Pissed you off did I, Derek?
WoodburnBob
>"I must apologise [sic] if I sounded a little strong in my earlier post. As I said, beauty is in the eyes of the beholder. However if you desire a critique ..."
You didn't sound "a little strong" calling someone's work hideous, you sounded careless, thoughtless and mean-spirited behind someone's back. Your apology now seems disingenuous, given the new 'damning with faint praise' critique you assembled to accompany your apology.
How do you know the planemaker isn't in the audience? Would you offer the same attitude and words to him/her directly?
I didn't "desire a critique" from you on this plane in this thread, or anything else. Just the opposite. I wish you'd take it somewhere else. Who did you think desired more critique from you on this plane? Really, your additions seemed more like reflex defensiveness.
Can't you imagine that some guy who's proud of his arduously built plane doesn't need your pronouncement of hideousness, then followed later by snide remarks. Can you be that full of yourself? Can you not imagine that there are lots of visitors, lurkers and silent members of this forum who might show off their efforts but for witnessing the comments they might expect from someone like you. You aren't advancing the forum's 'supportive community' of craftspeople by displaying how you might humiliate us with condescending criticism if we step out of the shadows to show off our efforts?






