Chisel Test in FWW
Steve Elliott
>"The largest whoopsie to me was that the deformation standard appeared to be out by an order of magnitude or two."
You're right about that. A few years ago I did a careful reading of the test results, comparing the edge images to the wear graphs. I became convinced the units on the graphs were off by a factor of 10. The typical deformation of the edges can be calculated by measuring the photo on the magazine cover, in which the peaks and valleys are about .013" apart. The graphs show this wear as being about 1000 micron inches, or .001".
I can't find my copy of the magazine but I�ll post an image that summarizes my calculations.
If I recall correctly the bevel angle for all of the chisels was 30 degrees, which is too acute for cutting mortises in white oak. The resulting edge damage is clear evidence that the angle should be increased, and the optimum bevel angle will be different for each of the chisels.
The high-tech method of measuring edge shape used in this article is less informative than looking at the edge under a good magnifier.



