Accuracy
MikeW
>Hi BB,
I obviously cannot speak for Joel, so these are my observations about us.
You need to remember that the bulk of our business is new saws--too busy to sharpen vintage saws except for the odd request or our own (yeah, I am still collecting and rehabbing. It's a sickness I tell ya). So we are starting out with mechanically produced teeth that are in near perfect order. Even on the teeth we hand-cut in using a template, the teeth are remarkably even--but then, I consider a template a mechanical device.
Accuracy, or variance, in these circumstance means something different than rehabbing a vintage saw. In this regard we can claim a high degree of accuracy, or the lack of appreciable variance from the spec'd rake/fleam angles involved.
Sharpening vintage saws without the aid or ability of first mechanically creating "perfect" teeth is where accuracy or variance takes on different meaning. Heck, has meaning at all.
Kris and I are the primary sharpeners here. Either of us produce what I consider acceptable filing on vintage saws without first mechanically creating "perfect" teeth. Neither of us do so with the help of guide-aids. Do we induce variance? Sure we do. How much? No idea as I do not foresee ever attempting to measure it. While I do not believe "accuracy doesn't matter much," neither do I believe accuracy (in the absolute sense) is a desired goal.
I believe consistency in rake and fleam are our goals. Even tooth-tip height and tooth shapes are a goal. Being fit for purpose is a goal. To those ends, we are bloody conscious about maintaining a consistent rake and or fleam angle according the the filing plan--it may suppose to vary from toe to heel. In such a filing plan where variance is a goal, guide-aids are not necessarily useful.
When a vintage saw comes in that needs to be fully hand-filed, we do so using the techniques ubiquitous on the web. Hand sharpening is far more than mere consistent rake and or fleam angles. During the sharpening process of saws in poor tooth condition, decisions are made as to corrective filing needs. A guide-aid would be a great hindrance, unless time was of no consequence.
Consistent tooth-tip height is relatively easy to achieve. But one can still end up with cows & calves as regard tooth base width. Crowding one direction or another is a tooth-by-tooth decision (I consider them tooth pairs). While a guide-aid would help in bringing the base of a tooth more in-line with its neighbors or where it should be all the while maintaining the rake angle during this shaping process, they are relatively cumbersome in use.
All that said, if someone feels that a guide-aid will give them peace of mind or that such a device will be more accurate, if that is what it takes to encourage hand sharpening of one's own saw, I am all for it. To me a guide-aid is no different than a honing guide for chisels and plane blades. I free-hand sharpen those edges, too.
In the end, you may be more accurate than I am on a vintage saw with the use of your guide-aid. I do not know. What I do know is absolute accuracy is not necessary and can be a source of hindrance. Absolute accuracy (even the degree of accuracy a honing guide induces on a chisel) is unobtainable using a guide-aid. It is for certain not obtainable without the use of one.
I think the better questions to ask are "how accurate does rake/fleam on a hand saw need to be," and "is this accuracy with or sans a guide-aid measurable?" If it cannot be measured accurately and reproduced consistently from saw filing to saw filing, why bother?
If one has a full kit of saws, they will (should be) touched up enough if they are used much at all, one will get enough practice in hand saw sharpening to keep adept at it.
Take care, Mike
off to worky...