Re: Let me get this straight
David Weaver
Larry - you practically explained everything I could do to sharpen the irons. I think I could answer the question by addressing all of the things you mentioned and affirming that I do them, without having ever picked up an iron.
But, really, I have had three planes with HSS irons, and still have two. They are all mujingfangs. What alloy they are, I don't know. All are 2" irons.
The first one was from a 63* smoother, a 1/8" iron. It was actually hollow ground on the back, and it came semi polished already. I finished polishing it on shapton stones, and I didn't use the ruler trick for it. For the front of the bevel, I used microbevels to limit how much work I had to do removing metal. I found that all of my 1000 stones would cut it to make the second bevel, but somewhat slow, except for a cheap diamond hone (copy of a koyama brand stone that has polycrystalline diamonds). It removes metal as fast as high carbon steel is removed on a regular stone - to the point that you can overdo the camber if you're not careful.
Final step is a shapton 15,000 stone on a third bevel - 35 degrees for the third, 25 for the primary and 32 for the secondary (I have jigs set up for that) - those obviously aren't critical. I usually check an iron for sharpness by loupe on both sides or by shaving hair with it with the bevel flipped both directions - bevel up and bevel down.
The other two irons are flat HSS (I guess I have a third, too, I didn't set it up yet - it's for a small useless plane someone sent me in error), and I did have to flatten them. i have a blade jig with handles that I put the iron in so that I can lean hard on it. stones were pretty worthless for that (could've done it, would've taken a long time), including a 400 grit diamond hone, but 100 grit diamonds on a steel plate worked really well, especially putting the iron in the blade jig (which is just a piece of 2x4 with handles on the end and two bolts to hold the blade by the slot). Took about 10 minutes to go through the grits from 100 diamond, 400 diamond, 1000 diamond, 5000 shapton and 15000 shapton. I did that just because the blade was already in the jig. For maintenance, those get the ruler trick on the highest grit shapton, and a microbevel like above.
It really isn't that bad as long as the second bevel is done properly with the 1000 grit diamond stone. You sharpen fairly rarely doing it, and even when you do, you don't have to chase the bevel far because the stones never get a large nick or really damaged. If they failed with large nicks, they'd be a pain.
Maybe hone four or five times before throwing them back on the tormek and chasing the primary bevel back down. I have the black wheel on the tormek - they cut noticeably slower than HCS, but like 2x as long, not like 10x as long. They are definitely to the grinder fewer than half as much, so at the worst, that's a wash.
Maybe I'll record it the next time I have to regrind the primary.