Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Just got back from W.I.A.

Posts

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#26

Rambly thoughts

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I don't know that it's gender-specific. I think we can agree that, at least in the English-speaking world, fabric work such as sewing is as heavily skewed toward female practitioners as woodworking is toward male practitioners (I am thinking mainly of the non-professional part of it, which is the focus of our conversation, I think). Googling "sewing patterns" brings me over 4 million listings - I'm sure there are a lot of folks sewing out there who would never design a shirt/dress/whatever, and who find the idea intimidating (I grant that, as I understand it, the development of a clothing pattern makes the development of the design for a lowboy look easy; the human body is not rectilinear, and cloth doesn't hold still, so the designer is dealing not just with three dimensions, but with dimensions that change as the wearer moves).

I think part of the difficulty is that design combines an emotional* aspect and an analytical one. One can conceive of a design that would be quite interesting and satisfying emotionally, but if the details of the design aren't carried out right, the piece will be ugly. Graham Blackburn did a series of articles in one of the magazines some years back (I want to say either American Woodworker or Popular Woodworking - maybe Ellis remembers if it was AW), in which he showed a piece of furniture he'd designed and then discussed his decisions about width of stiles, shadow lines, etc., as they supported the aesthetic aspects of the design. Starting, I think, with Krenov, more attention has been paid in the non-professional literature to the ways that grain should support the shapes in the design, such as the curvature of wood grain in rails and stiles of doors. I've found these sorts of articles quite helpful as I struggle to develop a sense of design.

The emotional element is trickier. Part of it is fashion, of course; LOML and I are bemused, to put it mildly, when 20- and 30-somethings get all excited about kitchen tables with chrome metal legs and red formica, which we think are ugly as mudpuppies. The viewer brings to the piece all his/her history and cultural influences, and pieces that were once the height of good taste get relegated to the garage. At one time, we had in our bathroom a print from my grandmother's house of a little girl giving her doll a bath. The basin rests on a hexagonal chinoiserie stand, and the little girl's outfit dates from a period after chinoiserie had gone out of fashion - since the stand was no longer desirable in the living room, holding a plant, it had been relegated to the nursery.

Nevertheless, as demonstrated by furniture in museums everywhere, there are pieces whose design holds up in spite of the winds of fashion. I suspect that the pieces that succeed long-term are those in which the emotional design decisions are implemented by sound analytical decisions, both visual and mechanical. Getting to harmony between the emotional and analytical elements of the process is hard work, and even some quite famous people don't do it well (as witnessed by just about every Frank Lloyd Wright house, which may [or may not, not everyone likes them] be aesthetically pleasing, but is usually an engineering disaster). No wonder people look for plans they can follow.

*Not sure this is quite the right word, and Word's thesaurus didn't help much; but I deliberately didn't want to use "aesthetic," because the word has come to have some value-judgment connotations.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#27

Re: furniture design chatter

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The little bit of work I've tried in Sketchup has reminded me of the old truism that the technology supports but also limits the design. If it's easier to draw a straight line and angles, less asymmetrical work is done.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#28

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

dave Jeske

>Roy,

It was good to see you. Hope the chisels work out well for you.

Wish I found some really good food (or coffee) while I was there.

The show was a lot of fun. Anyone thinking about going to the PA should really plan on it.

Dave

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#29

I like the smell of WD40....

John in NM

>But then I like the smell of gear oil too, so there's no accounting for taste ;)

WD 40 is available as a non-aerosol, though it can be hard to find that way at the hardware store. I also use whatever brand of thin penetrating oil is at the store, like liquid wrench or something. I've used 3-1 oil for honing, find it just a little too thick for my tastes, can't imagine using something as gooey as olive oil! I imagine its just a matter of what one is used to, like sooooo many other facets of this hobby!

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#30

Re: I like the smell of WD40....

Dan Donaldson

>I don't mind the smell either, but I don't think that I would want to cook with it. ;-)

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#31

Re: I like the smell of WD40....

Marv

>We like the smell too. We keep a can of it on the night stand.

Marv

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#32

Re: furniture design chatter

Monty Bates

>I read all of the posts here but very very rarely ever contribute anything. Pam's observation on design hits home with me at this point in time. I am just in the very first stage of restoring a Barber Chair from the late 1890's. After looking at it closely I have decided to just replace all of the woodwork instead of trying to restore what's there. It's oak with carvings on it. Since I have to replace the wood I thought why not enhance the design instead of just copying it. That's where I have a big problem. I don't know a darn thing about what is basically a Victorian design. If you were to ask me to outline the basics of Queen Anne or any of the other "popular" designs I could probably put together something passable. Victorian? Don't hold your breath! I don't have a clue! So yes Pam, we probably do more studying of design than any of us that try to stray off an existing design than we care to admit.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#33

Re: furniture design chatter

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, exactly; but I have to declare a financial interest here. The Sketchup people tricked me into paying $400 for SU by putting it on sale 2 or 3 weeks before Google gave it away for free. Oh, they didn't know? Bah! I'm a less than happy camper. :)

Pam

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#34

Re: furniture design chatter

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>That's cool, Monty. So why do you want Victorian? Why not take what's salvageable and design something that looks good surrounding it? Assuming a tight design to start with, that might turn out to be more Victorian than you'd planned.

Pam

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#35

Tradition vs. fusion

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>There's a lot to be said for respecting the traditions of a particular furniture period - acanthus leaves for carvings of a period when acanthus leaves were standard, for instance. It sounds like this is what Monty's thinking about.

There's a lot to be said for introducing new elements to a furniture design in a way that respects the design's traditions. This sounds like what Pam's thinking about.

It's like pure music vs. fusion. I really respect the people who are playing pure bluegrass, classical, traditional-culture, etc., and enjoy a lot of the music produced; I really enjoy a lot of music that combines several different traditions. I don't think my enjoyment of both approaches is contradictory.

The tricky part is doing fusion with taste. When LOML and I stay at hotels where they buy their furniture from a designer, she has to put up with my critique of the furniture. Interestingly, there seems to be an inverse correlation here: above a certain price point, you can almost guarantee that the furniture should be burned immediately. More modest places have simpler furniture that at least isn't offensively ugly.

Although I don't want to imply this is Monty's motivation, I think a lot of us fear that, if we try our own designs, we'll fall into building furniture that belongs in more expensive hotels/motels - that is, the ugly stuff. Sticking to someone else's plans seems safer.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#36

Re: furniture design chatter

Monty Bates

>Pam, some Barber Chairs from this era were really very complicated designs. Google Berninghaus Hercules Barber Chair to see an example that I would like to capture the flavor of. In this day and age it's almost impossible to imagine sitting in something like it just for a haircut. The chair isn't for me by the way, it's for my daughter & son in law who have a very successful company in that business. A surprise gift from me to them. My problem is how does one even begin to design something I would describe as over the top to say the least.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#37

Re: furniture design chatter

wilbur

>Hi Pam,

With most of the guys in my woodworking club, I think it is really an overall discomfort with design issues, period. A lot of them can join wood flawlessly, but talk to them about design and you can see the deer-in-the-headlights look.

The guy I knew who needed to change the dimensions, he really just wanted the piece to fit in the spot where it was going to be placed. There really wasn't much consideration as to how much the new vertical:horizontal ratio would affect the look of the piece -- much more consideration was spent on making sure that he adjusted the size of all the horizontal members accordingly.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#38

Re: Chisels and sharpening

Michael Brady

>I didn't see this answer posted yet: L-N was using Shapton glass stones for their sharpening demos at WIA. Apparently they are now recommending jojoba oil instead of water on those stones; although, I did not notice that myself. Their marketing is as sharp as their plane irons.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#39

It strikes me that you have an opportunity

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>unless you want something historically correct, this might be an opportunity to think about barber-related images and images related to your daughter and son in law, draw freely, and see how over the top you can get.

You may say, "I can't draw." I can't either, but I've done some images by tracing.

As I said in my other, related post, though, this IS kind of scary. An alternative is to print out several of the images that come up with you google those chairs and design from those.

They look like great chairs, and you'll get MAJOR dad points for delivering that chair.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#40

Reminds me of a 80's Y&T video...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>That's Yesterday & Today to you youngins'. Summertime girls was the song/video. Loved the tough girls at the beach using 30 weight as suntan oil. Yummy!

Yea, I remember when gas was pink and smelled good too...

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#41

I'll disagree...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Design is my first concern. How are you gonna make anything with out a starting point? After all that's what's it all about.

You have to design a box to make one. Whether DT, box jointed, or end nailed.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#42

Re: I'll disagree...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I really don't understand you. How can you say you disagree when I just said roughly the same thing?

Pam

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#43

Re: furniture design chatter

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I stand corrected. I never have the opportunity to talk with anyone but Jack and Paul, the builder across the street, about design issues, and then it's on a workshop/studio level, not furniture.

Pam

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#44

Re: furniture design chatter

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Sure looks over the top to me, too. Somehow or other you need to design something that will complement all that brass. Looks like you've got to redo the sides, pedestal, and legs. Maybe the grain and shape could work without that grotesque carving? Maybe a wood besides oak? That way the brass and leather could be more prominent; and the wooden supporting pieces could be just that.

Pam

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#45

Re: Rambly thoughts

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>True, designing clothing is much more difficult than furniture, with the possible exception of a custom fitting chair. At least with sewing you can drape the person.

Generally I've profited from reading/watching Blackburn's work.

As to retro kitchen design, kids are sold that nostalgia. Point of fact, some of it was beautiful and holds up today, just not the stuff the middle class suburbanites tended to have.

I'll go along with an emotional/analytical mix, sounds reasonable.

Do you mean that some people, on hearing the you use the word "aesthetic," have negatively judged you? I'm real tired of the seeming proliferation of intentionally stupid people. I used to try to accommodate them, but we simply can't afford that anymore.

Pam

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#46

Miscommunication?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>It's possible Scott read your first, italicized line quoting Wilbur Pan as your own message, Pam, and thought it was the thrust of your post. Your true point and Scott's do, indeed, seem like slightly different statements of the same point.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#47

Re: furniture design chatter

Monty Bates

>Actually there was no brass. One would think it would be brass but in reality it was Nickel Plated, something that has virtually vanished from the scene these days. I managed to purchase a reprint of a 1891 Barber Supply catalog which shows many other chairs so it's a good source of ideas. One easily forgets just how decorative things were made back in those days. The Stanley 41,42,43 and 44 Plow Planes are pretty good examples in woodworking. I have the 41 & 42 and must confess that sometimes I look at them and wish that attention to design were present in some modern tools. I find this project certainly out of the norm but you know the possibilities of what one can do with all that gingerbread is really kind of refreshing.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#48

Re: Tradition vs. fusion

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>There's a lot to be said for introducing new elements to a furniture design in a way that respects the design's traditions. This sounds like what Pam's thinking about.

That's certainly what I was trying to say. You did it better.

The fusion I like most is country-rock, say "Lay Lady Lay."

No one wants to be ridiculed about something they've bought and/or designed and built. Just human nature. But we have to get over that to get beyond "me too" behavior and taste.

Pam

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#49

I winced when you said "Victorian." :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#50

Clarification

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"Do you mean that some people, on hearing the you use the word 'aesthetic,' have negatively judged you?"

No, I meant that when we speak of something as being "well done aesthetically," for instance, there's often a value judgment there - an assumption that it meets certain criteria established by some arbiter somewhere. I wanted to avoid that implication, so chose another word.