Re: Pitch, pictures and language
Alan DuBoff
>Adam,
Funny, but I do know exactly how hard it is to photograph saw teeth, but have found a couple things that work well. The hardest part is getting the lens focused on the teeth and getting them in focus, I find shooting the pic into an open window helps, light wise. It is almost impossible to get a good pic of a saw laying on a bench and trying to take it from above, I have never had good luck with that.
But as far as progressive, I agree that nobody knew what progressive pitch was a few years ago, before LN introduced it with their product line. It makes sense, IMO, but just not sure it's worth the time, effort, and work involved to shape and file the teeth that way, for the results one gets from it.
Heck, I have many old saws that are filed progressive pitch, not on purpose, they just ended up that way from the owners! lol
I don't think any measurement that gives us the average can really help at all though, so even if we have a measurement, if we have several different PPIs mixed together, we can never have them all spaced off the average.
While I see an advantage, I also think it's more trouble than it's worth for the most part, and really don't see what all the fuss is about.
Seems more to be in vogue when Schwarz wrote about it in his blog, many of the woodworkers just had to have the most recent buzz...so many people wanting to try the progressive pitch saws...seems more like hype than anything else to me, as all of my saws that never had progressive pitch on them seem to work fine.
All types of ways people are looking to create an easier starting cut, look at what Kevin Drake does with the smooth section on the front of his saw that slides in the kerf to start the cut...
There just doesn't seem to be a big enough gain from it for me.
I've tried a couple of the saws filed like that...they seem like decent saws, but not earth shattering to me.
Even Schwarz mentioned sending them out to be sharpened, what's up with that? I don't need any tools I need to send out to be sharpened to the maker (in that case LN).
I like my joiners saws filed at 14ppi for rip, 13ppi for xcut. That might be a bit course for folks, but in hardwoods I typically work such as hard maple, that works well. For many they would prefer a bit finer, like 15ppi or 16ppi, and some even more like the Grammercy is 20ppi I believe.
Have you noticed big gains with shaping/sharpening progressive?
Cheers,
Alan (still waiting for JamesW to post pics of your saws you sent him!;-)