EZE Lap Plate
Tom Colligan
I finish my sharpening with an 8000 Shapton stone. Would the Extra Fine sharpening stone referred recently be an improvement beyond this 8000 Shapton? TIA, Tom
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
EZE Lap Plate
Tom Colligan
I finish my sharpening with an 8000 Shapton stone. Would the Extra Fine sharpening stone referred recently be an improvement beyond this 8000 Shapton? TIA, Tom
Re: EZE Lap Plate
David Barnett
Unless I'm reading your question incorrectly, the super fine 1200-grit EZE-Lap is nowhere close to the 8000-grit Shapton. While the Shapton 8000 isn't really a polishing stone, not in the same sense as the Norton 8000, say, which will leave a mirror finish*. The 1200-grit EZE-Lap leaves very fine but still visible scratches.
I'm not so fond of 1200-grit diamond stones for woodworking blades. I know it seems like a big jump, but a 600-grit diamond stone straight to 1 micron (14000-grit) paste on an iron lap does leave a refined and polished edge and rapidly so on the hardest and toughest tool steels you're apt to encounter.
*A few strokes on a strop will bring the Shapton edge to a mirror polish, of course.
Re: EZE Lap Plate
David Weaver
i'm confused - shaptons' 8k is a ceramic abrasive at 2 microns or so. What about it is not the same level of sharpness (implied by the polish bit) as the norton?
I don't have a shapton 8k, I go directly from 1k to 15k if using microbevels.
Particle size not the whole story *LINK*
David Barnett
"i'm confused - shaptons' 8k is a ceramic abrasive at 2 microns or so. What about it is not the same level of sharpness (implied by the polish bit) as the norton?"
Particle size is but one factor. The crystalline shape has much to do with the how a stone cuts and the finish it leaves. A zircon-based stone differs from alumina, silicon, CBN or diamond. Even diamond differs between monocrystalline and polycrystalline. The sharp edges presented differ as to crystal habit, breaking down according to their inherent cleavage planes. Furthermore, different binders promote differences in friability, particle presentation and breakdown, and slurry characteristics.
The 8000 Shapton leaves a somewhat grayer, frostier appearance to my eye, while the Norton 8000, or for that matter, a King 6000 leave more polished finishes. This does not mean that the Shapton edge is less sharp, however, as polish does not necessarily equate to sharpness.
The Dieter Schmid catalog states:
"In contrast to the traditional, and CERAX, 8000-grit waterstones, the Shapton 8000-grit polishes very little, instead leaving a very fine matt surface. Whether that influences the final practical sharpness cannot as yet be determined, but it is well known that even some of the finest and most expensive Japanese natural stones also do not leave a mirror surface, and the final sharpness that can be achieved with those stones is justly famous."
Japanese Waterstones: Shapton
Re: Particle size not the whole story
David Weaver
Yeah, I guess that's what I was getting toward.
The norton stones are Aluminium oxide if I recall, which is a pretty hard and deep cutting abrasive. I guess the ceramic alumina or whatever shapton uses may cut even deeper for the same grit size, but looks can be deceiving on an edge.
I have a shapton 5k stone. It is a pretty strong stone that almost polishes things, so i'm sort of guessing at what an 8k is like, having an 8k aluminum oxide stone already on hand, and only having the 15k shapton finishing stone beyond the 5.
For practical purposes, the strop doesn't do a lot beyond my 8k stone if the wire edge isn't persistent, and nothing really beyond the 15k stone unless the material being cut is HSS - which leaves a "rubbery" glaze on the shapton stone surface and has a stubborn wire edge, even with a 1 micron stone that cuts it marginally ok.
Two kinds of abrasion
Bill Tindall
The probably desirable kind, especially for grinding wheels, is where the abrasive particle penetrates the metal and "mills" off a shaving, thereby removing metal and especially in the case of a wheel, heat(the heat goes with the chip that is ejected. The other kind is where the abrasive particle plows across the surface deforming it. Deformation may extend into the remaining metal, for better or worse. I suspect this latter mode polishes and the first mode doesn't and this hypothesis is supported by my limited metal specimen preparation experience.
Diamond with its sharp, durable edges and unexcelled penetrating ability is more apt to mill off chips and leave "vee" scratches. At least that is what we see in photomicrographs. These reflect light in such a way as to show a matt surface. Aluminum oxide is tough and doesn't readily fracture and the dull rounded grits tend to plow more than diamond.
In practical woodworking we are using tools vastly duller (after a minute of use) than what is obtained off the stone. So, it seems to me that the metric of measuring benefit of sharpening to the nth degree is "practical edge life". And I have yet to see data on whether sharpening beyond the minimum necessary to achieve a practical cut leads to better edge life. I believe people are sharpening way beyond what is practically needed because the current availability of materials enables it. My definition of practical is that the tool cuts and if its a surface, I am going to finish sand it anyway. I appreciate this standard is off-scale below what some desire. On the other hand it is in line with many people making stuff.
Re: Two kinds of abrasion
wilbur
"I believe people are sharpening way beyond what is practically needed because the current availability of materials enables it."
I don't see anything wrong with that. If you are using a proper sharpening regimen and technique, the extra time spent going to a 12K, strop, sub-micron diamond paste, or whatever extra step someone might deem unnecessary is pretty minimal.
When I'm sharpening a tool, the vast majority of time spent is on the lower grit stage. Once the edge is done at that stage, the next stages go by fairly quickly. My final sharpening step is using a natural Japanese waterstone, which many might see as overkill compared to the edge that you can get off of an 8000 grit waterstone. If I drop the natural Japanese waterstone step, I'll save a whopping 45 seconds to a minute of time.
Sharp enough & edge life
David Barnett
"In practical woodworking we are using tools vastly duller (after a minute of use) than what is obtained off the stone. So, it seems to me that the metric of measuring benefit of sharpening to the nth degree is "practical edge life" ... "
That's how I experience using a freshly sharpened tool. For some tasks, say, paring to a line on dovetails, I want my chisel very sharp. As soon as it begins to noticeably dull I'm apt to bring it back, either on the stone or by stropping. For most tasks, though, after the tool loses its just-off-the-stone edge, it's still pretty sharp and will stay this way through sharp enough. To me, a good bench chisel is easy to get and keep very sharp if need be but will last a long long time at sharp enough before I need to re-hone.
There's a rhythm to the work that determines how often and how thoroughly I sharpen. Could be my mood, the cooperativeness of the wood, the level of craft I'm aiming for, and maybe the phase of the moon, for all I know. Sometimes I enjoy taking a little extra trouble when I sharpen, sometimes I just want to keep things moving along. A dependable sharpening regimen is fluidly adaptable to any style of working that might develop.
Finer grits: life beyond the wire edge *LINK*
David Barnett
"I guess the ceramic alumina or whatever shapton uses may cut even deeper for the same grit size, but looks can be deceiving on an edge."
You're right. Sintered versions of the same basic constituents present very different cutting and wear profiles.
"For practical purposes, the strop doesn't do a lot beyond my 8k stone if the wire edge isn't persistent, and nothing really beyond the 15k stone unless the material being cut is HSS - which leaves a "rubbery" glaze on the shapton stone surface and has a stubborn wire edge, even with a 1 micron stone that cuts it marginally ok."
You bring up a good point. This seems to generate a good deal of confusion among those who've used only traditional oilstones. Depending on the steel, of course, the wire edge developed on lower grit stones was usually gone by the time I'd honed at 6000 or 8000 grit on waterstones. Gone. And my microscopes simply don't lie.
Those who sharpen on their Arkansas stones are apt to believe a wire edge must always be generated, that sine qua non of every sharpening act until its final, decisive removal. And it's little wonder, too, as these stones, for all their admirable qualities, only equate to 2000-grit SiC sandpaper or 6-micron diamond compound for the finest translucent or black Arkansas*. I still had small but very real wire edges after 4000-grit waterstones, which are considerably finer than the finest Arkansas. Stropping after the Arkansas puts things right, of course.
It's hard to disabuse someone who's always sharpened that way of anachronistic notions. To each his own, of course, and if someone's satisfied with their results, that's what counts. Hey, I still keep my Arkansas stones -- for nostalgia and gravers, if nothing else, and admit I was skeptical before I experienced waterstones and later, diamonds. For some it's religion, for others science, for me, both. At any rate, my conversion was immediate and transcendent.
Re: Two kinds of abrasion
David Weaver
All it would take to figure out whether or not it's worth it is someone with a couple of nice straight-grained hard maple boards, a plane, and enough time to dull the edges ten times for each.
I did it once with a few irons for two times each iron, only one full time because I realized that all of the new irons but one chipped out right away and I needed to restart. I nominate someone else to do it!
A sample of 10 times with an iron that is not brand new should get conclusive results.
What I found when I did mine, trying to compare two irons, was that the iron that had chipout at the edge (of any kind) first stopped cutting first. The best iron was a fabulous A2 iron that, from what i could tell, did not chip out at all for the duration and was dulled completely by wear to an otherwise undamaged bevel. To get the plane to stop cutting a 2 thousandth shaving took more than 1100 passes with a plane on a hard maple board just short of two feet.
Anyway, I think a sample of 10 of those each with an iron sharpened to 2000 grit with the wire edge lightly stropped off (something that feels sharp still) and a 1/2 micron edge with no stropping (what would be the point?) would tell us something. What it would tell us, I have a guess, but whether or not it's significant, I don't know.
I sharpen with two stones. A 1000 stone and a 15000 stone, for almost everything. It's about as quick as using one stone and a strop. I really like the finish it leaves off a smoother. I think abrasives are so aggressive now that you can have quick and sharp with all of the standard tool steels (including D2) and not have to think so hard about whether or not something is worth the effort.
We are truly living in fortunate times ...
David Barnett
"I think abrasives are so aggressive now that you can have quick and sharp with all of the standard tool steels (including D2) and not have to think so hard about whether or not something is worth the effort."
... well, at least as far as sharpening goes.
Re: Two kinds of abrasion
TomD
As usual an interesting response, so if you don't mind:
"The probably desirable kind, especially for grinding wheels, is where the abrasive particle penetrates the metal and "mills" off a shaving, thereby removing metal and especially in the case of a wheel, heat(the heat goes with the chip that is ejected."
Some of the heat...
"Diamond with its sharp, durable edges and unexcelled penetrating ability is more apt to mill off chips and leave "vee" scratches. At least that is what we see in photomicrographs."
Unexcelled? I have seen a lot of stones that leave v groves. Too much of a v grove is another form of dull.
"In practical woodworking we are using tools vastly duller (after a minute of use) than what is obtained off the stone. So, it seems to me that the metric of measuring benefit of sharpening to the nth degree is "practical edge life". And I have yet to see data on whether sharpening beyond the minimum necessary to achieve a practical cut leads to better edge life."
Sounds like you are using dull tools. I notice that very sharp tools retain their edge longer the sharper the initial sharpening. NASA may not have published on this, but it is a very common observation. There isn't just one type of practical woodworking, but I share your concern than there is an optimal amount of sharpening for different tasks, and different woods, and that just exceeding it for no reason is not useful. My definition of professional grade tools, edge wise, is that they sharpen easily, and hold their edge well in the materials being worked, or the style of work. But that is a huge range of variability.
"I believe people are sharpening way beyond what is practically needed because the current availability of materials enables it. My definition of practical is that the tool cuts and if its a surface, I am going to finish sand it anyway. I appreciate this standard is off-scale below what some desire. On the other hand it is in line with many people making stuff."
Well as always there are Faberge eggs, and the ones stockings and silly putty come in. Though in the woodworking sphere sanding is likely to be involved, as you say. Joint cutting is another mater, planing difficult grains another. Right now in the guitar field we are in a little bit of a pickle, one of the traditional woods, Brazillian Rosewood, is very expensive, remaining "commercial" stock is often very low quality, often has difficult grain configurations, can certainly be sanded, but tends to load paper. We are talking a 2K mistake. Realistically most people are going to sand it. But if you did want to plane it, a very high quality edge would be a good thing. Or maybe a toothing plane... Decisions... I missed the boat on BR, but I have a model I am working on that requires planing end grain balsa, in a fragile configuration. I like my tools sharp for that. Many of the body woods are no picnic in a variety of species.
Retrograde question for neophytes
Doug Trembath
I have been following these sharpening debates for years, guys, and have had the pleasure of attending a class with Garrett Hack, where we all had a very lively debate and non-scientific test of sorts. One of the students was a former moderator of this forum, Ted Owen, who seems to know a thing or two about sharpening.
In the final analysis, doesn't it just come down, in a pragmatic view, to being able to achieve a cut that leaves no discernible surface difference, which does not require sanding, and having the edge retention reach an acceptable life?
I know, I have had professors in college tell me that I was too pragmatic, but I like to work toward an acceptable surface as quickly as possible, and spend the rest of the time goofing off, daydreaming, or finally cleaning up the shavings. I do admire the diligent experimentation some of you achieve, and we all benefit from it, but the many different types of abrasives, the wide variances of grit comparisons, and the friability of the various cutting agents simply boggles the admittedly simple mind.
From, again, a practical viewpoint, doesn't Scary Sharp with the addition of a diamond strop regimen achieve acceptable sharpness and edge retention for fine woodwork?
Or am I still out in the weeds?
Help!
Doug Trembath
Re: Retrograde question for neophytes
Bob Hackett
Doug IMO you totally get it,it`s the other guys who have wandered off into the sharpening wastelands.
A bit of background for those who don`t know me.I have been a metalworker all my life.One of the things I was tasked to do and still do from time to time is make deck hardware for yachts.I also had to keep most everything in the boatyard sharp so I know a thing or two about metals,abrasives,polishing and sharpening/durabliity.
Polishing is nothing more than using abrasives to make smaller and smaller scratches till those scratches are so small your eye cannot detect them and the surface appears smooth to the human eye.Look at that surface under magnification and you`ll see the scratches are still there.
If you want a more scratch free edge then you have to smoothly deform the metal so all those tiny scratches flow together.This is called burnishing and most of us do this while preparing card scrapers.As the metal moves it work hardens to some degree and it makes the edge a bit more hard/durable than an edge that was used straight from the stones with no burnishing.I don`t know anyone using a bench plane who burnishes the edge.Scraper plane sure,bench plane no.
What some of us see as a "polished edge" would probably turn out to be a rather ragged burnished edge under magnification.The abrasives in the stone they`re using are moving the metal on either side of a shallow groove as it plows along.The reason it`s shiny is that it has been burnished rather than cut and the light is reflected from those very small curved/rounded surfaces(think the letter U here) in a different manner than it will from the angled planes of a cleanly cut V shaped groove,.The size of the abrasive is the same but one is cutting while the other is burnishing.The shiny surface`s grooves will be less deep because the metal is skating more and deforming/work hardening rather being cleanly cut.The shiny surface will have all those round bottomed grooves blended together yet have some of the jaggedness of the cleanly abraded edge as some of the abrasives fracture and cut again. It`s just the highs and lows are more rounded rather than uniformly crisp.
As you might imagine,the rounded/burnished surface is bound to take a little longer to achieve just as it takes you longer to work any surface using dull sandpaper,the same principles apply.
I prefer my abrasives to cut cleanly rather than burnish.If I need a more refined edge I drop the size of the abrasive and may add a step to further hone the edge rather than burnish it with worn/rounded abrasives.
Funny how those most entrenched in the long and involved sharpening of a metal edge are those most likely to advocate the use of a less sharp/efficient abrasive.The use of the less sharp and effective (some may call it "brash") abrasives requires more time and more steps as they are deforming metal as well as cutting it in a less effective manner.
If you use sharp,durable abrasives then you have a tool that will allow you to skip many of those intermediate steps and arrive at your destination(a suitably sharpened edge) in far less time.
The polish or "shine factor" of an the two intersecting planes of an edge is a false indicator of what`s going on at the edge for most people starting out and your unaided eye a poor tool to measure sharpness.You need to look at the edge(not the bevel and the back) under magnification to get a true picture of what`s going on.A truly sharp edge reflects no light and you need magnification to evaluate it regardless of what system you use.
My advise is to work on sharp first and by the most simple means possible, this means as few steps/abrasives as possible.When you have simple/sharp down then work on cutting the time it takes you to achieve that same level of sharp.Improve your technique and MAYBE throw in an intermediate step if it`ll significantly cut your time down.Once you get to simple/sharp and fast THEN you can worry about longevity.
There are many factors to the longevity equation and contrary to popular belief they do not all involve sacrificing small animals during certain phases of the moon.Some can even be as simple as sharpening,if you allow them to be. 
Its interesting...
John in NM
How sharpening discussions seem to go awry.... many of us agree on the essentials and then argue over the details... 
Though I also find complicated regimens to be rather silly, I do tend to favor a couple oil stones for some reason. If it were only a matter of speed to me, I'd hollow grind and then a quick buff on a hard felt wheel - takes about 30 sec and makes the sharpest blade I've ever seen.
So John...
Bob Hackett
Care to tell us why you go to all that extra trouble and expense? 
Well....
John in NM
A friend of my dad's gave me the stones about 20 years ago, so there's no expense in using them....
And what can I say, I like rocks.
:D:D
However, when I was smoothing some book matched mesquite veneer drawer faces? - went with the buffing wheel and minimal tear out 
If I ever get a suitable piece of iron, I expect the rocks will fall by the wayside (diamond's also a rock, or at least closer than felt and waxy compound) 
Another retrograde question for neophytes
wilbur
From, again, a practical viewpoint, doesn't a set of 1000, 4000, and 8000 grit waterstones achieve acceptable sharpness and edge retention for fine woodwork?
Or alternatively:
From, again, a practical viewpoint, doesn't oilstones followed by a strop achieve acceptable sharpness and edge retention for fine woodwork?
Wilbur... Yes, and yes.
David Barnett
I don't have to flatten my waterstones, though, and no more buckets, soaking or mess, and if I'd started out using diamond, I doubt I'd have bought them.
As for good quality Arkansas, they don't come cheap these days, and diamond is faster -- much faster -- and cuts a broader range of tool steels more efficiently. Although you did specify acceptable, I'd say that diamond does a better than acceptable job. Both waterstones and diamond can, if needed, outdo Arkansas, especially on the harder, tougher modern tool steel alloys. Which was really my point, all along; fast, cheap, easy.
I do have a fondness for my Arkansas stones, aesthetically, for their feel when honing and leisurely pace.
Many paths to the mountaintop
Bob Hackett
I used to get good results from oilstones,waterstones and Scary Sharp.
Since I started using diamond they all have been doing an excellent job of gathering dust.
Grind,refine with diamond and maybe,if I feel like it,a little green compound or 3M finess-it on maple just for the shine factor.
2 steps to cutting,3 to bling.
No more grit in the sink or oily film in the dish washer.Domestic bliss at last. 
Re: R q for neophytes - You can't stand the truth!
TomD
"In the final analysis, doesn't it just come down, in a pragmatic view, to being able to achieve a cut that leaves no discernible surface difference, which does not require sanding, and having the edge retention reach an acceptable life?"
Sure but that is like saying "In the final analysis doesn't it just come down to getting where you want to go in reasonable style, with reasonable cost, at a reasonable speed?" sure, now would you like to tell me whether you are driving a truck NY to California, or racing in the Tour de France.
"From, again, a practical viewpoint, doesn't Scary Sharp with the addition of a diamond strop regimen achieve acceptable sharpness and edge retention for fine woodwork?"
Yes and no. It is going to cut nicely, but there are problems. Let me mention a very small one. Ever try scary sharp with a 1/16" chisels, hey it works but it isn't a precise feeling. On a narrow chisels it just isn't a nice index. What about black greasy residue for people who don't have water in their shops. One thing I am not super thrilled with on SS is the fact that little wisps of grinding dust rise up. Not too heathy. I use a power grinder, which is a hundred times worse, but it is extracted. I probably wouldn't chose to roll a brass jig over the diamond mess, though maybe it's great, I do it freehand.
Anyway, to paraphrase, no pragmatism ever survives the first contact with a grinder. Real practical hand tool use would involve sharpening on the belt sander, or those little platers LV sells, probably. Maybe that's too costly? Everyone has their own list of what is or isn't practical. At any given time there is no disagreement about what the consensus system is. Where I disagree with Bill etc... is over the idea that just because there are a lot of names under the fat part of the Bell curve, there is no reason to do it any other way.
What bugs me about that attitude is that there is no reason for woodworking once you go there. People like to talk about practical, science, real world kind of stuff, whereas if they really felt that way, they wouldn't make anything out of wood at all. There certainly wouldn't be any regular hand planes in use, possibly molding planes, but the flat stuff would all be power sanded. The real truth is that we make stuff that is about beauty and self-expression, and we use processes that are sometimes as much about the trip as the destination. The attempt to make it practical is what leads to chairs that stack nicely together in a cafeteria. The more points of distinction the better.
Re: Many paths to the mountaintop
TomD
I agree with you that they do an outstanding job of sharpening, Which is 90 percent of the point. I don't feel they are all that great at configuring an accurate edge. I think the comparison to buffing is more accurate than the comparison to sharpening on a stone. But in a well equipped shop a hugely larger component of the tools would be amenable to that. The only part I am still missing would be for say bench chisels, mortising chisels, slicks, rebate planes, small tools etc... For gouges, molding planes, curved edge planes. double beveled slicks, which are more numerous than than the aforementioned tools, I don't see much downside. And even the accurate geometry tools aren't going to be affected adversely through a range of uses. There are also weird little tools that need freehand care, and regardless of the geometry would be easier to sharpen with a diamond hone. Stuff like the blade out of my dad's rali plane, pencil sharpener blades, exacto knives, etc... I tended to buff those hitherto, but it is a lot safer to whisk them across the diamond plate.
Isn`t that kinda like...
Bob Hackett
Spending more time polishing your tools than using them?
Not that there`s anything wrong with that.That seems to be one the reasons that both LN and LV do so well.
I guess the big division is there are some of us who just want to fedutz around with wood and then there`s others who want to fedutz around with everything. 
Arghhh
David Barnett
So, my question, after all that's transpired here on this subject, comes down to:
If there is a new honing technology that produces an edge that is as good as the best edge that can be achieved by other, older methods, whether by oilstones or waterstones, natural or synthetic, sandpaper on glass, and strops, and if that new technology is faster, eliminates intermediate steps, is easily and quickly learned, cheaper, widely available, less messy and more effective on a wider range of modern tool steels, why would anyone who did not already own the older equipment and supplies, choose to sharpen that older way? And moreso, why would anyone (unless ignorant of such improvements) recommend such methods to beginners?
$$$$$
John in NM
"And moreso, why would anyone (unless ignorant of such improvements) recommend such methods to beginners?"
Sells magazines, polishes the ego, etc, etc.....
:D:D