Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Who sharpens saws well?

Posts

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#26

Re: Not to me it is NOT...

ThomD

>I think sharpening chisels is a bit of a lifetime skill, you can get a workable chisel first time, but after nearly thirty years I still don't feel as much like a human surface grinder as I would like to.

The one way in which saws are a whole other thing is that all the teeth work together in concert. I have used some rather poorly sharpened chisels with bevels nowhere near a spec and the edge at an angle yet they work. String 50 of those together on a saw and the result may not be as pleasing.

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#27

You have some great info here Joe...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I want to learn to sharpen saw myself. I'd to build a boat and a few other "Jones" as well. Send them out once to be sharpened. Then study the zen majik of it. Soon it will come to you.

Hopefully myself too...

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#28

Hi Guys...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Don't wanna cause a commotion here.

Cause ya both are.8^)

I love this...

Scott, learning all kinds of things 'bout sharpening saws,

and too scared to sharpen his own.

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#29

Re: Not to me it is NOT...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Without getting into a tit for tat kind of exchange with you, there is basically only one point that I'm trying to make that you seem to ignore.

Don't over simplify the process and of course don't over complicate it either.

No, it's not rocket science. I've never related filing saws to rocket science and I haven't seen anyone else refer to it as that either.

Personally, I have no reason or purpose to encourage or discourage anyone to learn to file their own saws. I'm sure if anyone has a desire to do so, they will. I see no need to possibly cause someone who doesn't have the desire to file their saws to feel they are somehow less of a person just because I know how to sharpen saws and they don't.

People who write me for information regarding filing saws, I always answer their questions. In some cases, the emails have gone on for weeks. Some people learn it faster than others.

I know how to make a wood chisel do what I need it to do. I also know how to file a saw so it will do what it is designed to do. No one is going to convince me that one is no different than the other.

This, IMO, is not the place to teach others how to sharpen saws. Too many cooks who are usually contradicting each other and cause mainly confusion for the person interested in learning.

It's not rocket science and it's not brain surgery and it's not bridge building and it's not following a pattern and making a jacket. My wife can do that, but I wouldn't even attempt it. Sharpening saws is much easier.

Another two cents.

Marv

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#30

Just grab a file and go at it....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#31

Re: Hi Guys...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Scott,

I hope you aren't relying on anything said here in this thread if you are thinking about filing that dovetail saw of yours. I have read very little that directly relates to the various steps you need to be aware of before you pick up that file.

Marv

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#32

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

L. Hanson

>I'll put it out there for Marv, he does very good work. You could also try Mark Harrell at Technoprimitives.com. He comes highly recommended.

As for the (very interesting) debate - eh, it's a flat piece of steel with some teeth filed into one side. A poorly sharpened saw will still work better than a dull one. The next time you'll do better. Or use a reputable service.

Some people change their own oil. Some pay someone else to.

;-)

Leif

Norse Woodsmith.com

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#33

Why not start a thread Marv?

Alan DuBoff

>Marv,

How about starting a thread to let folks know of the dangers of taking a *gasp* file to their saws?

Would be a good way for you to share your knowledge, IMO.

I could probably learn a thing or two from you, I'm certainly no sharpening wizard, but I don't let that stop me from doing it. *wink*

Regards,

Alan

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#34

Speaking for myself, pretty similar.

Alan DuBoff

>ThomD wrote:

"The one way in which saws are a whole other thing is that all the teeth work together in concert. I have used some rather poorly sharpened chisels with bevels nowhere near a spec and the edge at an angle yet they work. String 50 of those together on a saw and the result may not be as pleasing."

My real world experience shows otherwise. It shows that in most cases even if the teeth are not perfect, they will most likely cut better. The fact that you have 50-200 of them on a saw helps compensate if there is a bad one.

I look at sharpening all edge tools as being a lifetime skill, one that you continue doing since edge tools need to be sharpened on a regular basis. For people who don't sharpen their own saws, there could be a huge reward by starting to learn the skill, you can still send the saw out to be sharpened if one does mess it up...so no real loss in that sense for those that would send their saws out.

It is entirely possible to have a bad section on a chisel blade after one is done sharpening it, or to have a nick from hitting a nail, same with a plane iron. I have had it happen to me where I need to take a chisel back to the stone and redo it as it doesn't cut for me as I had anticipated. One can also have the corner cambered when you they didn't mean to as well, but the chisel will still work. This is similar to a saw. The half full view of the glass would be to say, "hey, you have 50 teeth on that saw, your chances are pretty good of getting one of them sharpened correctly!". :-)

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#35

experience

paul womack

>I'm all for encouraging people to "have a go", but understating the difficulty serves no one. If a task is described as easy, and a beginner fails at it, it's not going to do a lot for their confidence.

If you've genuinely never found any difficulty in sharpening saws, you're the only one I've heard of, and must be either talented, lucky, or both, and to a high degree at that.

Most people I've spoken to (including via the net) on the matter (and I take an interest in it, having taught myself) found areas of difficulty, which could be overcome with a judicious mixture of knowledge and practice, but areas of difficulty there most certainly were.

BugBear

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#36

experience

paul womack

>Would be good to start a thread on sharpening handsaws, the basics, what type of pitfalls to look out for, and some of the terminology used. Rather than just sending folks off to look at vintagesaws.com or Smalser's articles, the online Chris Gochnour's video at taunton,

Unless you think you can describe the process better than those good gentleman *who IMHO cover all the points you mention), I don't see the benefit of a thread.

Perhaps the aspiring saw sharpeners could go to those sites, and return here with any "questions arising"

BugBear

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#37

An open forum adds value, that's why...

Alan DuBoff

>Paul,

Because it is good to discuss things in an open forum, that is how threads lead to new ways to solve things.

For instance, there is quite a bit about pistol saw sets to understand, in that the size of the plunger determines what size teeth they can be used with, or how the bottom gets chewed up by the teeth when you set. Some folks have added in harder steel insets, or have swapped vintage plungers into newer Somax sets. You could easily cover a thread on sets for instance, something I have not read too much about at those mentioned sites. Similarly, some might be interested to understand hammer setting, those mentioned sites don't discuss that.

So, sure you could just send folks off to those sites but that is not adding any value in most cases, where I see an open forum as a way to add value. All of our mileage varies I 'spose...

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#38

Woodworking can be complex, why not quit?

Alan DuBoff

>Paul,

There's a lot of things we learn to do that are not intuitive. I have never said it was natural for me to sharpen, I was pointing out that I could actually learn something from Marv. That part seems like your trying to put words in my message...:-/

If we ignored every task that we didn't know how to do, there's a slim chance that any of us would grow our skills.

It is by doing that we learn, and I try to encourage folks to do so, so that they will develop those skills and feel much more comfortable at it.

At the end of the day we all sharpen our saws one tooth at a time.:-)

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#39

knowledge

paul womack

> I have never said it was natural for me to sharpen,

The phrase you used (as a subject, no less) was "I just don't see the difficulty...".

That seems fairly clear.

BugBear

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#40

Re: Woodworking can be complex, why not quit?

Dean J in MN

>At the end of the day we all sharpen our saws one tooth at a time.:-)


Actually -- I file mine a tooth pair (some may say a gullet) at a time. How do you manage just one tooth at a time? :)

-Dean

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#41

Smirk

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#42

Thanks Leif..!

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#43

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

MikeW

>Joe,

First, don't let any of us convince you to give saw sharpening a try if'n you don't want to. This post is not in that vein.

There isn't an unequivocal list of good saw sharpeners, but in these types of post requests there are four names which usually surface, Marv, one of the posters here; Mark Harrell of TechnoPrimitives; Steve Cook (formerly of Cooke's Sharpening but use the contact info Tony Sade gave); and Daryl Weir (weir@grics.net).

That said and for anyone reading along who desires to give saw sharpening a go, I would offer just a few points of advice. In the interest of motive disclosure, I fall into the camp of strongly encouraging anyone and everyone to sharpen their own saws.

And like some have pointed out, it is not an intuitve exercise. But it isn't onerous, either. Just a little time consuming and perhaps a source of nervousness at first.

One, like Dean Jansa pointed out, one is not filing just one tooth at a time but rather two. The file is removing metal from the face of one tooth and the back of another. This is almost always an equal amount of removal. One is applying pressure more to one surface or another. This fact is both a blessing and a slight curse because while you can generally see the effect of filing on the face of one tooth, you cannot easily see the effect on the back of the tooth the file is engaging.

Two, the amount of pressure on the file. Use light pressure to begin with. Just enough to file with. When confidence rises and one begins to understand the effect of a particular file, using light pressure aids in not removing much metal too fast.

Three, the thickness of the saw plate. Thinner plates means the file will remove metal faster than thicker saw plate. A good reason to use light pressure until you understand the effect of filing.

Four, the size of the teeth. Like the thinness/thickness issue, smaller teeth can have more metal removed more quickly than larger teeth. This, along with the somewhat corresponding thickness issue, is the reason most of us recommend beginning to learn saw sharpening on hand or panel saws. These saws have much thicker saw plate and larger teeth (less teeth per inch) than say a dovetail saw. So I generally recommend no greater than 10 ppi to learn. Learning on a saw with thinner steel and more teeth per inch simply means to go even slower, though.

Five. If the teeth are in generally even height and shape, just lightly file them. A couple light strokes of the file and move to the next tooth pair. Consider this like honing a plane iron not a full-fledged sharpening. So if the teeth are in good shape, skip the jointing process (using a flat file to even out the tooth tips).

There are several plans on the internet to build a quick saw vise. The picture I posted up above was done slightly tongue in cheek--it took a bit of juggling to get those saws between the strips of wood and the vise tightened. But I didn't have a saw vise with me and needed to make do.

Contrary to a few posters, if one does decide to give saw sharpening a whirl, it will likely turn out better than one began. On this I fully agree with both Alan and Leif. It is only jagged metal to begin with. And should the exercise prove too frustrating? Send the saw out. It has to be really bad before the cost changes incrementally with each degree of "badness."

Well, about time to head to the shop and I need more coffee!

Take care, Mike

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#44

Why bother?

John in NM

>"This, IMO, is not the place to teach others how to sharpen saws. Too many cooks who are usually contradicting each other and cause mainly confusion for the person interested in learning."

Because in spite of all the arguments that arise, that is exactly what makes a forum useful and interesting. That would be a thread I read with interest and learn from. Some of us even learn from the too many contradictory cooks, trying out their different methods and learning both methods that are effective and in-effective for ourselves. There is no single "right" way to do anything.

When this forum fills up with endless discussions of buying overpriced tools on ebay, and the strange compliment "you suck" is when I get bored and go elsewhere. To each their own.

In this case I have to say I admire Alan's attitude and intiative and I'm a bit mystified why others are so eager to stomp on both. That is hard to respect.

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#45

Re: Why bother?

Ace Karner

>I agree with John on this one, Pete has more than covered the basics of saw sharpening at VintageSaws, if I can learn to sharpen using his tutorials I'm sure anyone can.

I felt for years that saw sharpening was one of those mystical operations that belonged to the chosen few, then I started to read about how a carpenter 60 or 70 years ago could hardly find work if he couldn't sharpen his saws on the job and in a hurry. That's when I went looking for instruction and found Vintagesaws.

I'm probably not the best saw sharpener and I really messed up at first but I have a new Mike W. tenon saw and a LN carcass saw and I feel that my sharpened saws hold up fairly well against them.

Folks have no problem learning to sharpen chisels that can cost as much as $45.00 or more using jigs and stones that may have cost several hundred $ yet they are afraid to tackle a $5.00 saw with a $5.00 file using a $15.00 vise and a $20.00 set.

I for one am glad I learned to sharpen for one thing, I will never have to saw with a less than proper saw. Some of the saws I've sharpened have taken several hours as they were in sad shape, I can keep a saw sharp in just a few minutes if I make sure not to let it get too dull before I act.

Just my thoughts, worth at least as much as I charged for them. :)>>

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#46

Well, if you choose to split internet hairs...

Alan DuBoff

>Paul,

You can split all the Internet hairs in the world, but it won't put any words in my message. Twisting something that was typed to align with how you want to pose your side works well to support yourself, so I suggest you interpret how you like, and let others do the same.

If all folks interpret my message as you, there was obviously a problem in conveying my thoughts, since I don't interpret what I wrote as stating that. In fact, I stand by exactly what I said, "I just don't see the difficulty", and as such I won't be sending any of my saws out to be serviced by another person who will charge me, require I pay shipping, etc...

One thing I do find is that if you don't sharpen on a regular basis, you stand to loose the *feel* for it, and need to get accustomed to it once again when you do pick a file up. So, if you haven't been sharpening regularly, this could be something your seeing. It is easy enough to get more comfortable with, just grab a file and go at it! :-)

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#47

And there is a difference between you and me...

Alan DuBoff

>Dean,

I don't file two teeth a time, I only file one tooth. The reason is that if you were to file a gullet, you would then be filing into the bottom of it to disperse pressure evenly to both teeth.

However, in my real world experience, I have noticed that you must apply the pressure to the tooth which is being filed on the front cutting edge of the saw, since the gullet will often become larger than the 60 degrees on the file, and truth be told, I really am not concerned with the trailing edge of the tooth like I am the leading edge that will do the cutting.

If your managing your sharpening by the gullet, and not by the tooth, you may very well be applying less focus on the proper section of the tooth that is intended to cut the wood. In that regard I file each and every tooth, on the front cutting edge, not on the rear trailing edge, or even the gullet. :-)

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#48

Well stated....I agree

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#49

Re: Why bother?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi John,

I really don't have a strong argument with the points you make. We all have our opinions. I respect yours.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

"This, IMO, is not the place to teach others how to sharpen saws. Too many cooks who are usually contradicting each other and cause mainly confusion for the person interested in learning."

----------------------------------------------------------------------

I still stand by what I have stated, that which you have quoted.

Having taught more than a few people how to sharpen saws, my experience is, first make them aware of all the information that is available on the internet that someone else has already taken the time to tutorialize. Help them through any questions that might come from reading some of that material. Then when they are properly set up and beginning to file a saw, answer inevitable questions as they come up. This way, the beginner can more easily identify with what is being instructed.

Marv

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#50

This is the exact place to do so...

Alan DuBoff

>Marv wrote:

"This, IMO, is not the place to teach others how to sharpen saws."

While this is not where most people will *learn* how to sharpen, this is certainly a great place to help teach them. An open forum offers way more than some stale document on a website, which may or may not have all the information or present it in the best way, either. At best one has to read each one, take what they like from each, and formulate their own method that works for them. An open forum offers some advantages so that everyone doesn't need to go through the same process to understand the "why" or "how" of it.

Sure, others have put together documents, and those documents are well served as they have been to everyone, but an open forum offers us to talk about the process, and it allows people to interact together so that they are able to discuss the process in detail.

With that information, they can take it to their own shop and apply it. I know that this might sound odd, but this open forum interaction actually does get people interested in, and motivated to do something like sharpening their own saw. The amount of craftsmen that have fear of sharpening their own saw is only proof that the current stale documents do not work 100%, or every craftsman would be sharpening their own saw as was required (and performed) in days of lore.

You can smirk, scoff, or jest about it, but there are people that have been inspired enough to take on the task of trying it for themselves, as that is the only way one can really actually learn the skill of sharpening their saw...by *doing* it.

To discourage them at all is a dis-service to them, as a craftsman. and I wear a smile every time I see someone mention they did finally take the challenge and tried it for themselves...just to find out they should have done it a long time ago...

Cheers,

Alan