Re: I probably should keep my mouth shut...
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>The planes that Derek posted are ugly as well (sorry Derek), again my opinion, which I feel everyone is entitled to.

Hi Stephen
I designed that first one (the bevel down) in 2002 as an experiment in design and what could be done with a Stanley shell. At that time I was not even aware that anyone else had attempted this. At it turned out, just one other Stanley infill had been built, based on a #4 1/2 I think, and it used the frog of the Stanley, so it was really a semi-infill.
But I agree with you - that plane is Ugly to me now. However Beauty .. or Ugly ... lies in the eye of the beholder. Some loved the design enough to copy it. I look back and I squirm.... but I put it out there for critique ... now harm no foul.
Now the BU Stanley smoother was really ugly. I built it but it did not turn out the way I would have liked. Somewhere along the line it lost the curves I enjoy and developed these angles. Here is the first version, the MkI

But beauty is skin deep. This is a startlingly fine smoother, one of the very best I have used. Really.

Why? Well it was an experiment in bed angles. As far as I am aware, this is the first BU smoother with a 25 degree bed. Most BU planes have 12 degree beds.
There were two reasons for choosing this angle as part of the design. Firstly, wanted a high cutting angle (60 degrees) and I did not want to hone a secondary bevel to get there as I prefer freehand sharpening and would prefer not to use a honing guide. A 25 degree bed means that I can get the 60 degree included angle with a 35 degree hollow grind. This is proably the highest angle I would want to use when freehanding a (fine) camber on a blade. The second reason for the high bed angle was that I was curious to see whether a higher bed would alter the way a wear bevel is postulated to affect the performance of a BU plane (which, I must add, I have not experienced in the way the opponents of BU planes proclaim).
So it turned out to be an Ugly Duckling ... but a reliably excellent smoother. Still, I hated the looks and, after about two years, I decided to modify it (there's that compulsive modifier again!).
I altered the shape of the front infill ... now much more comfortable .... and I added a wedge-handgrip for comfort ... again much more comfortable. And I added side set screws to lock the blade to add ease when returning the plane to the desired setup afterthe blade is removed for sharpening. So we ended up with this ...


(The Philips head machine screws has since been replaced with a slotted style).
Now I quite like the looks but I still don't think that it will wow everyone, and it doesn't phase me one iota that you hate its looks. I really do not expect to please everyone. All I do ask, when I post something, is that the critic offer a reason for their remarks. In that way I can learn something new. I do appreciate your cander .. no harm no foul.
Regards from Perth
Derek