Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Pissed you off did I, Derek?

Posts

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#51

Even the Army does critiques

Bob Hackett

>After every training rotation or event there was what was called an AAR or After Action Review.The AAR was a mandatory attendance thing for all who participated in training and everyone was called on in turn.

When your turn came you were expected to provide examples of what you felt went well(written under the "sustain" heading) and what needed more instruction and/or training(under the "improve" heading).You were also expected to be able to explain why you felt as you did.Everyone from the captain to the private had their say and their comments were written down and reviewed equally by headquarters with the emphasis on improving training and keeping everyone engaged in training.

When done well the AAR led to real improvements in training and new approaches from some seemingly unlikely sources.

When allowed to get out of hand or if run by someone who just wanted to punch the ticket and get thru quickly they could turn into real fiascos with alot of resentment and animosity.

MB

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#52

Tact

Dan in NorCal ------WebKitFormBoundary1tz8esJg0Lrw

>It is evident from your posts on this thread that you value freedom of expression over the effects of poorly chosen words on others. This is certainly our right in this great country we live in, but does not mean it is the right thing to do. With a little tact and civility, one can achieve both and may even find happiness doing so.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#53

Re: Tact

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Actually, I practice tact in every interaction I undertake, especially in writing classes. I'd much prefer that people avoid tact when critiquing my work, as you just have. And as I have not.

That said, sometimes tact is very harmful - to the maker being critiqued, the critic, and to everyone else involved. Let's say an architect designs a bridge that looks dangerous. Would you prefer tact? I wouldn't? Let's say you're an art critic advising a potential buyer? Tact? I'd say not. Let's say you're the artist selling that work. Tact? Probably both good and bad; but as an artist I'd rather not embarrass myself when I decide to try to sell it.

Some times it's far superior to call a spade a spade, for everyone.

More on your critique of me: Did you read my critique of the plane yet? If not, please read it before commenting. What is your critique of the plane? Or is this just an opportunity to jump on an uppity woman?

Why don't you explain precisely what is untactful about either of my two preceding messages? I thought they were paragons of tact and a reasoned argument.

Pam, a Barbara Ehernbach (sp?) fan

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#54

Re: Tact

Bob Hackett

>If you stand Pam`s comments next to Woodburnbob`s comments(some no longer viewable) then IMO she is being very tactful.

Then again,this is coming from a heavily tattooed former Drill Sgt.

One thing about dealing with people like Pam and Todd H.,you don`t need guesswork or an interpreter.

"This is the cow,this is the cabbage,chomp,chomp.Any questions ?".

MB

For those who may be confused or unable to fully understand the humor I`m trying to convey here it would appear(to me at least) that I am on Pam`s side on this one.(surprise!)

More and more I find myself listening to conversations between people who object to a word or a tone or any number of things real or imagined who are missing the message completely.It`s like every interaction is an essay paper being graded on grammar,spelling and punctuation while completely disregarding the story.

What ever happened to separating the wheat from the chaff and looking for something you can use instead of being critical of the mechanics in the Nth degree?

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#55

Thank you, Bob.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#56

What?

Dean Lapinel

>"value freedom of expression over the effects of poorly chosen words on others."

Pam does value freedom of expression and does it well. I don't agree with some of her thoughts (about tools) but I respect and read them. Pam doesn't beat around the bush and I value that.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#57

Stephen Shepherd

I probably should keep my mouth shut...

Stephen Shepherd

>however, I am not very good at that.

Disclaimer: I am not an advocate of metal planes; they are heavy, cold to the touch in the winter, dents your work if you drop it on your wood and you can only drop them once on a hard floor. I like the feel of wooden planes, better center of gravity, warm in the winter, doesn't dent your work if you drop it and it can take repeated trips to the floor with little or no damage.

I appreciate the work that goes into those traditional metal 'infill' planes but I would never own one. And I think that the current trend of stuffing Stanley style old planes, turning them into infills is not a good idea, they don't make any of those old planes any more.

This plane in question that brought up this thread is ugly in my opinion.

The planes that Derek posted are ugly as well (sorry Derek), again my opinion, which I feel everyone is entitled to.

Stephen

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#58

So there. 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#59

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

Charles

>I think the term "woodworking expert" is bandied about much too freely.

The incredibly talented makers found at the following site are woodworking "experts." Strangely enough, I don't think any of them are regulars on any woodworking forums of which I am aware. Building masterpieces must be its own reward.

Enjoy:

http://www.furnituremasters.org/

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#60

The expertise continuum

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I certainly concur that the makers shown on that website are experts, and that there is a level in any trade and particularly in any highly skilled endeavor (furniture-making, music, etc.) at which one is demonstrably an authority on the trade/endeavor/subject.

But there is also a continuum of expertise. If you know more than I do, I can learn from you, and that differential needs respect. Granted, that way could lie lots of disasters - we must be skeptical of our teachers and learn to apply our best judgment as to the quality of the information received, but that's always been true anyway. I don't think there's a magic point at which someone is An Expert and anyone who hasn't reached that point of knowledge is A Dummy.

Derek's accomplished work makes my limited output look as pitiful as it is, and I have learned a good deal from his open discussion of how he's solved design and construction problems - as I have learned from many others here. Derek didn't claim himself as an expert, and Woodburn Bob didn't call him that, as best I can tell - merely stated that he has developed a role and reputation online as someone with sound judgment and a respectable body of work.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#61

Experts?

Bob Hackett

>What would be the criteria for being an expert and who would administer and grade the test?

Will we have experts in specialized areas of wood working or do you need to demonstrate skills in all areas in order to be an expert?

Will an expert be judged on his work alone or by his ability to demonstrate a set of skills to standard?

If judged by demo to standard will there be a time limit?

If judged by work alone will the maker be held responsible for all aspects of the work being judged including selecting and felling the trees,milling and seasoning of the timber,fabrication of any hardware,formulation and application of finishing material and complete manufacture of any other non-wood parts and pieces included in the work to include adhesives if used?

If judged by work alone will the criteria include original design, durability,functionality,visual appeal or other specified areas?if a combination then what percentage is allowed for each category and how will the total score be arrived at?

I trust you understand my point.

As stated before,to me an expert is anyone who has demonstrated the skills I may need in order to either successfully complete a project or improve my skill level.I seek out advise and guidance from this person because I have reason to believe they know more about the subject than I do.Once I have their guidance it is still up to me to weigh that information and determine if it can be incorporated into the way I choose to work.

I have yet to meet a single craftsman who is expert in all aspects of woodworking.I wonder if that is even possible.

I do know that I can come here and get sound advise from people who are experts at the way they approach the particular things they do.Together we have not failed to supply one or more real world solutions for any obstacle or problem so far.For me that`s about as good as you can ever hope for.

Potentially we are all experts waiting for the right question to come along.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#62

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>"Strangely enough, I don't think any of them are regulars on any woodworking forums of which I am aware."

Holy cow, man, you're just not paying enough attention.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#63

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

Charles

>I'd love to know where Lamb, Osgood, Terry Moore, et al. regularly hang out.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#64

Re: The expertise continuum

Charles

>Whenever you have problems making the distinction between truly expert furnituremaking and the ankle-biters of the world, Google the following:

David Lamb;

Ted Blachly;

Jere Osgood;

Terry Moore;

William Thomas;

John Cameron;

Your rather egalitarian view of 'expertise' doesn't build the community up as much as it tears down those who have achieved status in the field.

Continuum, schminuum.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#65

Re: I probably should keep my mouth shut...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>The planes that Derek posted are ugly as well (sorry Derek), again my opinion, which I feel everyone is entitled to.

:D :D :D

Hi Stephen

I designed that first one (the bevel down) in 2002 as an experiment in design and what could be done with a Stanley shell. At that time I was not even aware that anyone else had attempted this. At it turned out, just one other Stanley infill had been built, based on a #4 1/2 I think, and it used the frog of the Stanley, so it was really a semi-infill.

But I agree with you - that plane is Ugly to me now. However Beauty .. or Ugly ... lies in the eye of the beholder. Some loved the design enough to copy it. I look back and I squirm.... but I put it out there for critique ... now harm no foul.

Now the BU Stanley smoother was really ugly. I built it but it did not turn out the way I would have liked. Somewhere along the line it lost the curves I enjoy and developed these angles. Here is the first version, the MkI


But beauty is skin deep. This is a startlingly fine smoother, one of the very best I have used. Really.


Why? Well it was an experiment in bed angles. As far as I am aware, this is the first BU smoother with a 25 degree bed. Most BU planes have 12 degree beds.

There were two reasons for choosing this angle as part of the design. Firstly, wanted a high cutting angle (60 degrees) and I did not want to hone a secondary bevel to get there as I prefer freehand sharpening and would prefer not to use a honing guide. A 25 degree bed means that I can get the 60 degree included angle with a 35 degree hollow grind. This is proably the highest angle I would want to use when freehanding a (fine) camber on a blade. The second reason for the high bed angle was that I was curious to see whether a higher bed would alter the way a wear bevel is postulated to affect the performance of a BU plane (which, I must add, I have not experienced in the way the opponents of BU planes proclaim).

So it turned out to be an Ugly Duckling ... but a reliably excellent smoother. Still, I hated the looks and, after about two years, I decided to modify it (there's that compulsive modifier again!).

I altered the shape of the front infill ... now much more comfortable .... and I added a wedge-handgrip for comfort ... again much more comfortable. And I added side set screws to lock the blade to add ease when returning the plane to the desired setup afterthe blade is removed for sharpening. So we ended up with this ...



(The Philips head machine screws has since been replaced with a slotted style).

Now I quite like the looks but I still don't think that it will wow everyone, and it doesn't phase me one iota that you hate its looks. I really do not expect to please everyone. All I do ask, when I post something, is that the critic offer a reason for their remarks. In that way I can learn something new. I do appreciate your cander .. no harm no foul.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#66

Re: Experts?

Charles

>Kind of like learning to play golf from a kid who regularly shoots 65. On the Tiger Woods golf video game.

It seems to me that you're letting the internet shrink your world instead of expanding it.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#67

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I don't know where "Lamb, Osgood, Terry Moore, et al" hang out, but occasional posters here include Michael Dresdner, David Marks, Larry Williams, Adam Cherubini, Don McConnell, Wayne Anderson and others, and if you check the other forums like SAPFM you will see woodworkers whose work is world-class.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#68

Re: The expertise continuum

Dan Donaldson

>You said:"Your rather egalitarian view of 'expertise' doesn't build the community up as much as it tears down those who have achieved status in the field. "

I think that I would at least partially disagree. Those may be experts, but as you say, they do not participate in forums, which means that they basically do not pass on their expertise to others. They do beautiful work, but what do they contribute to the community? (Now I grant that there may be many reasons, but still....) Perhaps many of us here do not reach those heights (I know I sure do not), but there are those that are in that realm and they try to show others how to get there.. I have more respect for those willing to share.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#69

Re: Experts?

Dan Donaldson

>Again, I would disagree. Other than looking at the work of those you cite, what do they do to try to help others? Looks like nothing. There are those that participate on this board that I feel are every bit as good at woodworking and design, but spend time trying to help others reach the same goals. I see the comment about video games as rather insulting to those that have real expertise here. What you are saying is that no one here has any level of expertise relative to the list you posted, but I would disagree with that. You are also implying that unless you are an acknowledged master in the field, you have nothing to offer a beginner.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#70

Re: The expertise continuum

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I don't think it has to be either/or.

I have admired the work of many highly accomplished furniture makers, including some whose names did not survive their work. They, and their work, can teach any of us a great deal.

I have also learned from people who knew more than I did. They may not be "experts" as you understand this word, but they have nevertheless had knowledge I didn't and were able to share it with me, either directly or through my observation of completed work.

My biggest disappointment with Fine Woodworking in recent years is that it stopped showcasing work that's way, way over my competence. I need that goal, even if I never reach it. But, realistically, we all learn incrementally - no one goes from zero to mastery in 60 seconds - and if someone's farther along the increments than I, I'm thrilled if s/he will share that knowledge with me.

There are hazards in this, of course: someone who's only a little more knowledgeable than I am may think s/he knows more than s/he in fact does, or have poor habits. But every article I've ever read about Sam Maloof's working style pointed out that he used terribly unsafe habits at the bandsaw, so learning how to use a bandsaw from him might not have been the best schooling on that particular subject. We all need to apply judgment to information received.

If you're going to learn to maintain your own car, it's useful having your neighbor down the street teach you how to change the oil and check tire pressures, even if s/he would never make it as a full-time mechanic; and better to learn those skills than to wait for someone who may never show up to teach it all to you from 40 years of experience wrenching on cars.

Incidentally, I don't see my perspective as "egalitarian," although we may have somewhat different connotations for that word. But I do see a role for people who are not full-time professional workers but who have acquired knowledge and skills and are willing to share what they've learned.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#71

Re: Experts?

Charles

>My posts in this thread are about the casual use of the word "expert."

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#72

Nothing wrong with tradition

Dean Lapinel

>Stephen,

I do like some of the modern tools especially Bill Carters but I completely understand your position on an era where woodworking was beautiful (form fuction & design) yet I suspect underappreciated.

I think of the countless planemakers and craftsman that "just worked" but would be icons if they lived today.

Do you like the work of Clark & Williams (I do)?

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#73

Techniques for gathering information

Bob Hackett

>Charles,

I am aware of many of the names you point to and am also familiar with their work,some of it I have seen in person.Books and the small screen are not the only places I look to in order to expand my understanding and appreciation of the craft.

How many of those big names are accessable to us rank and file WWers?

How many will take the time to walk me thru sharpening in a quick, clean,simple and straight forward approach for free like Bill Tindal did?

How many can I contact that will listen and explain in detail the mechanics of saws and sawing outside a high dollar classroom like Marv has?

How many are willing to invest the time and effort to put together step by step instruction complete with pics for zero money and still be humble enough to ask for input from all comers like Derek?

How many can bring to the table years of experience in such diverse areas as blacksmithing,book binding,boat building,tool making,goldsmithing and a host of other seemingly unrelated skills that overlap and advance the craft?

I think it may be you are putting too much faith in the media and the recognition it hands out to those they`ve placed at the top.

For every big name like those on your list there are hundreds if not thousands more who are members here and in WWing clubs and guilds who`s work and mastery of the craft is every bit as impressive yet you never see their names in print outside a newsletter or a website.Folks who,if you knock on their door,will share everything including an entire day for nothing more than the joy of fellowship.Some will even make coffee and lunch for you if you stay long enough.

Some are content to read about those they feel are at the top or look at their work.Others find it more enjoyable to seek out local experts and work along side them and maybe build a relationship with them as they see first hand how they approach their work.Others come to places like this to discuss things with like minded highly talented people willing to share what they know.All are valid approaches and if they work for us then mine are no more or less valid than yours.

It was never my intent to discount the body of work that represents the top makers or to imply that they are not experts in their chosen areas.Rather it WAS my intent to get others to maybe look to less famous(yet just as competent) local experts(including those here)who are more accessable,approachable,and more than willing to help.

One very valid point I have learned from craftsmen who thought and talked about both their craft and things outside it is that the person who sweeps the floor has something to teach if you ask the right questions and are willing to truly listen with an open mind.

MB

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#74

Re: Techniques for gathering information

Charles

>They are more accessible than you might think.

Email one of them a serious woodworking question and find out.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#75

Comment, request, and news

WoodburnBob

>Nice looking plane, both versions, Derek. I favor the second version, too. Great use of an old cast iron body and an impressive effort to bring ideas and questions from a state of musings into a handsome, useful reality. That's what I say, anyway. Oh. Not ugly in the slightest to me. Quite the opposite. Handsome and stout-looking. Looks like something a journeyman might make for himself. And, really great pics.

On another matter:

Could you post the link of the original show and tell on this plane of yours. I think I saw it and read how you made the knurled screw, but have forgotten. I didn't remember the piece of brass(?) filling the blade slot. From your pics today, I'm curious now how it's involved in clamping the blade to the bed. Finally, today I realized that fitting the bed infill to the bosses and projections of the inner body casting would be a challenge, and I wonder how you dealt with them. I'm guessing it's all in your original post.

Also, I saw you post an approach to layout for forming an overstuffed infill (flush with the outer sides) in the past. I thought it was clever, but now can't remember it. Do you know the link for that, too, perhaps?

News update:

Incidentally, the Ebay plane that originally started the thread closed with 40 plus bidders at $835. I wouldn't have imagined that. Perhaps it casts a new light on what some might call your own "ugly" efforts, Derek.

[Just to be clear: No, I don't think Derek's efforts are ugly. I'm using mild sarcasm and mockery to say that, ironically, the tools Derek is making for himself may have an even greater monetary value in the marketplace than he might imagine, and for him to ignore breezy comments about them being ugly, defective or worthless...which I'm sure he does anyway.]

{Some editing by moderator}