This is true, but in practice...
Alan DuBoff
>MikeW wrote:
"One, like Dean Jansa pointed out, one is not filing just one tooth at a time but rather two. The file is removing metal from the face of one tooth and the back of another. This is almost always an equal amount of removal. One is applying pressure more to one surface or another. This fact is both a blessing and a slight curse because while you can generally see the effect of filing on the face of one tooth, you cannot easily see the effect on the back of the tooth the file is engaging."
I don't agree with this entirely because in practice what happens for me is that I have the teeth shaped close to where I want, but often change the rake slightly when I file, because I try to watch the tooth which I am filing the face of. If the teeth are shaped at 4 degrees, and one puts a tad steeper rake when filing, say 5 degrees, the top of the tooth in front is not filed the same and can possibly not be filed at all depending on the angle of the side.
If one puts less rake on the tooth, often the gullet will be cut at the bottom, applying less pressure at the bottom of the tooth in front (i.e., the tooth which the rear is being filed.
Because of this it is always wise, IMO, to focus on the tooth which is being filed on the front, it is that side of the tooth that will do the actual cutting, so to me it makes sense to watch that tooth.
This is also the very reason why mechanical filing guides don't work properly and/or why mechanical sharpening machines are marginal in practice, because sharpening handsaw teeth is most often done by feel, and by watching the top of the tooth one is filing to determine how much pressure to apply in each direction.
Speaking for myself, I like to apply more pressure to the front of the tooth to know that I will get a clean cut from the file. Maybe that is wrong, I don't know...it seems to work for me.
In the perfect world a mechanical filing guide would work fine, but in the real world and in practice that doesn't seem so from my experience, and I don't use any mechanical devices for the very reason that the amount of pressure changes between the teeth depending on how it needs to be filed.
After a tooth has been filed several times, the angles change slightly as it would be almost impossible to get every tooth precisely the same. Yet my real world experience shows that teeth can alter ever so slightly, maybe just my skills are not as good as others...
Cheers,
Alan