Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Pissed you off did I, Derek?

Posts

Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#1

Pissed you off did I, Derek?

WoodburnBob

>"I must apologise [sic] if I sounded a little strong in my earlier post. As I said, beauty is in the eyes of the beholder. However if you desire a critique ..."



You didn't sound "a little strong" calling someone's work hideous, you sounded careless, thoughtless and mean-spirited behind someone's back. Your apology now seems disingenuous, given the new 'damning with faint praise' critique you assembled to accompany your apology.

How do you know the planemaker isn't in the audience? Would you offer the same attitude and words to him/her directly?

I didn't "desire a critique" from you on this plane in this thread, or anything else. Just the opposite. I wish you'd take it somewhere else. Who did you think desired more critique from you on this plane? Really, your additions seemed more like reflex defensiveness.

Can't you imagine that some guy who's proud of his arduously built plane doesn't need your pronouncement of hideousness, then followed later by snide remarks. Can you be that full of yourself? Can you not imagine that there are lots of visitors, lurkers and silent members of this forum who might show off their efforts but for witnessing the comments they might expect from someone like you. You aren't advancing the forum's 'supportive community' of craftspeople by displaying how you might humiliate us with condescending criticism if we step out of the shadows to show off our efforts?

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#2

Not then, but you do now.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I was just trying to be analytical, Bob. I put myself out there and accept when others criticise my work. This is a forum for discussion and critique. Nevertheles, I did feel my use of "hideous" was too strong, and I even tried to edit out, but too late. That is why I apologised for the remark.

Clearly I do not see what you see. What is it you see that is so different from my analysis?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#3

On reflection ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>As I mentioned earlier, I did feel my use of "hideous" was too strong and I did try to edit it out. On reflection I do accept that I posted too thoughtlessly. While I believe that forums are for critique, they do not need to be rude, and I think my comment was rude. For that I apologise.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#4

Here's how I see it.

WoodburnBob

>You may see forums as places for objective, analytical critique. Perhaps not everyone sees them as you do.

You put your stuff out there as you say, and welcome what people have to say. Good, bad or indifferent. But would you feel good if a prominent, respected member of the woodworking community publicly announced that what you made, what you invested your vision and labor in, was hideous, or aesthetically challenged, or nothing special? That takes a rare kind of body armour. Most people aren't that hardened. So, you or I might easily pass off the glib, cutting, no-nothing comments of a known crank who never has anything good to say about anything. But you are not a crank.

Derek, the body and volume of your work on-line over the years establishes you as an accomplished and legitimate authority in woodworking circles. It is hard to Google something handtool related and not wind up eventually looking at some well-crafted and helpful piece of sharing, teaching or explanation by you. You review and perhaps collaborate with tool manufacturers, who must recognize you as legitimate reviewer, critic, consultation, and authority. I've never seen someone respond to you as a nut-case or thoughtless person.

I don't even think the "hideous" was meant by you to be taken all that literally and seriously. And the plane and it's features isn't the main issue for me now.

I think the issue is this. You are in the unenviable position of being a somewhat public figure and spokesperson on handtool stuff in the kingdom of hand tool stuff. Your words have weight and authority and meaning in the public. Whether by design or as a side effect of your interest and industry, your words carry at least some degree of extra power and can also presumably elate or demoralize the little guy. Alas, you also come to be seen as an arbiter of beauty, functional and worth, again perhaps a step above the ordinary Joe on some subjects. This exposes you to reactions such as mine. A crank calls a craftsman like object hideous and I move on to the reading the next post. You do it and I sit up and blink a few times.

That is mostly what has been on my mind about all this. No hard feelings. I hope you and I can drop it and move on. It would be interesting to learn the views of others, but it isn't necessary for me. I've said what I needed to say.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#5

you write well

Bill Tindall

>I couldn't care less about the topic of the plane but it was a pleasure reading your reasoned presentation which has broader impact than this specific instance. I will keep in mind what you have said should I be inclined to offer a critique of something on a forum. Your point of scaring off the more timid is well taken. We can't afford to loose any visitors to this Forum.

Now put these writing skills to use describing how to do something useful to me(others).

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#6

Thanks very much to both Bob and Derek

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>for their civility and respectfulness in expressing differing views. Shows great strength of character, in my opinion.

Wiley

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#7

How about a St. James infill for $50

WoodburnBob

>I just scored one on Ebay. It looks like he puts spare castings out there once in awhile to keep his name alive maybe.

Anyway, I've just recently got my mill trammed to my satisfaction, and thought I might put together a show and tell as I try to mill it and so forth...recording every stupid possible mistake and mishap along the way of course. SMT has a 3 issue show and tell in one of the old machinist mags, but it's the Norris St. James offers. The casting I'm getting is of a Spiers/Mathieson/Preston style parallel sided smoother.

On the other hand I may have pissed off enough people today to be a major target for guerrilla potshots in the future and may just slink off into the bushes.

Thanks for the kind words.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#8

Point taken

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Bob

Your point is taken and I agree.

I spend my days helping people deal with and heal from their hurts, and the very last thing I would wish to do is inflict pain on another. My words were ill-chosen and impulsive. I deeply regret writing them. The only excuse (which is not an excuse) is that I broke my own rule, that is, not to reply to a forum so late in the day (early hours of the morning for me) as my brain is no longer attached to my typing fingers.

I did write to Ellis (after my last post) to request he remove my first two posts on this matter (where I analysed the plane). Turning on my computer this morning I see that they are still there. Ellis ...?

Once again my apologies.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#9

Re: Point taken

wilbur

>

The only excuse (which is not an excuse) is that I broke my own rule, that is, not to reply to a forum so late in the day (early hours of the morning for me) as my brain is no longer attached to my typing fingers.

Oh, great. When I'm on call and up in the middle of the night waiting for the ER or hospital to call me back on one of my patients, I often pass the time reading and posting on woodworking forums. Now what the heck am I supposed to do? ;)

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#10

Congrats to all

Dan Donaldson

>I did remove the posts for you. I would like to express my gratitude for the way that this thread has progressed. It could very easily have degenerated into a flame war or worse, but did not. That says a lot for the board participants.

Dan D

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#11

I work rotating shifts

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>and I understand. When I'm on nights (as I am this week) I try like the dickens not to venture an opinion on anything. While that opinion might reflect my true thoughts, it is almost always couched in the most direct, unflattering terms and those thoughts would have been phrased differently had I been fully rested.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#12

Need your e-mail address, Derek

Ellis Walentine, Host

>The one you have in your profile is apparently mistyped or something, as all your e-mail notifications have bounced (back to me, sadly, since it is my address that sends the notifications).

I didn't get your latest note, but if I had, I would have reacted more quickly.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#13

Re: Need your e-mail address, Derek

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Ellis

My email address is correct and working. I've just tested it. Also, I've received emails today from both Wiley and Dan.

Not to worry - we sorted it out. We have a great team here!

Anyway, I thought you were meant to be taking it easy for a few days!!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#14

Re: Here's how I see it.

Chris Friesen

>"...But would you feel good if a prominent, respected member of the woodworking community publicly announced that what you made, what you invested your vision and labor in, was hideous, or aesthetically challenged, or nothing special?"

Realistically, most of what gets posted to the internet *is* aesthetically challenged, or nothing special, or even hideous. The number of people that can come up with truly aesthetically pleasing pieces is minute relative to the body of work out there. As author Theodore Sturgeon once said, "90% of everything is crud". Of course, most people think they're in the 10% category.

The thing is, there's nothing wrong with a piece I make being nothing special. It's special to me because of the effort involved. Maybe to my family and friends, because I made it. But in the grand scheme of things, very few people will make pieces that actually *are* special.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#15

Re: Congrats to all

Dean Lapinel

>I try to avoid contentious issues when they are of little value. This civil argument was wonderfully handled by both participants. Reading this was actually a pleasure and heightened my respect for both.

Bravo!

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#16

Re: Congrats to all

Dean Lapinel

>I wrote too soon. Is this discussion about the "Lazarus Infill Smooth Stanley 4 1/2 Sz Prototype plane"? If so, I see no problem with a critique. Personally I find that it lacks aesthetic value and there is nothing wrong with stating this.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#17

And now I want to see the plane...

John in NM

>Trouble is I've no idea where the original post is.... as near as I can tell from the context this was something on ebay?

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#18

Re: Congrats to all

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Whew! I thought for a moment you were about ready to give out citizenship awards, complete with gold stars. :)

Pam

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#19

You have to scroll down a bit, and, of course, *LINK*

Bill Houghton

>you need to know the name the plane maker is using for his planes. See below linky.

Some posts were deleted from this overall thread, at the request of the person posting, and subthreads got turned into threads on their own as a result.


http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/handtools.pl/page/1/md/read/id/144891/sbj/the-lazarus/

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#20

Re: Here's how I see it.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Personally, I'd rather be told it's hideous if it is than humored and coddled. I have this problem all the time in writing classes, everyone wants to be pampered. Now perhaps this is a good thing in beginners' classes; otherwise too many may give up the effort too soon, but after a while with any given writer, s/he needs to be told the unvarnished truth, whether good or bad. I think the same applies to woodworking and any other creative activity.

So in this case I hope the plane maker takes comments as they are intended and learns how to make an aesthetically pleasing tool, since s/he certainly has time, craft and energy to spare.

Pam

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#21

Re: Congrats to all

Dan Donaldson

>It is about that plane, and the problem had nothing to do with the critique, but rather the wording used that The participants deemed were not necessary, so were removed at their request.

Critiques and differences of opinion are welcome. The trick is to state the points without becoming personal or turning it into a flame war. This thread did a good job of having differences without flames.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#22

Please critique this..be honest now...

Marv

>

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#23

Re: Here's how I see it.

Dan Donaldson

>I would much rather be told something like; "I don't like this piece because the widget should be parallel to the whatzit" or I think that the proportions are not right because it creates this....."

Something constructive, not "it is hideous" or something like that. I agree that if something is badly done, there is nothing wrong with stating opinions to that effect, but there are ways to state opinions without being obnoxious or abrasive.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#24

Thanks for the link....

John in NM

>I'd picked up that there were deleted parts, but not that the thread had been scattered. I'm relieved it isn't some new feature of the forum upgrade.

That is an interesting tote.

Re: Pissed you off did I, Derek?

#25

Re: Please critique this..be honest now...

Bob Hackett

>That looks painful!On more than one level.

I can continue if you think I must but I`d rather not.I think the pic speaks for itself.

To leave on a positive note it may make someone who likes scrapers happy if you were to re-gift it.:^)

MB