I really hate to say it, Wilbur...
David Barnett
... but you're hopelessly overcome with sanity and rife with reasonableness.
"I concentrate on what gets you to a sharp edge quickly: using a hollow grind to provide the self-jigging, the technique of sharpening a tool, showing that an inexpensive honing guide and a setting jig provides repeatability, the importance of a flat surface on your sharpening method of choice, and moving from coarser to finer grits."
Nothing to improve on there, no sir.
"That's what gives you a sharp edge, not the choice of diamonds vs. waterstones vs. oilstones vs. sandpaper."
Never said otherwise, of course. Just argued for advantages in speed, cost, eliminating intermediate honing grits, versatility on modern tool steels, and so on.
"Speed: Like Bill Tindall, I can take my waterstone set and a reground plane blade, and get it to endgrain shaving sharp in 2 minutes as well. So there's no real speed advantage to diamonds that I see."
Now, unless I'm totally mistaken, Bill counts his time at the grinder in that two minutes. I grind quickly, as well. But another minute or so doesn't make a hill of difference, so you've got parity on that point.
"Quickly learned: I can take my set of waterstones and get beginners up and running with sharpening in an hour, including showing how to maintain and flatten the waterstones."
And parity on the learning.
"Widely available: what I meant is that you can go to any woodworking store/supplier and get waterstones and diamond stones with ease."
And if that's what you meant, then that, too.
"My main point is that any advantages touted for diamond stones are not revolutionary nor are they hugely better than any other sharpening method out there."
To me there are still some pretty big advantages; especially on some of my not-so-forgiving steels.
"There are too many people who can get wickedly sharp tools with a variety of methods for there to be only one true way to sharpening."
I'm one of those people -- eclectic with any sharpening system, and I've never said there was only one true way to sharpen -- only that diamond is fast, cheap, and easy -- but I still prefer diamond for those previously stated reasons. Maybe it's a matter of degree, but while those differences may seem small to you, they remain, to me, differences that make a difference.
"And to reiterate, in that video he never claimed that his system was the only way to go, despite what many here have implied."
Agreed. I don't recall seeing where anyone implied he claimed "that his system was the only way to go", however.
"The main reason, I think, to pick any sharpening system is by choosing the one that you find least annoying."
Here here. Fair enough. Right to the core. Personal preference is entirely valid. Amen.
"For me, I just don't like the feel of sharpening tools on diamonds."
To me, that's the strongest argument you can offer. If you don't like it, end of story.
"This is completely subjective, and I know this is just me. But it is enough for me not to pick diamonds as my sharpening system of choice."
Subjective? Maybe, but they're your reasons and that's fine with me.
"You can decide if that's too much bother, and if you think it is, that's cool with me."
You've argued well and demonstrated convincingly, Wilbur. And yes, it's damned fast. Still... I don't have to flatten my diamond stones. Ever.
And it is cheaper. 
Now if anyone told me that Arkansas stones were just as fast, I'd say I was from Missouri on that one, even though I only lived there a couple years and was born one state over.