Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

Posts

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#51

Re: choosing a steel for woodworking tools

David Weaver

I fold on this one. I don't turn unless I have to, I only turn exotics for tool handles (generally), only have M2 and powder metal gouges, and I always hone the bevel (both sides of it) after they come off the tormek because - i like to. Almost without exception, everything I turn is cocobolo or some type of ebony. The edge has a short enough life on powder metal and HSS.

Not tuned in to what most turners do. I don't favor turned elements in furniture general, and the whole community of wood turners seems like a set of strange birds to me.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#52

Re: I agree entirely

ThomD

I think both issues are equally relevant. The heat issue allows one to grind however one wishes as long as one's hands don't catch on fire, and the end result is always a good edge, that is major to me, and to a lot of newbies who don't yet have touch. When using the tool it wears a lot better, which is important on some tools and not others. I prefer HSS skews for sure, but I have a few of them in HC that are just great tools and I use them even though they weren't HSS tools, Same with light bowl finishing scrapers. But for any tools I can get in HSS it is always worth it. A third reason for using HSS is because, to me , it seems to take a better edge right off the grind stone, than carbon does. Harder to grind away equals finer edge for the most part. Anotehr example being that I prefer not to use a belt sander because it cuts too freely for sharpening. Since I mostly turn right off the wheel, this is another advantage to HSS. All that said. I don't worry all that much about the kind of HSS. I have found some super Oz tools I got sorta over the top for the work I do. Might be ideal for another.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#53

Re: correct on the silicon carbide

ThomD

The Kanaban I got from LV say 30 years ago seemed a lot more like Cold Rolled steel than cast iron (either the western or eastern type). If I were going this route I would dig up some old machine tool parts, or a very cheap cast iron plane body. Sure it will all work. The SC grinding is a very different process, it is very dirty compared to diamond. however, over time it breaks down further and further, and ultimately creates an incredible mirror polish. I don't think it is super fast like diamond. The obvious way to sharpen HSS both cost wise and speed wise is with power tools. Dry grinders or belt grinders just swallow the stuff up. The diamond honning thing is a boutique field.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#54

scott grandstaff

Re: grind

scott grandstaff

Well Guys

I am reading all this and Larry nailed it. But we are talking Larry Williams here.

His money is out far ahead of his mouth, nobody can deny.

And I am in the same camp.

I am reading about all this struggle and fear of sharpening and wanting edges that last forever because you can't be bothered to stop and sharpen when you need to.

And honestly if I had to suffer all the rigaramarole some of you apparently go through, I'd fear it too.

It doesn't seem to be as much fear of honing as it does fear of simple grinding.

First, forget exotic sharpening equipment. Break down and learn to grind.

Get any standard bench grinder over 6" size, put a coarse wheel on it, and take a piece of steel in your hand............... and make it do what you want.

Simple as that. No jig, no setup, just take it to the wheel and grind it.

I don't really even use the tool rest except to rest the backs of my fingers most times. I get even hollow grinds on anything I want and beyond that, can actually shape metal when I want.

Thousands of others do it, you can too.






As far as turning, I started when HSS was only really offered by Sears and they were stubby lightweight things I didn't like, so I learned on plain old regular tools and don't suffer so much. Its not impossible.

I don't produce production turnings of 3522 bowls nobody really wants, like so many do. ( I see these poor guys schlepping all their bowls around the craft circuit and everybody trying to avert their eyes as they scuttle past.)

I try to make what I turn count for something, at least to me.


Its plenty easy enough to grind regular carbon steel, so it's not any big deal at all when I need to grind and hone one.

Takes 1 minute, what is there to be afraid of??

Just do it. Break down and learn to grind steel.

It takes practice, it takes determination and its messy and dirty. You're going to screw up and you're probably going to burn yourself and maybe grind away a little skin, (hopefully minor). But so have millions before you.

Put on your big boy pants and face it.

You'll save yourself endless time and money and from the sound if it in this thread, worry.

You only have to learn it once and its --over--. Forever.

Oh PS, while learning to grind, make yourself a dedicated screwdriver to take off double iron screws, A nice short fat one that fits the screws exactly. You'll never fear having to separate the iron from the cap iron again. Its practically a pleasure when you have a great driver.

While you're at it, make yourself a dedicated saw screw driver to take off those saw tote screws.

Nothing you can buy really fits either of these screws, and you need them anyway.

See? Paid for your swap meet grinder in the first projects.

And you are on your way to taming metal.

Actually owning it and making it bend to your will.

Pretty soon you'll be looking at all the new products and stuff and thinking..

"These are all solutions to problems I don't have anymore."

yours Scott

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#55

Re: correct on the silicon carbide

ThomD

Actually that does have a casty look to it. Diamond will embed and not wear the cast iron away. What you may experience however is that the diamond embeds, and does not wear down because it so hard. This is great for sharpening, but if you want to subsequently use the same surface with finer SC... But you probably will like the diamond and be happy enough leaving it as is. So the plate will be fine, but the way you use it will be different. Reserve discrete sections for your different diamond pastes, because they don't reduce to nothing like SC.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#56

Re: chosing a steel for woodworking tools

ThomD

Larry I agreed with just about everything you say except -

1) The carbide bit that came with my Hitachi TR12 plunge router maybe 20 years ago, was razor sharp out of the box. Apparently the carbide tool grain size issue (as mentioned relative to carbide by others) is not true in Japan.

2) I have a number of HSS Japanese tools that are a little bit harder to sharpen than the Blue or white tools, but the edge is over the top fantastic. So again, why not for them?

Anywho, other than that I am an O1 dude. Cast steel for me seems similar, and white steel from Japan better still. I bought some O1 for molding planes the other day. I would not want to mess around with slips on those in some super steel, though anyone else who wants to may suit themselves.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#57

Re: grind

David Weaver

I'm the guy who complains about double irons. I have three screwdrivers that fit double irons well, two that are purpose designed for it. It's not hard to take them apart, it's a nuisance.

Nuisance and hard are two different things.

I actually don't have a better screwdriver to take them apart than the stubby husky that HD used to sell - $6, made in usa, wide thin blade.

Have the LN one, too, but that one doesn't fit some vintage screws - blade is too fat.

Also never had an aversion to grinders, used a grinder exclusively, a very cheap one, before I could justify a tormek and before I had a power belt sander. Still do use it sometimes, especially shaping unhardened steel. Never had a trick rest, and never needed one, got warm fingers plenty of times.

I'd rather have the hardest and toughest steel I can find and use the tormek and stones and leave the grinder for serious metal removal. I'd also rather have single iron planes with mouths sized for the task and completely avoid adjusters and chipbreakers. Waste of time and money.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#58

Re: correct on the silicon carbide

David Weaver

I think the kanaban I got a couple of years ago from TFWW is also mild steel. It doesn't look anything like what Pam showed, though. It's a thinner rectangle, more like a sharpening stone.

I use it with 100 grit diamond and nothing else. Really can't unless it gets ground or the diamonds lapped out. Works well for that, but I wish it was cast.

If LV offered a non-groove version of their lapping plate, that would be fantastic for diamonds. As it is with grooves, it seems like most of my abrasive ends up in the grooves and gradually comes out. I understand their purpose, but I can't get on with it when diamonds are used. There is a lot of sloppiness involved when using 60/90 or 220 grit loose silicon carbide, too, but that's really cheap stuff - 2 pounds for $7 on ebay maybe, and alox isn't much more from places that specialize in soap making stuff (never would've expected to see 100 grit alox in soap, but I guess that's the price of beauty).

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#59

Re: Let me get this straight

Larry Williams

David,

My post was misleading and I apologize for that.

Even with the oscillating grinder and a full compliment of available wheels at $200 a pop, I could only easily sharpen a HSS plane blade once. I could only do it the first time. After that, I'd be in for considerable work.

As everyone knows, you've got to hone both sides of an edge when sharpening. I don't care how slowly an edge wears, both faces that make up the edge wear. The bevel part of the edge of a plane iron is the easy part, the hard part is removing the wear from the flat face. While I'm no fan of Charlesworth's "ruler trick," the positive thing I can say about it is that it correctly identifies the location of nearly all the sharpening problems I see people struggle with.

The wear on the flat face will be greater along the length of the iron, extending back from the edge, than it will be deep into the thickness of the iron. If you're going to remove this wear by working only on the bevel you'll have a lot of steel to grind away every time you sharpen. Even with easy grinding high carbon steel irons, if you're doing this on a Tormek, I'm impressed with your patience and tenacity.

This wear on the flat face is easy and quick to deal with when working with high carbon steels and normal sharpening abrasives. While diamonds are an amazing abrasive that'll cut anything, they're pretty slow cutting because of their shape. Unless things have changed radically in the last couple years, even coarse diamond lapping compounds are pretty fine. Grinding or lapping HSS is also a very slow process. If you're going to lap the back of a 2" HSS plane iron using diamonds can I suggest you pack a lunch?

I think I could disassemble and reassemble a lot of Stanley planes before I could lap the back of a single 2" M4 plane iron with diamond lapping compounds. In fact, I'd much rather spend time taking apart Stanleys and putting them back together than lap 2" M4. Given a choice between the two, I wouldn't even mind risking lock-jaw from all that rusty iron.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#60

Thom and David - diamond paste grits *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks for the help. Once diamond paste goes on/in, that will be it, no returns to sc or anything else. I should mention at this point that all I use are water stones, mostly natural Japanese, for sharpening edge tools. I do use a Shapton lapping plate with sc for keeping the stones more or less flat. So, using the diamond paste will be only the second sharpening method.

I hope that the two systems will somehow fit together. One of the diamond paste vendors mentioned that if you needed to go finer than available diamond, use water stones; but when comparing grits (see Chris Schwarz's chart, available to download on the blog page below) it appears that diamond paste is the finest available, right up there with Shaptons. I think this will work, use the waterstones first and go to diamond for the end. There should be no problems carrying forward the paste to "corrupt" the stones.

I also should mention that according to the grit chart, green compound appears to be finer than anything but a 30k Shapton.

Thanks,

Pam


PopWW/Chris Schwarz grit chart

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#61

Re: Matching the tool to the sharpening system

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

My trip into natural water stones and Japanese tools has been very interesting because of the pairing up of a particular stone with a particular blade (or multiple blades made by a given maker of a given steel). Once determined (and it's kind of hard to remember, so I use a cheat sheet), it works like a charm. Thus, I plan to use the diamond paste mostly on any CPM 3V tools I make.

Scott, I don't think many here are afraid of grinders; but I just don't like them. I don't like all the stories of wheels exploding and bluing steel and hollow bevels; so I compromised and got a horizontal Makita water grinder, which does the job on the rare occasion I have a blade in need of serious repair.

Pam

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#62

Re: Let me get this straight

David Weaver

Larry - you practically explained everything I could do to sharpen the irons. I think I could answer the question by addressing all of the things you mentioned and affirming that I do them, without having ever picked up an iron.

But, really, I have had three planes with HSS irons, and still have two. They are all mujingfangs. What alloy they are, I don't know. All are 2" irons.

The first one was from a 63* smoother, a 1/8" iron. It was actually hollow ground on the back, and it came semi polished already. I finished polishing it on shapton stones, and I didn't use the ruler trick for it. For the front of the bevel, I used microbevels to limit how much work I had to do removing metal. I found that all of my 1000 stones would cut it to make the second bevel, but somewhat slow, except for a cheap diamond hone (copy of a koyama brand stone that has polycrystalline diamonds). It removes metal as fast as high carbon steel is removed on a regular stone - to the point that you can overdo the camber if you're not careful.

Final step is a shapton 15,000 stone on a third bevel - 35 degrees for the third, 25 for the primary and 32 for the secondary (I have jigs set up for that) - those obviously aren't critical. I usually check an iron for sharpness by loupe on both sides or by shaving hair with it with the bevel flipped both directions - bevel up and bevel down.

The other two irons are flat HSS (I guess I have a third, too, I didn't set it up yet - it's for a small useless plane someone sent me in error), and I did have to flatten them. i have a blade jig with handles that I put the iron in so that I can lean hard on it. stones were pretty worthless for that (could've done it, would've taken a long time), including a 400 grit diamond hone, but 100 grit diamonds on a steel plate worked really well, especially putting the iron in the blade jig (which is just a piece of 2x4 with handles on the end and two bolts to hold the blade by the slot). Took about 10 minutes to go through the grits from 100 diamond, 400 diamond, 1000 diamond, 5000 shapton and 15000 shapton. I did that just because the blade was already in the jig. For maintenance, those get the ruler trick on the highest grit shapton, and a microbevel like above.

It really isn't that bad as long as the second bevel is done properly with the 1000 grit diamond stone. You sharpen fairly rarely doing it, and even when you do, you don't have to chase the bevel far because the stones never get a large nick or really damaged. If they failed with large nicks, they'd be a pain.

Maybe hone four or five times before throwing them back on the tormek and chasing the primary bevel back down. I have the black wheel on the tormek - they cut noticeably slower than HCS, but like 2x as long, not like 10x as long. They are definitely to the grinder fewer than half as much, so at the worst, that's a wash.

Maybe I'll record it the next time I have to regrind the primary.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#63

Another place HSS shines

Bob Hackett

One of the places where the durability of HSS really shines is in scrapers,both cabinet and turning type.

I burnish my HSS scrapers so a hook forms(the turning tools are done on a Lee Valley jig and the cabinet scrapers a LV carbide adjustable angle burnisher) and the life of the hook is way more than double that of HCS.

MB

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#64

would-be tool designers

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thoughtful remarks, Wilbur. I have written before that our tools and cutting techniques and our sharpening media and sharpening technique, all taken together, are a system. They all have to be developed in concert. And a lot of thought and talent have gone into this process over the years. We have steels that have been developed specifically for edge tools in wood, specifically for certain sharpening media. The idea that one can search a library of steels that were designed for other purposes and find something to plug in here is somewhat dubious.

One thing that has not been mentioned is that those with good experience are much gentler on their tools, a big factor in edge longevity. They also sense the appropriate time to stop and sharpen and probably get considerably better results than a beginner would with the same media. Today it seems as though we have premium tools being designed around the problems beginners are having.

For a would-be tool designer, I have the following suggestion (taking my own preferences out of the equation). Read how Toshio Odate makes a mortise. Get his kind of chisel and stones and make a thousand mortises. Learn to do this with discipline and speed and neatness. If you can, watch him or have him watch you. While you are at it, sharpen your plane irons five or six thousand times using his methods. Then think about what tool alterations you might adopt.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#65

Re: would-be tool designers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Warren

Let us assume for a moment that you were given a new mortice chisel. It was shaped with the identical dimensions to your favourite mortice chisel. It had the same balance and the same heft. It was, for all intents, the same chisel that you love to use .... but ... it was made with some new space age steel alloy, and the edge only needed to be honed once each month... and that this task was no more effort than for your old chisel, although it did require a different type of stone ...

Would this new chisel change the way you worked?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#66

The well analogy

Bob Hackett

I was speaking with one of my teachers a while back about people who jump around from thing to thing and then wonder why they never find satisfaction and success in what they do.

He told me that success comes through commitment and understanding and he compared it with digging a well.When looking for water you do your homework and take into account what others who have gone before you and had success have done.With that in mind you choose your spot and start digging.If you stay with that spot sooner or later you will hit water.

On the other hand if you jump from spot to spot following trends and/or what looks like an easier dig,never committing yourself there`s a good chance you may never find water.

MB

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#67

Yes.

Bob Hackett

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#68

scott grandstaff

Re: would-be tool designers

scott grandstaff

Absolutely no doubt Derek

If it was just like the old chisel, except held the edge longer?

Sure I'd go for it in a heartbeat,

unless............

If I couldn't grind it without buying new equipment 18 times more expensive than the old stuff I already have?

and I couldn't hone it without buying new stuff costing 210 times more than the old?

and the "new" chisel cost approximately 2118 times more to buy than the old one?

A chisel I get perfectly admirable service out of as it is??

Not so much.

yours Scott

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#69

Re: would-be tool designers

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Well, Derek, it happens that efficient mortising is not too hard on a chisel. If I were spending all my time just mortising, I would need to spend about a minute and a half sharpening each day. I think this is a trivial amount. I don't think the idea that sharpening mortise chisels is a burden comes from people who have a lot of experience in using them.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#70

Stretching things a bit

Bob Hackett

One of the reasons the Vikings were so successful and able to raid and spread thier empire pretty much at will was their weapons were stronger,sharper and held an edge better than their opponents.Their choice of metals had a huge impact on the way THEY worked I can tell you!

Thinking in reverse,if you had to use nothing but bronze or stone for edged tools would that impact how you work?

Anyone who tells you stone can`t be sharpened to a fine and durable edge has never worked with a flintnapped knife.You might want to check out the guy hewing a log with a jade bladed adze on You-tube too.

MB-Who hears the return of stone tools calling. :b

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#71

Re: would-be tool designers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

My own view is that there are essentially three types of woodworker personalities involved herein (I'm deliberately being simplistic to stay with the issue).

The first type follows the fashions, buying the tools as they are developed and manufactured, in the same way that one might acquire a new car or kitchen because it is perceived to be desirable. This person may have strong brand allegiance as a result (but brand allegiance, per se, does not indicate membership of this group as it may also signify a form of quality control).

The second type is focused on production, follows technology and invests in new equipment if it improves on work skills, output and the finished quality. This person may have little brand allegiance (however the absence of brand allegiance, per se, does not indicate membership of the group since many buy what they can afford, and/or what is available at the time).

The third group have a love affair with their work, and the tools they use become an intimate partner in the journey. They may say that they do not have allegiance to tools because they are happy with their old, their battered, and their used-up tools in their collection, but it appears that really they are in love, rather than being anti-tool advancement. They may experience new or unfamiliar tools as an incursion into the existing intimacy of a familiar ritual.

Guys, please take the above with a pinch of salt. While there is no doubt truth here, it was meant to be in humour :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#72

I've done some flintknapping

Bruce, a MN Galoot

my hands were a mass of micro-cuts. That stuff is extremely sharp. I'm not sure I'd like to cut mortises with it, though.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#73

Well, why would you joke about such things? 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#74

Ah ha ... you can read into it what you will

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Maybe it will be taken seriously. Maybe not ... :)

Do you want to add to the reasons one may or may not buy new tools?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#75

Re: Ah ha ... you can read into it what you will :

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Do you want to add to the reasons one may or may not buy new tools?

No, there are too many variables to make categorizations and/or predictions (also the main reason I never tried to make a living using my econ degree (the secondary reason was that it was hard to take a discipline seriously that awarded Nobel prizes for such trivial work such as pointing out that people spend/save differently depending on where they are in their lives)).

Pam