Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

Posts

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#26

Re: M2 availability and footnote on sharpening

David Weaver

Wilbur, I asked raney about that exact plane when I was kind of gathering information to build my first one, and he seemed to have sort of mixed feelings at the time.

I wish I could find the email that he sent to me, but I lost 9 years worth of yahoo emails about a month ago, and that was among the group.

The wonderful thing about japanese planes is how tunable they are, how comfortable they are to use, and how they aren't fatiguing or hard on the elbows and shoulders. I think making them heavy with a metal carcass takes some of that ease away. There's something to be said for the fact that you can lean backwards and pull a very light plane through a tough spot, as opposed to when you are providing momentum for a western woody or a bench plane and you hit nasty spots and the bucking, etc, is transmitted seemingly directly to the palms of your hands and definitely into the elbows. With a pull plane of any type, it just puts more tension on your arms, but with no shock.

I've had the same experience with my kanna in terms of finish - a .002 or .003 shaving can come off looking like a very fine finish, but I have also gotten surprise tearout doing that from time to time. The infill provides sort of a fool-proof way of dealing with hardwoods (so far). I haven't been able to create any tearout yet with it.

I recall a conversation on WN a while ago where high quality infill smoothing planes were criticized because they have that ability - to take the "skill" out of planing because you can't get into trouble with tearout with them. Have to wonder why you're using a plane in the first place if a primary reason is just to create possible trouble that you can avoid easily.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#27

Japanese planes

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

This is easy enough to test, simply make a dai that has a flat sole from toe to heel; or use a jointer (Mosaku, e.g.) for the planing test, assuming the blades are similar (mine are). I know the surface created by an ECE Primus Reform was very, very close to that of Japanese planes; but the planes are too different to judge anything from such a test.

Pam

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#28

Re: correct on the silicon carbide *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I just ordered a Tsunesaburo kanaban (link below) to start playing with diamond paste; but since it comes with 1000 grit silicon carbide powder, I decided to choose the paste after trying the silicon. It occurred to me that possibly the diamond would eat into the kanaban more readily than I'd like. Is this possible? Japan Woodworker sells a kit of diamond pastes along with mdf; and Tools for Woodworking and LV say it's best used with a substrate such as mdf, hard maple, etc. Not a one recommends using the paste on metal.

Pam

PS This is leading to an attempt to make some carving tools, such as background pounders, from CPM 3V, on which many more questions later


Tsunesaburo kanaban

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#29

Re: Japanese planes

David Weaver

The surface created by a lie nielsen or stanley bench plane with a good quality iron, a clean sole and a light cut is also very close. Actually, I don't know if I could tell the difference between that and a japanese plane where neither surface had tearout.

Certainly, the 45 degree bench plane leaves more shine behind than any of the high angle planes I've used.

The difference between the japanese plane and the bench plane is that there seems to be a tad less tearout with the japanese plane at the same mouth size and similar bed angle.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#30

Re: D2

David Weaver

Bugbear, for whatever reason, yesterday at lunch I was looking up D2 information to find out what it was designed to do.

One of the articles said it was designed to be a cheaper and easier to machine alternative to M2, but it turned out that it didn't fare well at all in high speed applications, so it was a failure at that.

Also, as noted, it's much cheaper here (after looking) to get D2 stock than M2 stock.

Those two things together seem to clear it up, cheaper to acquire the stock and easier to grind it into blades. Makes sense now why it is more popular as a standard iron than M2.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#31

Re: Japanese planes

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

The Primus produced a very smooth surface; but the Japanese planes produce a smooth, satin shiny surface that I really don't have to finish. Don't know about infills. Just as I was about to finish making one, I learned how to make Japanese dai, never looked back (anybody want a great infill kit? :) )

Pam

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#32

Re: correct on the silicon carbide

Bob Hackett

Pam,is then plate you`re using made out of cast iron?I couldn`t tell by reading the link you provided.

If you`d like to try diamond on cast PM me and I`ll see what I can do about cutting up some of the old stuff I have.

I recently acquired a diamond saw and that makes things much easier.

MB

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#33

Re: correct on the silicon carbide

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'm pretty sure it is cast iron, but that was quite the assumption I made since JW doesn't say one way or the other. Thanks for the offer, but I have a big hunk of cast iron from a disused table saw that I don't mind abusing, so I can try the diamond paste on that first. Tsunesaburo spent time making this "dead flat on both sides" kanaban, and I'd sure hate to muck it up. I haven't got it yet, ordered it last night, got tired of seeing it on my wish list for the last 5 or 6 years. :)

Pam

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#34

Clever recommendation if you are SELLING diamond p

Bill Tindall

I promised myself to eschew further comment on these matters but I had to respond to your post. I don't know why there is still any discussion of how to use diamond abrasives. It got settled 100+ years ago.

On cast iron a tube of 1 micron paste, or a few grams of loose diamond, will literally last a lifetime. A charge on a 3 x 12" plate is measured in a few milligrams and it lasts a long time.

Picture in your minds eye the structure of wood on a 1 micron scale and then imagine what will happen to 1 micron particles added to it. 99+% of the particles are going to vanish uselessly into the soft porous structure never to be seen again by the metal to be abraded. The second problem is how do you get rid of the grinding grunge that builds up on wood or other soft substrate ( it floats harmless away on cast iron). Even acrylic, an acceptable substitute for cast iron, is wasteful and slower cutting because the particles are sunk into it(unless it is a coarse grit). .

I didn't invent the idea of using cast iron. It has been found to be best through more than a hundred years of "polishing" (actually grinding) diamond gem stones. Everything else that has ever been mentioned is not just a little worse, it is a lot worse for one reason or another.

The history is as follows: I called abrasive suppliers and asked what to use for hardened alloy steels. The universal recommendation was diamond abrasives. So then I inquired of diamond suppliers what to load the diamond onto. Cast iron was the universal recommendation. There is available diamond coated abrasive sheets like the 3M stuff but they are not readily available in small quantities and they are more costly than loose powder or the paste. I have some of these sheets but found them to not be advantageous.

No more wheels need to be invented. If you want to effectively grind hard tools steels use diamonds, either as fixed stones or loose on cast iron, or ideally a combination of the two as I have previously described so as to avoid the fatal flaw of loose powder, namely carry-over of grits, which I found described in a machinist manual from the middle of the last century. This stuff ain't new.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#35

Re: chosing a steel for woodworking tools

Larry Williams

"...Turners have overwhelmingly "voted" that the additional wear resistance is worth the price..." Hmmm when I was using HSS for turning, I did it for heat resistance. Wear resistance wasn't part of the equation. When I wanted a good finish off the tools I used my old Disston high carbon turning tools that would take a very good edge.

Today, on my way back to my bench from the bathroom, I passed the shop coffee area. I inadvertently ran my hand over the end of the microwave shelf to find my finger tips black from a layer of fine grinding dust. I remember thinking, "Gee, I wish this dust that's all over the shop was full of cobalt and other toxic heavy metals like one gets from M4."

My experience is that most who are attracted to this are because they haven't mastered basic sharpening. It a "if I ever manage to get a good edge, I want it to last," kind of thing. So let's help these folks out and answer a few basic questions:

Will I get a better edge on an M2 or M4 plane iron? No, you won't get as good an edge because edge quality is directly related to grain size. For the finest grain look to high carbon steel like 0-1, W-1 or 1095.

Will I need to sharpen less frequently? Well yes, your edge, such as it is, will last a little longer.

Will sharpening be easier? No, here's the big issue. This stuff is hard to cut and even very slow to grind. Loose diamonds do a good job but they're tedious and time consuming. You'll actually spend more time sharpening for every hour of use and it will be considerably more difficult.

So what's the gain? Well, you've got me. I invested a lot of time grinding M4 custom tooling for machining wood on metal working equipment. Some though, I made from O-1 because scrap from other things was already at an ideal size and free. The O-1 tooling holds up just fine and gives a better finish. Others in the shop can sharpen the O-1 but I end up resharpening all the M4 stuff because it's such a hassle. In the future, all the M4 stuff will be replaced with O-1 tooling.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#36

Re: chosing a steel for woodworking tools

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I was looking at the LN site today and noticed that they now sell O1 chisels. Have you guys been talking? :) If so, please keep it up.

Pam

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#37

Re: Clever recommendation if you are SELLING diamo

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks for the perspective on selling substrates that eat more diamond paste, even though I can't verify that that's the motive of the sellers, probably more about an easier/cheaper way to get started.

The rest of your message is why I bought the kanaban finally, to get a known flat cast iron base; but, sellers, your message is a bit confusing for those of us who plan to use ci.

So I'll go out and get some diamond paste. And, Bill, please don't eschew commenting on this stuff. Your knowledge is much appreciated.

Pam

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#38

I have to disagree

Bob Hackett

For hand tools especially chisels I prefer the old laminated chisels and those would be closer to a W type steel than an O type.

Turning is where the big difference comes in though and while heat resistance is a factor it`s wear resistance that makes the difference.The use of diamond hones makes HSS and CPM steels no harder to sharpen to as fine an edge as O1 and it takes no longer for me to get it done.Being in the minority of turners that feel the need to hone things like bowl gouges I`m no stranger to a refined edge and I think I demand more from my tools than most turners.

I use whatever`s at hand and there is a marked difference between the longevity of an edge in O1,HSS and especially CPM.

The reason I look for increased durability in a turning tool is turning requires making both smooth flowing shapes and precise details.Having to stop in the middle of something and hone is a distraction at best and I find that having a tool that I can count on to carry me thru the work and stay engaged in turning rather than breaking for sharpening is a big plus.All the turners I know feel the same and that`s why we use HSS for turning and not just because we bought into the hype.

Not to discount your considerable experience Larry but the myth of HSS and CPM not taking as fine an edge as O1 was debunked long ago.

As far as grain size goes very few of us are willing to take HCS to any finer a scratch pattern than HSS is taken to using 1/2 to 1/4 micron diamond and that scratch pattern while mostly impacting performance is at least a contributing factor to how long an edge will hold up wouldn`t you say?

I gave Bill`s approach to sharpening a try and it made me a believer.Both he and Leonard Lee proved to me that sharpening can be quick and relatively easy,especially for turning.A fine edge on HSS and CPM is no longer a problem and with the ability to obtain as refined an edge on these steels as on O1 I find my WWing experience more enjoyable and my time better spent working with edges and steels that allow me to work the wood longer and spend less time at the sharpening bench.

Given a choice,what do you prefer in your bandsaw,carbon steel or bi-metal blades?I prefer the later and I also resharpen and tune them with no problem now that I have the proper tools to do so.

Respectfully,

Mainely,Bob

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#39

I agree entirely

Bill Tindall

The vast majority of turners and perhaps 100% of the turners that began turning after the extinction of carbon steel tools would agree with everything Bob said.

I am a member of a very active, large turning club and nobody uses carbon steel lathe tools, except occasional home made specialty tools. We have had oodlins of professional turners in and none of them used carbon steel tools. Know any company that still sells them? Run the calculation of how many miles the tool travels in a 2" spindle at 2500 rpm (1200' per minute!) during fabrication of a leg or what ever and it becomes clear why turners value (and know about) abrasion resistance, and why carbon steel became extinct in this area, and why you are always turning with an edge duller than any plane iron you would find useful.

Furthermore, Steve Elliot provided quantitative data from well designed experiments showing that the tool steels can be made as sharp as carbon steel provided the optimum technique is used. If there is something other than traditional notions suggesting they can't, where is the data? There are lots of reasons to not choose modern alloys for flat earth woodworking- cost, ease of fabrication, tradition, etc. that even the modern-steel-enthusiast will agree on. In turn, the traditional-steel-enthusiasts need to accept that it is possible that some elements of steel performance have been improved upon since carbon steel was invented. And, in some situations, these improvements are worth "the price" of using these steels.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#40

Re: choosing a steel for woodworking tools

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I agree with you, Larry. In the finest 17th and 18th century work, we see clean and crisp work, silky surfaces straight from the tool. To do this kind of work you need an extremely refined edge, not something brash and coarse. If you are trying to replicate good old 20th century work, you can use any old steel and refine with sandpaper or put on such a coarse finish that it doesn't matter.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#41

Re: choosing a steel for woodworking tools

David Weaver

I guess I'm a little bit confused by these statements, because there seems to be some conflict.

In one camp, we've seen in various places that modern abrasives are an exercise in getting steel sharper than it needs to be, that work doesn't need to be sharper than ___ stone (fill in the blank, this is often 4000, 8000, hard arkansas).

Then, in this string of posts, there seems to be the sentiment still that higher alloy steels mean that there is no chance of a fine edge, and that a high carbon steel with the properties of O-1 at the worst must be used.

This suggests a lack of experience in sharpening the high alloy steels, because the subjective level of sharpness should be very similar after diamonds on high speed steel or CPM steels.

For a long time, this existed with the claim that A2 was a hard-to-sharpen steel that could not achieve a good edge. I have never noticed this to be the case on any kind of waterstone - clay or ceramic binder. Maybe on an oistone, I dont' know - I don't use them.

But I can say with certainty that I can get an M2 tool plenty sharp enough to take clean 1/2 thousandth shavings that hold together well with the two HSS ironed planes that I have, actually without even using diamonds.

This stuff about not being able to do fine work with modern steels should probably go the way of the dodo bird. For the record, the three things I use most are white steel, O1 and A2, and not anything more difficult to sharpen, but I have seen enough to know that the edge it will take off of diamonds, or even green chromium oxide compound - is probably easily as sharp as what a very large % of craftsmen were using in the 18th century, and it will hold that edge longer.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#42

Re: choosing a steel for woodworking tools

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I was talking about turning tools specifically. I like a fully honed flat bevel for turning. A great number of high speed steel users do not hone their turning tools at all. I am suggesting that it shows in their work.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#43

Re: choosing a steel for woodworking tools

Bob Hackett

FWIW-I don`t get it either.

I just don`t understand why the same people who look at me like I have 3 heads when I hone a turning tool`s edge think it`s just fine when they have to start power sanding at 60 grit or larger.

Many of these same people feel that more pressure on the pad/disc equates to faster sanding and can`t understand why the end grain on their work always seems to develop cracks.

I chalk this sort of thinking up to mis-information,poor research and an inability to keep an open and questioning mind coupled with failure to experiment on their own.

One of my favorite aspects of being a member here is that my fellow members are constantly helping me to keep an open mind and to question my assumptions.

As I`m beginning to understand late in life,flexibility is key. :)

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#44

PS.

Bob Hackett

One of the all time most incredible statements I have ever heard came from a(supposedly experienced)fellow turner I was teaching.

After honing a bowl gouge for him I suggested he try it.I was working with another student when he quickly came back handed it to me and stated it was no good.When I asked why he said"you made it too sharp to cut".

I excused myself,stepped to his machine and proceeded to do a bevel rubbing planing cut with one wing held vertical swiveled it while cutting to the nose of the gouge and then ran around the rim and used the other wing to continue cutting the inside all it one continuous smooth cut(a trick I first saw David Lancaster perform).

It was admittedly a "showboat" move but it got the point across.

I stopped the lathe,showed him the finish left by the tool and asked if he had any questions.He was speechless.The other student was grinning from ear to ear.

What was also amazing was that the director of the turning school I was teaching at was as dumbfounded as the first student was.Until he saw me make that cut he was under the impression that you could only use the wing of a bowl gouge to shear scrape.

I went on to show him how you can use the wing of a 1/4" bowl gouge to take a 3/4"+ wide chip while rubbing 2 bevels at once on the inside of a bowl(the nose and the wing bevels) all very controled and relaxed.I learned that from Jacques Vesery who also showed me how to hollow a deep closed vessel quickly using a 1/4" bowl gouge.The technique produces continuous chips not scraped dust.

The most valuable lesson I learned from those 2 gentlemen was to question everything I thought I knew for sure.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#45

Let me get this straight *LINK*

Larry Williams

Originally Bill, in part, posted: "The typical failure mode for a plane iron is dulling by abrasion. Adequate toughness and hardness are required, but for this application high abrasion resistance is property to be optimized. While 3V has better abrasion resistance than some steels it is far from the best in this regard. I expect M4 would be the steel of choice for a long lasting plane iron, if cost was no object. "


Are you saying you think this is a good idea, Bob?

Long lasting? Well, maybe but why? The underlying message here is that sharpening is somehow a big problem. I believe a lot of people who haven't mastered basic sharpening look at this and think they've found a solution to their sharpening woes. Once they get this sharp, they won't have to deal with sharpening again for a long time. Basically, I think these people are being set up for failure. If someone is struggling with sharpening a normal plane iron and you give them one of M4 they'll be in for some real difficulty. We have the equipment (see the link) to easily handle an M4 plane iron but I still don't think it'd be worth the effort or offer any advantage. Let me see, the last time I saw a similar grinder in another wood shop was, ahhh, never. I think it's pretty unlikely many woodworkers would have access to something similar.


oscillating diamond grinder

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#46

Matching the tool to the sharpening system

wilbur

There's been a lot of interesting discussion here, and I find it pretty fascinating.

One theme that seems to be percolating under the surface of the O-1/A-2/CPM-3V/M-2 back and forth is that for someone really looking to optimize the sharpness of their hand tools, they really need to consider the types of steel used in their hand tools and their sharpening system as a whole. It's pretty clear that if you are going to start using CPM-3V tools, you need to have diamonds as your sharpening system. If you use O-1, oilstones and a strop will give you excellent results. A-2 and Shaptons seem to be a good match as well. But if you start using oilstones with CPM-3V, at the very least you'll probably get less than optimal results, and in the worst case scenario you'll be quite frustrated.

As an aside, one thing that I notice is that there are many more similarities between Japanese woodworking and western woodworking than there are differences, despite first appearances. People who get very involved with Japanese tools seem to eventually come to the conclusion that the best match for sharpening is Japanese waterstones. One of the things that I had a hard time believing was that there seemed to be a rule of thumb that softer Japanese waterstones worked best with harder steels, and vice versa. I read about people "matching" a Japanese waterstone to a particular tool. That seemed like a lot of mumbo-jumbo to me. But if you look at that idea in the context of the discussion above about the best sharpening media for O-1/A-2/CPM-3V, that idea suddenly seems a lot less crazy.

One last comment on the edge durability issue: I do agree with Larry somewhat as to questioning how much is gained with increased edge holding of these steels. Sharpening should not be that big of an issue -- people have done that for hundreds of years, and I think I've been able to learn how to sharpen a tool pretty well, and if I can do it, anyone can. But there is an element of practice, and unless you engage in the act of sharpening regularly, your proficiency at sharpening will never improve -- unless you are going to be completely dependent on sharpening jigs, in which case sharpening will always seem like a chore.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#47

Coupla things *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Larry and all,

Bill Tindall was making distinctions between chisels and plane irons. Bill was the first to bring CPM 3V to our attention, because he was making chisels. And it needs to be said right here: Bill Tindall never does anything to achieve a shortcut. He rigorously follows the internal logic of project or process, rationally optimizes his decisions, researches what he doesn't know, and spares himself nothing in that pursuit.

In this case we're talking about, he needed chisels. My recall on this, and I think my recall is pretty good, is that he was looking for performance. Specifically, he wanted to know what steel would retain its edge against chipping, at very acute angles. The more acute the bevel angle, the deeper the penetration for a given strike force, and similarly for paring. He wasn't looking for a chisel that didn't need to be sharpened. In researching steels, Bill found that CPM 3V excels in toughness--think resistance to chipping. In the Charpy C-notch test, for example, for steels at RC60 and all data in ft-lb required to break a standard sample, O1 scores 30; A2 scores 40; M2 and D2 score approx. 21; and CPM 3V scores 70. As I recall, and Bill can straighten this out if I'm remembering incorrectly, Bill has beveled his CPM 3V chisels at about 23 degrees, with no ill effects. Bill's research provided him the results he was looking for in his chisels.

Bill's quote (given by Larry above) is distinguishing the fact that the M series steels have opposing attributes to CPM 3V--M2 and M4 are more abrasion resistant than 3V, but less tough.

On the issue of whether carbide size limits the ultimate sharpness of a steel....powder metallurgy is making a big difference. Ron Hock, in his great book "The Perfect Edge", discusses this on p. 25, and especially in regard to vanadium carbides. Vanadium carbides, such as found in CPM 3V, are notably tiny (2-4 microns) and very, very hard. The powder metallurgy provides even distribution through the steel billet, which makes the steel more sharpenable and tougher. Ron, though a staunch traditionalist on high carbon steel, makes a distinction in his book, that he is very interested in the further development of particle vanadium steels.

Disclaimer: I'm not pitching CPM 3V, though I think it's a great steel. I just don't want to see folks I respect being tarred by the brush of 'they can't sharpen'. Another reason I'm not pitching 3V is that straight high carbon and O1 will always be with us--think moulding planes, gouges, and tapered blade woodies, for example. Or Japanese tools. Most folks want to keep their sharpening procedures simple, familiar, and compact, and that is a higher value for them than optimizing different steels for different applications. So it's all very personal, which makes for a bad argument, since we all end up arguing our personal preferences. I personally love straight high carbon that has been optimized as to grain size and hardness. But everything considered, I also think there is room in woodworking for CPM 3V--not so sure about M2 and especially M4.

Attached is a pretty good piece on alloy steels. Bear in mind that Crucible Service Centers is 'talking their book', but still, the info is succinct and useful.

Wiley


Crucible Service Centers on Various Steels

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#48

Re: I agree entirely

Phil Joines Krum,Texas

Know any company that still sells them?

Harbor Fright............

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#49

Re: Let me get this straight

Bob Hackett

Maybe it`s the early hour or it could just be me being thick but I am not getting where you`re coming from here Larry.

On one hand you say the problem is not having a proper grasp of sharpening and then you post a link to a high tech and high dollar machine used primarily by machinists to diamond hone carbide tooling.

I use simple diamond paste or powder purchased from ebay and a cut down cast iron table saw table I got from the dump as substrate and pocket diamond hones and I have no problem mirror polishing most HSS or CPM in the same time or less than I used to get similar results doing HCS on water stones.I also don`t have to spend time flattening or maintaining stones of any sort anymore.My grinding wheels are the only thing that need attention as to dressing or truing.If I use my sander/grinder I don`t even have to do that.

From what I`ve seen there are 2 schools of thought in regards to edge retention/maintenance.

One camp doesn`t mind popping the iron out of the plane at a moment`s notice or just because it may not be as sharp as it could possibly be.The stories of the temple builders in Japan who hone after each stroke of their plane are an extreme example of this school of thought.The edge is everything to them and sometimes the wood or finished product almost seems a secondary consideration. I can see where an O1 or laminated blade would be a big attraction to them.

The other camp is more interested in moving thru the work and time making chips is what`s important.I would be a member here.

I know how to sharpen,have spent a lot of time researching my gear and attempting to understand the mechanics of how and why things cut and fail to cut.Sharpening is not what I consider a chore or something to be avoided.I want to get an appropriately sharp edge relatively quickly with a minimum of fuss and get back to making chips.I like to use steel that will remain in this sharpened state as long as possible in order to prolong my time making chips.

I tend to treat my edges with care and respect as I know what a PITA it is to deal with a deeply chipped or damaged edge.

I use what I feel is appropriate for the task at hand,carbide machine tool inserts for rough turning stumps with sand and small stones.CPM turning tools for production turning and work on clean yet abrasive woods like Teak and Greenheart.HSS plane irons in scrub planes and my low angle block planes that I use for every thing under the sun.My much loved laminated chisels for what they do best and my HSS bench chisels for grunt work and as loaners.HCS spindle gouges that come in sizes and types of flutes and thicknesses that aren`t offered by anyone anymore.

There`s room in the world of all of it.What they all share now is the common approach I take to keeping them sharp.It works well for all those steels and more and is successful in bringing them all to the same level of sharpness quickly and painlessly.The only difference is the durability and longevity of that sharp edge.The type of steel decides that and that is maximized by matching the appropriate steel to the task.

Now that I have a successful system involving simple, cost effective tools sharpening is pretty much a given across the board.

Thank you and Wiley both for your time and consideration,

Bob

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#50

Re: Let me get this straight

David Weaver

Larry - prefacing this with the statement that the vast majority of my planes are old cast steel, O-1 and A2, I see it as this:

I have a lot of double iron planes. It's not the sharpening that's a nuisance, it's fooling around with taking the double iron out of the plane, putting it back together and setting it up. I think that's a complete waste of time, mostly because I'm not the double iron enthusiast that some seem to be.

On a single iron plane, especially one with no adjuster, I don't have nearly the preference, though I would say I *do* like the iron to be hard. But assembling and disassembling isn't an issue, and I can set the mouth on those single iron planes to take the place of screwing around with creating a higher effective angle with a cap iron.

With diamonds, it doesn't really take any longer to sharpen a really difficult iron than it does an easy one. Even with ceramic stones, etc - it's quick. So, the less I have to screw around with the whole double iron assembly, the better.

I don't usually wait until an iron stops cutting to sharpen it, I either sharpen when I don't like how the plane performs with a waxed sole (easy for a lot of people to think a metal plane is dull when it's not just because the sole is creating friction), or when I don't like the surface that a plane is leaving in the case of a smoother. That's usually well before it will stop cutting - maybe 1/3rd or 1/2 of the way there in my experience, thus the interest not only in how long the iron will continue to cut, but also how it fails. The way a japanese iron fails, generally, you can get closer to "dull" and still have a nice surface without lines on it. The way a new A2 iron fails, in my experience, that's not the case - you have lines all over everything. Every once in a while, you get a very good A2 iron that doesn't behave like that, and most of them don't behave like that once they've got a couple of grinds.

That's just my take.