Professionals and hobbyists
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Derek and all,
I thought your post was well conceived, because look at this long thread, concerned about whether it is admirable or foolish for someone to do a single non-traditional thing. The mention of CPM 3V has consistently brought out these passions time and again.
Which brings me to another way to categorize--professionals and hobbyists. For me, woodworking is a hobby. I enjoy the wood, the tools, the forum, swapping yarns, learning stuff, unlearning other stuff; I don't care how long things take; and it doesn't have to pay for itself. And I have a high tolerance for what anyone else wants to do with their time and money. Live and let live.
But the professional life is different. Changes in tools and methods need to pay for themselves, or you don't do them. Time is the air you breathe. One of the most damning things that a professional can say about another--and this is true in craft skills or the white collar professions--is that 'he's slow'.
Slow is really bad. Inefficiency is really bad. I can recall watching two different contractors doing huge earthwork at a dam under construction some years ago here in So. Calif. One contractor would haul all the earth to a pile to get it out of their way, and then rehaul from there. Double handled every bucket load. With the other contractor--a great one named Peter Kiewit--every truck load was hauled to final line and grade. For engineers looking on, the double handling was an abomination, and on the other hand Kiewit's great organization validated everything we were living our life for. Our work life anyway. For a sightseer, it would not have mattered--two contractors working against a contract, and under the eyes of inspectors--let them haul dirt their way--who cares?
Which brings me to my point about professionals. I don't really think Warren and Larry are thinking about tools per se. I do think they are thinking about the totality of their craft, in which every procedure relates to every other one, in a seamless continuum of time and efficiency. They can't even remember all the reasons why A is better than B--it's too nuanced and interconnected with every other thing, to remember and relate. If I found a forum on water engineering, populated largely by hobbyists, or if Derek found a forum where hobbyists proposed, and implemented on their children, amateur and innovative methods in clinical psychology based on notions they had developed--we both might be a tad intolerant about it.
So I think an inquiry into 'groups' as Derek was doing is a useful thing, but I would propose professionals and hobbyists (maybe with a mid-range 'advanced amateur') as the primary breakdown.
One thing that was overlooked in this latest incarnation of the CPM 3V discussion, was that the topic arose in Australia. I seem to recall from many conversations, that Australia is the land of dense semi-tropical woods and iron woods of all sorts. I want to get into this subject in another thread, as this one is way down the page, but I think that our experience with O1 and straight high-carbon steel on temperate zone No. American and European hardwoods may not translate to Oz. It may be that Oz really does need high-alloy steel and efficient ways to sharpen it, as a standard practice.
Wiley




