Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Who sharpens saws well?

Posts

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#51

Re: Why bother?

Alan DuBoff

>John wrote:

"When this forum fills up with endless discussions of buying overpriced tools on ebay, and the strange compliment "you suck" is when I get bored and go elsewhere. To each their own."

I agree with you completely about the forum, and when it gets to the that point, you won't be the only one going elsewhere. This holds true for all online forums...

John wrote:

"In this case I have to say I admire Alan's attitude and intiative and I'm a bit mystified why others are so eager to stomp on both. That is hard to respect."

I'm glad that at least one person around here gets it. While most of the folks that have spoken up in this thread have only countered my idea of people learning to sharpen their own saw, I suspect there are others that have just kept quiet. Thankfully, you get it! *wink*

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#52

Now, just think if...

Alan DuBoff

>Ace wrote:

"I for one am glad I learned to sharpen for one thing, I will never have to saw with a less than proper saw."

Now, just think if...you were planning a project and wanted to use a handsaw. You say to yourself, "self, I'm gonna be using a handsaw, so I better send that out to be sharpened for me, so that I don't ruin it...I know that it will take at least a week turnaround even if the sharpener was able to do it quickly...so I better get that out immediately as I don't want to start without a sharp handsaw...".

That would be a pretty morbid thought, IMO...

Congrats on taking the plunge Ace! As most realize it is not that severe a plunge, but once taking it, the water sure feels nice...

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#53

This is true, but in practice...

Alan DuBoff

>MikeW wrote:

"One, like Dean Jansa pointed out, one is not filing just one tooth at a time but rather two. The file is removing metal from the face of one tooth and the back of another. This is almost always an equal amount of removal. One is applying pressure more to one surface or another. This fact is both a blessing and a slight curse because while you can generally see the effect of filing on the face of one tooth, you cannot easily see the effect on the back of the tooth the file is engaging."

I don't agree with this entirely because in practice what happens for me is that I have the teeth shaped close to where I want, but often change the rake slightly when I file, because I try to watch the tooth which I am filing the face of. If the teeth are shaped at 4 degrees, and one puts a tad steeper rake when filing, say 5 degrees, the top of the tooth in front is not filed the same and can possibly not be filed at all depending on the angle of the side.

If one puts less rake on the tooth, often the gullet will be cut at the bottom, applying less pressure at the bottom of the tooth in front (i.e., the tooth which the rear is being filed.

Because of this it is always wise, IMO, to focus on the tooth which is being filed on the front, it is that side of the tooth that will do the actual cutting, so to me it makes sense to watch that tooth.

This is also the very reason why mechanical filing guides don't work properly and/or why mechanical sharpening machines are marginal in practice, because sharpening handsaw teeth is most often done by feel, and by watching the top of the tooth one is filing to determine how much pressure to apply in each direction.

Speaking for myself, I like to apply more pressure to the front of the tooth to know that I will get a clean cut from the file. Maybe that is wrong, I don't know...it seems to work for me.

In the perfect world a mechanical filing guide would work fine, but in the real world and in practice that doesn't seem so from my experience, and I don't use any mechanical devices for the very reason that the amount of pressure changes between the teeth depending on how it needs to be filed.

After a tooth has been filed several times, the angles change slightly as it would be almost impossible to get every tooth precisely the same. Yet my real world experience shows that teeth can alter ever so slightly, maybe just my skills are not as good as others...

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#54

Nery nice Alan

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>ANY type of sharpening knoledge should be looked upon with note and as you said... Learn and remember.

Scott, enjoying this.

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#55

Now Marv...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>It just so happens a box showed up on my doorstep that's a great size to ship saws in. I was nicely surprised to see what was in it too.

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#56

Re: This is true, but in practice...

MikeW

>Heh heh heh...

But, one really is filing both if done "correctly." The caveat I didn't fully explain is that one "crowds" the face of one tooth or the back of the other. This simply means more pressure is being applied in one direction than the other (forward into the back of the next tooth, or backwards in the face of the present tooth). But both are being filed into by one degree or another.

In the scenario you present, if one desires to steepen the rake of the present face (say going from 8 deg. of rake to 4 deg. of rake), the back of the other will be filed into towards the top. This is as it should be. Once finished, this helps ensure the teeth are of a certain height in relation to the teeth behind and in front down the toothline.

Likewise, if one is relaxing the rake (say going from 4 deg. to 8 deg. of rake), the top of the present face is receiving more pressure and correspondingly, the bottom of the tooth's back in front of the file.

I would strongly suggest if one desires to change the rake angle, to first joint the teeth (that is, to run a flat file down the tooth tips). Jointing will be the biggest aid in giving a visual clue as to the progress. With a saw in good condition, one does not need to create wide flats when jointing. If the teeth of a given saw are in poor condition, I suggest jointing down part way, filing, jointing again and so forth. In this case, and desiring to keep the saw's PPI intact, jointing down further than half way down the lowest tooth would cause more work than necessary (in the sense of keeping track of tooth spacing).

Even with a new saw, if one was to joint the teeth (like before a full filing) one would see flats on the tips of varying widths no matter how small a variation. "Crowding" the file into a face of one tooth or the back of another is how one begins evening out the spacing. For it is the varying widths of flat that indicates one tooth is larger (wider flat) than another. This process I refer to as repointing or shaping.

Once the flats are nearly gone and of pretty darn equal size, this indicates the teeth are of an even size. But only if a reasonalby consistent rake has been maintained. There's reasons that one would file a changing rake, but one should be aware that when doing so the teeth will be of different widths at the baseline and or the toothline will not be exactly and "perfectly" even. This in practice is a non-issue.

Anyway, fun discussion. But tis time I go home...

Take care, Mike

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#57

I find this very useful to start...

Alan DuBoff

>Mike wrote:

"Two, the amount of pressure on the file. Use light pressure to begin with. Just enough to file with. When confidence rises and one begins to understand the effect of a particular file, using light pressure aids in not removing much metal too fast."

Mike,

I find this to be one of the most helpful with the folks I've taught to sharpen saws. A couple of them I had just very lightly take a pass to get a feel for it, so that as they do add more pressure it will be even. This works well, in my experience, for folks new to sharpening.

This is also why someone can take a file, put their saw in a simple vise to secure it, and sharpen their saw. Even to take one cut for each tooth. I see you like to refer to the tooth pair, I tend to think of the tooth set towards me as I file, as I make that the front edge tooth in the pair. I always file into the tooth facing me, and to me that is the tooth being sharpened. The rear of the other adjacent tooth is arbitrary in the sense that it should not be used.

Something I didn't notice in your post, that one should skip every other tooth-pair as you refer to it. This could be why I like to think as it in every tooth, I take one pass and flip the saw around and do the others, but the reference for me is always the front edge tooth and the one I'm gaging my file on.

Other than that, a very good place for folks to start. Thanks for offering this up Mike! Maybe someone will be inspired to give it a try, and even get some help if they find something difficult.

So far I don't see anyone willing to try this, or at least admit it in this thread, who hasn't sharpened their saw before. Let's hope they didn't get scared off by the few warning them of all the difficulties...:-/

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#58

We're on the same page, just different terminology

Alan DuBoff

>MikeW wrote:

"Once the flats are nearly gone and of pretty darn equal size, this indicates the teeth are of an even size. But only if a reasonalby consistent rake has been maintained. There's reasons that one would file a changing rake, but one should be aware that when doing so the teeth will be of different widths at the baseline and or the toothline will not be exactly and "perfectly" even. This in practice is a non-issue."

I can certainly use your terminology and haven't seen you add anything I don't agree with, just that I think of it differently.

One of the things I learned from Tom Law's video was to watch the tooth that I'm filing (i.e., the front edge tooth), and to watch it file cleanly and shore up against the file. But since I use a Foley, it's not perfect to set the rake as you probably know, so getting it close and shoring it up with the file to the proper rake angle seems to be about the best I can do in the situation. Maybe you have a trick for making the settings on the Foley more accurate. The Foley is more consistent for the amount of time for my purpose than shaping by hand, but I can do a pretty good job these days with shaping by hand. I don't recommend someone shape the teeth by hand the first time they sharpen, though, that takes some practice most certainly...

Cheers,

Alan

PS - For anyone following at home, don't ever use a saw file without a handle on it, ALWAYS make sure you put a handle on it.

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#59

sorry for beeing late

Pedder

>Hi Alan,

I'll show some pictures later this weekend on my blog.

This guy, a really good woodworker, has all it needs. A good vise, lights, files, lenses. It just was his first attempt. As Paul states: 15ppi isn't the best place to start.

Cheers Pedder

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#60

I'd like to see...but...

Alan DuBoff

>Pedder,

I'd like to see, but I'm sure it's not hard to come up with someone that tried to sharpen a saw and failed. I think we can come up with folks that were successful at it, I would put myself into that category.

I will say that the first time I shaped a saw by hand it was pretty bad looking, but I always took filing pretty cautiously in the beginning and started of with very little removal to get a feel. That is what I recommend to others as well.

I think like anything, we can find both success stories and failures if we look, but that is no reason that others shouldn't try it either.

Heck, for that matter we see a lot of folks fail at cutting dovetails by hand, some folks just don't have enough skills within them to do it. OTOH, many, many folks have cut a lot of dovetails successfully, even those that have never done it before.

IMO, the tone of this thread is over exaggerated.

It's only a freakin' tool, after all...and not a very expensive one at that...

Regards,

Alan

Re: Who sharpens saws well?

#61

Re: I'd like to see...but...

Pedder

>Hi Alan,

"IMO, the tone of this thread is over exaggerated."

Hope you didn't point at me. If please blame it on my mothertongue. :o)

I don't want to discourage people. All I say is: Be carefully if you do.

Do it but do it carefully.

And take a cheap saw for training.

Cheers

Pedder