We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I certainly don't have the saw sharpening experience that all of you do, but here's my take on the issues of angles and consistency.
On one extreme, there are machine made saw teeth that are perfectly consistent across the length of the saw. On the other extreme is the type of hack job that I would do. Somewhere in the middle is a skillfully done hand sharpening job, where the filing is very consistent but includes a slight degree of variation that is beneficial.
So to take rake angle as an example, with machine made saw teeth, every single tooth would have exactly a 5� rake angle. If I sharpened a saw, the individual teeth would have rake angles all over the place, and the average probably would be close to 5�. If any other WC Hand Tools forum member sharpened the saw, the average rake angle of all the teeth would be 5� exactly, although there would be variations for each individual tooth on the order of fractions of a degree.
My feeling is that with practice, it is relatively easy to achieve consistency from an "average of all the teeth" standpoint. It is a bit harder to achieve consistency from a "variance around the mean" standpoint, but not impossible. And probably, the variance that gives you a really nice saw is higher than what we think.
>I think Mike's post says it all. The only area I would amplify and not disagree is
"Consistent tooth-tip height is relatively easy to achieve. But one can still end up with cows & calves as regard tooth base width. Crowding one direction or another is a tooth-by-tooth decision (I consider them tooth pairs). While a guide-aid would help in bringing the base of a tooth more in-line with its neighbors or where it should be all the while maintaining the rake angle during this shaping process, they are relatively cumbersome in use. "
The problem with mechanical guides is that they can restrict the "english" you can put on a tooth as you are making your "tooth by tooth decisions.
Optical guides to help maintain angle and things can be very very useful - the pete taren flag at the end of a file for example. but mechanical guides even for a beginner I think will hinder developing fluency with the file.
>Or..big tooth-little tooth syndrome, as Pete Taran refers to them.
I find this problem to be my biggest bugaboo. I can accurately control all other aspects of filing, within an acceptable tolerance, but I will at times produce a consistant big tooth-little tooth saw. Seems that when I do it, the teeth are consistantly different from one end of the saw to the other. As Mike said, it's a filer's judgement call on each tooth as to how much of the jointed flat is filed during the first alternate tooth filing.
If the difference isn't extreme, the saw will still perform well and the teeth will set evenly enough. However, I have had to reshape the teeth and start over from time to time in order to correct the problem.
Question for those of you who do lots of saw filing.....do you consider some difference in tooth width acceptable? In other words, if it's noticeable with the nekked eye, do you correct it or do you go ahead and pack it up and ship it to a customer?
I sharpen mostly old used saws. So I'm starting with badly maintained saw teeth most of the time. I'm sure the problem is much less prevalent with mechanically produced teeth with the jointed flats being minimal and consistant. That's more like me starting with freshly shaped teeth on an old saw.
>Am I the only sawmaker who sharpens his saws entirely by hand? I'm surprised to hear you guys are using machines and jigs.
I've used other makers saws side by side with mine. I usually (but not always) prefer my saws. At least, I think my saws are comparable if not better. I say this not to be competitve. I recently finished my last saw and I'm not taking orders at present and won't in the near future. But rather, I think a few degrees one way or another, inconsistency in pitch (tpi), matters not at all.
If the use of jigs or machines results in cost savings, skilled labor reductions, I'm all for it. I don't think I ever made money making saws. I don't know who I could possibly hire to do what I do. I have to hand it to all of the sawmakers who are able to operate successful businesses. That takes skill beyond my own and I respect it.
But for folks interested in retoothing an old saw, I don't think a jig or template is necessary (assuming you can file a saw in the first place). Beyond basic saw filing skill, I don't think the increased accuracy offered by a jig or machine offers any functional benefit. I'd also go further and say that I prefer graduated teeth which I suspect can be difficult to make with machinery (but not impossible). In terms of DIY jigs like Bugbear's, that might be good to get the knack, but it would beome limiting (like every other sort of jig or machine).
To answer Bugbear's question, my saws' teeth typically vary from one end to the other on purpose. But within 2 inches, they can sometimes vary unintentionally by a tooth or 2 per inch. I think I can control pitch +/- 5 degrees with respect to absolute angle. Tooth to tooth I'm pretty sure I do much better that that (adjacent teeth won't be off 5 or 10 degrees from one another).
I would encourage folks to buy new saws when finances allow. We need to develop and support the tool makers that will supply future generations of woodworkers (when the old Disston's are gone). I would buy a new saw from any of the small makers (up to and including Joel, LN, and Wenzloff) without hesitation. Pax I'm less sure of.
In summation, I've not personally found that the accuracy of machine made teeth results in a better cutting saw over well filed hand cut teeth. A small inconsistency either has no effect or has a positive one.
For people who actually prefer the inconsistency of hand filed teeth, worry not about buying new machine cut teeth. The inconsistency of hand filed teeth are only a sharpening away!
I think you need to read Joel's and my responses better. Creating teeth isn't sharpening. But perhaps you meant you may be the only saw maker filing in teeth from scratch by hand?
Just how do you think early and later saw makers in England created saws, created the toothing? By hand with a file? No templates really early on? No hand-operated toothing punch and dies a bit later? Nah. You would be wrong if you thought that.
What surprises me more is a saw maker would dismiss the mechanized or guided punch and die methods of those saw makers before them and try to have a viable business.
You wrote, "If the use of jigs or machines results in cost savings, skilled labor reductions, I'm all for it." As for Joel, W&S and LN--and the other saw makers such as Medallion Toolworks, Eccentric Toolworks and now Bad Axe Tool Works--may create teeth on saw plate in a number of ways, but they are still hand filed before they ever leave their respective shops. Point being, creating teeth may be semi-skilled to skilled labor, but the final settings and sharpenings certainly are skilled labor.
>I got beat up on that usage. Disston and his contemporaries never used pitch to describe the number of teeth in an inch. They used pitch and rake interchangeably. I prefer Pete's way, where pitch is like the engineer's definition, like threads per inch, rake as an angle.
Sorry for the confusion. I've been trying to translate these terms since the flood (of 3) emails and personal calls.
>Yes, I'm talking about toothing, not sharpening. And yes, I thought I read carefully what was written here. And tho my post is lengthy, I think it's clear; I don't see a functional advantage to mechanically filed or jig filed teeth. I'm not against the practice.
I only wrote what I did to encourage guys to not worry too much about filing their teeth perfectly. I don't think jigs are necessary to achieve the level of precision some may feel is required. Precision isn't required for functionality in my opinion.
Moving along- I've found that I am more sensitive to inconsistencies in rake (angle) than pitch(tpi) or even set. Based on my observations, folks who say their saws are getting hung up or stuck should look for a tooth whose rake is steeper than it's neighbors, rather than stoning away set. I don't think stoning should ever be done to cross cut saws (or people).
I get the sense from your posts that accuracy is not important. If that is the case, why even joint the teeth before filing?
Why not purposely file all the teeth with different heights, different rake angles, different fleam angles and lets toss in some sloped gullets here and there? And random points per inch? And lets set the teeth at random too.
Of course accuracy is important. Is it important to file all the teeth perfectly the same? No it isn't, but if it was possible, I would do it.
I want my saws to be filed as accurately and as consistantly as I possibly can. I use any aid I can to make it happen. I also, always side joint the teeth.
>When I went to school (1969, not quite the Middle Ages), the pitch of a screw was the distance between adjacent threads. It was the reciprocal of threads per inch. Has this changed to mean threads per in?
Frankly, it was a lot less than forty years ago when one could say he used an 8 point saw and there was no confusion.
>... is an awful word. It's used for the spacing of things, and ALSO for angles.
One can quite reasonably speak of the "pitch" of a roof.
Since no-one's ever come up with a good alternative word for tooth spacing, but there is a good alternative for tooth-face-slope, using "pitch" for spacing and "rake" for angle, when speaking of saws seems good.
>The dictionary definition will probably say something about the distance between teeth. But we don't think of it that way as engineers. We say "32 thread pitch" meaning 32 threads per inch. In metric, pitch is the actual space between threads.
I don't really care how one thinks about it. Is 8 the pitch or is 1/8 the pitch? I just don't care. Like Bugbear said, we need a word that describes the spacing betwen teeth OR the number of teeth in and inch BESIDES just writing the number of teeth per inch. In my parlance, pitch is a variable applied to other factors, there's a delta pitch, the change in the number of teeth per inch on a blade (I think LN's progressive picth DT has too great a delta- at least I thought so on the saw I used).
How do guys do this with band saw blades? Circular saw blades? Is it the number of teeth on the blade total? At the time I wrote on this subject, the emails and calls I got wanted me to go back to using pitch and rake interchangeably. I refuse. If not pitch, give me some other word. We need a word for this. My saws have progressive teeth. They have progressive rake and progressive...............(fill in the blank. "teeth per inch" doesn't seem to fit).
In times past the nominal PPI was what was expressed regardless of whether, like in the instance of coarser hand saws, there was progressive PPI at the toe.
PPI (points per inch) is a time honored expression of the spacing of the teeth of a hand saw. It is specific. TPI (teeth per inch) is a relatively newbie to describe tooth spacing on a hand saw. One which I do not like at a personal level.
If one wishes to be contemporary with the few saws out there that seek to set themselves apart by varying tooth spacing over the length of a saw or rake/fleam, one can add descriptors to PPI. These words also exist. LN's use of "progessive PPI" (or TPI, I forget which LN uses) describes the saw precisely.
In a saw where say "rake" is not closely maintained from one end to the other whether by accident or design, one can describe it as variable rake.
But "pitch" to describe tooth spacing? It simply isn't necessary to invent usage or words to hand saw tooth spacing. PPI pretty much says it all.
Take care, Mike
Who's shaking his head in wonder...and now back to writing saw sharpening stuff.
>When I side hone or joint, I do a very light touch with a slipstone, just enough to bring all those points even. Sometimes only a single swipe. I do it with the blade laying flat on a flat surface. The side jointing does two things, it removes any burrs that might be left from filing and as I said, makes all the points even. I will do the side jointing if I have just finished setting the teeth after filing or if I have set the teeth before filing right after reshaping. Side jointing is a simple step and only takes a moment to do. It surely does no harm, while at the same time produces a smoother cut from the gitgo.
>The word "pitch" only confuses the issue when relating to handsaws.
As Mike said, all we need is to specify PPI points per inch. The number you see stamped just below the handle on any and all older saws indicates the points per inch, not teeth per inch. If you count the points on a 10PPI saw, it will have 9tpi. TPI is always one tooth less than PPI.
This subject has been discussed numerous times. Lets wait a few weeks and we can discuss it again.
Anyone want to discuss the "nib"?......again? Mike, you go first. *grin*
>I think "progressive teeth" would be a better term. Like "a 12 point saw with progressive teeth" or "progressive rake and progressive teeth". I sort of think you have used this term yourself. I think most would know what you are talking about.
If you insist on a new term, I think frequency would be a better term than pitch. Frequency is always a rate like teeth per inch is. And pitch is misleading because it very often refers to angles or slopes and there are lots of angles in saw teeth.
On chainsaws they use pitch commonly, as it describes the average of the driver link spacing, so you take the distance of 2 between 2 sets of rivets and divide by 2 (or the length of any 3 rivets divided by 2, same thing). 1/4" pitch, .325" pitch, 3/8" (or .375") pitch, etc...
This actually is a term that has been around and has been used for many years, could even go back to 2 man crosscut saws where the teeth are not evenly spaced, not sure.
I also like the term "progressive PPI" because it does describe what it is.
But I would like to pose a question on pitch, to those that thing a term is needed. What would you do with the average spacing when a saw has 3 or 4 different PPIs, as in Progressive Pitch?
How would that even help us in shaping teeth or in sharpening?
The reason it is done with chain for chainsaws is that you have differently spaced drive links, and you need to know the pitch in order for the proper bar slot, as well as the tip sprocket and clutch sprocket/rim. In reality it's the tang that needs to be a given distance...to match the sprockets and/or bar channel.
I don't see how that would help us do anything with a handsaw though, even if we did know. How would you use that for spacing/shaping teeth? Maybe I'm missing something.
I used to side hone my saws, but typically will not anymore as I believe it removes some of the sharpness of the tooth. I have heard others say how it brings the teeth in line but it seems to physically make the saw less sharp, in my experience. I don't measure the kerf and/or teeth width with a micrometer, though.
As you describe with Xcut teeth, the same holds true for rip filed teeth, IMO. Through use I find the burr gets removed naturally, but by removing it with a stone it removes more than the burr. All of our mileage varies I believe...it's all good...
>The dictionary definition will probably say something about the distance between teeth. But we don't think of it that way as engineers. We say "32 thread pitch" meaning 32 threads per inch. In metric, pitch is the actual space between threads.
I guess that means Central European engineers do indeed think of it as per the dictionary definition.
The TPI concept always seems fine right up until you start talking about fractional teeth.
Of course, I'm talking about screw-threads here, but if you've ever seen a thread gauge, you'll know how similar it all is.
>Pitch is that hard to remove gummy stuff that builds up on the sides of saw blades.
Pitch is what solder flux is made of.
Pitch is that sticky stuff that ooozes from some woods and gets on your hands when you don't wear gloves. Acetone will take it right off.
Pitch is what you do with a baseball.
Pitch is the slope of a roof.
Pitch. as in "pitchman", a salesman..opps, sorry Pam, "pitchwoman" "Pitchperson".
Pitch is what you do with horseshoes.
Rake is the angle of the business side of a saw tooth, whether progressive or otherwise.
PPI is the number of points within one inch when counting saw teeth and is represented by the number you see stamped on a saw blade just below the handle on older regular type, western style handsaws. Not seen on backsaws.
TPI is the number of teeth per inch when counting the number of teeth on the full length of the blade.
Bevel, also referred to as "fleam" is the angle of the business side of a saw tooth that makes it a crosscut versus rip, but sometimes added to rip teeth just for kicks.
Sloping gullets is another angle used on crosscut teeth, supposedly to gain more depth to the gullet or lengthen the tooth, depending how you look at it. It serves little if any useful purpose other than add confusion to the process of filing a saw.
I have to say, if I were a person wanting to know how to file a handsaw and came in here and read this thread, I would be so confused, I would never give it another thought. *grin*
It would be very interesting for someone who has never filed a handsaw, comment on what they have read in this thread and tell us what they have learned.
Chicki, started this thread, I hope he got his answer regarding filing guides, not to be confused with "filing aids".
Sorry Chicki, we do digress in here at times. *grin* Those of us who think we know something about filing handsaws like to take full advantage of the opportunity to bloviate about our filing prowess and won't stop adding to the thread until we have filled at least one page on our screens.
I for one, like to see the humor in it all and not take it very seriously. :))