M2 availability and footnote on sharpening *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
David,
Welcome! You queried M2 availability. Ray Iles of the UK will make M2 irons suitable for infills. He certainly used to, as I have one in an early generation Sauer and Steiner A6, and in an early generation S&S panel plane. Steve Elliott's blade testing showed pretty much a horse race between 3V and M2 (Steve used an Academy Saws M2 iron) as far as edge durability goes. I find the same thing--3V and M2 being comparable--using Ray Iles M2 and Steve Elliott's CPM 3V irons. When using 1/4-micron diamond paste, Steve got essentially the same initial sharpness across all steels tested--O1, A2, CPM 3V, and M2. And it was real sharp.
Some anecdotal experience on sharpening of 3V and M2.....The key to efficient sharpening of either of these steels (IMO) is hollow grinding to the edge, prior to honing. Grind all the way to a primary burr. Once the grinding is done, the usual recommendation for honing is with diamond paste on a cast iron plate. The diamond does work very well. I believe Bill T. is using 1 micron diamond paste. I have used various diamond meshes, down to 1/4micron.
However, there is an option to diamond for honing, for those not wishing to go that direction. I have recently set up a small honing area away from my main bench and stones. This consists of no more than a granite plate (cheap through Grizzly for example), with strips of PSA silicon carbide 15micron and 5 micron, plus strips of 0.5micron chromium green--all from Lee Valley. See link.
For either 3V or M2, if you come off the grinder with a primary burr, you can go straight to the 5 micron silicon carbide, followed by 0.5micron chromium green. 3V is faster than M2, but both are easy to put on a critically sharp edge, using the mylar-based abrasives. A note: These mylar-based 'micro-abrasives' are very satisfactory for sharpening and do not dub the edge. The sheets are thinner and harder than ordinary sandpaper. No financial interest; I just needed a dry honing area, and these products work well.
The test I use for 'critically sharp'--meaning working sharp--is that I take a single sheet of the L. A. Times newspaper, and want to see the blade slide through the edge of the paper, held at right angles and no sawing or cheating. It should slide through both the side edge and the deckle edge of the paper. The honed blade edge should act like it doesn't even 'see' the paper. The sharpening method above yields this result on 3V and M2 immediately.
Incidentally, I find Ron Hock's O1 to be absolutely outstanding. He described his heat treating recently on these pages, and has standardized on RC62. Konrad Sauer has been using these for a few years as his standard blade for infill planes, and it does excellent edge holding in temperate zone hardwoods, plus it sharpens right up on anyone's sharpening gear.
Steve Elliott, working with Bill Tindall, Phil Smith, and Bruce Thornton (all in East TN) made an excellent small run of CPM 3V irons for both infills and LN4.5, 5.5, and 7 planes. I sure hope that some time in the future, Steve will see fit to make another run of these.
Wiley
Lee Valley--3M Microabrasives for Sharpening