Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

Posts

Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#1

Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

Bill Tindall

It was brought to my attention that there was a post on another Forum regarding this "new" steel for chisels. Apparently someone is selling chisels made from 3V. An owner of some new 3V chisels effused about their edge retention. The usual discussion followed. I suggested that their readers peruse the WoodCentral and Badger Pond archives for useful information on this steel.

Maybe in another 10-20 years it will be rediscovered that for best performance, with ease of sharpening, carbon steel will remain the best choice, and the other choice will be 3V or M4, or similar high vanadium particle steel, if optimum abrasion resistance, toughness and hardness is most important and diamond sharpening is an acceptable price to pay for this attribute. It makes no sense for A2 to be used in woodworking tools other than historical and inertia.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#2

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

David Weaver

I'm sure there used to be some reasonably instructive discussion on there - it's more a social club now with an odd oscillation between selective overmoderation and allowance of trolls. If you disagree with the moderators, you'll eventually be banned (trust me on that).

I recall another well known and accomplished poster on there spinning like a top and exploding a couple of years ago, that most of the content was gone and replaced by repetitive already known discussion (precisely like what you've mentioned) and trolling. He left on his own, though, and did not get banned like I did.

Aside from what gets reposted there from a few posters who also post elsewhere, what you posted is some of the better stuff you can find there. It's not like there's a lack of posting, there's just a lack of useful posting and good contentious discussion between knowledgable posters where people really get down to details without trolling. You can find all sort of futzing that goes by without contest, like a post recently that you will not be able to get shavings less than 0.002" if you lap your own planes and don't send them to a machinist to be ground.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#3

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

No one is reinventing the wheel at WoodNet, and no one is raining on your parade. There is no need for sarcasm. All that happened is that someone is interested in making and selling plane and chisel blades from CPM 3V, and one person he made a chisel for was so impressed that he posted it on the forum. WoodNet is the forum you go to when you want to gloat about tools you bought (rather than tools you made).

As it happens, the same seller/maker has been discussing CPM 3V and D2 with me for over a year. He is just an enthusiastic amateur but he is aware of the research you did. He is not claiming to have "discovered" anything new .... just offering to others. Has anyone else offered CPM 3V in woodworking blades?

My own part was to agree (several months ago) to review/assess the blades, write an article of interest to all. This lies in the future. So I got to thinking about this and had the idea that what most woodworkers would want to know is (1) how difficult are these steels to hone on their existing kit, (2) how easy is it with (the recommended) diamond paste, (3) do you get as good an edge as with the more familiar O1 and A2 steels, and (4) what is the advantage of such steel in both hard and soft woods?

I am aware that Steve Elliott has prepared much of the ground work here - indeed I do not know if there is a lot more to determine outside of demonstrating in real terms the qualitityof wood that may be planed with each steel type. Steve did an amazing job.... as you did in bringing this steel to our attention several years ago. Now why has no one done something about it to date?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#4

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

David Weaver

Better yet, can anyone discuss the virtues of CPM 3V vs the S53 irons that Karl Holtey uses? If I recall reading correctly, Karl was the first to use A2 in tooling.

It'll be interesting to see how the powder metals hold up in irons, and how they fail in irons and chopping applications in chisels.

The one I'm confused about lately is the want for D2 instead of M2. There is a lot of D2 interest, presumably because of how well the RI mortise chisels work, but the stat sheet shows it to be not nearly as wear resistant as M2 (and the wear resistance of M2 vs. A2 and O1 is the entire reason to use it). So, what's the deal with going there when it's already known that M2 makes a good plane iron where the wear resistance of A2 isn't satisfactory. Is D2 cheaper and easier to manufacture than M2?

Why not more commercially available M2 irons in general? So far, the only ones I've found cheaply are a group buy on the .au woodwork forum and presumably something similar in mujingfang planes, but their slot/keyhole upside down from bench planes. They do work extremely well in cocobolo compared to A2, though, at least so far as being able to work without having to take the plane apart to sharpen all the time.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#5

irony or sarcasm?

John in NM

It can be a fine line. No need to chastise though, haven't you ever felt the need to remark on the novelty of coming across someone (or several in this case) who has such exuberance for what you thought was old news?

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#6

Irony is the correct answer

Bill Tindall

Would anyone have mentioned to the Woodnet crowd that there was a wealth of information on the topic of 3V and diamond sharpening on WoodCentral if I hadn't? It would seem that one of the responsibilities we have in life is pointing people to useful information that they could use.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#7

Actually,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

two months ago on Woodnet, I posted a reference to your WoodCentral thread, "Steel for Tools...," from 2003. Although a couple of the principals in today's thread posted after that, I don't think it was widely read. I alerted you to today's thread so you would have the option of straightening out the record - it was evident that there was some information missing and only you and Steve Elliott were capable of providing it.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#8

Re: new information

bugbear

I've got a pre 1900 book where the author recommends filing padsaws to cut on the pull stroke like the saws in the far east, to avoid the blade buckling.

Who says enthusiasm for such notions started in the (19)80's ?!

BugBear

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#9

Re: D2

bugbear

you asked Is D2 cheaper and easier to manufacture than M2?

I can't answer that question, but in the UK, the Ray Iles after-market plane blades are one of the cheapest, and they're D2.

2" blade is 26.50.

Same shop, Hock O1 is 32.50, Clifton is 42.75.

(Different Shop) Smoothcut (or Samurai) Laminated Japanese, 38.00

(all prices GBP)

BugBear

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#10

chosing a steel for woodworking tools

Bill Tindall

I believe that plane irons and chisels require different steel properties. The three properties to be balanced are abrasion resistance, hardness (which correlates with edge deformation) and toughness (which correlates with edge chipping. For chisels that are pounded I don't see that abrasion resistance is of much importance. Compared to a plane iron a chisel just doesn't get pushed through many linear feet of wood. The edge failure mode for a mortise chisel, for example, is either edge crumbling or chipping, not dulling by abrasion. Hence, for a chisel one would select a steel of exceptional toughness so that the tool could be hardened to a high degree while preserving sufficient toughness to resist chipping. I should note that 3V excels among the tool steels in this regard which is why we selected it for chisel fabrication years ago. I remain convinced that 3V will yield the most durable chisels if "most" is the goal fo the fabricator.

The typical failure mode for a plane iron is dulling by abrasion. Adequate toughness and hardness are required, but for this application high abrasion resistance is property to be optimized. While 3V has better abrasion resistance than some steels it is far from the best in this regard. I expect M4 would be the steel of choice for a long lasting plane iron, if cost was no object.

The fabricator has some other steel attributes to consider- cost, ease of fabrication and name recognition. While the cost of the metal in a 1/2" chisel is nearly insignificant, the material cost of a 2 3/8" plane iron is definitely not. High performance steels like M4 and M2 cost many times what carbon steel or A2 costs. Turners have overwhelmingly "voted" that the additional wear resistance is worth the price. So far the flat stock workers have not. Additionally there is the issue of fabrication cost. How difficult is the metal to cut, grind and heat treat? Again there are huge differences among the metals. 3V can be worked with a hack saw and file- not the case with M4. And finally there is name recognition. Until the public equates performance to a steel's name they will not pay a premium for a tool made from a high performance steel. No doubt name recognition is why A2 gets used for chisels, an application where A2's properties are deficient compared to many alternatives.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#11

Re: chosing a steel for woodworking tools

David Weaver

Thanks, Bill and Bugbear. I didn't realize that M2 was significantly more expensive than A2, or maybe thought before that it may be but forgot given that it seems similar to what's in mujingfang irons that are $10.

Maybe getting the initial work done in China is an option to making affordable HSS irons that may not be as high quality as a western made iron, but would still be an improvement over A2 and O1 for planes where abrasion resistance and toughness is desirable (especially jack planes and fore planes).

Never priced it (m2) on mcmaster carr before because I can't harden it in my garage, but just looked it up and see that it's on the order of 4x+ as expensive as O1 there. D2 steel is slightly more than O1, but no prohibitively expensive like the M2 bar stock appears to be.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#12

Re: new information

Stuart Hough

Every day I log on I learn something new. Sometimes I can use it right away, and other times I have to let it percolate for a while. Through it all I get a wealth of knowledge I can access (along with meeting some pretty cool people). Thanx Wood Central, and Ellis for helping me along the journey!

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#13

scott grandstaff

Re: chosing a steel for woodworking tools

scott grandstaff

Over in the knifemaker world, this debate will probably never wind down.

Each new steel attracting fans and critics and ever more and more

exotic/expensive steels.

The American Blademakers Guild, (or something like that) torture tests

steels to the point of failure all the time. I'm pretty sure you have to submit a perfectly good finished knife to be destroyed if you want to join the club.

I once saw a guy making 22,000 layer Damascus.

It gets elaborate. Steel fans and fanciers are an entire subculture.

But then up pops a guy like Len Thompson who is able to lop off a free

hanging hawser rope in the 3" diameter range with one swipe of a knife

made from 1095, often considered too poor a steel to even make a knife

out of at all.

Its all in the skill.

I like plain old O-1 because its cheap and adequate.

I have nothing at all against A-2 or any one of a number of other kinds of

steel, as long as I don't have to pay extra. :)

If I ever become good enough at anything, to "need" a better chisel than Jim Swan made??

I'll just roll over and die, no need to shop.

yours Scott

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#14

Re: chosing a steel for woodworking tools

David Weaver

I'm pretty sure that I'll remain in your camp. I don't understand the knife fetish thing with some folks, and consider 1095 perfectly fine for knives - after all, they are pretty easy to sharpen, and if you make one dull, just get out another one until you get a chance to sharpen them.

O-1 is fine with me, also, but my favorite is plain old hitachi white steel (no specialty super expensive japanese steels, though in my limited experience togo inukubi is nice if you can get it for the same price as white - it seems to sharpen and behave a lot like white steel). I like the way it fails in a plane iron - it fails in a way that still leaves wood shiny with no marks. It's easy to sharpen, especially in a thin lamination attached to wrought iron.

The only thing I keep around for nasties is a mujingfang pull-type jack and a mujingfang smoother, both with HSS irons. They do extremely well in the kind of wood that has shiny things in it that wink at you when you look at it under light.

However, if someone could come up with an iron that is nearly indefinitely sharp but fails the way white steel does (i.e., just wears slowly, no unexpected chips disappearing from the edge), my ears are open. I don't see that happening, though.

HSS irons are nice for their durability, but they don't quite fail extremely finely the way japanese steels do.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#15

M2 availability and footnote on sharpening *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David,

Welcome! You queried M2 availability. Ray Iles of the UK will make M2 irons suitable for infills. He certainly used to, as I have one in an early generation Sauer and Steiner A6, and in an early generation S&S panel plane. Steve Elliott's blade testing showed pretty much a horse race between 3V and M2 (Steve used an Academy Saws M2 iron) as far as edge durability goes. I find the same thing--3V and M2 being comparable--using Ray Iles M2 and Steve Elliott's CPM 3V irons. When using 1/4-micron diamond paste, Steve got essentially the same initial sharpness across all steels tested--O1, A2, CPM 3V, and M2. And it was real sharp.

Some anecdotal experience on sharpening of 3V and M2.....The key to efficient sharpening of either of these steels (IMO) is hollow grinding to the edge, prior to honing. Grind all the way to a primary burr. Once the grinding is done, the usual recommendation for honing is with diamond paste on a cast iron plate. The diamond does work very well. I believe Bill T. is using 1 micron diamond paste. I have used various diamond meshes, down to 1/4micron.

However, there is an option to diamond for honing, for those not wishing to go that direction. I have recently set up a small honing area away from my main bench and stones. This consists of no more than a granite plate (cheap through Grizzly for example), with strips of PSA silicon carbide 15micron and 5 micron, plus strips of 0.5micron chromium green--all from Lee Valley. See link.

For either 3V or M2, if you come off the grinder with a primary burr, you can go straight to the 5 micron silicon carbide, followed by 0.5micron chromium green. 3V is faster than M2, but both are easy to put on a critically sharp edge, using the mylar-based abrasives. A note: These mylar-based 'micro-abrasives' are very satisfactory for sharpening and do not dub the edge. The sheets are thinner and harder than ordinary sandpaper. No financial interest; I just needed a dry honing area, and these products work well.

The test I use for 'critically sharp'--meaning working sharp--is that I take a single sheet of the L. A. Times newspaper, and want to see the blade slide through the edge of the paper, held at right angles and no sawing or cheating. It should slide through both the side edge and the deckle edge of the paper. The honed blade edge should act like it doesn't even 'see' the paper. The sharpening method above yields this result on 3V and M2 immediately.

Incidentally, I find Ron Hock's O1 to be absolutely outstanding. He described his heat treating recently on these pages, and has standardized on RC62. Konrad Sauer has been using these for a few years as his standard blade for infill planes, and it does excellent edge holding in temperate zone hardwoods, plus it sharpens right up on anyone's sharpening gear.

Steve Elliott, working with Bill Tindall, Phil Smith, and Bruce Thornton (all in East TN) made an excellent small run of CPM 3V irons for both infills and LN4.5, 5.5, and 7 planes. I sure hope that some time in the future, Steve will see fit to make another run of these.

Wiley


Lee Valley--3M Microabrasives for Sharpening

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#16

Well stated, Stuart, same for me...... 

Marv

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#17

Re: A2

Thomd

A2 has been in use for a long time. I remember getting some in the early 80s for a rebate plane project. It stalled when I realized I wooul dhave to send it out for heat treating, which wasn't an easy option at the time. I got the stuff as a result of an article in FWW.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#18

Re: CPM v3

Thomd

Looking over the product lit, it seems to yell road drill moreso than chisel. Of course none of our favorite steels were designed for us, so that doesn't really mean much.

I think some knocks on it would be relative to availability, cost, workability and difficulty to heat treat. It does sound like the the ideal tool for a careless apprentice (been reading CS's latest book) Sorta like having a Beismeyer fence on the crew saw - they can't break it. Now that I am closing in on some moulding planes I have to ask myself what steel I want to have to mess with in Ovalo form. I don't think I want to have to set up a lot of complex shapes with really abrasion resistant steels.

http://www.crucible.com/datash/ds3Vv5b.pdf?CFID=886690&CFTOKEN=30896433

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#19

Re: M2 availability and footnote on sharpening

David Weaver

Wiley -

Thanks for that response. That's exactly the kind of information I'm looking for.

Do you recall off the top of your head (subjectively) how the two different irons (M2 vs. CPM 3V) fail? I.e, did one fail with larger chipouts than the others?

I only have the mujingfang hss irons, and I've noticed them to fail and leave (very) small lines in the work, or not quite as much shine as a good high carbon iron - maybe not so much lines, but they stay in that state for a very long time and keep cutting. (this lack of shine is really only noticeable when you're looking across the work into the light)

It'd be great if there was an iron that stayed sharp that long but matched the shine a nice japanese iron leaves.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#20

Re: M2 availability and footnote on sharpening

David Weaver

By the way, I have a lot of hock high carbon irons and think highly of them, too. In the only two infills I've built so far, there are two hock irons (one of them by way of Ron Brese, but I'm pretty sure it's a hock iron).

The iron from Brese has a different feel on the stones, though, a more persistent wire edge. It was advertised as O1, though. I haven't been able to use it long enough yet to get past the very initial edge, so I don't know what its terminal performance will be like. I'm sure it'll be fine.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#21

correct on the silicon carbide

Bill Tindall

It is hard enough to cut the vanadium carbides in M2 or 3V. I have used it myself when I was without diamonds. However, it is a brittle abrasive particle and it will not have the life of diamond. I think it makes more sense to come off the grinder and then to a fine fixed diamond stone next, then the abrasive sheets if you don't have a chunk of cast iron to loading diamonds on.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#22

Re: M2 availability and footnote on sharpening

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

Wish I could help on the failure mode comparison, but I usually don't examine worn edges under magnification unless something feels wrong. Also, both M2 and 3V are on smooth and panel planes, so I sharpen before they begin feeling dull, because it begins to seem like it's just been too long. I don't get the full benefit of the steel's abrasion resistance, because I'd rather sharpen before I notice them dulling.

I use C&W jack and fore planes for roughing--these have O1 irons. Have often wondered if the cambered blades increase edge life by their slicing entry. It seems like it, but I may be imagining.

A purely anecdotal observation comparing freshly sharpened blades, is that my infills leave a nice gloss, but the highest gloss is with the Japanese planes. These are not differences that would survive any kind of finish--they're quite close. My hunch about these differences is that the Japanese plane is attacking at 42-43 degrees, whereas the infills are attacking at 48-50 degrees. The lower cutting angle I think would leave a higher gloss, everything else being equal. Another thought is that on the Japanese plane, the iron is the last thing that touches the wood, whereas the infill has the sole trailing behind--maybe this has some effect. Finally, these results and opinions are anecdotal and reflect only my own methods and abilities--someone else might have opposite results. I don't know whether the Japanese blades 'get sharper' as is frequently said--my newsprint checks do not separate Hitachi steel from O1, A2, 3V, M2. Some other test might well find differences. At one point, Steve Elliott was planning to use his controlled methods to test Japanese irons against the others; this will really be worth our attention if he is able to get the test set up. Because Steve controls for the variance through replicate tests, and in general is a meticulous worker.

One other point on sharpening: I don't like to take Japanese steel to diamond--the steel is too hard in the RC sense for diamond, and if I examine the Japanese blade under magnification after, say, 1 micron diamond, it seems ragged compared to the edge off an 8K stone (which would also be rated in the 1 micron range, I believe).

Wiley

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#23

Re: correct on the silicon carbide

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Bill,

You're right. I should have qualified a little. I was speaking of coming off a Tormek silicon carbide wheel graded to 1000g. With that grinding, I can go straight to 5 micron. I double checked today just to make sure.

However, if I had ground using a high speed grinder, say 60g or even 100g wheel, I would go to either 15 micron silicon carbide paper, or as you recommend, a fine fixed diamond stone of similar mesh. The purpose of my bringing up the paper (actually mylar) idea was to offer an alternative to diamond media, fixed or paste. Trying to eliminate barriers to people using the high-alloy steel, by showing options and alternatives.

Wiley

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#24

Re: M2 availability and footnote on sharpening

wilbur

I was planing the edge of some 8/4 cherry late last week with a Japanese plane, and even though I had it set to take a fairly thick shaving, the finish off the plane was just like as if I had set it to take a 0.001" shaving. Maybe there is something to that "blade is the last thing to touch the wood" thing.

Raney Nelson made an infill with the same overall geometry of a Japanese plane -- blade set back, designed to be pulled. I don't remember if he machined the sole so that the rear of the plane was off the board, like the way a Japanese plane is set up. It would be interesting to see what such a plane would do.

Re: Woodnet discovers CPM 3V, years later

#25

Re: chosing a steel for woodworking tools

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Bill, you wrote, "The edge failure mode for a mortise chisel, for example, is either edge crumbling or chipping, not by abrasion." I must say I can't recall ever seeing a mortise chisel having chipping or crumbling. Frankly, a 35 degree edge, like we use for such chisels, is not vulnerable to these problems. The edge of a mortise chisel gets slowly rounded over.