No gold stars
Dean Lapinel
>Pam,
You and I call a spade a spade so naturally we would rarely give out gold stars 
Dean
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
No gold stars
Dean Lapinel
>Pam,
You and I call a spade a spade so naturally we would rarely give out gold stars 
Dean
Re: Please critique this..be honest now...
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Marv,
Congratulations on a good job!! I particularly like the faux-primitive look. None of the fussiness of those over-elaborate 1910 handles, though it hints at elegance with those understated but distinct upper and lower horns.
Great job!
Wiley
Yahbut...
Bob Hackett
>Can you type that with a straight face?
MB
Re: Here's how I see it.
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>Yeah, OTOH, nothing wrong, IMO, with being abraded from time to time, again, if deserved. This is what spurs me on to bigger and better work, but so discourages some that they never pick up the work again. I could just as easily dismiss the latter as the reaction of those who really have nothing to say as condemn the critic for dismissing a very sensitive worker who could, maybe, do great work.
In this case I think it's important that Derek's first reaction was "not pretty." That's very important if the maker takes it as inspiration and would prefer that people like his/her work on first sight. I had that reaction on looking at the handle, all those round brass pins, presumably for holding the three piece handle together, as if the maker had got in over his/her head with the center brass part. So a better criticism would have been if the critic had noted the handle and then suggested other ways around the problem.
I found the body not very appealing, but it appears that was a result of the maker trying to define/continue lines with screws, something of an all too pervasive desire for symmetry. I expect some may like it.
All in all, I think the maker needs to gain more knowledge of his/her materials and how his/her aesthetics affects others.
However, it's important to remember that we didn't ask the plane maker to show us the plane, s/he put it on ebay complete with a fancy box hinting that it's one of the first in a new line of planes. Therefore, it's fair game for whatever arises.
Pam
We do so like receiving them, though.
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Re: Please critique this..be honest now...
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>Just hitting the reply button has already taken more time than it's worth, aesthetically and monetarily. A child's saw?
Pam
Thanks for your honesty.
Marv
>Pam,
I'm not sure what it is. I have a folder with a collection of "interesting" saw handles that I have collected while scrolling eBay saw auctions. I named the folder "Wierd assed handles".
Marv
That was the funniest thing I've read all week!
wilbur
Easy . . .
steve mackay
>Somebody (out on the prarie ?) needed a saw REAL BAD and couldn't wait or didn't have the bucks. Asthetics were the last thing on his mind. I'll bet this one finnished that barn though.
Re: You have to scroll down a bit, and, of course,
Marv
>Finally had to go see what you guys have been posting about.
I like the plane. Consider all the skills required to produce such a tool. Thats a lot of what the plane represents. That tote is made like a highend knife handle. A typical method of attaching wood to metal for that particular purpose.
Maybe it's just me, but I like it when someone jumps out of the proverbial box and does it a little differently.
Marv
At any rate, your post made a very fine point.
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
A child`s saw?
Bob Hackett
>I can`t help but wonder what the poor dear did to deserve that type of punishment.
Did the little fellow accidentally take an axe to your Stradivarius?;^)
MB
Critiquing
Bill Houghton
>Any art teacher can tell you that critiques are a critical part of art learning - and that students need to learn how to do them, which is itself a critical part of art learning. In a good critique, the students making observations about what works/fails in someone's work are learning as much in the process of making those observations as the student whose work is being critiqued is learning by hearing the critique.
I agree with Dan - a critique should be like any academic argument (a term with a specific meaning in the academic context): "I think this works because of a, b, and c; I think that doesn't because of x, y, and z [exact number of reasons obviously case-dependent]."
If it's worth doing, it's worth doing badly
Bill Houghton
>I agree with Steve Mackay: the handle was made by someone who needed to get a job "out the door." It's got all the basics: a hole for the fingers, top and bottom horns to orient the hand, and screws to hold it on. It wouldn't be very comfortable in the long run, but if your belongings are getting dripped on because the roof leaks, or the pigs keep escaping because the pen needs repair, comfort in sawing may not be a high priority.
Re: A child`s saw?
Marv
>Bob
I didn't want to admit it at first. I wanted to wait for some honest critiguing from a few of you before fessing up to having made the handle myself. After countless attempts at making saw handles I think I at least have the hang just right. I do like the darker color wood, don't you?
Wiley's comments inspires me to continue the pursuit of excellence. 
Pam's comments however, instill doubts. But considering what we said earlier about present day saw makers, no matter how hard they try, just can't please everyone.
Marv
That turnip truck in the distance...
Bob Hackett
>is NOT the one I fell off of Marv.
I know that is not one of your handles.
The reason I know is because there`s no wheat carving on it.
I DO get up pretty early you know!
The woodstove door creaks when the wife loads it before sunrise every morning.That and those big logs clunking around wake me up every time.
MB
What you say is very true, however,
Marv
>The person who made the plane is not here to read our critiques and cannot benifit one way or the other from them. So what it boils down to is, our critiquing is basically our opinions on someone elses efforts that to me appear to be her/his best. Most of the opinions are coming from people who probably don't have the skills to build such a tool. We are all entitled to our opinions, but in order to "critique" we need to possess at least some of the skills that the maker of the plane obviously has.
Marv
Re: What you say is very true, however,
Dan Donaldson
>Not sure I totally agree. Part of a critique could be just "that I, personally , do not care for it." I see art that I like, and other that I do not. I do not, however have the skills to make even the ones that I do not like. I Look at some of the awesome work done here. I can appreciate the skills that went into it without particularly liking the piece if I had to live with it. I wouldn't have the imagination to create a lot of the stuff I see here, but most times I can articulate what I like or do not like about it, even if I couldn't design it.
Re: A child`s saw?
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>I don't think it would be total punishment for a child, certainly didn't see it as punishment, really was commenting on the small finger opening.
Pam
After all that...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
>You Finally figure out what's going on? Marv...
Critiques
Bob Hackett
>IME a successful critique requires that the person giving the critique be willing and able to articulate ways to improve the work and hopefully the maker`s way of looking at or thinking about that work.
The point of any critique should be growth.
MB
Some are just fashionably late!
John in NM
Agree somewhat...
John in NM
>I'm not sure I like it per se, but it certainly took some skill to make. I do like the brass lamination in the tote, that's a very good idea, and while the shape is visually appealing, I keep thinking its not likely to be comfortable in use. I may be wrong about that, but I tend to favor fatter totes for comfort in long sessions.
What I really don't understand is the walnut infill.... why put an infill under a rigidly fixed frog plate?
Cap screws don't bother me a bit, I like them. I went to a lot of trouble to get 2" button head cap screws for some grips I make, rather than using a socket head or worse yet, phillips. Screw heads can be an appealing detail.
I also like the pins. That's a good alternative to dovetailing. I'd like to see that on a traditional infill too.
Woodworkers are often aesthetically conservative, hand tool woodworkers especially so. I think on the whole I do like this plane, but I don't know as I'd own it. I often feel the same about stuff Bridge City comes up with. As usual, I can appreciate both sides of the recent flap, though I don't wish to see it continue so I'm going to keep any other observations about that to myself.
Re: What you say is very true, however,
Marv
>Hi Dan,
I was responding to Bill's post, mainly to his analogy of an art teacher critiquing an art student's work. The teacher is qualified to critique the student because the teacher has the skills to do what he is teaching. The teacher is helping the student learn the basics that allows her/him to produce something unique. Critiquing is a tool that is used to teach skills that the teacher possesses.
Merely liking or disliking something, in my opinion, isn't critiquing or teaching, it's one's personal opinion.
Critiquing is meant to be constructive or instructive. The word critique is a close relative to criticize. Criticizing may or may not be instructive, depending on the person being criticized and how they deal with criticism. Criticism usually carries a negative connotation while critiquing doesn't or shouldn't.
When Derek used the word "hideous" he was offering his opinion, not teaching or instructing. It was as if he was voicing his opinion on a painting he didn't like. It's a personal thing. I don't think he needs to apologize for his opinions. Perhaps we don't like his choice of words, but that's our opinion.
Marv
Critiquing in a classroom setting
Bill Houghton
>It's not an uncommon practice in university art classes for the entire class to critique a piece. The teacher does, indeed, have to lead the students in the practice - it's not easy to do well.