Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

Posts

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#76

Professionals and hobbyists

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Derek and all,

I thought your post was well conceived, because look at this long thread, concerned about whether it is admirable or foolish for someone to do a single non-traditional thing. The mention of CPM 3V has consistently brought out these passions time and again.

Which brings me to another way to categorize--professionals and hobbyists. For me, woodworking is a hobby. I enjoy the wood, the tools, the forum, swapping yarns, learning stuff, unlearning other stuff; I don't care how long things take; and it doesn't have to pay for itself. And I have a high tolerance for what anyone else wants to do with their time and money. Live and let live.

But the professional life is different. Changes in tools and methods need to pay for themselves, or you don't do them. Time is the air you breathe. One of the most damning things that a professional can say about another--and this is true in craft skills or the white collar professions--is that 'he's slow'.

Slow is really bad. Inefficiency is really bad. I can recall watching two different contractors doing huge earthwork at a dam under construction some years ago here in So. Calif. One contractor would haul all the earth to a pile to get it out of their way, and then rehaul from there. Double handled every bucket load. With the other contractor--a great one named Peter Kiewit--every truck load was hauled to final line and grade. For engineers looking on, the double handling was an abomination, and on the other hand Kiewit's great organization validated everything we were living our life for. Our work life anyway. For a sightseer, it would not have mattered--two contractors working against a contract, and under the eyes of inspectors--let them haul dirt their way--who cares?

Which brings me to my point about professionals. I don't really think Warren and Larry are thinking about tools per se. I do think they are thinking about the totality of their craft, in which every procedure relates to every other one, in a seamless continuum of time and efficiency. They can't even remember all the reasons why A is better than B--it's too nuanced and interconnected with every other thing, to remember and relate. If I found a forum on water engineering, populated largely by hobbyists, or if Derek found a forum where hobbyists proposed, and implemented on their children, amateur and innovative methods in clinical psychology based on notions they had developed--we both might be a tad intolerant about it.

So I think an inquiry into 'groups' as Derek was doing is a useful thing, but I would propose professionals and hobbyists (maybe with a mid-range 'advanced amateur') as the primary breakdown.

One thing that was overlooked in this latest incarnation of the CPM 3V discussion, was that the topic arose in Australia. I seem to recall from many conversations, that Australia is the land of dense semi-tropical woods and iron woods of all sorts. I want to get into this subject in another thread, as this one is way down the page, but I think that our experience with O1 and straight high-carbon steel on temperate zone No. American and European hardwoods may not translate to Oz. It may be that Oz really does need high-alloy steel and efficient ways to sharpen it, as a standard practice.

Wiley

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#77

Australian woods

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"It may be that Oz really does need high-alloy steel and efficient ways to sharpen it..."

From the handful of Australian woods I've handled, it's my impression that the first specialty toolmaker to perfect tactical nuclear bench planes will make a fortune in Oz.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#78

Behind the times

Bob Hackett

You guys are just now finding out what the fellows from OZ and BBers have known for decades.Exotic woods require exotic steels.

Anyone who works teak on a regular basis can tell you that when you see sparks coming off with the chips and there`s nothing wrong with the machine you are in for a long,hard day.

From what I`ve heard there are woods In OZ that make teak, greenheart and desert ironwood seem like white pine by comparison.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#79

Re: Professionals and hobbyists

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

OK, Wiley, file away; but how do semi-professionals and serious hobbyists muck up your neat little categories?

Pam

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#80

Models

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Any organizing system is ultimately arbitrary at some level. When I was getting my degree, the phrase "management models" was quite popular, and I used to argue that it was a great phrase because they were, indeed, models - simplified facsimiles - not the real thing. A useful management model was then one that, when you laid it over reality like a Tinkertoy framework, highlighted useful patterns; but it was never reality.

Wiley's model will be useful if it highlights some distinctions among different sorts of woodworkers.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#81

Re: Professionals and hobbyists

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

A new thread is a good idea, and perhaps this section of the current thread may be moved to start it.

You wrote: So I think an inquiry into 'groups' as Derek was doing is a useful thing, but I would propose professionals and hobbyists (maybe with a mid-range 'advanced amateur') as the primary breakdown.

It is important to take what Bill said about models being approximations and that there are more often exceptions to the rule in practice.

In the medical and psychiatric world a diagnosis is intended to offer a succinct classification so that a proven treatment is able to be offered for a specific subgroup. In practice we know that this does not always work, that there are disorders with features that overlap and, for this reason, one must be sure of the exact facts.

So it is with creating nice, clean and predictable categories of woodworker types ... I think that one may use a number of different classificational systems. All may be correct and relevant - but not necessarily so for all people as it is expected they may weigh features differently from one another.

For example, your classification of "professionals" and "hobbyists" does make sense. However it assumes that all professionals think alike and that all hobbyists think alike. Take one area you raised, speed of work. I would assume as well that a professional, that is someone who earns a living from his woodwork (as opposed to someone who just gets paid for some work), will attempt to work as efficiently as possible. Time is money. But ... why would this characteristic not also extend to some hobbyists? I know many who are more interested in the destination rather than the journey. It would be an equal over-generalisation to assume that this type of behaviour is the domain of the powertool user and not those that prefer handtools.

What I am getting at is that there is likely to be a deeper personality type that influences the choices made in the workshop, in the same way as these are likely to be reflected in life outside the workshop.

Does any of this really help on the forums? I believe it does, if only that we are a diverse group of personalities, with varying life experiences, and varying objectives, but all bound together by a love of woodworking. But would it not be better to focus on the similarities than the differences?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#82

Categories and strawberries

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek and Pam,

Very informative! Thanks.

Well, I was just making up a bowl of fruit for my wife, strawberries and raspberries and cream. No problem with the raspberries, but those supermarket strawberries can be just miserable. So red and tempting at first view, but then I get a knife into them, and by the time I get done carving out the 90 percent of them that is white pith, I ain't got much left to go in the bowl.

And so it is with my attempt at categorizing folks--if I go ahead and try to carve out all the exceptions and special cases and the many people I know who can't be categorized, there ain't gonna be much left. So much for economic determinism--a concept which was proven wrong in the 20th century.

I would like to have a thread on Aussie hard woods, and how they may require special steels. Or not!

Wiley

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#83

Re: Models

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

It's all way too large grained a division; and to me, nonsensical. I guess I haven't said this for a couple or three years, but all woodworkers want basically the same things, not divided by any two or three groupings. Such a grouping is for the convenience of the speaker and does not, I think, add to our knowledge.

Pam

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#84

Re: Categories and strawberries

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Well, don't buy the conventionally grown so cal version of strawberry, loaded with pesticides; but I'm having great luck this year with organically grown, very tasty.

BTW, did you know that the strawberry's closest relative is marijuana?

Pam

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#85

Completely different division

Bob Hackett

I tend to divide things (when pressed to) according to Pye.

When working for money or with limited resources supplied by others I employ the "Craftsmanship of certainly".

When working for family,on speculation,or when I have spare timber to cover mistakes I`m more likely to go with the "Craftsmanship of risk".

I also have noticed that the closer I get to completion the less risk I am apt to take so after I`m say 75% done there better be a very good reason to risk it rather than play it safe.

I do find I enjoy it way more if I`m doing what I want,how I want and have matching wood in reserve.When there`s no deadlines,agreements or potential money exchange looming I tend to drag out the wood and wing it.

There`s a lot of trees out there going to waste every day.If I end up with nothing more than a learning experience costing only my free time then I count that as both an addition to my skills and more wood for the stove/less wood in the landfill.

The models/categories divisions are like herding cats,nailing Jello to a tree or trying to decide if someone`s an artist or a craftsman.

The important thing to remember is that you are an individual,

Just like everybody else. ;^)

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#86

Re: Thom and David - diamond paste grits

David Weaver

Pam - thanks for the clarification. My thoughts about going to diamonds only go back and forth. Firstly, because the shaptons do great things with high carbon steel and I have no issues with them on d2 mortise chisels that I have. That leaves japanese tools and a couple of high speed steel irons.

The japanese tools go on natural stones after a run up through synthetics, none of which have any problem with them, either.

So after this discussion again, I got a 16k shapton stone the other day to look at and compare to the 15k pro for someone. I had occasion to plane cocobolo again a bunch over the weekend so out came the mujingfang continental smoother again, and with it what has become a fairly thick microbevel. This time, I should've just run it back to the grinder. I couldn't quite get satisfaction on it for sharpness in 2 or 3 minutes on the glasstone (I was not impressed with its performance), and took the lazy way out and finished it off on green stuff on a veg tanned leather disc on a bench top belt sander. That took care of it super pronto - to the point that I think I will not again think of using diamonds. I don't know what the green stuff cutting power is, it's not diamonds, but on a wheel spinning a couple of K rpms, it works just fine, though it does generate some heat. Given that it's HSS, that's not really a problem.

I only mention that because I have found green stuff to be an OK step after a finish stone if you really want to go nuts, but it does cut exceptionally slow on a piece of MDF or a man-powered strop. On a machine, though, it's a whole different world. ten seconds worth of time and a finish on a board that nearly looks like the work of white steel is in order (and most importantly, it can be effectively used on cocobolo for thicknessing and squaring up infill parts for a very long time).

So, I do recognize some of larry's comment about difficulty with some stones now that the microbevel has gotten a little larger, it isn't quite as quick as it was before, and to have gotten satisfaction on the shapton stones, it could've taken at least twice as long as HCS would have. I could've trudged through it, but the same as larry says he goes back to the grinder if it takes more than a few swipes to hone an edge, when it starts to take twice as long as normal to hone something, I'm looking for something different. In this case, it was the electrified strop. I may leave it permanently on my bench as I'm chomping a little at the bit to use it for turning and carving tools - two things I don't often use, but I also don't enjoy honing when I do use them.

What have been your favorites in natural stones? Maybe that's something for a different topic. In my experience, I should've probably stopped with the first decent suita that I ran across (one with an incomplete mine mark from Alex Gilmore), because I have spent a lot of money on other stones since, and have only gotten stones that cut finer if they slower. I have several other stones from fujibato, one shobu mountain stone that is sort of a somewhat coarse finish stone (but is very usable in skilled hands), and one of the hida ohira stones (which I haven't found to be bad, but I also haven't found anything about it better than the suita stone). They are a good way to spend a lot of money quickly, and to my knowledge, there isn't a good way to sell the ones you've fallen out of favor with. Maybe my kids will like them :)

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#87

Re: Thom and David - diamond paste grits

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

My reason for adding diamond paste to my sharpening regimen is solely to accommodate CPM 3V, and that's to facilitate my making some special chisels that doesn't involve forges and the like (I hate blacksmithing). I'd note that just because green compound has very small microns doesn't mean that it's good for CPM 3V. That's a cool result you've gotten with A2, green, and leather wheel.

I agree that a natural stone discussion is another topic, so I'll just say that I have problems remembering which stone does well with which chisel type(s). It's mostly trial and error at this point, though they usually find each other eventually. :) I suppose I have to devise a labeling system for tools and stones and stick with it, but that's antithetical to the way I work. (:

Pam

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#88

I don't agree about the grain size...

John in NM

Wiley's division makes perfect sense to me, being that I've been on both sides of the division and I'm currently in between. But I think he could have summed it up this way - the professional has to be concerned with efficiency to survive, the hobbyist does not. Both may make tool choices based on personal tastes and liking, but at the end of the day there is a bottom line for one group and not for the other. The hobbyist will benefit from efficiency, but it is not essential.

I think the reason that the categories seem too coarse grained is that making money as a full pro or semi-pro gets exceedingly complicated, there being many, many factors involved in the struggle to sell your products at all, let alone at a profit. It is easy to get lost in all those details, but over the course of a career, I don't think they matter much compared to efficient work habits.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#89

Re: I don't agree about the grain size...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I think I simply don't have a need to categorize people. They are what they are, with or without my attempts to describe them. I place great value on working with efficiency and speed, but I make no money from woodworking at the moment.

Pam

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#90

Re: Pour on the power.

ThomD

I am not sure who these professionals are. My Grandfather was a joiner. These days there are few if any people working in the same way with hand tools. Power tools are all over the place even in the pro hand tool user ranks. And many of the people who really work with hand tools are in some place like A museum where they aren't really being paid for the piece work.

If speed were the issue nobody would be touching diamond sharpening I suspect. CPM 3V can be ground on a belt sander, it is a knife steel after all. Playing around with diamond paste is very slow in comparison, and the cost isn't all that persuasive either. Embedded diamond wheels are fast, but mostly designed for sharpening carbide. Not for use with HSS.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#91

Blanket statements can confuse.

Bob Hackett

I think you need to provide a little more info for folks Thom.

Yes CPM steels can be ground on a belt grinder,provided you have the right belt.Try and use the wrong type of abrasive or too high a speed and you will ruin the belt just like you would the wrong choice of wheel.

Belts need to be matched to the task at hand just like a grinding wheel does and there are almost as many variables involved too.

Embedded diamond wheels are made for a wide variety of applications as well.The right wheel will cut mild steel (like a first responder`s rescue saw) or stone(like a gem faceting lap) and a lot of things in between.

Much of the carbide I rough ground and saw ground was done on a green wheel and we saved the diamond wheels for final grinding and renewing the edge on both carbide and HSS machinist bits.The HSS was a holiday for the diamond compared to the carbide.

Those of us who work a lot of metal tend to forget that non-metal workers don`t know these things and we really should be more specific about what can do what and how before we send WWers off into metalworking tasks with limited info or blanket statements.

I say this to keep someone from trying to do something with their gear that it may not be designed for.I`d hate to see someone get hurt because they misunderstood something said on this forum.

MB

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#92

Re: Pour on the power.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

What sandpaper do you use for CPM 3V on that belt sander?

Pam

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#93

Re: Pour on the power.

ThomD

I don't, but I have yet to see almost anything that a knifegrinding belt won't take on. Lee Valley sells the ones I use on my 1x42. Mostly stuff like "B"

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=48040&cat=1,43072

Pops is said to be a good supplier in the US for 2x72:

http://popsupply.bizhosting.com/kingspor_belts.html

I don't currently have a supplier up here, as both my previous are no longer doing it.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#94

Re: Pour on the power.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, Thom, but I don't know CPM by experience, so I think I'll stick with the old grinders and new diamonds for the time being, just need some CPM now. Alas, an emergency HDTV purchase brought on by the untimely failure of the 12 year old JVC beauty has shot the tool budge for this month, maybe next, too; so it will have to wait just a bit. However, I'll keep knives in mind if the diamond turns out to be too slow for me. That's excellent advice.

Pam