Re: Who sharpens saws well?
MikeW
>Joe,
First, don't let any of us convince you to give saw sharpening a try if'n you don't want to. This post is not in that vein.
There isn't an unequivocal list of good saw sharpeners, but in these types of post requests there are four names which usually surface, Marv, one of the posters here; Mark Harrell of TechnoPrimitives; Steve Cook (formerly of Cooke's Sharpening but use the contact info Tony Sade gave); and Daryl Weir (weir@grics.net).
That said and for anyone reading along who desires to give saw sharpening a go, I would offer just a few points of advice. In the interest of motive disclosure, I fall into the camp of strongly encouraging anyone and everyone to sharpen their own saws.
And like some have pointed out, it is not an intuitve exercise. But it isn't onerous, either. Just a little time consuming and perhaps a source of nervousness at first.
One, like Dean Jansa pointed out, one is not filing just one tooth at a time but rather two. The file is removing metal from the face of one tooth and the back of another. This is almost always an equal amount of removal. One is applying pressure more to one surface or another. This fact is both a blessing and a slight curse because while you can generally see the effect of filing on the face of one tooth, you cannot easily see the effect on the back of the tooth the file is engaging.
Two, the amount of pressure on the file. Use light pressure to begin with. Just enough to file with. When confidence rises and one begins to understand the effect of a particular file, using light pressure aids in not removing much metal too fast.
Three, the thickness of the saw plate. Thinner plates means the file will remove metal faster than thicker saw plate. A good reason to use light pressure until you understand the effect of filing.
Four, the size of the teeth. Like the thinness/thickness issue, smaller teeth can have more metal removed more quickly than larger teeth. This, along with the somewhat corresponding thickness issue, is the reason most of us recommend beginning to learn saw sharpening on hand or panel saws. These saws have much thicker saw plate and larger teeth (less teeth per inch) than say a dovetail saw. So I generally recommend no greater than 10 ppi to learn. Learning on a saw with thinner steel and more teeth per inch simply means to go even slower, though.
Five. If the teeth are in generally even height and shape, just lightly file them. A couple light strokes of the file and move to the next tooth pair. Consider this like honing a plane iron not a full-fledged sharpening. So if the teeth are in good shape, skip the jointing process (using a flat file to even out the tooth tips).
There are several plans on the internet to build a quick saw vise. The picture I posted up above was done slightly tongue in cheek--it took a bit of juggling to get those saws between the strips of wood and the vise tightened. But I didn't have a saw vise with me and needed to make do.
Contrary to a few posters, if one does decide to give saw sharpening a whirl, it will likely turn out better than one began. On this I fully agree with both Alan and Leif. It is only jagged metal to begin with. And should the exercise prove too frustrating? Send the saw out. It has to be really bad before the cost changes incrementally with each degree of "badness."
Well, about time to head to the shop and I need more coffee!
Take care, Mike