Re: "lining" versus "laminating"
ThomD
>"Maybe there's some (purposeful) confusion between "lining", laminating a piece of steel to wrought iron or low carbon steel as a way of saving the cost or use of steel,"
This is a constant refrain, I doubt very much that economics had anything to do with it. When you are making a sword for someone you regard as a god, I don't think this is the issue. You may be confusing Williamsburg freeman peasant culture, with Japanese samurai and court culture. What was there are the time was more like being on the Sadam Iraqui soccer team.
" and "laminating" non-homogenous steel to make a more homogenous product."
I am not sure what you are saying here, The folding of the billet used in making a sword is not done to make it more homogenous, it is done to combine properties, if they become too blended one has gone too far. It is like we mix materials to make bread and want it to be well blended, though even there it is "better" if there is a little texture left to it. When we make pastry the idea is retain distinct separation in layers. With swords it needs to be mixed to retain properties of the combined metals. It's a bit like a cloth that combines carbon and kevlar strands, a comon composite solution.
"Personally, I prefer "lined""
This is a new word to me, great, we need yet another word...
" steel blades (I've called them laminated in the past because they are indeed laminated). Forge welding steel to a softer material makes for a blade that is easier to sharpen."
Another property of no concern to a samurai
"Legend has it, there are some vibration or impact reducing properties due to the difference in Young's modulii."
Your legend tellers are unusually well read in metallurgy...
" I don't know of any western chisel makers still doing this. The Japanese chisels are certainly lined and that is indeed an advantage in my book."
Or put in a different way, I don't know of any western chisel makers who are making chisels period, two spaces. I mean what LN etc... are doing is virtually not even a business, and has zero centrality to anything seriously socially important. It's nice for us, but not a defining attribute of modern US civilization.
"The lamination of Samurai swords was done because sword makers were making their own blister steel."
I don't think so
"Blister steel is made with a wrought iron bar"
I am unaware they bought their steel in a bar, form or locale. I am being picky because there is an unusual amount of dismissal going on in these threads, and where there is dismissal there may be some faulty assumptions.
", placed in a sort of kiln (or forge), and packed with carbon. The kiln heats up to 3000F and the iron absorbs some carbon and becomes steel."
The pictures I have seen show a material rather like steel wool being used in this process, maybe they got a better distribution of carbon that you are assuming based on you amero peasant technology.
"The problem with blister steel is that it is steel only on the outside and remains iron in the center. And the diistribution of carbon is inconsistent. By continually forging that into thinner and thinner layers and welding the layers together, you can minimize the effect of the non-homogenous metal."
Anyone just happening on this discussion would assume therefore that their swords or chisels were sorta inferior to a Fuller chisel in a blisterpack. While as we know, there has never been a test in a US mag that identified the cutting power of a Japanese chisel as inferior to the best anyone else could muster. Things that make you go Hmm.
" That's what Japan's great sword smiths did. "
Their results may vary
"There may be people still doing this. They certainly did this a few years ago in Colonial Williamsburg."
That would be the "came several generation too late and am just guessing" leading the "I don't do this for a living...". A similar gathering in Japan, if they needed to gather, would be composed of the "my family have done this for generations, (beat steel)" selling to the "my family have done this for generations (beat chisels)". Se we have to have these windy discussions, because at the base, none of us has much idea what we are doing. Even if we have been at it for 40 years. Who amongst us actually makes a living with hand tools? I mean sweating, hitting, sawing, and planing all day long. There are people out there who do.
"it remains structurally inferior to the leaf springs at my nearby metal scrap yard."
Yeah, but what does that mean? Leaf springs are tough as all get out, and can be made into wonderful knives and swords, at least given the skill level we have in the present age.
Things are only "structurally inferior" relative to some defined need, It would be surprising, and I don't think it is likely correct, if.6 percent carbon steel/leaf spring stock were actually superior to any of the steels in common use for better boutique chisels.