Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

saw sharpening device

Posts

Re: saw sharpening device

#51

Pitch

paul womack

>It would be very interesting for someone who has never filed a handsaw, comment on what they have read in this thread and tell us what they have learned.

I know yer' joshin', Marv, but in a written discussion, we NEED unambiguous words.

Otherwise someone can say "I like to use a reasonable amount of progressive pitch on a saw", and no-one knows what they mean.

Now, if we were all standin' round in a workshop, and could point at things, and pick them up, it'd all work out just fine.

But here on Woodcentral - it's mainly words, so words matter.

BugBear

Re: saw sharpening device

#52

Couldn't agree with you more...

Marv

>I respectfully submit.....

The word "pitch" is ambiguous in this discussion, that's why I used it in the way that I did, to point out how the word is used in so many ways in general.

It boggles my mind how the most difficult language to learn is the accepted standard around the world.

We do have other words that can be used to discribe what we do when we file a handsaw, accepted words that have been used in similar discussions and the written word for more than a century. However, other words have crept in over time.

For some reason, we think our english language needs more than one word for each description. Bevel angle and fleam angle for example. We only really need one of those words. Fleam is a fun word, but Bevel carries a clearer meaning. At least to me it does, but maybe not for others.

Tote versus handle.

Blade versus plate.

Rake angle is all we need when discussing the angle of the cutting side of a tooth. I don't like the word "pitch" when discussing handsaws when we have other means of conveying the number of teeth. Now we have confusion between pitch as it pertains to rake angle and as it pertains to teeth per inch. This is just silly. This is the kind of thing that when someone who is trying to acquaint themselves with the basic jargon get confused and makes it difficult for them to ask questions and understand answers. And it makes it more difficult for the teacher.

Our discussing it here will not solve the problem. The discussion we are having in this thread will be repeated time and time again. You are right, they are just a bunch of words here in this forum, but, if we were standing around in one of our shops discussing these kind of things, we might come to a conclusion or two, but in reality, only for the moment. I don't have a clue how we go about establishing a standard jargon. It would be nice to have, but certainly not in my lifetime.

Marv

Re: saw sharpening device

#53

Agree, miscellany, and suggestion

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Paul,

Absolutely agree with you. It seems to me there is less clarity in saw terminology than in bench planes for example. Even where there is clarity among the knowledgeable, not everyone knows for sure what the words refer to--'fleam' comes to mind. Nobody was born knowing this stuff.

I believe folks understand that rake is measured from the vertical, but which direction is positive rake, and which negative?--many Japanese saws will have zero to slightly negative rake. Or is it positive?

And we haven't discussed set. If set is said to be 3 thousandths, what does that mean? I always think of set as being the projection--on one side!--of the tooth beyond the plate just above. So therefore, if someone says 'the set is 3 thousandths'--the picture in my head is, for example, the plate above the teeth is 20 thousandths, the kerf is 26 thousandths, and the set is half the difference between plate and kerf, or 3 thousandths. (26-20)/2. But is this what others understand? Or is set described some other way?

Suggestion: is there a drawing somewhere in Disston or other literature that shows all these points of a saw on one or two diagrams? If not, one of those patented Bugbear originals would be a great contribution. In a new thread, of course, because the drawing itself would draw considerable discussion.

Wiley

Re: saw sharpening device

#54

Re: Pitch

Alan DuBoff

>Paul wrote:

"But here on Woodcentral - it's mainly words, so words matter."

It doesn't have to be, grab a hunk of wood and go at it!

A picture is worth a thousand words, so post pics! :-)

Re: saw sharpening device

#55

Re: Agree, miscellany, and suggestion

Marv

>Wiley,

When I specify set, I just give the blade thickness and the measurement across the points of the teeth. When the amount of set per side is desired, they just do the math.

Marv

Re: saw sharpening device

#56

Positive & Negative Rake

Steve Elliott

>I believe folks understand that rake is measured from the vertical, but which direction is positive rake, and which negative?--many Japanese saws will have zero to slightly negative rake. Or is it positive?

On this one issue I think there's pretty good standard terminology. Positive rake tends to pull the saw toward the workpiece, and both my Western and my Japanese rip saws have small positive rake angles.

Negative rake angle tends to push the saw up away from the workpiece. My Western crosscut saw has significant negative rake and my Japanese crosscut saws have either zero rake or a small amount of negative rake.

Negative rake helps to give a cleaner crosscut because the wood fibers are being pushed into the surface no matter what angle the saw is held at.

On a table saw negative rake will tend to push the workpiece up off the surface of the saw, and negative rake angles are usually confined to special blades meant for cutting plastics and nonferrous metals.

On a radial arm saw or a miter saw, negative rake is important for safety reasons. With the blade cutting from the top, negative rake pushes the workpiece down onto the bed of the saw.

Since I'm not an expert in hand saws I'm prepared to defer to someone who is, if it turns out that the terminology for hand saws is the reverse of other cutting tools.

Re: saw sharpening device

#57

Re: Pitch, pictures and language

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Alan, do you have any idea how difficult it is to photograph saw teeth? I've done it. It's no picnic. No normal camera is going to produce a decently revealing picture. I took my pics with a $500 macro lens bought just for the purpose.

Sorry if I sound a little annoyed by this conversation (I'm not btw). A few short years ago, I dont think folks knew what a progressively filed saw was let alone that the progression could be in pitch, rake or both. This board, my articles, and the work of saw makers have all helped improve teh general understanding and our tools as well.

Marv may think the OP is confused. I think the OP and all readers are well served here. This is another WC thread to be proud of. This is a complicated issue that needs careful discussion. We need another to discuss progressive teeth specifically Andrew Lunn posted a blog about this. Schwarz commented, saying something about tope tooth stress. I think I know what he meant, but stress is really the wrong word. When I begin a saw cut, I alsmost always begin at a corner. Having finer picthed teeth there, helps the cut initiate. It also eases the saw into every subsequent cut. Makes sense to limit the action where the momentum of the saw is the least. Language like tooth stress, while sorta clear, probably isn't clear enough.

Adam

Re: saw sharpening device

#58

Re: Pitch, pictures and language

Alan DuBoff

>Adam,

Funny, but I do know exactly how hard it is to photograph saw teeth, but have found a couple things that work well. The hardest part is getting the lens focused on the teeth and getting them in focus, I find shooting the pic into an open window helps, light wise. It is almost impossible to get a good pic of a saw laying on a bench and trying to take it from above, I have never had good luck with that.

But as far as progressive, I agree that nobody knew what progressive pitch was a few years ago, before LN introduced it with their product line. It makes sense, IMO, but just not sure it's worth the time, effort, and work involved to shape and file the teeth that way, for the results one gets from it.

Heck, I have many old saws that are filed progressive pitch, not on purpose, they just ended up that way from the owners! lol

I don't think any measurement that gives us the average can really help at all though, so even if we have a measurement, if we have several different PPIs mixed together, we can never have them all spaced off the average.

While I see an advantage, I also think it's more trouble than it's worth for the most part, and really don't see what all the fuss is about.

Seems more to be in vogue when Schwarz wrote about it in his blog, many of the woodworkers just had to have the most recent buzz...so many people wanting to try the progressive pitch saws...seems more like hype than anything else to me, as all of my saws that never had progressive pitch on them seem to work fine.

All types of ways people are looking to create an easier starting cut, look at what Kevin Drake does with the smooth section on the front of his saw that slides in the kerf to start the cut...

There just doesn't seem to be a big enough gain from it for me.

I've tried a couple of the saws filed like that...they seem like decent saws, but not earth shattering to me.

Even Schwarz mentioned sending them out to be sharpened, what's up with that? I don't need any tools I need to send out to be sharpened to the maker (in that case LN).

I like my joiners saws filed at 14ppi for rip, 13ppi for xcut. That might be a bit course for folks, but in hardwoods I typically work such as hard maple, that works well. For many they would prefer a bit finer, like 15ppi or 16ppi, and some even more like the Grammercy is 20ppi I believe.

Have you noticed big gains with shaping/sharpening progressive?

Cheers,

Alan (still waiting for JamesW to post pics of your saws you sent him!;-)

Re: saw sharpening device

#59

Progressive pitch teeth before LN

wilbur

>Japanese saws with rip teeth, including the rip side of a ryoba, have had progressive pitch for many many many years.

Re: saw sharpening device

#60

I will check this out next weekend...

Alan DuBoff

>Wilbur,

I'm going over to MannyH's house next weekend to check out his Japanese saws, and I will definitely check that out.

I hadn't realized that Japanese saws did that. I used one of Manny's handmade Mitsukawa ryoba saws a couple years ago, but it wasn't filed progressive, I don't think. I was just looking around Japan Woodworker and those don't appear to be filed progressive there. I can't see the teeth on the Hida site very well.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: saw sharpening device

#61

Indeed and progressive gullet depth too *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Adam referred to Andrew Lunn's blog entry (and Chris Schwarz' comment) on progressive pitch. See link below. Andrew distinguished between rip hand saws, stating his thought that progressive pitch is the best solution for an easy start saw, and back saws, where in his opinion a softer rake angle is a better solution for easy start. In other words, there are (at least) two variables--rake and pitch--which can be varied to ease the starting cut, depending on the absolute tooth size of the saw. Mike Wenzloff uses similar custom toothing, and perhaps the other custom makers do the same.

I have a question: In western saws, does progressive pitch also entail progressive gullet size? In Japanese saws, it does.

I am looking at a set of three Japanese single-edge rip saws--210, 240, and 270--by the same maker and made at the same time. Each of the saws is double tapered, progressive pitch and gullet-depth. For example, the smallest saw, the 210mm, is 16ppi at the starting end (heel) and 10ppi at the toe. The gullets on the starting teeth are a little over 1/16" deep, compared to 1/8" deep gullets at the toe. Now these teeth have a pronounced aggressive rake--I would estimate 15 degree aggressive rake. On a kerf that is 22 thousandths. This is set up for dry hardwood.

The rake varies in an interesting way among the three saws. Each saw has a consistent rake. But the smallest (210mm) saw has about a 15 degree aggressive rake; the largest (270mm) saw has 4-5 degree aggressive rake on a kerf that is 34-35 thousandths; with the middle saw (240mm) being in between at 8-10 degrees aggressive rake. By 'aggressive' rake, I mean tilted toward the cut.

So the Japanese rip saws have progressive pitch and gullet size in each saw, combined with progressively less rake as the saw teeth get absolutely larger in the larger saws.

Wiley

Note to Alan: I'm sure you will find that the rip side of Manny's handmade ryoba is progressive pitch and gullet.


Andrew Lunn on progressive pitch

Re: saw sharpening device

#62

Re: Progressive pitch teeth before LN

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I agree, Wilbur, that this stuff has been around for a long time. I can remember guys discussing it in 1981 when I learned to pitsaw. We used an 18th century saw that had what we might have called graduated teeth. Pretty sure that predates the LN company.

Re: saw sharpening device

#63

Re: Indeed and progressive gullet depth too

MikeW

>Hi Wiley,

Increasing (or decreasing) tooth spacing using the "normal" files for the disciple of origin (Eastern / Western) all but guarantees there will be a change in gullet depth. Gullet depth and tooth spacing using said files have a direct relationship to each other.

Get finer in tooth spacing and there is a decrease in gullet depth. Likewise, an increase in tooth spacing and there is an increase in gullet depth.

This is as long as "typical" saw files are being used. Saws filed peg-toothed properly (can) have extra space created between the teeth.

Take care, Mike

Re: saw sharpening device

#64

No offense to LN

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Last LN progressive saw I used had a fairly simple, what looked to be linear progression in pitch (ppi) only. And the difference between toe and heel was severe. I also thought the model they first put it on, a short DT, was not a good candidate for this toothing.

Some folks liked it, tho, including Schwarz. And tho a quick filing wouldn't fix the large pitch change, one could alter the rake easily and have a different performing saw quickly. Not saying the performance was lacking btw. Just saying that saying "progressive toothed" isn't anywhere near precise enough to be helpful.

In 18th c pitsaws, they did all sorts of things to saw teeth, adding secondary angles, rounded gullets, etc etc. I'm not sure such things are helpful for handsaws, but one never knows. Joel has convinced me of the advantage of using needle files for small teeth. The sharper corners create deeper gullets that really do seem to clog less.

In all, I think this is a complicated subject whose surface we have just barely scratched.

Adam

Re: saw sharpening device

#65

My two cents, albeit somewhat late

Andrew Lunn

>A friend of mine wrote and told me about this thread--sorry to be such a late entry. I'm really swamped these days juggling orders with preparations for the upcoming WIA in Valley Forge. This is quite a thread. I've read through it and have a few thoughts, so I'll share them all in one shot here.

I wouldn't recommend someone use a filing guide, as they prevent you from controlling meaningful parts of the sharpening process yourself, but if someone really wants to use one, I think that's their business, and I would hardly judge them for it. It's not the end of the world. It surely won't result in a saw sharpened as well as it could be--but it may well result in a saw sharpened well enough to be quite serviceable. Probably depends a lot on what sort of shape the teeth are in to begin with.

From my perspective as a saw maker, in my own work, I do think accuracy in saw filing is a big deal. However, as has been said already, a bit of variation is beneficial. How much? I don't know. If you are filing by hand you will without fail introduce some variation. My guiding principle is simply to do my best work, as I will introduce enough variation without trying to do so.

I don't see what the big deal is about mechanically producing teeth when you make a saw, so long as the teeth are subsequently hand filed. Any variation you want in the teeth will be produced by the hand filing. Insisting that the hand filing begin at the point where no teeth exist at all seems unnecessary to me. The old makers punched their teeth just like the new ones do, just with different equipment.

With progressive rake vs. progressive ppi, progressive rake is just my preference. It's certainly not the only way to go. You could well do neither progressive rake nor progressive ppi and simply create the effects you desire through technique and a light touch in the right places. I simply tried to build into my saws a mechanism that would simulate applying touch in the right places.

The point I was trying to make in my blog was simply that with a saw that already has relatively fine teeth, you can adjust the rake to achieve the effect you desire. With a saw with large teeth, like a long ripper, I think it makes more sense to vary the ppi at the toe than the rake. That's all.

Andrew

Re: saw sharpening device

#66

PIcs?

paul womack

>Alan, do you have any idea how difficult it is to photograph saw teeth? I've done it. It's no picnic. No normal camera is going to produce a decently revealing picture. I took my pics with a $500 macro lens bought just for the purpose.

I'd like to see those - where are they?

BugBear

Re: saw sharpening device

#67

Labelled Diagrams *LINK*

paul womack

>Suggestion: is there a drawing somewhere in Disston or other literature that shows all these points of a saw on one or two diagrams? If not, one of those patented Bugbear originals would be a great contribution. In a new thread, of course, because the drawing itself would draw considerable discussion.


Those fine people at TFWW have done it (link to blog attached)

BugBear


saw spectra

Re: saw sharpening device

#68

Great chart!! Thanks Paul and Joel.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>

Re: saw sharpening device

#70

Tooth-top profile *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Warren,

Excellent article. Mr. Disston spends time on a subject that was discussed in the 19th century, and that is the profile of the top of the saw tooth as you are looking down the length of the saw. Especially for crosscut saws. Disston's 1907 text and figures owe a lot to those of H. W. Holly, writing in 1874 ("The Art of Saw-Filing--Scientifically Treated and Explained on Philosophical Principles"). Both show how the fleam on the back side of the crosscut saw tooth can be used to control the front profile of the top of the tooth. Both show the way the file must be tilted down to vary the top profile. It's an interesting thing, that the 1907 Lumberman's Handbook contains this material, and a later version I have does not. Maybe the golden age of handsaw filing had already occurred in the 19th century, and the fine points were beginning to fade.

I still don't get the mechanics of how reducing the back-side fleam helps with harder wood. As the backside fleam is reduced, two things happen--(1) the tooth-top gets flatter (doesn't fall off to the inside at such a sharp angle) when viewed from the front; but also (2) the tooth top angles more to the rear, away from the cut, so that the tooth top is making a more skewing cut.

Question 1: Does anyone out there vary the backside fleam when they are filing?

As an observation, the Japanese modify the backside fleam with a third facet which comes up over the top and directly controls the profile of the tooth-top.

Question 2: Which crosscut tooth would dull the fastest, one with 45 degree fleam front and back, or one with 45 degree on front and 0 degrees on the back? Or would it matter?


H. W. Holly on Saw-Filing [google books]

Re: saw sharpening device

#71

Re: I will check this out next weekend...

James Watriss

>Check again.

Every Ryoba I've seen, sold, or used, all were made that way.

It's more subtly done, though, and it's not obvious to everyone. But it's also what I'm used to. For a long time I cut dovetails with a ryoba because I couldn't find an affordable rip dozuki that interested me. So, I got used to the feel of progressive pitch, and being able to cut more quickly once the saw was going. So, to me, the L-N felt a little more like "coming home." It just felt right in use, and chugs through wood very quickly once you're in tune with how it works.

Re: saw sharpening device

#72

Re: Tooth-top profile

Marv

>Hi Wiley,

Question 1: Does anyone out there vary the backside fleam when they are filing?

As far as I'm aware, we don't do anything to the backside fleam other than what occurs while filing the front side. Perhaps in rare occasions, but normally we don't. It's all about the front of the tooth. The back gets filed only because it's there and gives the other side of the file something to do.

Question 2: Which crosscut tooth would dull the fastest, one with 45 degree fleam front and back, or one with 45 degree on front and 0 degrees on the back? Or would it matter?

IMO, 45 degree fleam is too sharp an angle. This much angle will dull quite fast, especially in hardwoods. I know that Disston says to use that angle in their handbook, but I think they had a hiden agenda. It will result in sharpening the saw more often, hence selling more saws.

Marv

Re: saw sharpening device

#73

Re: Tooth-top profile

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Marv,

Thanks. What fleam angle do you use? Inquiring minds.....

Wiley

Re: saw sharpening device

#74

Re: Tooth-top profile

Marv

>Wiley,

For general purposes, such as on eBay saws, I usually us a 25 Degree bevel/fleam angle. It does a good job of slicing the fibers and remains sharp for longer and still cuts a smooth surface. 25 degree bevel is quite common among saw filers. Some filers will change it a little depending on type of wood being sawn.

Marv

Re: saw sharpening device

#75

Fleam and rake

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Marv,

What rake do you use with that 25 degree fleam?

And also, do you need to choose the fleam and rake together? Or are they pretty much independent? What I mean is, if there is a lot of fleam, like for example 40 or 45 degrees, would that choice associate with a more aggressive rake or a less aggressive rake?

Thanks,

Wiley