Who sharpens saws well?
Joe Shelton
>I can't find, via a Search, any unequivocal list of good saw sharpeners. All I know now is that I'm not good enough to suit myself...
Can anyone recommend a professional saw sharpener?
Joe
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Who sharpens saws well?
Joe Shelton
>I can't find, via a Search, any unequivocal list of good saw sharpeners. All I know now is that I'm not good enough to suit myself...
Can anyone recommend a professional saw sharpener?
Joe
Tagging on...Japanese Saws too??
Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level
>I have a Dozuki saw that needs work. So I'm also looking for a good saw sharpener, and one who is good with Japanese saws? Might be one in the same as the referrences Joe is seeking? Let me know. Thanks.
Tom
Re: Tagging on...Japanese Saws too??
Howard Pollack
>Here is a link to Daiku Dojo re: Mark Grable- the only one I know who does this. -Howard
Re: Who sharpens saws well?
ThomD
>Are you looking for a western style? Tom Law did the best saw I have, though someone mentioned he is out of it.
Cooke's
Jack Guzman from Maine
>Adria Tools,who makes good quality handsaws recommends this place. I haven't tried them but I own two Adria backsaws and can tell you that they are first class.---Jack
Cooke's Sharpening & Grinding, Inc.
3331 W. Market St.
York, PA 17404
Phone: (717) 793-9527
Get a file and give it a try!
Alan DuBoff
>Joe,
Get a file for about $5 and give it a try. You will be surprised at how easy it is to get your saw sharp.
Sharpening a handsaw is akin to sharpening chisel and hand plane irons, IMO. At least speaking for myself, I feel that sharpening is a skill that all woodworkers should possess. Don't let anyone lead you to believe otherwise. My $0.02
Cheers,
Alan
Re: Who sharpens saws well?.....I do
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Hi Joe,
I sharpen western type saws.
email me directly.
Marv
Re: Tagging on...Japanese Saws too?? *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Thomas,
I have had excellent work done by Mark Grable--my Mitsukawa 270mm rip dozuki came back better than factory. If you hire Mark, make sure you have an understanding as to schedule--when you'll get your saw back.
The best option in Japan is Heiji-san, with So Yamashita acting as go-between. So's website is linked below. So-san is overwhelmed by business, so if you write, be sure and put the word Heiji in the subject line. I have a saw made by Heiji, and his metate is superb. I have a friend who recently sent a well-known maker's _new_ saws to be reworked by Heiji, with good results.
Re: Who sharpens saws well?
Ray Binnicker
>I've used Cooke's service (mentioned above). I am very pleased with his ability, and his price. I will use him again.
Ray Binnicker
Not exactly. . .
Tony Sade (Charleston, WV)
>This may be old information, but I think that Steve Cooke, at least as far as sharpening goes, is out on his own. I had him do a saw for me about 6 months ago and his address then was:
Steve Cooke
1160 Taxville Rd.
York, PA 17408
Phone 717-779-8632
If this is out of date or no longer true, my apologies.
Tony
Thanks
Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level
>I appreciate the leads. Both look like good resources. Much appreciated!
Tom
Re: Get a file and give it a try!
Mike in Florida
>I agree. I've done a few rip saws of my own now and am getting better with each one. Just did a cross cut saw; at least it was better than before the sharpening. Will keep practicing as long as I keep finding cheap Disstons at garage sales.
Re: Get a file and give it a try!
Alan DuBoff
>Good for you Mike!
The hardest thing is getting over the fear, and doing it. Once most people realize that:
1) it is not that difficult (albeit seems awkward at first).
2) in most all cases leaves the saw sharper than it started, even if the teeth are not perfect.
3) it is pretty darn hard to ruin a saw.
They tend to get more comfortable with it, and as you are seeing, it starts growing...you start out sharpening a rip saw, next move on to xcut, pretty soon getting more saws and/or tuning them up is not out of the question.
It is funny to see people fret over a $100-$150 saw like it is some sacred object. It is only a tool, nobody should have fear of sharpening their own saw any more than they would their chisels or hand planes.
Again, good for you Mike! You are learning a skill that every craftsman who uses handsaws should know how to do.
Regards,
Alan
harder
paul womack
>Sharpening a handsaw is akin to sharpening chisel and hand plane irons,
I would rate it a good deal more difficult than that, and you need more than a 5 dollar file.
A saw vise and set are also essential.
I would rate the difficulty of sharpening a saw roughly comparable with planing a 2 foot by 8 inch board fairly accurately flat.
I think that many people would indeed enjoy sharpening their own saws - having to spend 20-30 bucks to get a 2 dollar yard-sale Diston into working order sours the bargain considerably.
But it's not a trivial task. Doable, by all means, but not trivial.
BugBear (speaking from experience)
It is much harder
Pedder
>because there are no jigs to help you.
A friend just shipped a saw to work out his first tries in sharpening a 15ppi saw. I'll have to retooth it. So if someone wants to learn to sharpening saws he'll better gets a cheap one for the first steps. My sharpening skills improved dramatically after the first four saws.
Cheers
Pedder
Re: harder
John Pappas
>For those who may give it a try for the first time, I offer this from my own learning experience. I believe it is absolutly essential to have the right light. If you can't see the flats created by the jointing process you probably won't succeed. If you can clearly see them you have made one giant step in the right direction. I describe myself as a rookie at this, but I have been happy with my results.
harder
paul womack
> first tries in sharpening a 15ppi saw.
Not a good place to start!
BugBear
Re: harder
wilbur
>I've been learning on really rusty saws. The advantage is that the contrast between the rust and the filed areas make it really easy to see how your filing is going.
The second advantage is that no matter how bad a job you do, it will be better than how the saw was when you got it.
Re: harder...AMEN!........(long)
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Hi Bugbear,
I totally agree with you. May I add a few "general" comments?
Takes a lot more than a file to properly sharpen a handsaw..absolutely!
This thread was started with Joe asking for information about someone who sharpens a saw "well". He also indicated that he was not satisfied with his own efforts. So, he has already grabbed a file and tried it.
Looks like all he wants is to have a saw that cuts as it should so he can get on with doing the things he would rather do. He no doubt realized early on that the process is just a bit more involved than sharpening a chisel.
Most people have a knack for something. Some people have a knack for filing saws and find it easy to learn, while others don't.
Some people have a knack for learning to play a musical instrument while others don't. And so it goes with countless endeavors.
To compare sharpening a handsaw to sharpening a chisel is very missleading for someone who might want to learn to file their saws.
It is not true that after filing a saw it's going to be sharper than before, well, maybe it will have pointed teeth, but that doesn't mean anything if one wants the saw to actually cut wood.
A saw might feel sharp to the touch, but that doesn't mean the teeth have been filed with the proper rake and fleam angles and the right amount of set for the type wood being cut.
We often hear it said that a hand sharpened saw is better than a machine sharpened saw because the teeth are not filed as consistantly. IMO this is just an excuse for not being able to hand file the teeth even and all the same. A saw will cut best when each tooth is doing an equal amount of the work.
I like what I read on one of the forums when discussing the subject of filing your own saws...Quote:"the reason I don't file my own saws is the same reason I don't make my own plywood". End quote; Now, that's not the best comparison, but it does make a good point.
I have no argument with encouraging anyone to learn to sharpen their own saws, however, so they don't become discouraged as soon as they get started, it is only fair to make them aware of some of the basics and not lead them to think it is as easy as grabbing a file and trying it. Probably 75% of the saws I get have been filed by someone who just grabbed a file and tried it.
It's amazing how badly many saws are filed. With some, it is obvious that the same person had been filing it for a long time because it takes a lot of filing to make a tooth edge look like a roller coaster. The person who did the filing probably thought they were really good at it and probably thought it cut just fine. They probably never used a saw that was actually filed properly in order to experience what it feels like to use a properly filed saw.
This subject reminds me of some people I've been in certain learning classes with who would brag about how easy the final exams were, how they "aced" it, how easy it was. Well, fine, but it wasn't easy for everyone and that usually included me. All that kind of strutting and boasting does, is make others feel stupid. The point is, just because one person finds it easy to do a particular thing, doesn't mean that it is easy and simple for everyone else.
Just some general thoughts...
Marv
Re: harder
Mike Bridger
>A trick I learned from Daryl Weir (who sharpens saws expertly): coat the teeth with layout fluid. This makes it easier to see the flats on top of the teeth as you file.
I just don't see the difficulty...
Alan DuBoff
>Pedder,
I just do not see the difficulty you elude to, and akin this very much to a chisel, for instance. Most folks do not grab a chisel and automatically learn to freehand sharpen on a stone, but they do develop that skill rather quickly.
Not knowing how the person attempted to sharpen a 15ppi saw, it's hard to comment, but proper lighting, being comfortably seated, using the proper file, and even magnification could each play a factor in the equation.
This is not rocket science after all...
Regards,
Alan
Not much harder, or more difficult for that matter
Alan DuBoff
>Paul wrote:
"I would rate it a good deal more difficult than that, and you need more than a 5 dollar file."
I wouldn't rate it much more difficult at all, and in fact, aside from a couple pieces of wood to put in a typical woodworking vise to secure the plate, you can do it with minimal tools.
I find it amazing how many people will attempt to cut dovetails by hand, yet those same people will be in fear to sharpen their saw. Cutting dovetails by hand is much more complicated and much more difficult than sharpening a saw.
IMO, it seems best to encourage folks to try it, because it is a skill that comes quickly, and a skill that every craftsman who uses handsaws should possess.
There has been a fair amount of FUD (fear, uncertainty and doubt) tossed around this area of woodworking. There should be none, this is no more difficult than learning to sharpen a chisel, yet most everyone will learn that skill rather than sending them out. Why is that? Why would they be more persistent with chisels or plane irons than a saw? Since it is advisable to sharpen before use, I see not having the skill as being more detrimental. All of our mileage varies...
I can think of as many or more reasons why sharpening a chisel can be more difficult than sharpening a saw, each situation is different, and each skill presents it's own set of challenges.
I am a big advocate of learning to sharpen your own saws. I do not sharpen saws professionally, and don't plan to, yet I wouldn't think about sending out a saw to be sharpened for me (talking Western saws, Japanese saws are a whole 'nuther topic). That says a lot about the craftsman doing so...my $0.02.
Regards,
Alan
Not to me it is NOT...
Alan DuBoff
>Marv wrote:
"I would rate it a good deal more difficult than that, and you need more than a 5 dollar file."
While you can think of reasons why you do, the truth is that you do not. And relating someone taking a file without any knowledge of doing it properly is not a good reason to base an opinion on, solely (not implying that you are doing exactly that).
I can think of many reasons why a chisel can be more difficult to sharpen, yet people do it all the time. They can be chipped, they can be at the wrong angle, they can be improperly sharpened previously...the list goes on...as I'm sure you can come up with reasons why sharpening a saw can be difficult.
Marv wrote:
"I have no argument with encouraging anyone to learn to sharpen their own saws, however, so they don't become discouraged as soon as they get started, it is only fair to make them aware of some of the basics and not lead them to think it is as easy as grabbing a file and trying it. Probably 75% of the saws I get have been filed by someone who just grabbed a file and tried it."
I agree with this statement, it is fair to do so. I have not seen you encourage folks to sharpen their saws though, or offer any tips on how to go about that in a more rewarding way the first time. More so it seems you have tried to discourage folks from doing so, while at the same time offering sharpening as a service.
Sharpening a saw is really not rocket science, it is really no harder than sharpening a chisel or hand plane iron. It *is* a skill that any craftsman using handsaws should know. It is also a skill that most all craftsman can easily learn.
While it is easy to point out why it can be more difficult, it is also easy to point out why it can be easy. How each of us sees the glass of water is important for each of us. In this case I always try to see the glass as half full, rather than half empty. A minor, yet fundamental difference between what each of us are pointing out.
Regards,
Alan
Re: Not to me it is NOT...
MikeW
>"I wouldn't rate it much more difficult at all, and in fact, aside from a couple pieces of wood to put in a typical woodworking vise to secure the plate, you can do it with minimal tools."


Best not to use just a couple strips in a vise [g], but I agree Alan.
Take care, Mike
Yes, and that proves the point...
Alan DuBoff
>Mike,
I don't recommend that folks sharpen their saws like that either, in reality, but the point is that it certainly does work. Your photo proves that point very well.
Nobody really needs a lot of fancy frills to sharpen.
Would be good to start a thread on sharpening handsaws, the basics, what type of pitfalls to look out for, and some of the terminology used. Rather than just sending folks off to look at vintagesaws.com or Smalser's articles, the online Chris Gochnour's video at taunton, I think it's good for people to exchange thoughts and get people aware of it so that less folks have a phobic fear. I'm not sure if others are interested in that particular aspect of handsaws, maybe not and the majority are happy to send their saws off to Cooks, Weir, Werner, and
I am certainly no expert sharpener, but still I try to share any thoughts I can, as well as encourage folks to try it. I would agree that it is not intuitive for some, but it ain't rocket science either...and I wouldn't label myself as a natural sharpener...still I was able to learn enough to get the teeth sharper than they start out at...heck, if I can do it, most anyone can do it...
Regards,
Alan