Re: furniture design chatter
ThomD
>I tend to think not. No design forum here. Design books are relatively rare from within the woodworking fied. And the same newbies who can't sharpen have not even conceived, normally of doing their own design. Where is our version of this:
http://www.boatdesign.net/forums/
In my case, in the real world, I tend to be a little shy about tooting my horn, even when the only person listening (usualy) is me. But when I got started in all this stuff 30+ years ago, There was one egotistical impulse. I was a little embarassed at the menial nature of craft, and decided I would design everything starting with my first big project, a canoe. I don't always do the design since it always comes down to production vs craft, there are times when I want something and I just copy it, but normally I do the design also. I really don't think this is comon. I can reliably design you a boat, bike, small structure, tooling, etc... I design furniture, but I don't really know the rules, because it is rarely discussed.
About 15 years ago, I thought we were going through a craft revolution in which design was the new frontier, and it is true to some extent. Craftsmen were growing up and taking on new challenges, and powerful tools, like CAD and FE were becoming widely available. So it seems more part of the scene than ever before, but it also didn't really move ahead. Mostly we are still 95% project dominated, and a lot of that is badly designed. I'm not counting horrid design here. There are people who will knock stuff off that is really awful without any thought, and that is great, but it doesn't spring from their love and depth of exposure to design.
One can discuss design by the numbers in something like boats. There is an aesthetic component, but there is also a lot of stuff that is pretty scientific, and can be shared. One problem with furniture design is that people won't discuss it honestly because they don't want a flame war, or to be rude. Taste is individual, and the odd time a design has been discussed here, people normally gush, yet there is no chance they would actually go out and buy the thing being discussed. So what is the point. There would be a point in discussing the design underpinings in the western (or otherwise) canon. I read a book on it once that expanded my mostly zero base. That kind of thing would be worth while and factual.