New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

EZE Lap Plate

Posts

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#26

BRILLIANT!!!

Bob Hackett

So as long as it makes dollars it doesn`t have to make sense.

Thanks for clearing that up for me.

This capitalism stuff always throws me,I suppose I`m just a realist at heart.

Well,I`m off to start my new venture selling attentive(and diamond studded) toads. :)

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#27

Re: Arghhh

wilbur

"if that new technology is faster, eliminates intermediate steps, is easily and quickly learned, cheaper, widely available, less messy and more effective on a wider range of modern tool steels..."

That presupposes the following:

1. That the new technology is faster. I've said this before, but I'll repeat it again: from my experience with waterstones, we're talking about a time savings of a few minutes, tops, and more likely 1 minute per sharpening session.

2. That the new technology eliminates intermediate steps. From my experience, I have three steps. Converting that to two steps again is a minimal improvement.

3. That the new technology is more easily learned, which I don't see as being the case.

4. Cheaper: I'll give you that one. I don't know what you think the start up cost is for diamond paste, but on eBay three syringes can be gotten for $15. My current set of waterstones would cost about $200, including a diamond plate for flattening. You can easily put together a waterstone set for much less, though. Lie-Nielsen, not a place known for bargains, sells a sharpening set including a combo waterstone, coarse sandpaper, and sharpening jig for $99. And you could find cheaper alternatives.

5. That the new technology is widely available. But it's not more widely available than waterstones.

6. That the new technology is less messy. I don't find waterstones to be particularly messy, having built a small waterstone pond to corral the water. But I don't have to worry as much with cross grit contamination, which is the diamond paste version of "messy", and from these discussions, I think I can recover more quickly from waterstone cross-contamination than diamond paste cross-contamination.

7. That the beginner is going to go straight to modern tool steels. Waterstones are effective on A-2. They might not be so effective with CPM, M2, D2, or any of the newer options. But I doubt that a beginner would start off with these tools in the first place.

I want to be clear: I believe that sharpening with diamonds is quick and effective, and suitable for teaching a beginner. I just don't believe that it is miles better than other sharpening methods out there, and so there's no reason to believe that it should be the only method for beginners. The only exception is if you are ridiculously strapped for cash. But one thing to consider is that if your budget is so tight that you can't even afford the $85 difference between diamonds and the Lie-Nielsen set, how are you going to afford to get wood? Not to mention that the tools being made with the more exotic alloys that you need the diamonds for are also going to be more expensive as well.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#28

Re: BRILLIANT!!!

John in NM

I may have to mothball my stones and just use the buffing wheel, I think I have about $30 invested in it (hand crank, bought used with the felt wheel and polish).

If I don't do this, I'd feel morally obligated to buy one of your attentive diamond studded toads! :D :D :D

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#29

David Barnett

Our mileage may vary

David Barnett

"That presupposes the following:

1. That the new technology is faster. I've said this before, but I'll repeat it again: from my experience with waterstones, we're talking about a time savings of a few minutes, tops, and more likely 1 minute per sharpening session."

I'll let Bill Tindall answer this one (from his post myth busting diamonds......., March '08): "During a recent demo we reground the bevel on a plane, and then sharpened it in less than 2 minutes. The diamond part took about 30 seconds. Seldom do I pull the tool more than 10 times down the abrasive surface to complete that sharpening step. Other than dressing the wheel occasionally there is no maintenance."

I'll add that he hollow grinds (as do I), so the bevel self-indexes on the honing stone (I use 600 grit polycrystalline), and the lap, as well -- so no jig required for most blades.

"2. That the new technology eliminates intermediate steps. From my experience, I have three steps. Converting that to two steps again is a minimal improvement."

Every intermediate step introduces the possibility for error and inconsistency, even when using a jig. However, if one's technique is excellent and everything's ready to go, no waterstones to pull out or put back into the pond, ScarySharp sandpaper already mounted for each grit, and so on, then yes, perhaps minimal improvement. Over Garrett Hack's video progression, well... that's another story.

"3. That the new technology is more easily learned, which I don't see as being the case."

Actually, what I said was "is easily and quickly learned" -- not more easily learned.

I taught several one-hour sharpening classes, start to finish, with excellent results. I covered hollow grinding and bench grinder safety, sanding and coarse stones for flat bevels (for those without grinders), honing angles and sources for a 600 grit stone and diamond paste. Yes, this was condensed and intense, but with handouts we covered the ground and everyone knew they could (with practice) achieve satisfactory and repeatable results. The survey of available waterstone choices, their care and maintenance would've taken that long without ever getting around to how they're actually used. At least that's what I think.

"4. Cheaper: I'll give you that one. ... "

"5. That the new technology is widely available. But it's not more widely available than waterstones."

That's interesting, as I counted 32 diamond bench stones in the current Woodcraft catalog, compared with 24 waterstones. As for diamond paste, they only offer 8000 grit (3 micron), and at the less than attractive price of $24.99. Many woodworking tool catalogs carry 1 micron (14000 grit) diamond paste, though (LV, Highland, et al).

And again, I only said it was widely available -- not more widely available.

"6. That the new technology is less messy. I don't find waterstones to be particularly messy, having built a small waterstone pond to corral the water. But I don't have to worry as much with cross grit contamination, which is the diamond paste version of "messy", and from these discussions, I think I can recover more quickly from waterstone cross-contamination than diamond paste cross-contamination."

I rather found flattening waterstones somewhat messy, but maybe that's just me. As for cross grit contamination, if you go from a 600 grit diamond bench stone to lapping with 14000 paste, and that's the only diamond paste you own, it's not going to be much of a problem.

"7. That the beginner is going to go straight to modern tool steels. Waterstones are effective on A-2. They might not be so effective with CPM, M2, D2, or any of the newer options. But I doubt that a beginner would start off with these tools in the first place."

I agree that waterstones are effective on modern tool steels, although they may take a bit longer and need flattening sooner. As for beginners -- perhaps not the rank beginner who buys used planes -- what about beginners who do opt for LN or LV planes from the get-go? Even if they don't start with the tougher steels, when they do get there, those Arkansas stones will be pretty slow going.

"I want to be clear: I believe that sharpening with diamonds is quick and effective, and suitable for teaching a beginner. I just don't believe that it is miles better than other sharpening methods out there, and so there's no reason to believe that it should be the only method for beginners."

Point taken on whether it's miles better. But as for beginners, what might be the advantages, as you see them, of promoting waterstones over diamond, or for that matter, as just as good?

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#30

David Barnett

Your hand-cranked buffer trumps me, ...

David Barnett

... although I think I should get a few hand tool points for occasionally thrumming my complex moulders with chromium crayon.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#31

Re: Our mileage may vary *LINK*

wilbur

"Point taken on whether it's miles better. But as for beginners, what might be the advantages, as you see them, of promoting waterstones over diamond, or for that matter, as just as good?"

That's the thing: when I've shown people how to get up and running with sharpening, I don't get bogged down with the particular system, because I don't see huge advantages of one over the other, regardless of whether you are talking about Scary Sharp, oilstones, waterstones, or diamonds. I concentrate on what gets you to a sharp edge quickly: using a hollow grind to provide the self-jigging, the technique of sharpening a tool, showing that an inexpensive honing guide and a setting jig provides repeatability, the importance of a flat surface on your sharpening method of choice, and moving from coarser to finer grits. That's what gives you a sharp edge, not the choice of diamonds vs. waterstones vs. oilstones vs. sandpaper.

Next month I'm doing a sharpening demo, and I'll be using waterstones because that's what I use. But I'm careful to emphasize that waterstones are not the only way to go, and I concentrate on the technique and principles.

As to the counterpoints you made above:

Speed: Like Bill Tindall, I can take my waterstone set and a reground plane blade, and get it to endgrain shaving sharp in 2 minutes as well. So there's no real speed advantage to diamonds that I see.

Quickly learned: I can take my set of waterstones and get beginners up and running with sharpening in an hour, including showing how to maintain and flatten the waterstones.

Widely available: what I meant is that you can go to any woodworking store/supplier and get waterstones and diamond stones with ease.

My main point is that any advantages touted for diamond stones are not revolutionary nor are they hugely better than any other sharpening method out there. There are too many people who can get wickedly sharp tools with a variety of methods for there to be only one true way to sharpening. And again, Garrett Hack may be using a system that none of us would use, but I can guarantee that for him, there are no downsides. The quality of his woodworking proves that. And to reiterate, in that video he never claimed that his system was the only way to go, despite what many here have implied.

The main reason, I think, to pick any sharpening system is by choosing the one that you find least annoying. For me, I just don't like the feel of sharpening tools on diamonds. This is completely subjective, and I know this is just me. But it is enough for me not to pick diamonds as my sharpening system of choice. I do keep in mind that others may have different preferences, which is perfectly fine.

By the way, if you want to see how much mess I make when flattening a waterstone, here's a link to a video on my blog. 35 seconds to flatness. You can decide if that's too much bother, and if you think it is, that's cool with me.


Video on flattening a waterstone

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#32

David Barnett

I really hate to say it, Wilbur...

David Barnett

... but you're hopelessly overcome with sanity and rife with reasonableness.

"I concentrate on what gets you to a sharp edge quickly: using a hollow grind to provide the self-jigging, the technique of sharpening a tool, showing that an inexpensive honing guide and a setting jig provides repeatability, the importance of a flat surface on your sharpening method of choice, and moving from coarser to finer grits."

Nothing to improve on there, no sir.

"That's what gives you a sharp edge, not the choice of diamonds vs. waterstones vs. oilstones vs. sandpaper."

Never said otherwise, of course. Just argued for advantages in speed, cost, eliminating intermediate honing grits, versatility on modern tool steels, and so on.

"Speed: Like Bill Tindall, I can take my waterstone set and a reground plane blade, and get it to endgrain shaving sharp in 2 minutes as well. So there's no real speed advantage to diamonds that I see."

Now, unless I'm totally mistaken, Bill counts his time at the grinder in that two minutes. I grind quickly, as well. But another minute or so doesn't make a hill of difference, so you've got parity on that point.

"Quickly learned: I can take my set of waterstones and get beginners up and running with sharpening in an hour, including showing how to maintain and flatten the waterstones."

And parity on the learning.

"Widely available: what I meant is that you can go to any woodworking store/supplier and get waterstones and diamond stones with ease."

And if that's what you meant, then that, too.

"My main point is that any advantages touted for diamond stones are not revolutionary nor are they hugely better than any other sharpening method out there."

To me there are still some pretty big advantages; especially on some of my not-so-forgiving steels.

"There are too many people who can get wickedly sharp tools with a variety of methods for there to be only one true way to sharpening."

I'm one of those people -- eclectic with any sharpening system, and I've never said there was only one true way to sharpen -- only that diamond is fast, cheap, and easy -- but I still prefer diamond for those previously stated reasons. Maybe it's a matter of degree, but while those differences may seem small to you, they remain, to me, differences that make a difference.

"And to reiterate, in that video he never claimed that his system was the only way to go, despite what many here have implied."

Agreed. I don't recall seeing where anyone implied he claimed "that his system was the only way to go", however.

"The main reason, I think, to pick any sharpening system is by choosing the one that you find least annoying."

Here here. Fair enough. Right to the core. Personal preference is entirely valid. Amen.

"For me, I just don't like the feel of sharpening tools on diamonds."

To me, that's the strongest argument you can offer. If you don't like it, end of story.

"This is completely subjective, and I know this is just me. But it is enough for me not to pick diamonds as my sharpening system of choice."

Subjective? Maybe, but they're your reasons and that's fine with me.

"You can decide if that's too much bother, and if you think it is, that's cool with me."

You've argued well and demonstrated convincingly, Wilbur. And yes, it's damned fast. Still... I don't have to flatten my diamond stones. Ever.

And it is cheaper. :)

Now if anyone told me that Arkansas stones were just as fast, I'd say I was from Missouri on that one, even though I only lived there a couple years and was born one state over.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#33

leisurely pace

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The leisurely pace you mention, David, puts a different perspective on sharpening with Arkansas stones. I do see sharpening as a break from work and a change of pace. Using three stones and a strop, I currently spend about 25 seconds sharpening a carving tool. I spend about 70 seconds on bench chisels and 90 seconds on plane irons. I never bother with a grinder. It could be that I could save a few seconds per tool with another method, and after using it for 30,000 tools or something that would amount to something. However, I feel that a worker does best with a method he has lots of experience using and it would be quite a few years before I was getting results on a par with what I do now.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#34

From the peanut gallery

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

This thread is a response to one started by Bill, as I recall, in reaction to Garrett Hack's sharpening video on FWW. There is a great deal here about the best sharpening media for Beginners, and I think that this misses the point of what is important. Apologies for the length - it is hard to say the following without illustrations.

I have spent a few years working wood and most of those looking for an efficient and effective way to sharpen my blades. I find sharpening intrusive, and just want to get back to the fun side asap. Getting a sharp edge on the predominant A2 blades I use is a prerequisite to work the hard, abrasive and interlocked woods of Western Australia. As a result I have experimented with several sharpening systems.

A few days ago I would have said that I have a system that works perfect for my needs, but now I am not so sure.

What it comes down to is this ...

1. The first thing I teach in workshops are the very basic principles of how a sharp edge is achieved. Thats is, two sides meeting at a point, and that "sharp" is really just another word for "smooth" - the smoother the two meeting sides, the finer the serrations at the point will be. Yada ... yada ... The goal is to make clear that there is no magic to sharpening, just a process to achieve this goal.

The second area I focus on is technique (grinding and honing). Whether grinding flat or hollow primary bevels, or sharpening freehand or with a honing guide, the goal is the same - to end up with two sides smooth sides. Some strategies are more efficient than others (I prefer working with hollow grinds) but all will get you there in the end.

In Garrett's video I observed excellent technique, which I believe was the object of this video ... not the media used, which are of secondary consideration.

I would say that good technique (strategy and method-of-work) is more important than the best sharpening media. You will generally always get a good edge with good technique (albeit it slowly), but there is no guarantee that you will get an edge at all with poor technique on the best sharpening media.

3. Depending on the blade steel, one can sharpen on anything. Hell, last night I was watching TV and gazing adhoringly at my new chisel set (that I posted the other day). I haven't got to the point of my current project where they will be needed and so they are still in the box on the glass-topped coffee table. The bevels are formed but not working sharp. I took one out and started freehanding the blade on the glass top. It seemed to get sharper, not quite able to cut hair. The thought went through my mind that I could probably get a working edge on the newsprint lying around. I would have tried but sanity prevailed as I was concerned about dubbing the edges.

I was reading an old article by David Savage (UK furniture designer/maker) in which he was critical of A2 blades as he could not get them as sharp as his O1/vintage HCS blades. I thought to myself "what am I missing here?" as I have used both for years and the A2 get as sharp as the O1, and hold the edge longer. Later in the article it transpired that he used King waterstones. I went, "OK, that explains it - King are fine on O1 and will abrade A2, but more slowly". I wonder what his conclusion may have been had he been using Pro Shapton waterstones?

So why am I now saying that my sharpening system is not the be-all-to-end-all? Well, I was using a CPM-3V plane blade on a Jarrah panel and it did not hold an edge much, if any, longer than an A2 blade. Indeed, the A2 blade seemed to be sharper initially as well. The simple answer is that I did not get the CPM-3V blade sharp enough to start with. I had treated both blades exactly the same on my 1000/5000/12000 Pro Shaptons, needing much the same number of strokes to get the initial wire edge on the 1000 ... but now I believe that the polishing regime on the CPM-3V does not work the same as on the A2. Either I will have to do this longer (and accept this state of affairs), or I will have to find another medium to use that works more effectively with CPM-3V.

4. There is the realisation that sharpening systems will change over time, not just to seek Sharpening Nirvana, but that some media are better suited to the emerging (new) steels being used increasingly in handtool blades. At the same time, this does not discount the old technology (oil stones and natural waterstones), since it is not a case of "better for all", but for me one of Horses For Courses (which you knew all along! :) ).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#35

David Barnett

There is that, of course, Warren

David Barnett

"The leisurely pace you mention, David, puts a different perspective on sharpening with Arkansas stones. I do see sharpening as a break from work and a change of pace. ... I feel that a worker does best with a method he has lots of experience using and it would be quite a few years before I was getting results on a par with what I do now."

One simply cannot fault taking one's time to do something one finds enjoyable.

While I may seem strident and driven to some (because I am, no doubt), I can appreciate change of pace in the rhythms of work. I intersperse my allegros with plenty of adagios.

Point taken.

I forget sometimes.

Fast enough.

Clean enough.

Cheap enough.

Even sharp enough.

Slow down. Stop. Smell the roses. Smell the coffee. The coffee! That's right... the coffee... yes...

The Balkan blend curls carelessly up from my pipe, the Latakia and Yenidje, muse and midwife of reverie, nudge my age-dimmed memory, awakening recuerdos de los Andes. Ah, those good distant days, back in Colombia, in the early '70s along the banks of the Rio Magdelena, along the winding Pan American Highway, near the sleepy little town (back then) of Melgar.

I gave a young lad five pesos to stone my long Collins machete. Perhaps he spoke only his quaint dialecto indio, but that was no barrier to striking our deal. It took him all day long, stroking the unforgiving steel across that flat rock at the rivers edge -- ceaselessly, and in that blazing light, that withering heat and stifling damp. Nothing I love more than good, hard work, I always say. Back then, I could watch it for hours, even days, on end.

I sat in the shade, of course, in the disintegrating hammock sipping my gin and Schweppes, longing for ice, as all civilized men do, all the while feeling quite, well... colonial, enjoying this child's honest, grueling labor for what surely amounted to no more than one U.S. quarter. Every now and then he'd bring his work for my inspection with that trusting hopefulness which only innocents possess. It was never quite good enough, of course -- didn't want to spoil him. "Chop! Chop!" I'd say to our little laboring Sisyphus, until all-too-soon the sun began to sink behind the mountains, casting long fingers over the sugar fields and coffee plantations, and the insects asserted their ear-ringing, shadow-loving dominion over the tropical evening.

Haunting, fleeting visions of Empire percolate from my collective unconscious. The Transvaal, Nagpur, the Punjab -- things as they once were and things as they should've remained. They never did, of course. They never do.

And now the craving returns. If only I could get just a few more grams of that superb conflict diamond paste -- from Sierra Leone, perhaps, maybe even Waterloo Camp! I promise to myself to make it last, really last this time. Oh sure, it costs more, but that's hardly the point, now, is it?

I wonder if J. Peterman sells diamond compound yet.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#36

Re: From the peanut gallery

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

And now you've discovered why I stick with O1 and kin to the exclusion of all others. I may change my mind a bit if I start making edges, perhaps CPM will be much easier; but since I've got diamonds for my small carving chisels, I won't have to add another entire system.

Pam

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#37



Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

We laugh, whether a real story or not; but I have to say I really enjoyed my sojourn in San Blas, Nayarit, for many reasons; one of which was that in that little fishing village in the mid-seventies anything could be fixed, well and for cheap, including my BMW's valve cover made from some weird alloy.

Pam

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#38

Re: From the peanut gallery

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

I can understand your reluctance to move from HCS. If our local woods were not so abrasive (they contain a high level of silica), I would be most happy to stick with O1 steel.

The point is that many woodworkers shy away from A2 (and other steels) because they have not adapted their sharpening regime to include it, and so assume it is hard to sharpen. It is no more difficult than O1 when using Pro Shaptons.

So what about the D2 and 3Vs of this world? They really do have something good to offer. Does one embrace or avoid them?

Regards from Perth

Derek (taking time to cool off from the heat outside - 93 F and 61% humidity - dripping puddles over the wood)

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#39

Here's what gets me....

John in NM

Another response to the long complicated thread that never dies... :D

(This is not a reply directed specifically at Wilbur's post, it's just hard to know where to put it :D)

We make sharpening far more complicated than it needs to be, by whatever method it is accomplished. It seems we spend far more time writing about the subject than actually doing it, based on the sharpening times quoted elsewhere in this thread :D

Sharpening is a basic skill that can be accomplished well enough for most purposes using a single grit of almost any type. The tendency to delve into the minutia of achieving slightly better or quicker results is what confuses people, not the process itself.

The focus on the minutia comes because it is fun to feel that we've mastered a skill, not because it is necessary for an acceptable edge under everyday use. Incidentally, this is probably the reason I've not tossed the Arkansas stones in a drawer - someday I'd like to feel that I've mastered their use, and the buffing wheel is just so darn easy, there's no challenge. Totally irrational :D

The beginner's assumption that something is too difficult should be what more experienced people try to dispel, rather that pushing our own personal methods. For the most part I think that's what these posts try to do until it devolves into a competition for the "best" method. Once that happens (and it always happens :D), we're just adding to the confusion and the subject would be better off un-discussed from a beginner's point of view.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#40

Re: Arghhh - Derek's chisels are a joke

TomD

When it comes to promoting it to beginners, that for the most part makes sense, and the everyone will do it, and other methods will ultimately be forgotten. So I don't doubt Bill wins in the long run.

For those of us who may seem troglodyte, I would just say I used diamnond stones going back to the 70s or early 80s, so I am not anti diamond.

That said, here are my two main points. Parenthetically there is a difference between being on the margins, and being marginalized. I have no problem with being out there, I don't think the promoters need to attack the people on the margins like they can only be right if everyone else is wrong.

1) A sharp edge is not the whole story, though it is most of it. There is nothing new about a method that at least as currently marketed is not that good at pure geometry. We have been buffing and stopping for a long time. Yet we thought it was worth while to also have the ability to create straight intersecting surfaces. For a long time, even though slower, people stuck with stones over buffs because of this. What changed? Speed mainly, diamonds are fast so out with the rest. Not that admirable. On the other hand there is also something good about rounded edges, and stones don't do them well. We find them on certain chisels and drawknives, axes and knives, so that's just gravy.

2) There was a thread on Derek's knew chisels. Really nice Japanese Chisels. People seemed to be impressed. Seems to me that as Bill says, if diamonds are as good as he says they are, and the high speed steel tools also, then Derek's new chisels are a joke. Why would anyone other than a tool twidler with too much money consider them.

So for me the answer comes down to the hard core, which is over whether these techniques actually work best for everything, and the aesthetic. I don't get why that is so hard to understand, can you explain why you don't use a router or cnc for everything?

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#41

Re: BRILLIANT!!!

TomD

I don't think it is dollars. The sellers make two kinds of money, they sell whatever to newbies, and they sell more of the same to people who already have everything. Diamonds work on both counts.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#42

Re: Our mileage may vary

TomD

"I'll let Bill Tindall answer this one (from his post myth busting diamonds......., March '08): "During a recent demo we reground the bevel on a plane, and then sharpened it in less than 2 minutes. The diamond part took about 30 seconds. Seldom do I pull the tool more than 10 times down the abrasive surface to complete that sharpening step. Other than dressing the wheel occasionally there is no maintenance.""

Actually that sounds slow, whether for stones, or power.

"I'll add that he hollow grinds (as do I), so the bevel self-indexes on the honing stone (I use 600 grit polycrystalline), and the lap, as well -- so no jig required for most blades."

Yeah well hollow grinding is tool abuse, and any method is fast with hollow grinding, I would rarely make ten strokes with a waterstone and hollow grinding. One can get into a whole big deal on HG. I use it for some stuff, and not for others, and some stuff I hollow grind then don't bother and just let it fill in. Some stuff like turning tools lathe bits etc... can be sharpened and used right off the wheel. But however bullish you are on HG one would have to be ignorant to say it is always the only way. You can't hollow grind someone's 5K bowie knife, and I wouldn't want it done to my planes, japanese tools, drawknives, double bevel chisels, and good luck doing it to complex molding profiles. But there are a number of things there where diamonds will shine specifically because they aren't hollow ground.

" The survey of available waterstone choices, their care and maintenance would've taken that long without ever getting around to how they're actually used. At least that's what I think."

Come on. This is what I do in the summer. bucket: 2x 800, 1x intermediate, 1x 8000. Rub them together to make them flat, sharpen on the wide bits. Here's and idea, when you have a good product, let the product do the taking.

"4. Cheaper: I'll give you that one. ... "

Well I won't, because I already have enough of the old stuff to see me and the next generation through, and I am not likely to get rid of it, because I know where it fits in.

"5. That the new technology is widely available. But it's not more widely available than waterstones."

That's interesting, as I counted 32 diamond bench stones in the current Woodcraft catalog, compared with 24 waterstones.

That stuff was there 20-30 years before I saw my first tube of diamond paste in a woodworking catalog. It was often there to flatten stones. A lot of it has been crap. I wish the paste etc... Had been put there before the fixed diamonds. Consider how expensive Odates Crowned diamond stones fad was a few years back. There is a 5 dollar idea with paste.

" As for diamond paste, they only offer 8000 grit (3 micron), and at the less than attractive price of $24.99. Many woodworking tool catalogs carry 1 micron (14000 grit) diamond paste, though (LV, Highland, et al)."

Just became available up here when LV put it in. It must be there for your kind of thing Dave, but it never penetrated sadly.

"7. That the beginner"

To me "beginner" Implies someone who is starting at the beginning. What we have in woodworking iare newbies who show up at the first playoff hole of the Masters and want to stand in for Tiger Woods.

"I want to be clear: I believe that sharpening with diamonds is quick and effective, and suitable for teaching a beginner. I just don't believe that it is miles better than other sharpening methods out there, and so there's no reason to believe that it should be the only method for beginners."

Point taken on whether it's miles better. But as for beginners, what might be the advantages, as you see them, of promoting waterstones over diamond, or for that matter, as just as good?

Other than the already mentioned 500 reasons that the promoters of diamonds routinely ignore? :)

I would argue they shouldn't waste their time with diamonds which are inefficient compared with dry grinding and lead nowhere. If you are going to be using license plate tools anyway, who cares. Diamonds are a solution or a tool culture that the promoters don't have sympathy with. If you are going to be using HSS why would you not dry grind them, and buff or dry finish them? If you learn dry grinding it opens up tool making and many other things. according to Bill's presentation he dry grinds tools, then sidesteps grinding when finishing the edge, which is just perverse when you already own the grinder. It is odd that the industry has routinely dissuaded people from dry grinding. I buy the silly idea they think the temper of tools will be drawn, and not that people will decide to just make their own tools.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#43

Re: I really hate to say it, Wilbur...

TomD

"Now if anyone told me that Arkansas stones were just as fast, I'd say I was from Missouri on that one, even though I only lived there a couple years and was born one state over."

For the most part I agree with you on that one. I think the key thing with speed is no wasted steps, and a good fit between the tool you are trying to sharpen, and the sharpener. Would an old pro with a good set of oil stones have more down time on them. I doubt it. How many less cabinets did James Krenov deliver because he decided not to shift to waterstones or scary sharp? There is also the whole small tool thing. Diamond over soft iron is not a very durable surface, if highly abrasive. I might not choose to use them on small gravers and chisels, and would reach for ceramic stones, or oils stones. It is too easy to catch a corner. Think of the long promoted DMT stones. Not a nice surface for small tools. And there isn't much to sharpen on small tools. Machine tool bits are another example. excellent candidate for loose diamonds but the bits are small so, it doesn't mater a lot.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#44

Re: From the peanut gallery

TomD

+1

That does leave me wondering Derek, how you got off the stones with a dull tool in the first place. I am most indebted to the razor crowd for the wet fingernail, wet fingertip thing.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#45

Missouri is real close...

Larry Williams

"...Now if anyone told me that Arkansas stones were just as fast, I'd say I was from Missouri on that one, even though I only lived there a couple years and was born one state over."

Missouri is real close, it's a local call to the border. Come on down.

I don't really care how most people sharpen as long as they get good results. I do get concerned about how our customers sharpen and try to give them advise about good and efficient sharpening techniques. I assume you teach about dressing grinding wheels. "Flattening" or dressing oil stones is the exact same thing--truing everything up and exposing fresh abrasive. It doesn't take any longer to dress an oil stone than a grinding wheel and it makes just as big a difference.

One thing I see is that most sharpening discussions on the web assume a straight iron. What if one wants to progress beyond the most basic rectilinear wood working? Traditional sharpening methods, i.e. oil stones, evolved with the tools and what's needed is readily available.

How would you sharpen these two #11 veiners and this "V" tool with diamonds? The little 1/16" veiner is difficult even though I have the slips to fit it. Old eyes, I guess.

On edit: BTW, it's traditional to have a 5� inside bevel on carving tools.


Or what about these two molding plane irons?


Contrary to the popular myth, you can't just work on the face because you'll enlarge the radii of the arcs and the profiles won't match the planes.

If you go beyond the basics in woodworking, you're most likely going to end up using oil stones. They can be incredibly efficient, you know. Why accumulate multiple sharpening systems that won't go the distance and will end up just cluttering your work space while adding unnecessary expense?

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#46

Router? CNC?

Bob Hackett

Thom you are a wonder.

Why don`t you just ask me why I don`t go down to Wal-mart and buy a Chinese particleboard TV table to set my stuff on and a folding camp chair to set my butt in? :D

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#47

Re: From the peanut gallery

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I consider my Pro Shaptons a mistaken purchase, and will probably sell them soon, before I'm tempted to gouge them out to eliminate stiction on western tools. I now use natural waterstones and a horizontal water grinder (Makita) and plan to add diamonds real soon.

If I start making my own edges, which is dubious given that I really don't like working metal, I'll use 3V. Another reason to add diamonds.

Sorry about your heat, although 93� is about 10� below Austin in the summer, no big deal. 61% humidity is a big deal. Fortunately, here the humidity gets lower when the temperature gets hotter; and it always lowers about 20� at night. It was delightful playing tennis this morning in 70� + heat, it's 80� now.

Pam

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#48

Re: From the peanut gallery

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

Just add a little liquid soap to the water you spritz on your Shaptons - no more stiction (plus clean stones and hands).

Incidentally, humidity in Perth is unusual, which is why I am struggling with the heat. Generally Perth gets around 104 F in summer, but with very low humidity.

Enjoy the tennis.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#49

Re: Router? CNC?

TomD

Thanks! Sounds like we are on the same side. To quote the Bard "Oh... Reason not the need". If it doesn't make life easier for a beginner, work faster, or cheaper, apparently it doesn't have a leg to stand on.

Re: EZE Lap Plate

#50

For some, regardless ....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... of the evidence of modern progress, they will doggedly hold onto out traditional methods and tools. No accounting for taste, is there? :)

Regards from Perth

Derek