Rambly thoughts
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>I don't know that it's gender-specific. I think we can agree that, at least in the English-speaking world, fabric work such as sewing is as heavily skewed toward female practitioners as woodworking is toward male practitioners (I am thinking mainly of the non-professional part of it, which is the focus of our conversation, I think). Googling "sewing patterns" brings me over 4 million listings - I'm sure there are a lot of folks sewing out there who would never design a shirt/dress/whatever, and who find the idea intimidating (I grant that, as I understand it, the development of a clothing pattern makes the development of the design for a lowboy look easy; the human body is not rectilinear, and cloth doesn't hold still, so the designer is dealing not just with three dimensions, but with dimensions that change as the wearer moves).
I think part of the difficulty is that design combines an emotional* aspect and an analytical one. One can conceive of a design that would be quite interesting and satisfying emotionally, but if the details of the design aren't carried out right, the piece will be ugly. Graham Blackburn did a series of articles in one of the magazines some years back (I want to say either American Woodworker or Popular Woodworking - maybe Ellis remembers if it was AW), in which he showed a piece of furniture he'd designed and then discussed his decisions about width of stiles, shadow lines, etc., as they supported the aesthetic aspects of the design. Starting, I think, with Krenov, more attention has been paid in the non-professional literature to the ways that grain should support the shapes in the design, such as the curvature of wood grain in rails and stiles of doors. I've found these sorts of articles quite helpful as I struggle to develop a sense of design.
The emotional element is trickier. Part of it is fashion, of course; LOML and I are bemused, to put it mildly, when 20- and 30-somethings get all excited about kitchen tables with chrome metal legs and red formica, which we think are ugly as mudpuppies. The viewer brings to the piece all his/her history and cultural influences, and pieces that were once the height of good taste get relegated to the garage. At one time, we had in our bathroom a print from my grandmother's house of a little girl giving her doll a bath. The basin rests on a hexagonal chinoiserie stand, and the little girl's outfit dates from a period after chinoiserie had gone out of fashion - since the stand was no longer desirable in the living room, holding a plant, it had been relegated to the nursery.
Nevertheless, as demonstrated by furniture in museums everywhere, there are pieces whose design holds up in spite of the winds of fashion. I suspect that the pieces that succeed long-term are those in which the emotional design decisions are implemented by sound analytical decisions, both visual and mechanical. Getting to harmony between the emotional and analytical elements of the process is hard work, and even some quite famous people don't do it well (as witnessed by just about every Frank Lloyd Wright house, which may [or may not, not everyone likes them] be aesthetically pleasing, but is usually an engineering disaster). No wonder people look for plans they can follow.
*Not sure this is quite the right word, and Word's thesaurus didn't help much; but I deliberately didn't want to use "aesthetic," because the word has come to have some value-judgment connotations.



