Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Pissed you off did I, Derek?

Posts

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#76

Re: Comment, request, and news

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Could you post the link of the original show and tell on this plane of yours. I think I saw it and read how you made the knurled screw, but have forgotten. I didn't remember the piece of brass(?) filling the blade slot. From your pics today, I'm curious now how it's involved in clamping the blade to the bed. Finally, today I realized that fitting the bed infill to the bosses and projections of the inner body casting would be a challenge, and I wonder how you dealt with them. I'm guessing it's all in your original post.

Also, I saw you post an approach to layout for forming an overstuffed infill (flush with the outer sides) in the past. I thought it was clever, but now can't remember it. Do you know the link for that, too, perhaps?

Thank you Bob for your encouragement. Keep an eye out on eBay for my forthcoming offerings of retreaded Stanley infills! :D

There are three articles are on my website (link to website below). These are:

"Shopmade Tools":

Making Lever Caps and Lever Cap Screws in the Backyard

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/Making%20Lever%20Caps%20and%20Lever%20Cap%20Screws%20in%20the%20Backyard.html

A Galoot�s Infill Smoother

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/A_Galoots_infill_smoother.html

Essentially, all projections inside the shell were ground out to fit the infill. The blades' slot was filled with brass by filing it fractionally too large, leaving it in the freezer to shrink, and eventually force-fitting with a big hammer. The brass thawed and expanded to create a solid connection.

The third article you refer to was a restoration I made to a Spier smoother. I did not know it was a Spier at the time I purchased it, and this article chronicles the discovery and research on the OldTools List.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolRestorations/Renovating%20an%20Infill%20Smoother1.html

I must say I am very tempted to rebuild the Spier to meet more closely with the original design. I was having a bit of fun because the plane had zilch collector value (all that was original was the shell and the levercap). So it came out a bit OTT.


Nevertheless I did demonstrate making templates to recreate the stuffing for the plane, which is what I think you remember.

Regards from Perth

Derek

p.s. look out for the #4 infill on eBay

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#77

A tangent...

John in NM

>With many antiques, I agree entirely with your viewpoint Stephen, extending it to include many things that I'd categorize as simply "old" rather than antique.

But tools I find more complex. Many people here and on other boards use antique and old hand tools frequently if not every day. Re-sharpening eventually consumes a tool, even when done as conservatively as possible. Modifications are made, either to improve the tool in everyday use, or to apply it to a special purpose. Does it matter when the modification is made? Isn't a modern adaptation part of a tool's history just as a 200 year old adaptation would be?

I consider the justification for adaptions to be in their use. Taking the iron bodied plane and making an infill of it as an example, if it sees use that perhaps inspires further developments, then isn't it just a step in the evolution of how handplanes are designed and used?

I for one appreciate candid observations, even if I don't agree with them. Just like I appreciate blunt and concise descriptions (say, for example "ugly"), even when I tend to write more wordy ones.

I'm also impressed that the ebay plane went so high! I'm not much of an auction watcher, but I didn't expect much over $300.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#78

whats in a name?

John in NM

>"Keep an eye out on eBay for my forthcoming offerings of retreaded Stanley infills! :D"

I suggest you call them the "Huarache Plane".

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#79

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

Charles

>A reasonably respectable list. More than a few toolmakers and they're important for sure but increasingly less so as one gets a kit fully in place.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#80

Well stated.

Marv

>Hi Bob, :)

Being a machinist of sorts I have a pretty good idea what is required to build a tool such as that plane and am not all that surprised that it got bid up as high as it did. Lucky for the maker of the plane there are people who place great value on another person's expertise and innovation. The beauty of the tool is to some extent symbolic of the person who designed and built it. It actually tells a lot about his personality and his skills. We can see and appreciate so much more when we allow our thinking processess to reach beyond what we see. Thinking in those terms, if I could justify spending the money, I would have bid it up even higher.

Of course everyone is intitled to their opinions. However, even opinions can be ugly. Ugly is in the eye of the beholder. It's interesting how some of us will view a painting by a famous painter, for example and find it ugly while someone else will see beauty in it and pay a huge amount of money for it. I have experienced this first hand and have questioned the person who saw the beauty in something I thought was ugly. Once they explained why they felt it was beautiful, it didn't seem ugly to me. I was able to see the beauty through the other person's eyes and how their thought processes. I learned something. From then on I was able to see beauty in things I would have otherwise thought ugly. Everything is much more than what we see.

Marv

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#81

Re: The expertise continuum

Charles

>Its simple: An expert can produce works such as those seen at the New Hampshire Furniture Masters site and do it in commercially feasible timeframes.

For an example of a bona fide "expert", a professional furniture maker, please check out David Lamb's website:

http://www.davidlambfurniture.com/flash/davidLamb.html

He's also a member of the NH Furniture Masters Assn.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#82

Time Out, Folks!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>There have been some good elements to this discussion, and some good ideas put forward.

Remember: it's fine to put your ideas forward. It's fine to lay out why you think someone else's ideas are wrong or incomplete. It's fine to disagree. Out of conflicting ideas comes a higher truth (thanks, Hegel).

What's not fine is name calling or personal attacks, and there has been some of that here. We moderators have had to intervene a couple of times.

Please, before you click on the "post" button, take a deep, calming breath; look back over your text and ask yourself if you've stayed focused on the idea(s) or if you've let your emotions move you to personal attacks or insults; delete what you need to before posting.

If it's late, or you're otherwise tired, and you're not so sure about what you said, don't post it. If you've spent time writing out your ideas and hate to lose your work, copy the text and save it somewhere on your computer; then, when you're feeling brighter, you can review, edit, and post.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#83

Re: The expertise continuum

Charles

>I'm hesitant to hang the term 'expert' on somebody whose only recommendation is that they happen to know more than me about some particular subject.

If we were lucky enough to have a David Lamb visit the forum we might enjoy hearing him speak about relatively mundane tasks like maintaining edges but in a much different context, I think, than most of us are able to discuss it.

I'm not particularly a fan of taking minutiae out of context and inflating it to an area of expertise when in the hands of a bona fide expert it's merely the mundane.

The danger is just that - losing the context in which these things out to be considered. [remainder edited. WH]

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#84

The thread is git'n a bit long in the tooth:D

Marv

>

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#85

Cause it looks like a foot in a shoe/sandle?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Kind of a cool intrepretation. BTW, Derek, I don't think your planes are ugly either; but I think I said that at the time, back in the day....

Pam

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#86

Email them?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>This is the most ridiculous thing I've heard in a long, long time. If these "experts" wanted to talk to us, they'd be here talking. You've just suggested that people who don't even know these other people waste their time in a huge way.

As a woman, I tend to denigrate the term "expertise," which is bestowed by the press, who are informed by some other "expert," who almost always were men (not so true today, but not far off either). For example, all the Rhodes scholars only had to compete with half the population for the honor. Guess what I think of their qualifications.

OTOH, I really enjoy watching those who are very good at what they do, my preferable description for your "experts." I truly appreciate their work and learn a lot from it.

You may find a few more "experts" at SAPFM, at least there are several such as Jeff Headley and Al Breed and others too numerous to mention. Now their participation there is related to building/restoring very old masterpieces, but their work habits and tactics are applicable to most any woodwork.

Pam

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#87

Re: Email them?

Charles

>Sorry you think it's ridiculous. I've found it to be anything but.

[edit by moderator]

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#88

Re: Email them?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>In October, 2002, I demonstrated my pole lathe at Landis Valley Farm Museum here in Lancaster County. The next week I got a call from the museum saying that some woman from Austin, Texas wanted my email address. I did not have an email address then, but encouraged them to give my phone number.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#89

Funny. Well, it wasn't I. Hope you made a sale.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#90

Re: Email them?

Charles

>I don't care for the term 'expert' when it clearly doesn't apply. The links I provided are to 'experts' - master craftspeople beyond a doubt. I would have included Kristina Madsen in the links but at last check she didn't have a website.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#91

Re: Email them?

Charles

>I would classify as 'expert' the following craftspeople. You be the judge if I'm off-base about that:

Maura Macaluso

Barbara Howell

Florence Webb

Janet Collins

JoAnn Schuch

Caz Foster

Kristina Madsen

.... the list goes on and on.......

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#92

Re: Email them?

Charles

>Check out New Leaf Furnituremakers from the U.K. too.....

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#93

Re: Email them?

Charles

>Here are some more experts whose work you might be interested in becoming familiar with:

http://www.newleaffurniture.co.uk/html/gallery.htm

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#94

Re: Tact

ThomD

>I think tact is mostly about the how not the what is said. Particularly if one is a wordsmith, one ought to be able to write or speak one's way around the dual objective of incisive comments and accurate characterizations.

One thing is that often there is an exchange missing. Someone puts up a pic and asks what we think about it. There is often a huge lack of context, and then to boot someone else may already have answered along certain lines. It seems too late to verify what kind of response the OP is looking for. "A" asks a question, "B" answers it saying "nice". As "C" it is too late to ask, "so what kind of feedback did you want", and possibly the comment that flows is that C thinks it's awful.

The net in funny, because I am a very considerate person, and yet there is something about the internet where I let my guard down and say something harsh every so often just slips out. The fact a person is not actually present may be part of it. Even though there is a person somewhere out there. And one knows all of this and has been through it thousands of times.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#95

Re: Email them?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Certainly some excellent work (good idea to hit the Women in Woodworking list), and, as you say, there are thousands more doing such quality work. Experts? I don't even know how someone qualifies as a woodworking expert, nor if it's even possible to master all aspects of such a wide ranging craft/art.

But I also still say that it's not really polite to email/call these people and ask for help. They are probably very busy. I think the only valid reason to contact them is to inquire about purchasing a piece (gallery owners, too), attending a class, or setting up a class and you're asking them to teach it. Anything else would be intrusive. Now I'd expect them to be polite if I were to contact them, but that doesn't mean they can afford or appreciate the interruption.

Pam

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#96

Re: Email them?

Charles

>Suit yourself, love. Your loss not mine.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#97

Re: Email them?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I don't see it as a loss, but as a consideration of another person's time constraints. I was one of those "experts" in another industry and I freely offered help within the context of various forums; but there was no way I'd have appreciated a call or email asking for free help. I got those all the time and I had to tell the contact that if s/he would post the question in the public forum I'd certainly help, but not privately without dollars changing hands. The reason? My help would have been noticed, a very good marketing device; others could contribute, often answering the question; and all would see the answer.

It's really not an issue of access or desire, it's purely an issue of time and how I have to choose how to spend it.

Pam

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#98

Agree for the most part.......

Marv

>Pam,

I agree with you for the most part, however, it's a subject that can be discussed in general terms. I get questions from people quite often about how I do my saws. When I have the time to spare and am in a generous mood, I will give some detailed answers to questions from people who seem to think less effort is involved than there actually is. It's not really their fault, they just aren't aware. Many times the person will hire my services, I think, because I took the time to help them or inform them about their concerns.

Now, if I were in the business of making my living at working saws, I have to agree with you totally.

Marv

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#99

Re: Email them?

Sgian Dubh

>Pam, I must admit I find people that email me off-forum(s) with questions can sometimes be difficult to handle. I nearly always feel obliged out of politeness to respond to them, but I don't always do so. It's the questions that really need an hour or three to research and prepare a nuanced, comprehensive illustrated and balanced response that I usually either bat back or simply delete from my inbox.

I always feel a bit guilty about it when I do that, but I just don't have enough time in the day to for that sort of thing, and I do wish that the questioner hadn't thought to ask me a question that doesn't have a simple one line answer, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#100

Re: Email them?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>:) Big laugh. I always felt a little less than giving, but I had a partner and employees to answer to. If I wasted time and didn't do what I had to, they'd be out of their jobs. And Jack and I were partial to our house.

Pam