for an A2 blade is not enough for the 3V.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#56

Re: "sunshine?"

Larry Williams

David,

There's an underlying acceptance of technological Darwinism in your comment, "Absolutely, but steels keep evolving. Novaculite, not so much. Furthermore, the sharpening technologies adapted to modern challenges can sharpen the old tools as well as the new..."

I think modern varieties of steel have a lot in common with modern varieties of tomatoes. The "improvements" have a lot to offer to the supply chain but not so much the end user unless you're fond of the taste and nutritional value of cardboard. When is the last time you saw the white bones of a mature chicken on your plate after a meal of fried chicken? Yeah, technology can make a baby chicken grow faster and you can take Viagra to overcome the effects of the estrogen they feed chickens to make 'em grow. I don't think a lot of the "improvements" necessarily make things better.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#57

David Barnett

Re: "sunshine?"

David Barnett

While your distaste for modern tomatoes and chickens is entirely founded and shared, I'm not so sure it's isomorphically mappable onto tool steel innovation, but I do get it. It's probably more helpful, though, to discuss steel in the language of metals and the specific applications for which those steels have been developed than analogies from unsavory agribusiness, practices, entertaining though that is.

I doubt all of these steels could succeed where there was no need, which doesn't in any way excuse their misapplication and misuse. For example, simple high carbon steel just won't cut it (quite literally) for gravers when you're cutting hard modern firearm alloys. For that you need tough cobalt alloys such as M42, which responds well to diamond. To use M42 for a paring chisel makes little sense, I'll grant you.

As I've just written to Warren on this thread, those older, simpler tool steels are wonderful to use and sharpen, especially on domestic woods, but perhaps less so on some tropicals that are now widely available. As Warren stated, those steels are simply not available in our modern catalogs. So now, we're stuck with Cr and V and Mn and Mo and a few others. So, I do understand.

And I used evolved because you used it in your prior post...

"Traditional sharpening methods, i.e. oil stones, evolved with the tools and what's needed is readily available."

...rather than any actual "underlying acceptance of technological Darwinism" in my comment, although admit I may be guilty of that from time to time.

I ate a tomato yesterday that was tough as a golf ball and every bit as tasty.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#58

For Marc Adams Students

roninkokomo

We get into these discussions at least twice a year. Would some other Marc Adams student besides me care to share what he learned from Tage Frid on this issue?

Yes.. I really do have three totally different sharpening systems and do use them a lot, BUT.....

I really do think sometimes we get way more interested in sharpening than we are in working wood.

Ron ( ducking behind the sharpening bench)

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#59

A more apt simile

Bob Hackett

I would like to introduce what I feel in a better comparison and perhaps context.

I think of the comparison of new and old steels as being very close to medicine,the old steel is like the herbal remedies that our forefathers used.They do the job but you have to know where to get them,how to work with them and their appropriate uses.New steels are like pharmaceuticals,they have been highly refined and synthesized in facilities where their manufacture is closely monitored and controlled. They are usually meant to be used for more narrow and specific applications.Some find them more harsh in their action and there can be side effects that make their use difficult without consulting people who have specialized knowledge and training.

As far as steel being made more for the manufacturers and less for the end user I believe that has always been the case.As demand for something goes up manufacturers look for ways to produce it more cheaply by way of improved techniques or processes that cut labor/manufacturing costs.Along the way they discover ways to substitute cheaper materials/ingredients or eliminate materials or processes that have little to no percieved impact on the final product.

The is a HUGE difference between durable goods such as steel which benefit from technology like digital controls during smelting,refining,alloying and especially heat treating and analysis and consumable goods such as food where nature still holds the cards and we are dependent on the luck of the draw.Vastly different equations with several orders of magnitude more variables involved in growing rather than making the things in question.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#60

Lubrication with eze-lap?

Howard Pollack

Do you use lubrication with the eze-lap stone? If so, what do you use? If not, does it get plugged up? Thanks for all the information.

-Howard

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#61

Not just Marc Adams Students

Bob Hackett

What I am seeing here is the old science vs magic routine.

The science guys want to get back to making stuff the magic guys want to wear the fancy robes and amaze people with their talents.

For those who came for the show,grab a seat,the wizard will appear shortly.You may want to put on your 3D glasses to get the full effect.

Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain!

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#62

Re: Well, when you put it that way

TomD

"I doubt that an experienced oil stone user would ever feel limited. No, my main point when arguing for diamond was the initial cost to beginners and the elimination of unnecessary steps. I still do not see how Arkansas stones or water stones offer any advantages over diamond."

I don't know if I would go that far, but I basically agree with that. But that would be a pretty low standard, the vast majority of my tools are useless to beginners. I would support a wider claim as I am sure you also do.

"Which is why I still use oilstones and ceramics for gravers and other small tools with high sectional density when sharpening freehand. I do, however, use diamond on these stones for HSS."

You mean all your oilstones are diamond impregnated. I haven't done that yet for a variety of reasons, but it's a point. When you do that, do you still need the oil? If not then I assume it is just a substrate for the diamonds. That could have practical advantages, gut I wouldn't want to eliminate my oil stones for that purpose, at least not yet.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#63

Re: Not "show me" but "sunshine"

TomD

My tools are kinda evolving in that direction also, but I don't find that performance works on harder woods. There I need the uptick to japanese tools, or HSS tools. Western HSS is not easy to hand sharpen, which is where the diamonds or power comes in. But most of my work is on woods that the traditional/O1 tools handle easily. The main problem we have over the old days is that whatever people say about the license plate number steels, they were not designed for making hand tools.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#64

Re: Well, when you put it that way

TomD

By the way, on the beginner thing. I would encourage them to power sharpen. Learning to grind, like welding, is one of the most liberating workshop skills one will discover. I would still want power for some sharpening like wood turning tools, or machine tools, not to mention took making. So I think power is more fundamental. I know this is the hand tools forum, but the hand tools are all made with power.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#65

Re: "sunshine?"

TomD

"While your distaste for modern tomatoes and chickens is entirely founded and shared, I'm not so sure it's isomorphically mappable onto tool steel innovation, but I do get it. It's probably more helpful, though, to discuss steel in the language of metals and the specific applications for which those steels have been developed than analogies from unsavory agribusiness, practices, entertaining though that is.we're stuck with Cr and V and Mn and Mo and a few others. So, I do understand."

It is and isn't the same. The analogy from food would be the same if food where not even designed for human consumption, the driver was some completely different use. But it is apt in the sense that food isn't primarily created with a concern for human nutrition and safety, and is inappropriate for those aims. When a tomato hits your plate without any vitamin C in it, that's a problem.

It is the case that these modern steels are not designed as stock for hand tool woodworking, or anything similar. And part of the disconnect is the feeling of inapplicability. It's like that guy you take on the canoe trip because he effortlessly carried the heaviest boat over the longest portages, but is a boring and vulgar companion otherwise.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#66

Re: From the peanut gallery

TomD

I would test every blade that came off a stone if some of them regularly revealed themselves as dull. The great thing about the razor test is that it takes no time, and does no damage. It is also interesting to speculate why professionals who traffic in razor sharp edges invented the test.

To answer your question. For me, sharpening is one of those things that goes in and out of phase. At some point the tool is in good condition, the sharpening was undertaken soon enough, the technique well done, stones in good condition, etc... Coming off all that I would be surprised at the edge not being perfect. i might go through a stage of that harmonious use. But things can tip in the other direction and I might be testing a bunch of the time. I can't really see getting deeply stuck into some new tools without any idea of their sharpness.

Actually, while we are on this whole new vs old tech stuff. One nice thing about organic sharpening is I know that any of the stuff getting into my mouth is not poisonous.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#67

Re: Not just Marc Adams Students

TomD

I'm sorry? Did I miss something? Can you show me a single scrap of science associated with this thread or any other on this subject? Just more rhetoric.

NASA may employ scientists. That wouldn't make you more scientific for playing with a Buzz Lightyear action figure, than the girl with the rag doll. :)

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#68

Bob, you crack me up

John in NM

I think you've got it there, neatly summed up in a few amusing sentences, though I see the hyperbole is already fanning the flames :D:D:D

I need to find you a nice antique bellows and get Marv to carve some wheat and your initials on it :D

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#69

NEWS FLASH...

Bob Hackett

Scientists have conclusively proven that diamonds are more durable(less prone to degrade by fracturing and/or rounding) than chert/flint (novaculite)!

This just in;Cast iron scientifically proven to require flattening less often than either natural or manufactured waterstones/oilstones!

Also proven to need replacement less often due to wear than oilstones or waterstones!

Although CI tied with stones durability wise in the drop test.

In the economic news,$15 is still less than $40 no matter how you look at it!The laws of mathematics(science) still prove that.

Stay tuned for further breaking news in the worlds of SCIENCE!!!

Take it awayyy Mr Wizard! :D

Bonus question;What weighs more,a ton of lead or a ton of feathers?

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#70

David Barnett

Re: Well, when you put it that way

David Barnett

"You mean all your oilstones are diamond impregnated."

No. Just the ones that I for gravers and very small incising knives and so on. I have other Arkansas stones that are diamond-free, as are all my slips and stone files, and diamond-free they'll likely remain.

"When you do that, do you still need the oil? If not then I assume it is just a substrate for the diamonds.That could have practical advantages, but I wouldn't want to eliminate my oil stones for that purpose, at least not yet."

I use oil on most quarried stones charged with diamond, especially with oil-based diamond paste, but it's not a must. My polishing stones, both microcrystalline and crypto (such as jasper or chrysoprase), can be charged with oil-based diamond and used with water, glycerin, oil, or dry. And only the jasper and ceramics made specifically for diamond (such as spray diamond in very low concentration) do I even think of as substrates for diamond. The other stones I consider diamond-enhanced.

There's really no need to use diamond along with oilstones unless you're either dissatisfied with that stone's performance, or dressing/flattening that stone, which includes removing glaze.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#71

Don`t go to any trouble John

Bob Hackett

As most of the people who read my posts know,I am not suffering from lack of wind. :D

I appreciate the thought though.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#72

David Barnett

It took me awhile, and it's rather brief, Tom...

David Barnett

... but no way can I let such a lively and provocative reply go unanswered, especially when you're obviously having so much fun, heh.

"Yeah well hollow grinding is tool abuse, and any method is fast with hollow grinding, I would rarely make ten strokes with a waterstone and hollow grinding. One can get into a whole big deal on HG. I use it for some stuff, and not for others, and some stuff I hollow grind then don't bother and just let it fill in."

I won't even began to argue in favor of removing metal behind the edge for any reasons other than speed and convenience in honing. I'll freely admit my penchant for committing the vile act, sometimes publicly, in fact.

I'll further admit that I do flat grind some tools -- I would never HG mortise chisels -- on a 1" x 42" belt sander with a modified platen and jig that greatly improves precision, or on an exceptionally versatile Raytech rotary lapping system with water drip intended for faceting, which is perfect for gravers.

For flat grinding large knives, as your Bowie example, I prefer a VS Wilton flat wheel belt grinder. This is also ideal for jointer/planer knives or even machetes, if you lack an exploitable child.

As for grinding things other than planes and chisels, I use it for all turning tools, whether hand held or metal lathe tool bits. I also use the Raytech with diamond over steel laps for tool bits and occasionally other turning tools.

"I would argue they shouldn't waste their time with diamonds which are inefficient compared with dry grinding and lead nowhere."

You do know, that one can (and many do) dry grind with diamond wheels, right? As for leading nowhere???

"Diamonds are a solution or a tool culture that the promoters don't have sympathy with."

"Huh??? What??? Huh??? What???" -- Merrill Beth Nisker

"If you learn dry grinding it opens up tool making and many other things. according to Bill's presentation he dry grinds tools, then sidesteps grinding when finishing the edge, which is just perverse when you already own the grinder."

Wow! Just... wow!

"Other than the already mentioned 500 reasons that the promoters of diamonds routinely ignore?"

Wow! Just... wow!

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#73

absolutely

roninkokomo

I can take a Hock iron from my 608 and scary sharp it and strop with diamond paste and quite literally shave my face with it.

I use if for a few minutes, take it out of the plane... strop it for 30 sec and put it back in the plane... a minute lapsed time and it is quite a while before I have to go back to the scary sharp or the 8000 grit water stone.. or whatever.

Plenty good enough for me.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#74

Re: NEWS FLASH...  laughable!

TomD

"Scientists have conclusively proven that diamonds are more durable(less prone to degrade by fracturing and/or rounding) than chert/flint (novaculite)!"

You're just making that up right, no citations or actual quotes from real scientific sources? Your not an expert in the field? Even though presumably true, it is hardly interesting, manufacturers have been making very bad diamond sharpening devices for decades. The recent success with current stuff shows not all diamond systems are automatically better than stones. Before throwing around claims that your method is scientific, rather than just better based on your personal experience, you have to have actual scientific evidence.

Second part of the challenge, is that should there be any scientific evidence, you have to show it was relied on in previous arguments on this subject by you so called "science guys". I think there is zero percent chance of that. You aren't for real.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#75

Re: It took me awhile, and it's rather brief, Tom.

TomD

"I won't even began to argue in favor of removing metal behind the edge for any reasons other than speed and convenience in honing. I'll freely admit my penchant for committing the vile act, sometimes publicly, in fact."

I do it too, for a variety of reasons as mentioned. Too many hobbies and sub-hobbies to keep it all straight. :) I would prefer not to hollow grind something that doesn't need it, and now that these diamonds create instantaneous results, I wonder why the rush. The marketing would work better for me if the diamond nuts said: "and now that I have diamonds the time to do a really good and appropriate job is reduced". Rather than "these things are great now I can make a bad edge faster than ever before!"

"I'll further admit that I do flat grind some tools -- I would never HG mortise chisels -- on a 1" x 42" belt sander with a modified platen and jig that greatly improves precision, or on an exceptionally versatile Raytech rotary lapping system with water drip intended for faceting, which is perfect for gravers."

There ye go!

"For flat grinding large knives, as your Bowie example, I prefer a VS Wilton flat wheel belt grinder. Tis is also ideal for jointer/planer knives or even machetes, if you lack an exploitable child."

You guys will eventually catch up... Belt sander with flexible moving platen!

"As for grinding things other than planes and chisels, I use it for all turning tools, whether hand held or metal lathe tool bits. I also use the Raytech with diamond over steel laps for tool bits and occasionally other turning tools."

Totally arguable, straight from the wheel isn't as good as honed, so honed with diamonds would be a serious uptick. Haven't got around to trying it yet.

"You do know, that one can (and many do) dry grind with diamond wheels, right? As for leading nowhere???"

My point is if you want fast, you will get more versatility out of owning a power sanding set-up, or wheel grinder. They aren't mutually exclusive, but I know which one I would take to a desert, but junk yard supplied island.

I have diamond wheels, I use them for sharpening carbide scrapers, and TIG welding electrodes. The manufacturers say don't sharpen plain steel, though the turning guys seem not to care.

"Diamonds are a solution or a tool culture that the promoters don't have sympathy with."

Just in a vast generality, The guys in a rush like xxxx are not the best guys to promote this stuff to say the folks who work with Japanese tools and value sharpening at an art level. I may be, as usual too far north to know what is really happening, but I do wonder how many inroads have been made with sword polishers. There are some seriously skilled people who won't even use man made stones. You get these wizards in a room with the scientist, and I have fairly good idea how the pecking order on woodworking will sort out.

""If you learn dry grinding it opens up tool making and many other things. according to Bill's presentation he dry grinds tools, then sidesteps grinding when finishing the edge, which is just perverse when you already own the grinder."

Wow! Just... wow!"

Well as I say, I live in canada where it takes an extra month for National geographic to show up. But I doubt all these guys that sell tools to you guys with diamonds, are actually sharpening the tools to razor sharpness prior to sale, using hand methods on scraps of CI with diamonds. Last I heard there was still a pretty good market for belt laps and super fine 2x72 abrasives, but I could be out of date.

""Other than the already mentioned 500 reasons that the promoters of diamonds routinely ignore?"

Wow! Just... wow! "

I know, I know. But I have been through a few of these threads where you guys get given 20 reasons why other people have places they prefer something other than diamonds, and all we get back is, "I have yet to hear anyone give me a reason why blah blah is better than diamonds" We are pitching, you aren't catching. I want the diamonds for my desert island kit, but that doesn't mean there isn't anything I would prefer in any case. I think they are a niche product, like everything else.