Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Just got back from W.I.A.

Posts

Just got back from W.I.A.

#1

Just got back from W.I.A.

Roy Anderson

>Just got back from the Woodworking in America conference. Had a great time. Good speakers. Learned a little about the history of furniture, details of various styles of furniture etc. Bought a set of chisels from Blue Spruce Tools (my sinful indulgence!). Ate way too much good food. Got some great pointers on sharpening at the Lie Nielsen booth.

If you didn't go, Nya, Nya, Nya!!!

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#2

Chisels and sharpening

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Roy,

Thanks for the post--you're the first to write in on WWIA. Which of the Blue Spruce did you get? The dovetail chisels or the longer ones?

Also, am curious about specifics on the sharpening tips. It's interesting how there is always another thing to learn about sharpening.

Wiley

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#3

Re: Chisels and sharpening

Roy Anderson

>I got a set of 4 little delicate dovetail chisels.

The sharpening tips were:

1. Put a thin steel ruler on the sharpening stone and hone the back of the blade using the thin ruler to elevate the blade slightly to flatten only a small part of the back. Makes things go faster than trying to flatten a large area. I think I've seen this tip in something that David Charlesworth wrote also.

2. With bevel up blades it is even more critical to hone with a honing guide because variations in the bevel make a noticeable change in the performance of the plane. It looks like I'm going to have to give up the free hand honing. Rats!

3. They were using ceramic stones with jojoba oil, not water stones. I've got to try that. Water stones do a great job, but it's a hassel to keep them flat.

4. Jojoba oil is just as good as Camilla oil. They are both non-oxidizing veg oils. I've got to look that up and see what other (cheap!)veg oils are non-oxidizing. I wonder if cotton seed oil or peanut oil will work just as well--another subject for research.

5. Wipe down your tools with Jojoba oil when you are through. They are really pushing the Jojoba oil, because it is harvested in New Mexico, USA. What am I supposed to do with all that Camilla oil I got?

5. In Spanish Jojoba is pronounced Hohoba. I would still rather use something named Jo rather than something named Ho on my beautiful plane blades!

6. Lie Nielsen has a demonstration of this on You Tube. I've got to try to find that.

By the way, I've read that in Japan, Camilla oil is just cheap cooking oil, sold by the gallon. I wonder if anyone else ever read that. And WD-40 doesn't have silicone in it. It works just fine also. Just look up their web site if you don't believe me.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#4

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

wilbur

>I had posted the following on the main WC message board, since it really didn't have much hand tool content:

I was able to spend Friday at the Woodworking in America Furniture Construction and Design Conference in the Chicagoland area. Today is the only day I was able to go, and I really wish I could spend the rest of the weekend to attend the rest of the sessions.

I was able to attend some really excellent talks on the evolution of American furniture styles in the 18th century, the transition of woodworking operations from hand techniques to the machine age, joinery considerations in early American casework, and part of a survey of the Arts and Crafts movement. All the talks were excellent, but the talk by Jeffery Greene on the types of 18th century American furniture styles really was outstanding.

It seems to me that among us woodworkers, learning and understanding design issues may be second only to finishing as the least favorite aspect of woodworking there is. I know that I would rather talk about techniques, like the best way to make dovetails, or the pros and cons of various planes. But along with a better understanding of the historic aspects of furniture, I've come to realize that understanding the design aspects of furniture actually will help me with the actual making of furniture in the future.

Unless you happen to be in the Chicago area this weekend, it's not going to be feasible to go to this conference, but if you are, get a one day pass or sign up for single sessions if you can. This conference didn't get the same buzz as the WIA hand tools conference in Berea last year, but in many ways I think I got more out of the one day that I was able to attend this conference.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#5

Re: furniture design chatter

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>It seems to me that among us woodworkers, learning and understanding design issues may be second only to finishing as the least favorite aspect of woodworking there is.

Assuming that I'm not that unusual a woodworker, I'd suggest that many woodworkers spend a lot of time with furniture design. We just don't often talk about it.

Pam

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#6

Jeffrey Greene's design lecture

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Wilbur!

Was it your impression that the different Period styles evolved for economic reasons, changing functional requirements, and changing aesthetics--and each new aesthetic style then created a set of design problems (cross grain, joint strength) which had to be solved? Or did the Period styles evolve, in part, as a way to overcome design problems with the previous style?

I'm thinking about such things as the evolution from case goods which stood on those elaborate turned legs in the William and Mary style, to later case goods which stood on Queen Anne legs or short/stout bracket feet.

Tell us a specific!

Wiley

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#7

Re: Chisels and sharpening

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks for the additional detail, Roy!

Dave Jeske really makes useful tools. I have a 3/8" dovetail chisel by Dave Jeske and that chisel is never far away. It is the very thing for fine details, because it is so fine-boned itself. I really need to get the 1/4" and 1/8" ones.

What kinda ceramic stones were the LN folks using with Jojoba oil? I always think of ceramic stones as wanting water (e.g., Shapton).

Did you observe any of the sawing competition, or other competitions?

Wiley

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#8

Re: sharpening tips

Edward in Vancouver

>I believe olive oil is chemically identical to camilia oil. As someone who has worked in professional kitchens for over 25 years, I can attest that most vegetable oils--other than olive and walnut, gum up very quickly when exposed to air.

Gawd knows how many hollowed out cheap waterstones I've found in kitchens-all perfectly useless because they were gummed up. The only way to get rid of this is the same method to remove dead protien from soup bones: You place the item in a pot of cold water and slowly bring to a boil, and repeat if necesary. Alot of the stones were so gummed up that even this didn't help

That being said, I haven't used ANY oil on my edge tools, and I only get surface rust if I haven't wiped a chisel or iron perfectly dry afer using a waterstone.

So, extra virgin or pomace? Who really knows what those olives do at night anyway?.....

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#9

Re: furniture design chatter

Roy Anderson

>Pam, you have a valid point. This message board is all about hand tools so that's what people tend to talk about, not that there aren't a certain fraction of O.T. messages. If it were a furniture design message board, there would probably be a lot of discussion about furniture design.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#10

assumptions...

paul womack

>Assuming that I'm not that unusual a woodworker,

Hmmm.

BugBear

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#11

Re: furniture design chatter

wilbur

>Hi Pam,

It may be that those who participate on woodworking internet forums are a self-selecting group. I'm basing my observation on the following experiences:

-- In my woodworking club, most members really are not comfortable with with the design aspects of woodworking. They much prefer making a copy of a piece of furniture from plans, or if they are making a change in a plan, it tends to be strictly dimensional changes, like making a chest of drawers a little narrower to get it to fit into a particular spot in their house. One of my good friends here in New Jersey, who is a phenomenal woodworker, has told me that he just thinks that the design aspect of making a piece of furniture is really not something he has ever been able to do. This is a guy who can make a flawless reproduction of a Federal style piece of furniture, inlays and all.

-- The relative popularity of design type articles in woodworking magazines, vs., say, tool reviews, or how to make a particular joint articles. Even in those articles that detail the making of a Queen Anne style lowboy, for example, my feeling is that most readers will faithfully copy the plans, with the only changes being minor dimensional changes, as I mentioned above.

-- The relative popularity and internet buzz of the WIA hand tools conference compared to the WIA furniture design conference. Although I think that the WIA furniture design conference was quite successful, the overall numbers of attendees seemed to be less than the WIA hand tools conference last year. Most internet chatter about the WIA furniture design conference has centered around the marketplace, or going to the marketplace, not the talks themselves.

It also could be that we are using the word "design" in different ways. In this context, I'm using "design" to be more on the aesthetic choices that are made in a piece of furniture, although I'm fully aware that design does cover the technical aspects as well.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#12

Olive oil

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>similar in composition. A refined olive oil would be best. But, I don't see any advantage over WD-40 which I find best for diamond sharpening.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#13

agreed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>And I like finishing too. Maybe if people devoted as much time to practicing finishing as they do to , say learning to carve, their finishing would be more successful and they would like it better.?. Buying a spray gun helps too...........

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#14

mahogany

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Mahogany enabled the design of 18th and 19 furniture. As always fashion drove design; materials and technology enabled it.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#15

not identical....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>but close enough for woodworkers.

One can remove vegetable oils and animal fat from stones the same way soap is made. Boil in lye. I guess that would turn the "oil" stone into "soap" stone. (I shouldn't attempt humor before becoming fully awake.)

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#16

Re: Jeffrey Greene's design lecture

wilbur

>In Jefferey Greene's talk, it seemed to me that most of the influences driving the style evolution from William & Mary --> Queen Anne --> Chippendale --> Federal style furniture were primarily aesthetic influences, and that they came from all areas: the art world on the European continent, cyclic interest in Asian styles, or even just a stylistic reaction to what had come before. Publication of style catalogs from designers like Chippendale, Adam, Hepplewhite and Sheraton helped spread these aesthetic changes quickly through Europe and America.

There were some economic and political considerations as well. The end of Puritan rule in England with the restoration of Charles II to the throne in 1660 and the Great London Fire in 1666 combined a stylistic backlash against Puritan ideals and a need to make a lot of furniture for people who had lost theirs in the fire, both of which led to the development and adoption of the William & Mary style. Also, from time to time there were embargoes on what wood could be shipped into the colonies, which explains why walnut is so popular some times, and mahogany so popular at other times. These coincided with the placing and lifting of embargoes of the importation of wood from the Caribbean into America.

The only woodworking technology issue that really seemed to be important to this process was the adoption of dovetail joinery. This allowed furniture makers to move away from frame and panel construction in Jacobean furniture, and to make lighter and stronger boxes, which led to taller pieces and the ability to put a lot of drawers into a chest. Beyond that, there didn't seem to be many woodworking technology design issues, like cross grain and joint strength, that were that important in this process. Things like the development of the Baroque and Rococo styles in the art world were much more influential.

For example, the Queen Anne leg was primarily the result of contemporary French styles, an interest in Chinese furniture at the time, plus a little Flemish influence. The only woodworking technology issues to be solved in this leg is to make sure that the grain runs the right way, and to not make certain parts of the leg too narrow. It's clear that furniture makers of the time pushed these limits. When they pushed too hard, those legs became firewood. But it's not like that the relatively thicker legs of the Chippendale period that followed were made because Queen Anne legs consistently failed. You could put a relatively massive looking Chippendale high chest on Queen Anne legs and it would hold up. It just wouldn't look right. Likewise, the more powerful, sinewy ball-and-claw feet that were part of the Chippendale style demands a more aesthetically substantial leg than what was popular in the Queen Anne period.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#17

Re: Olive oil advantage

wilbur

>Olive oil smells nicer than WD-40. :@)

There's also potential respiratory issues with WD-40.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#18

oil

paul womack

>I can attest that most vegetable oils--other than olive and walnut, gum up very quickly when exposed to air.

That's odd - walnut is often listed as being polymerising to the extent it can be used as a finish, similarly to linseed.

BugBear

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#19

Re: agreed

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Oh, yeah, I spent my teen years refinishing stuff, great fun and great results.

Pam

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#20

Re: furniture design chatter

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Maybe your ww club friends just aren't tutored in the design language, therefore they feel a little uncomfortable. That guy who needed to resize an item was probably very concerned about how it would look, just didn't know how to talk about it. Maybe you're right, might be a guy thing not to discuss design issues as such.

Me? I walk around redesigning the world. Between that and constant internal visuals I use to rewrite the world, it's hard to pay attention to where I am at any given time. In fact, I walk at night a lot which seems to alleviate some of this, with my monster pooch to keep me focused. "Hey, Pam," he says every time he chases small animal, "wake up! Here, I'll help." :)

Pam

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#21

?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#22

Re: Olive oil

ThomD

>I don't know, is WD40 something you would eat, take a bath in or put in your hair. Camelia oil is nice to be around, WD40 sees mostly the machine shop side of my shop where the day start by me putting on rubber gloves. Still maybe not that bad since the developer of water displacement oild formula 40 jsut died recently of advanced old age. I am still working my way through the first small bottle of C oil I bought 30 years ago. I think it is far from necesarry to put it on every time one uses a tool, I just use it if I get the tool wet, which doesn't happen all that often, might depend a lot on where you work though.

I used walnut oil occasionally, the stuff without anti-oxidants is pretty good drying oil. Only problem is at some level it can harden off into a film WD40 and CO are nice in that they seem to stay put, but don't seem to cause problems.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#23

Re: Chisels and sharpening

ThomD

>"2. With bevel up blades it is even more critical to hone with a honing guide because variations in the bevel make a noticeable change in the performance of the plane. It looks like I'm going to have to give up the free hand honing. Rats!"

That sounds a little overwrought to me, how big an angle change are we talking here? A tenth of a degree, a degree? I'm waiting for the blind tests on that one. My feeling is the same joker who can't tell the difference in hand sharpening results within a gross amount, can't tell the difference in cutting either. If you're that good (or bad), you're that good (or bad).

For instance a half degree over a .5" bezel is 4 thou +. That is gross. I can easily tell whether I have the bezel flat to the stone, or one corner is jacked up on a playing card. So having an varience of .5 degrees would be very gross, is that really a problem in bevel up planing?

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#24

Re: furniture design chatter

ThomD

>I tend to think not. No design forum here. Design books are relatively rare from within the woodworking fied. And the same newbies who can't sharpen have not even conceived, normally of doing their own design. Where is our version of this:

http://www.boatdesign.net/forums/

In my case, in the real world, I tend to be a little shy about tooting my horn, even when the only person listening (usualy) is me. But when I got started in all this stuff 30+ years ago, There was one egotistical impulse. I was a little embarassed at the menial nature of craft, and decided I would design everything starting with my first big project, a canoe. I don't always do the design since it always comes down to production vs craft, there are times when I want something and I just copy it, but normally I do the design also. I really don't think this is comon. I can reliably design you a boat, bike, small structure, tooling, etc... I design furniture, but I don't really know the rules, because it is rarely discussed.

About 15 years ago, I thought we were going through a craft revolution in which design was the new frontier, and it is true to some extent. Craftsmen were growing up and taking on new challenges, and powerful tools, like CAD and FE were becoming widely available. So it seems more part of the scene than ever before, but it also didn't really move ahead. Mostly we are still 95% project dominated, and a lot of that is badly designed. I'm not counting horrid design here. There are people who will knock stuff off that is really awful without any thought, and that is great, but it doesn't spring from their love and depth of exposure to design.

One can discuss design by the numbers in something like boats. There is an aesthetic component, but there is also a lot of stuff that is pretty scientific, and can be shared. One problem with furniture design is that people won't discuss it honestly because they don't want a flame war, or to be rude. Taste is individual, and the odd time a design has been discussed here, people normally gush, yet there is no chance they would actually go out and buy the thing being discussed. So what is the point. There would be a point in discussing the design underpinings in the western (or otherwise) canon. I read a book on it once that expanded my mostly zero base. That kind of thing would be worth while and factual.

Re: Just got back from W.I.A.

#25

Re: furniture design chatter

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I think maybe CAD programs have stunted design activity by non-professionals. Sketchup is pretty close to simple to use, but even it is tedious and obscure at times. Best things for amateur designers are the ability to visualize, paper, and pencil/pen.

Pam