Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

saw sharpening device

Posts

saw sharpening device

#1

saw sharpening device

chichi1golf

>I have had several hand saws sharpened by a local Amish watchmaker. The device he uses works very well. It is bench mounted and has a file mounted to a guide which can be set at various angles. The saw clamps in the device and the mounted file is lowered into the tooth and there is a handle to push the mounted file back and forth. Maybe not the best description but has anyone else seen one of these? This guy did many saws for $4 per saw. He kept the Amish comkunity going. Surprisingly, I only met one Amish guy who knew how to hand sharpen his saws?

Based on a few crude sketches, I made my own and it seems to work pretty well. I would love to pick one of these up but doubt there are many available. Any for sale?

Bob

Re: saw sharpening device

#2

Did it look something like this?

Marv

>This is Disston's version of their filing guide designed to fit their 3D saw vise.

Marv


img

Re: saw sharpening device

#4

Re: Take a look at this one

chichi1golf

>The device was much larger and older than either of these. The Disston has similar features and looks like it would operate in the same fashion . The back bar on which the file guide slides is either 3/8 or 1/2 round bar about 24 to 30 in. long.It was probably made for a commercial sharpening shop. How well does the Disston or later model work?

Bob

Re: saw sharpening device

#5

Re: Take a look at this one *LINK*

Marv

>Hi Chichi,

The Disston file guide works kinda sorta, pretty good. The guide is ok for people who might not want to take the time to learn how to file a saw without a guide and only file an occasional saw. It will work ok for a dulled saw that only needs a touch-up. But for major reshaping and filing a saw that has been badly filed for years, the guide just isn't up to the challenge. I've only used one enough to acquaint myself with how it works. For me, it just slows me down and gets in my way.

The Lee Valley guide requires an expensive special file. Files don't last forever, in fact wear out quite rapidly. And it won't file the smaller teeth like what you see on a 15PPI dovetail saw for example. When you read and look at the instructions, they show a profile of both rip and crosscut teeth and how they should look after filing. The diagram is very misleading to anyone who isn't already familiar with how crosscut teeth should look. I don't recommend the Lee Valley guide.

Learning how to file western style handsaws is a very useful addition to your skill base. The essence of filing a saw is not only knowing how to use a triangular file, it is learning why a saw cuts at it's best and why it doesn't and what to do with that file to make a saw perform properly.

If you have a desire to learn the skill, I recommend two treatise, one written by Pete Taran and the other by Leif Hanson. Here is Leif's website http://www.norsewoodsmith.com/content/sharpening-hand-saws.

Pete Taran's trestise is here on Woodcentral.

Marv


Pete Taran on how to file saws

Re: saw sharpening device

#6

History and DIY jig *LINK*

paul womack

>There's some good info in the link (Brent Beach's page)

Personally I find the mechanical guides intrusive on my ability to manipulate the file, and use "optical" aids.

I am in awe of anyone who can achieve the needed accuracy without aids.

BugBear


http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/sawjig/

Re: saw sharpening device

#7

Re: History and DIY jig

Joel

>I don't find the mechanical filing aids useful - a hindrance actually. Optical aids on the other hand work well and specially if you don't file often or are trying a new filing pattern they can be really helpful.

The simple way to file totally by eye is practice. After the first couple of dozen you get good.

PS - we should start taking orders for our new saw vise in a week or less

Re: saw sharpening device

#8

Re: History and DIY jig

Marv

>I have to use "optical" aids....I wear glasses plus a magnifier visor.

Marv

Re: saw sharpening device

#9

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Whoa, whoa, WHOA! NEW Saw Vise?

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Joel,

You wrote:

"PS - we should start taking orders for our new saw vise in a week or less">

Excuse me if I'm "late to the party" or have misinterpreted your comment. But is this saw vise something TFWW is going to start selling? I just looked on the web site and didn't see anything. Is there a page devoted to this?

You see, I've been watching Ebay for the last month or so in the hopes of snagging a saw vise. :>)

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: saw sharpening device

#10

Re: Whoa, whoa, WHOA! NEW Saw Vise? *LINK*

joel

>Will have pictures up and a proper description either late this week or early next but here is a link to a recent blog entry.

We are extremely happy with the prototypes and our saw filer here has switched over which makes us even happier


Saw Vise Teaser

Re: saw sharpening device

#11

History and DIY jig *LINK*

paul womack

>The simple way to file totally by eye is practice.

I have to say, I don't see HOW it is possible to aim a 3-cornered file to within a couple of degrees "unaided"

The file is very small, and the working surfaces are obscured by the nonworking surface. An angle change of 2 degrees (which make quite a different to rake performance) only involves the edges of the upper flat-ish surface of the file moving by 0.3 mm relative to each other!

That's beyond my hand-eye skills.

Of course, for touch-up sharpening, you can let the file follow the existing angles, but that doesn't work for reshaping, and (even for touch up), cumulative errors will eventually mess up your tooth profile.

BugBear


http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/sawjig/

Re: saw sharpening device

#12

Re: History and DIY jig

joel

>We do it all the time.

hand saw filing is a little random - there is variation but that's why hand file saws cut smoother than machine filed saws anyway. A degree or so either way is not a big deal and in general as you file fleam will change slightly also. It's actually a good thing. A perfect machined file or human pretending to be a machine doesn't produce as smooth cutting a saw. and it's faster.

Re: saw sharpening device

#13

Re: Whoa, whoa, WHOA! NEW Saw Vise?

Marv

>Dominic,

I just bought two Disston 3D vises on eBay during the past two days. I'll be reburbishing them for resale on eBay soon.

I'm very curious about Joel's new vise though. I hope it has extra wide jaws and has a clamping mechanism that won't wear out in a short time. Maybe we can talk Joel into giving us a sneak preview here?

The Disston 3D has jaws that are 12-3/4" long, just short of 13", just enough too short so you have to move a common 26" saw blade two times per pass instead of only once. However, the 3D is wider than most old vises we see.

Marv

Re: saw sharpening device

#14

Re: Whoa, whoa, WHOA! NEW Saw Vise?

joel

>Here it is. It's a rendering because none of the prototypes have the brand stamp on it - that's what we are waiting for to fully let it go into production - which is happening now. THere are other minor changes to the production vise but it has 14" jaws and weights a ton.


img

Re: saw sharpening device

#15

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Thanks Joel!!

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Joel,

Thanks for posting this! I await the unveiling of your saw vise with baited breath.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: saw sharpening device

#16

Thanks Joel for the preview.

Marv

>I once found a hard to find 14" Wentworth at a tool show for only $5.

I rebuilt it and sold it on eBay for about $250.

As expected it had some wear on the clamping mechanism. The pictures will show how I fixed it.

I suspect that your vise will experience similar type wear. If you incorporated a roller device in the cam action, you would minimize the wear and extend the life of the vise ten fold.

Hope this works. These pictures are from an album in Google Picasa.

Marv


Re: saw sharpening device

#17

Re: Thanks Joel for the preview.

joel

>The Wentworth is a great saw vise and the best one we have seen. Wear doesn't seem to be a problem on ours - and we have plenty of travel left. Of course we have no idea how much usage the century old vises saw. Since we are using machined jaws you will get better contact with the blade than the original.

Re: saw sharpening device

#18

History and DIY jig *LINK*

paul womack

> A degree or so either way is not a big deal

I strongly suspect hand filing will introduce a lot more variation than that into the rake angle.

In experimenting with my rake-angle gadget, I reckon that WITH it, I can achieve +-1 (for a total variation of 2 degrees).

If anyone can get near that without aids, I would be (frankly) stunned.

And people (like Mike W) appear to have quite string opinions about the performance implications of quite small rake angle changes.

I do get the thing about random variations though, but I think they may be bigger than you imagine.

Try knocking up my little pointer thingy - it can be used to measure, as well as create, saw teeth.

BugBear


http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/sawjig/

Re: saw sharpening device

#19

Re: Thanks Joel for the preview.

Marv

>Joel,

Lubricating that cam area will help, but what ultimately happens, metal filings find their way down there and act as grinding compound. The same problem is what increases the wear on the Disston 3D vise.

Lots of heavy handed people who use your vise will over-tighten the jaws. This will increase wear and reduce the life of the vise.

If I were to use your vise, I would attach some kind of cover over the clamping cam area to prevent filings from getting down there. The cover could be just piece of thin flexible plastic or whatever.

I used a piece of foam rubber to prevent filings from getting into my Disston 3D vise after I fixed the wear problem. Those vises get worn to the point they won't stay clamped. Instead of the cam, they should have incorporated a roller bearing like Acme did on their big 28" jawed vises.

Marv

Re: saw sharpening device

#20

Re: History and DIY jig

joel

>I agree with Mike on rake angle - but I would say that it's an average no lock step of every tooth - and we have tried various jigs even ones very similar to yours but they get quickly discarded.

The way we train saw filers here is Tim gives them a piece of steel, a file, and a pitch template and they have file a saw full of teeth. The first saw usually is usable but good or rough depending on the guy learning. The second one is fine. And after that it just gets faster and faster. The trick of course is paying attention and going slowly in the beginning so that you can learn to feel where your file is and of course periodically rechecking your posture and positioning.

Re: saw sharpening device

#21

Re: Thanks Joel for the preview.

joel

>Marv,

Covering the cam a good idea - although we haven't seen this as an issue on the wentworth design because you have so much cam travel that even as the cams wear you just work further into the cam. On the Disston 3D I would 100% agree - almost every one I have seen needs work before clamping tight enough.

Re: saw sharpening device

#22

Re: History and DIY jig

Marv

>The point to keep in mind is, dry metal rubbing against dry metal really does need to be lubricated. It's the filings mixing with the lubrication that does the most harm.

The two metal to metal surfaces on your vise that does the clamping appear to be fairly thin. That's why a roller bearing would be advantagous for slowing down the wear. Any tool of that kind will work great in the short term, but after a year of frequent use, it can be a problem. In a few years, we'll be seeing them pop up on eBay with sellers describing them as being in perfect working order as we see with most of the vises we on eBay now days.

In any case, you have a potentially great selling vise there. With more and more people getting into filing their own saws, your new product will encourage more people to do it. You have no doubt put some serious thought into it instead of taking short-cuts and taking the cheap route.

Marv

Re: saw sharpening device

#23

Re: History and DIY jig

joel

>Marv,

we thought about and came up with a bunch of ways of mitigating wear - including bearings but so far we don't really see a need. Even just case hardening the wear surfaces would change the wear pattern by a lot. Will the vise wear - sure - will it last years and years - sure. Steel also wears differently than cast iron.

BTW The production vises are heavier than the prototypes.

Re: saw sharpening device

#24

History and DIY jig

paul womack

>OK - so after the training, roughly what tolerance (or variation) do you think your filers are achieving around your target rake?

I'm slightly unclear on wether you're claiming accuracy doesn't matter (much), or wether accuracy is achievable without aids.

BugBear

Re: saw sharpening device

#25

Accuracy

MikeW

>Hi BB,

I obviously cannot speak for Joel, so these are my observations about us.

You need to remember that the bulk of our business is new saws--too busy to sharpen vintage saws except for the odd request or our own (yeah, I am still collecting and rehabbing. It's a sickness I tell ya). So we are starting out with mechanically produced teeth that are in near perfect order. Even on the teeth we hand-cut in using a template, the teeth are remarkably even--but then, I consider a template a mechanical device.

Accuracy, or variance, in these circumstance means something different than rehabbing a vintage saw. In this regard we can claim a high degree of accuracy, or the lack of appreciable variance from the spec'd rake/fleam angles involved.

Sharpening vintage saws without the aid or ability of first mechanically creating "perfect" teeth is where accuracy or variance takes on different meaning. Heck, has meaning at all.

Kris and I are the primary sharpeners here. Either of us produce what I consider acceptable filing on vintage saws without first mechanically creating "perfect" teeth. Neither of us do so with the help of guide-aids. Do we induce variance? Sure we do. How much? No idea as I do not foresee ever attempting to measure it. While I do not believe "accuracy doesn't matter much," neither do I believe accuracy (in the absolute sense) is a desired goal.

I believe consistency in rake and fleam are our goals. Even tooth-tip height and tooth shapes are a goal. Being fit for purpose is a goal. To those ends, we are bloody conscious about maintaining a consistent rake and or fleam angle according the the filing plan--it may suppose to vary from toe to heel. In such a filing plan where variance is a goal, guide-aids are not necessarily useful.

When a vintage saw comes in that needs to be fully hand-filed, we do so using the techniques ubiquitous on the web. Hand sharpening is far more than mere consistent rake and or fleam angles. During the sharpening process of saws in poor tooth condition, decisions are made as to corrective filing needs. A guide-aid would be a great hindrance, unless time was of no consequence.

Consistent tooth-tip height is relatively easy to achieve. But one can still end up with cows & calves as regard tooth base width. Crowding one direction or another is a tooth-by-tooth decision (I consider them tooth pairs). While a guide-aid would help in bringing the base of a tooth more in-line with its neighbors or where it should be all the while maintaining the rake angle during this shaping process, they are relatively cumbersome in use.

All that said, if someone feels that a guide-aid will give them peace of mind or that such a device will be more accurate, if that is what it takes to encourage hand sharpening of one's own saw, I am all for it. To me a guide-aid is no different than a honing guide for chisels and plane blades. I free-hand sharpen those edges, too.

In the end, you may be more accurate than I am on a vintage saw with the use of your guide-aid. I do not know. What I do know is absolute accuracy is not necessary and can be a source of hindrance. Absolute accuracy (even the degree of accuracy a honing guide induces on a chisel) is unobtainable using a guide-aid. It is for certain not obtainable without the use of one.

I think the better questions to ask are "how accurate does rake/fleam on a hand saw need to be," and "is this accuracy with or sans a guide-aid measurable?" If it cannot be measured accurately and reproduced consistently from saw filing to saw filing, why bother?

If one has a full kit of saws, they will (should be) touched up enough if they are used much at all, one will get enough practice in hand saw sharpening to keep adept at it.

Take care, Mike

off to worky...