Re: M2 availability and footnote on sharpening
David Weaver
Wilbur, I asked raney about that exact plane when I was kind of gathering information to build my first one, and he seemed to have sort of mixed feelings at the time.
I wish I could find the email that he sent to me, but I lost 9 years worth of yahoo emails about a month ago, and that was among the group.
The wonderful thing about japanese planes is how tunable they are, how comfortable they are to use, and how they aren't fatiguing or hard on the elbows and shoulders. I think making them heavy with a metal carcass takes some of that ease away. There's something to be said for the fact that you can lean backwards and pull a very light plane through a tough spot, as opposed to when you are providing momentum for a western woody or a bench plane and you hit nasty spots and the bucking, etc, is transmitted seemingly directly to the palms of your hands and definitely into the elbows. With a pull plane of any type, it just puts more tension on your arms, but with no shock.
I've had the same experience with my kanna in terms of finish - a .002 or .003 shaving can come off looking like a very fine finish, but I have also gotten surprise tearout doing that from time to time. The infill provides sort of a fool-proof way of dealing with hardwoods (so far). I haven't been able to create any tearout yet with it.
I recall a conversation on WN a while ago where high quality infill smoothing planes were criticized because they have that ability - to take the "skill" out of planing because you can't get into trouble with tearout with them. Have to wonder why you're using a plane in the first place if a primary reason is just to create possible trouble that you can avoid easily.
)


