Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

Posts

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#26

Re: backwards

Hank Knight

>Warren,

I agree that there is a big difference between making steel and making a chisel from a steel blank. I don't know what Imai san uses as his base material, but I do know that his blades are made of many layers. It is my understanding that he forges his blades by traditional methods that involve folding the steel over upon itself and hammering it into a solid piece. Imai originally marketed his steel in this country as "sword steel," but I believe he has abandoned that name and now refers to it as "special white steel." I don't know if the name change speaks to his manufacturing method, but I do not believe the steel in an Imai "special white steel" chisel is the same steel you would find in a 19th Century samurai sword. My guess is that he does not start with "blister steel" obtained the old way. I do believe his blades are hand forged using a traditional layering method. Unlike some other Japanese smiths, Imai does not use acid to etch the surface of his blades to expose the layers. Nevertheless, you can see the layering if you look closely at the bevel on one of his chisels. I have other, less expensive Japanese chisels that do not exhibit this characteristic. I do not think they are made using traditional techniques, and the quaity of these blades is not on the same level as an Imai blade - they are more brittle and do not retain an edge as well.

I am clearly over my head in this discussion, but I stick by my comments earlier, based on my own experience with Sheffeild steel and some (not all) Japanese hand forged blades. If you will notice, I exempted modern exotics from my comments to Adam. I had CPM-3V in mind when I wrote that, but there are other modern tool steel alloys and exotics available to us today that were unknown or technically impossible to make 100 years ago. My comments to Adam were intended to compare Sheffield carbon steel made in the latter part of the 19th Century with the best hand made Japanese steel of the same era. Introducing modern alloys and exotics into the discussion spoils the argument. CPM-3V and Sheffield Steel of the late 19th Century are apples and oranges.

Hank

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#27

Re: "lining" versus "laminating"

ThomD

>"Maybe there's some (purposeful) confusion between "lining", laminating a piece of steel to wrought iron or low carbon steel as a way of saving the cost or use of steel,"

This is a constant refrain, I doubt very much that economics had anything to do with it. When you are making a sword for someone you regard as a god, I don't think this is the issue. You may be confusing Williamsburg freeman peasant culture, with Japanese samurai and court culture. What was there are the time was more like being on the Sadam Iraqui soccer team.

" and "laminating" non-homogenous steel to make a more homogenous product."

I am not sure what you are saying here, The folding of the billet used in making a sword is not done to make it more homogenous, it is done to combine properties, if they become too blended one has gone too far. It is like we mix materials to make bread and want it to be well blended, though even there it is "better" if there is a little texture left to it. When we make pastry the idea is retain distinct separation in layers. With swords it needs to be mixed to retain properties of the combined metals. It's a bit like a cloth that combines carbon and kevlar strands, a comon composite solution.

"Personally, I prefer "lined""

This is a new word to me, great, we need yet another word...

" steel blades (I've called them laminated in the past because they are indeed laminated). Forge welding steel to a softer material makes for a blade that is easier to sharpen."

Another property of no concern to a samurai

"Legend has it, there are some vibration or impact reducing properties due to the difference in Young's modulii."

Your legend tellers are unusually well read in metallurgy...

" I don't know of any western chisel makers still doing this. The Japanese chisels are certainly lined and that is indeed an advantage in my book."

Or put in a different way, I don't know of any western chisel makers who are making chisels period, two spaces. I mean what LN etc... are doing is virtually not even a business, and has zero centrality to anything seriously socially important. It's nice for us, but not a defining attribute of modern US civilization.

"The lamination of Samurai swords was done because sword makers were making their own blister steel."

I don't think so

"Blister steel is made with a wrought iron bar"

I am unaware they bought their steel in a bar, form or locale. I am being picky because there is an unusual amount of dismissal going on in these threads, and where there is dismissal there may be some faulty assumptions.

", placed in a sort of kiln (or forge), and packed with carbon. The kiln heats up to 3000F and the iron absorbs some carbon and becomes steel."

The pictures I have seen show a material rather like steel wool being used in this process, maybe they got a better distribution of carbon that you are assuming based on you amero peasant technology.

"The problem with blister steel is that it is steel only on the outside and remains iron in the center. And the diistribution of carbon is inconsistent. By continually forging that into thinner and thinner layers and welding the layers together, you can minimize the effect of the non-homogenous metal."

Anyone just happening on this discussion would assume therefore that their swords or chisels were sorta inferior to a Fuller chisel in a blisterpack. While as we know, there has never been a test in a US mag that identified the cutting power of a Japanese chisel as inferior to the best anyone else could muster. Things that make you go Hmm.

" That's what Japan's great sword smiths did. "

Their results may vary

"There may be people still doing this. They certainly did this a few years ago in Colonial Williamsburg."

That would be the "came several generation too late and am just guessing" leading the "I don't do this for a living...". A similar gathering in Japan, if they needed to gather, would be composed of the "my family have done this for generations, (beat steel)" selling to the "my family have done this for generations (beat chisels)". Se we have to have these windy discussions, because at the base, none of us has much idea what we are doing. Even if we have been at it for 40 years. Who amongst us actually makes a living with hand tools? I mean sweating, hitting, sawing, and planing all day long. There are people out there who do.

"it remains structurally inferior to the leaf springs at my nearby metal scrap yard."

Yeah, but what does that mean? Leaf springs are tough as all get out, and can be made into wonderful knives and swords, at least given the skill level we have in the present age.

Things are only "structurally inferior" relative to some defined need, It would be surprising, and I don't think it is likely correct, if.6 percent carbon steel/leaf spring stock were actually superior to any of the steels in common use for better boutique chisels.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#28

P.S.

Hank Knight

>I did say to Adam that the steel in a Samurai sword or an Imai chisel was at least as good as Sheffield steel of "today." That comment comes from my experience with some modern English chisels. I'll gladly trade all of my Sorbys for Imais any day, any time. I can't say that about all modern English chisels, though.

Hank

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#29

Re: Windbags by the dozen..

ThomD

>"You used the term "virtual perfection" to describe ancient Japanese steel. That may be hyperbole on your part, but I'm sure I've heard others say the same things having seen those PBS specials about Japan's living treasures."

That's an abstraction anyway. what has perfection got to do with it. A more relevant comparison might be the results seen in the Golden temple, vs. the repro church at Williamsburg. Or the planed surface in a shogi vs. a sash window

Aren't the Japanese the folk who like an evident flaw? Not sure that carries over to the swords...

"I love the whole idea of having people as national treasures instead of buildings or battlefields like we have. And I love Japan so much, I studied Kendo to learn to speak Japanese, and learn to appreciate the religion and traditions of this fabulous culture."

Fabulous, really.

"I just think some of the romantic imagery has spilled into the world of engineering and it shouldn't have."

Who lives in that world. We are talking about fighting to the death or making glorious wooden buildings without the benefit of a diagonal braces. This is a Poindexter free zone. The world of engineering is like the world of accountancy, best left to people who put a naked lady Godiva on a horse for orientation.

"I don't believe Japanese knives, chisels or plane irons are anything like Japanese swords and that's a good thing. Japanese swords aren't as great as we have been led to believe."

There is truth in that, though it is a separate issue.

"If there's a mystical steel out there, it's not a samurai sword or damascus sword from the second crusade, it's Bill Tindall's CPM-3V! It's amazingly clean, abrasion resistant, fine grained, and strong."

Even if that ludicrous contention were true, it would be a late arrival on the field. I totally agree that if Warren Buffet put a few hundred million dollars into some kind of meaningful program of steel for tools development, that was actually centered on something real vs. just tests, we could easily surpass current steels. One gets into the whole "what's this all about thing". I mean maybe it escaped someone's attention, but serious woodwork where hand tools mater isn't hardly on anyone's mind these days. Production has moved to automated machines or offshore, and CPM blah blah may not even have been used in a single noteworthy saleable piece of woodwork.

But back to your contention if we are being engineers here I am assuming you have a long list of fights to the death where CPM blah blah was the defining steel? One thing about the Japanese swords is they did a lot more testing than Bill, they may have determined that polishing mattered they certainly did a lot of work to polish the swords. Does bills miracle steel hand polish real well? There are innumerable factors that may be present, there are probably a few things in CPV that shouldn't be there, I doubt the odds are good for a clean sweep. Bill is tilling the obvious soil of a steel that has more edge retention and can still be sharpened with modern means, which is certainly worth a try, but is not the whole series of characteristics that make a good tool. In fact it mostly lies in the not wanted column.

I have been through the semi-primitive worlds, as have many. There are always windbags by the dozen, ascribing non-existent religious attributes and claiming old performance levels were bunkum. One of my favorite stories is the atlat. I guess some engineers or whatever discovered the Atlat, and thought it would be fun to play with. The historic examples had little figures in silver or some such, that were lashed to the limb of the atlat, and that were off course only there for religious or mythical reasons, etc... well it turned out they were adjustable weights that allowed the user to time the release of the limb to coincide with the spine characteristics of the spear, and the action of the thrower. Kinda sophisticated, and not easy for an engineer to figure out on first blush.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#30

Re: Metalurgy Merry Go round

ThomD

>"Eutectoid steel is 1077 (O-1), .77% C. The added carbon does increase the Rc hardness but doesn't necessarily improve cutting ability. Rc hardness is a measure of the matrix."

O1 has 90 points of carbon.

"Grain size is sorta unrelated to the alloy. I can change the grain size in the forging process. But that's an inexact science."

So is cutting dovetails, that is why people enjoy it, and some get darn good at it.

" CPM is nice because the grain you start out with is the grain you end up with unless you screw up the heat treat."

Which is 90% of the issue with anything.

"The last paper that talked about lamination actually includes a quote comparing Japanese swords with shear steel used to make scythes. It didn't really talk so much about the Japanese sword lamination as modern laminates with good clean materials and "lining". I've used Aluminum- aluminum composites and ceramic aluminum composites which were pretty cool. But this isn't similar to what the Japanese sword makers were doing."

Actually it is, they were making composites.

"Let me just sum up this way- What the Japanese sword makers did is try to bake a cake without a measuring cup, without controlling what ingredients went in, and without a mixer."

And what Adam does is try to cut wood without a table saw, computer software to determine the cutting program, or high quality computer made saw blades to handle the cut. Me too actually, how do we manage.

" They baked what they had, it came out vanilla in some spots, chocolate in others and there were bits of egg shells and old boots. Then they crumbled it up and stuck it back together."

That's like what comes out of my 2 year old one way or another, that's an interesting characterization I hope you are never called upon to back up.

"They had no alternative. Modern cakes have precisely controlled ingredients and when we bite into them, we don't find any surprises. Guys can say they like the old ways, and that's fine. But it's not a better cake."

Well no, the one with the eggshells does sound like crap, but modern baked goods are revolting, where have you been hiding, and is there any chance you will be let out. If so come on over and we will feed you a Neapolitan cake.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#31

Re: Sheffield steel superior

paul womack

> I think its possible the Japanese can make superior tools with inferior steel.

I'm still hunting for a more authoritive reference, but it appears that the cutting edges (i.e. the steel, not the iron) of modern Japanese chisels are made from modern steels, manufactured by the perfectly up to date Hitachi company.

http://www.groupsrv.com/hobby/about3700.html

Excerpt:



mmon shorthand name for white paper steel ("shirogami

hagane") which can be any of several fairly simple high carbon, water

hardening steel grades. The carbon content varies by grade, and runs from

0.8 to 1.4%. The range of carbon content within a grade is a tight 0.1%.

For example, the carbon content of Shirogami Hagani No1A is specified to

be between 1.3 and 1.4%. Each grade also contains 0.1-0.2% silicon and

0.2-0.3% manganese, and only trace amounts of the impurities sulfur and

phosphorus.

Blue paper steel ("aogami hagane") is also offered in several grades,

with carbon content ranging similarly to the "white" grades. However,

blue steel contains the additional alloying elements chromium and

tungsten, and one grade ("aogami super") also contains molybdenum and

vanadium. The blue steels can be quenched in water or oil, whereas most

of the white grades need a faster quench and require water.


No need for magic.

BugBear

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#32

Re: Metalurgy Merry Go round

wilbur

>Hi Adam,

Well, I agree that metallurgy is a complicated field, but the point I was making isn't really that complicated. You said that Japanese swords aren't as great as we have been led to believe, and you mentioned CPM 3V as an excellent steel for tools. Which is true -- I don't doubt that you can make excellent tools from CPM 3V.

My point is there is data that shows that the type of steel used in Japanese swords (and modern day Japanese chisels and plane blades), which is high carbon steel with >1% carbon, has measurable characteristics that exceed that of CPM 3V.

Yes, I know that O-1 and W-1 don't have carbon content >1%. But Japanese swordmakers and tool makers didn't use O-1 or W-1 steel. The Hitachi white and blue steels that are in wide use today do have a carbon content >1%, as did the Swedish and English steels that the Japanese toolmakers love to use now and in the past.

No romance here. Just data.

You mentioned CPM 3V as being "amazingly clean, abrasion resistant, fine grained, and strong".

Clean: I'm not exactly sure what you mean by clean, but the best examples of forged high carbon steel show very consistent distribution and size of the grains in the steel.

Abrasion resistant: As I mentioned, I have no comparative data here. But my experience using Japanese tools leads me to believe that the abrasion resistance is really good. I have some turning tools that use powdered metal technology, and it appears that the abrasion resistance is similar.

Fine grained: Forged high carbon steel has a finer grain (>1 micron) than CPM 3V (2 microns).

Strong: Here's where the lamination comes in. Laminated forged high carbon steel has a higher impact toughness (>320 J) than CPM 3V (53-115 J).

This is what the data shows.

It is easier to get more consistent results with CPM 3V than with the forging process used to make forged high carbon steel, which also gives it a cost advantage. I don't argue that at all. What I am saying is that if you know what you are doing, you can get a forged high carbon steel that is at least as good, if not better, than modern day steels.

I haven't found any data on this yet, but I wouldn't be surprised if you analyzed the hard layer of 18th century laminated western chisels and plane blades and found similar results.

This is much like making dovetails. You can cut them by hand, or use a router jig. The router jig will make dovetails more consistently, and well. If you look at the spread of had cut dovetails, there will be many that are worse (like mine) than what a router jig will be able to do. But there will some people (like you) who have the skill to cut dovetails by hand that will be of better quality than by using a router jig.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#33

Re: Metalurgy Merry Go round

Adam Cherubini

>No I get you brother. All I'm trying to say is that the problem with the data is that it doesn't adequately predict the performance of a chisel. Woodworkers think of hardness as a tool's ability to penetrate a material. But it really doesn't work that way. Toughness does not equal edge holding.

I've mentioned a couple times that laminating hard steel to soft iron has legendary shock reduction. I could run a little program at work that would show the composite stiffness for the lined tool was less (better) than an unlined solid tool.

But the reality is, we sharpen our chisels to a very fine point. And the stiffness there is really all steel and the local stiffness will dictate the edge holding. You're not going to find test data for that. This is not an industrial use. So that data can be misleading.

Until someone does his doctoral thesis on this, I think we are better off trusting Todd Hughes who's said all this before. I think it's also true that modern Japanese chisels are nothing like samurai swords. And that's probably a good thing.

Adam

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#34

I was hoping to stay to of this round but...

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I will clarify some comparisons....

First, grain size by itself does not determine that this or that steel is "better". So, let us compare quantifiable performance factors.

Hardness: Hardness is determined by the ability of something to penetrate the alloy. 3V can be hardened to Rc64, with some sacrifice in toughness. Hardness mainly determines a tools resistance to bending or deflection, an important attribute for chisels and plane irons. Hardness has little to do with abrasion resistance. Abrasion resistance is determined by the carbides distributed in the steel matrix. CPM 3v contains vanadium and vanadium carbide is more abrasion resistant then iron carbide. Hence, a vanadium steel will typically be superior to carbon steel in abrasion resistance. The wood turners settled this issue long ago. All the high performance lathe tools are high in vanadium. But this is not 3V's strongest attribute.

Toughness: This is the ability of the steel to bend without breaking. This is 3V's most outstanding property and the reason it is considered by some (for example Jerry Hossom) to be the best combat knife steel. At a RC hardness of 60, 3V can be bent without breaking. Don't try this experiment with a carbon steel knife at Rc 60. This property makes 3V a superior chisel steel because it resists chipping.

Sharpening: There was a myth that Steve Elliot put to rest that tool steels could not be sharpened to the same degree as carbon steel, perhaps because of grain size or whatever. 3V, M2, M4 and similar tool steel can be sharpened equivalently, but it might take something harder than an ARK stone to do it because of the greater abrasion resistance of these alloys.

The bottom line for me is that I can't make, nor afford, a tool from boutique Japanese steel, so what ever its properties, its irrelevant. In the hand, as opposed to in the head, there would be little difference in my ability to make furniture that depended on the whether I had a Japanese sword chisel or a Two Cherries, or Swan. Now when it comes to making a chisel the choice is easy. I don't forge so I must rely on stock steel. What stock steel to use? Many would conclude 3V is a better choice than A2, for example. If Japanese sword steel was inherently superior I would think there would be industrial applications for it.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#35

Re: Metalurgy Merry Go round

Paul Kierstead

>But the reality is, we sharpen our chisels to a very fine point. And the stiffness there is really all steel and the local stiffness will dictate the edge holding. You're not going to find test data for that. This is not an industrial use. So that data can be misleading.

Ah, one of my pet peeves. Utter lack of relevant data.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#36

Re: backwards

Charlie

>Adam - nothing like the murder of a beautiful theory by a gang of brutal facts!

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#37

Chris Scholz

Re: backwards

Chris Scholz

>Attached a closeup of the bevel of our Master-Series blade to amplify your point.

The construction is similar to swords, but of course the steel is different. The cutting edge of swords is much softer than woodworking tools to avoid chipping (obviously the old warriors don't did not have time to sharpen their swords during battle). None of the Japanese blade makers that I aware of is capable of making swords, and yes our bladesmiths make highly-prized authentic reproduction swords that have won various international awards (including Japanese-style Samurai Katanas). As far as I know all blades are make with modern steel, I agree with Adam that the traditional way of cooking steel is a hit-and-miss process at best.

You can compare the ancient sword/blade design with modern high-tech designs such as composite materials used in modern fighter planes. If folded steel is done right the performace will exceed that of mono-steel design using comparable materials. On the the very high end (not currently on our website) we can also do various twist core patterns as custom blades similar to for top of the line custom swords. This is cosmetic, there is no performance increase over our Performance-Series Blade.

Some musings on grain size, resistance to chipping, etc. of cutting edge tools

Etched blades are a sure giveaway of tourist-quality tools. A good lamination/folding pattern is very subtle and is only visible at very high levels of polish.

By the way the art of sword making originated in ancient China and came to Japan via Korea (Amazing how much isolationism and Communism can screw up a great culture).

Chris


img

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#38

I like that description

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Let me just sum up this way- What the Japanese sword makers did is try to bake a cake without a measuring cup, without controlling what ingredients went in, and without a mixer. They baked what they had, it came out vanilla in some spots, chocolate in others and there were bits of egg shells and old boots. Then they crumbled it up and stuck it back together. They had no alternative. Modern cakes have precisely controlled ingredients and when we bite into them, we don't find any surprises. Guys can say they like the old ways, and that's fine. But it's not a better cake.

That pretty much sums it up, good description.

I stayed away from this discussion so far because I don't know enough to make statements on this subject. And there is some truth that "romanticism" has led some to turn Japanese steel into some kind of a legend. The fact is that Japan has very little mineral resources, and to manage to produce top quality steel (tamahagane), out of unknowm quality raw materials, by hand, with limited resources is totally amazing IMO. But like western steel, tamahagane is not a guarantee of quality, as there must have been bad cast steel too. The maker might be the most important link in the chain from ore to final product. Even with modern "paper" steel the maker still makes a difference.

You mentioned eslewhere that:

every cast steel chisel produced in Sheffield at the end of the 18th c, and throughout the 19th c was comprised of vastly superior steel

Besides qualifiying what "superior" means to you, in the end the proof of the pudding... One way to settle this discussion would be to get the best possible example of these Sheffield chisels, and compare it to modern alloys like CPM3V, A2, etc., and also to old (tamahagane) and new (paper steel) Japanese chisels. My limited experience has shown me that my Imai sword steel chisels take a keener edge and outlast by a wide margin my sole LN A2 chisel (this is obviously a non-scientific test here).

Until we do such a test (paramaters to be defined), all the theories and reasoning in the world won't give us the answer (if there is one)...

DC

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#39

Re: Sheffield steel superior

Patrick Gibbons, Somewhere in Texas

>Bugbear is right. An article in American Woodworker from the 1990's concerned the making of Japanese tools. Blue and white refers to the color of paper the Hitachi steels were wrapped in. Ellis was the editor then. He probably would remember the article.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#40

Re: backwards?

dburnard

>Did someone claiming that 18th century japanese woodworking tools were superior to 18th century western tools? I would seriously doubt that anyone reading this would have access to japanese tools of that vintage. Since the best tamahagane went to swordmaking, the materials used for toolmaking were not the best to begin with. Adam's point, as it applies to comparing pre-1870 period materials may well be correct. Raw materials don't determine the whole story, someone still has to forge and heat treat before it becomes a tool. But...

Tamahagane woodworking tools died out almost completely during the late 19th century (Meiji era) when Japan was opened to foreign trade (at gunpoint - no hard feelings I'm sure). High quality and comparatively inexpensive (through industrialization) western steels and wrought iron became available and were utilized to the fullest. Eventually Hitachi started producing comparable modern grades of cutting edge steels in their Yasuki mills - this became the white, blue and super blue steels we see today. The highly regarded Togo Reigo steel was imported from England. Many high end japanese woodworking tools are still made from imported Swedish high carbon tool steels.

The point is that the japanese tools we know and love/loathe are not made from tamahagane, not made from folded steel, but are made from modern homogenous high carbon tool steels laminated (once) to various types of soft iron/steel. They've been made that way almost exclusively for more than 120 years. So let's not confuse traditional japanese sword making techniques and mystique with toolmaking - that's the job of ad-men.

There are still a few tools made in the old way with tamahagane, or other hand manipulated steels, mostly for restoration work, where like Adam, they either choose or are mandated to use period accurate tools and techniques.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#41

I question the lack of relevant data

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Hardness and toughness are both relevant, if not the most relevant parameters for a chisel. These are common attributes studied and published for steel .

Chisel edges get dull by bending(crumbling) or chipping, unlike plane irons that normally dull through abrasion. Hence, one wants a steel that is tough (resists chipping) at high hardness for a chisel. For a first pass, comparing toughness vs hardness for various steels will enable selection of appropriate chisel steel. From this perspective, A2 was a poor choice compared to carbon steel.

The picture (if I recall, at 100X with a very expensive scope) is a Sorby chisel used for chopping dovetails in a controlled test from some years ago. Note the lack of hardness that led to edge crumbling. By contrast the edge failure for a Japanese chisel, as well as M2, was chipping.


img

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#42

Re: I question the lack of relevant data

Paul Kierstead

>Hardness and toughness are both relevant, if not the most relevant parameters for a chisel. These are common attributes studied and published for steel .

Show me the research.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#43

Re: I question the lack of relevant data

Adam Cherubini

>Hardness and toughness are certainly good starting places. But edge retention also has a lot to do with he size of the grains, the impurities at the grain boundaries, the shape of the grains themselves, and edge "morphology", the degree of polish.

There is no test data because real tests cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. Who's going to pay for that? Not Fine Wood Working magazine. And not Lie Nielsen or Master Yamaguchi

It's also true that this is an amazing complicated thing to test. The way you hold a chisel, hit it, the wood you push it into, the depth of penetration all play a roll.

So it's great to "go shopping" for mech. properties as Bill did. But personally, I'm much more interested in his subjective analysis than reading manufacturers' data sheets. I think his use over these past few years is more relevant.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#44

Re: I question the lack of relevant data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Bill, I was carving kiln dried white oak last week. It was repetitive work, a stack of the same stuff. As luck would have it, I was using my one and only blue chip chisel for some of the roughing cuts. After about 900 cuts, I looked at the edge with a lens before sharpening. It was abraded like a plane iron. There were no bends and no chips. I mention this because I think it points up the difficulty of testing these things. Who among the testers is going to sharpen the chisel the way I do? Who is going to handle the chisel the way I do?

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#45

Re: backwards

charlie belden, san jose, CA

>I think there's a key characteristic being overlooked. These are cutting tools that are both tough AND hard. A steel tool that is tough typically won't hold and edge well, but you won't chip the edge. A metal file has to be harder than the metal it will be used on - but files, while very hard, are brittle. The teeth can be very hard and sharp, holding an edge well. But drop one on the concrete, or hit it with a hammer - or a wooden mallet.

The japanese laminated cutting tools use the tough stuff for the body and the higher quality steel that will take - and hold an edge - where it's needed.

Then there's the decorative heat treating artwork that adds an aesthetic quality that takes the tool to another level entirely.

charlie belden

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#46

Reference *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Paul,

Your info. is correct. Attached link is a tabular summary from HItachi. I'm not sure which Swedish steel they use, but it is highly regarded as well. Uddeholm comes to mind.

Wiley


Hitachi Blade Steel

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#47

Re: I was hoping to stay to of this round but...

ThomD

>I agree with most of that. Good sense.

"This is 3V's most outstanding property and the reason it is considered by some (for example Jerry Hossom) to be the best combat knife steel."

Of course there is pretty nearly zero agreement as to what makes a good combat knife, since in large measure it is nothing more than a thought experiment. That said the modern history of a Bowie sized knife with the ability to bend not break is pretty clear. It is a series of attributes consistant with hand forged and heat treated carbon steel knives. Bill Moran set that ball rolling, and the ABS continues the tradition and requires Journeyman and Master smiths to complete projects of a high order that pass that test. The tests require that a carbon blade with great edge holding, as tested, be bent to 90 degree with no chipping of the edge. There are a number of ways of getting there, but the simplest is differential hardening.

" At a RC hardness of 60, 3V can be bent without breaking. Don't try this experiment with a carbon steel knife at Rc 60. This property makes 3V a superior chisel steel because it resists chipping.

"

As far as chisels are concerned, you can't chip what you don't pry. Sorta inspirational in that regard are machine tool bits that waste yards of steel, let alone wood, and remain sharp. Most of these machines are designed to keep cutting geometry clean as should we all so aspire.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#48

Re: backwards

Todd Hughes

>I believe that the Japanese style sword was devoloped because of the difficulty of the jappanes to produce high quality steel and not because they had easy access to high quality steel. How they were made was a way to make a very high quality blade out of what they had to work with.....and it worked very well. The master bladesmith I apprenticed with told me befor he thinks if they had old chevy truck springs in Jappan back then as a source of steel they would never have devoloped the methods they did to make these swords and thier steel.

I sort of collect old Jappanese swords and blades and they are things of wonder. Cant really compare them to a western sword because you are comparing apples to oranges....Todd

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#49

Re: I question the lack of relevant data

wilbur

>I do agree that this is very complicated stuff, and that shopping for mechanical properties in steel doesn't really predict how the tool will perform.

I am a bit frustrated, though, on how these sorts of conversations tend to develop. It seems that one can't mention Japanese toolmaking without also bringing in terms like "romanticism", "hype", "myth", and "oriental mumbo-jumbo", all of which have been used on this forum in this context. On the other hand, modern day steels are "engineered" to be better.

This is why I try to bring some data to the discussion. It may not be great data, or the be all and end all of this subject, but at least it serves as a point of comparison. And one of the reasons I looked into numbers for hardness, grain size, toughness, and abrasion resistance is that those were all the factors mentioned in why modern day steels should be better than forged high carbon steel.

To which point, there are responses along the lines of the numbers don't predict tool performance, or are not important in those cases where the data suggest that forged high carbon steel may perform better than previously suggested.

Which leaves us ultimately with subjective analysis of the tool in use, which I agree is probably the only test, if it really can be called a "test", that matters. But isn't subjective analysis the very thing that romanticism and hype is built on?

Not that it's a bad thing: one thing that I dislike about the BCS college bowl system the way it stands is that it takes away one of the great party conversation topics: who really should have been ranked #1 in the AP poll.

One other comment on CPM 3V/forged high carbon steel comparison: Is there any documentation on being able to harden CPM 3V to RC 64? I couldn't find any, including looking at the spec sheet from the manufacturer.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#50

chipping failure in chisels- summary of a study

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You said, "As far as chisels are concerned, you can't chip what you don't pry."

To "pick a nit" what mortise chisels do is pry and what got me into making chisels in the first place was the desire to own a mortise chisel that held up better and was more ergonomically favorable than the Two Cherries. In the end what we made performed better too because it could be sharpened to penetrate easier and still have the edge survive the pounding and prying of mortise construction.

How chisels get dull: Now we all agree that chisels get dull which means the sharp edge is no longer present. The edge can go away by wear, deformation as see in the picture of the Sorby chisel or by micro chipping as seen in the picture below. (My one Swan chisel failed (dulled) by the same mode as the Sorby but not as readily) In this study the chisels were used for chopping dovetail waste and all the chisels failed(dulled) either by chipping or bending(crumbling) more or less. I suppose that in paring or carving the failure of the edge could be by abrasion but I have not studied this facet of chisels dulling nor sen an abrasion failure except in plane irons.

Chipping is an edge failure(dulling) mode for some chisels(steels). They are not large chips or even chips one can see with out magnification. But in the case where the steel is not sufficiently tough, bits and pieces of the cutting edge will break away as seen in the picture. In the case of the picture the chisel was sharpened at 27 degrees and the waste from 10 dovetails was chopped as part of a study on edge retention of chisels used for chopping dovetails.

It was from these studies that we concluded that a balance of toughness and hardness was the most important property for a steel used in mortise chisels and chisels used for chopping (struck by a mallet).

As an aside, I think it is better to have the edge dull by deformation rather than by chipping. In this regard I must "eat crow" and admit that a hard ARK stone has merit, even with a modern steel like 3V. If the edge deforms it can be largely brought back to life by honing on something hard and smooth, eg a hard ARK stone. However, if the edge is too brittle(not tough) and it chips away, this chip notch is a propagation for more chipping and wear. Rubbing on an ARK stone will not restore sharpness without abrading away the damaged metal.


img