Re: Metallurgy of Swords and Chisels (long and bor
ThomD
>"REAL WORLD TESTING
The only way to know for sure who makes a good chisel is to test them in a real world application. FWW tested chisels by pounding them into red oak (FWW #139). The top 3 were all Japanese models. #4 was Hirsch which corroborates what many of us have found ourselves empirically. Interestingly, the top 3 chisels were all very hard, all in excess of 62 RcC. Aside from these, Rc hardness was no indicator of performance. (#1 was 64, #2 was 67, #15 was 63) This tells me that Rc hardness is not a good measure of performance of a chisel."
This was not a real world test though, it was a test with all the usual problems. For instance Japanese chisels are not designed for red oak; using a consistent (and subjective) sharpening routine is like feeding every car the same gas regardless) The largest whoopsie to me was that the deformation standard appeared to be out by an order of magnitude or two.
I don't remember exactly but their erosion standard seemed to measure an area and penetration (or some such), and then string them out in a linear fashion when what was being measured was exponential. It sounded sorta like saying the 22 is half as powerful as the 45, because it has only half the diameter, while it's an area and height issue, and a whole lot more to boot. In this case it was an area and penenetration issue. Just seemed like their ranking was good and their order of mag was bad. My gut was that a square was closer to reality than a directly linear variance.
"METALLURGY MERRY GO ROUND
I think woodworkers should avoid discussion of metallurgy."
My sister got her PHD in stats from Oxford doing stuff for CM/US steel in Pittsburgh. As I remember it there are a lot of things you don't want to know about what they don't/didn't know about welds in nuke plants. So right, I imagine nobody is actually saying anything that makes any sense here, and should they start "nobody" will understand it.
"Misunderstandings of even basic principles (like what heat treating is, what a critical temperature is, or at what temperature a steel goes non-magnetic) are so prevalent, that we may end up worse off for the discussion."
Yeah all that stuff is impenetrable Houdini stuff unless you need to make something you can't buy, and just go through the motions. Frying sausages is more difficult.
"I've found that modern blacksmiths and among the worst offenders."
I think that is extremely unlikely unless you mean the guys who shape steel rods into flowers, and even then most of those guys have scary shop skills, make hugely more stuff than the average woodworker etc... Here it's "send me the catalog", those guys just make the tools from found junk.
"I think it's very telling that these folks can make very good blades without understanding the steel phase diagram."
Did you understand what that was when this thread started. That stuff is in blade magi all the time. The only reason to understand it is if you want a graphic treatment of something you can learn from reading the label on the steel, or just enjoy that kind of thing. Sorta like taking a verbal set of directions, reading a map, or using your car's GPS. Plenty of guys can do all three. A lot of guys do or used to use scrap, so to some extent it wasn't diagramed, and they had to wing it. Makes sense, right?
"MY ADVICE
When it comes to choosing a chisel, I think woodworkers are better served listening to their friends, or trusting their own hands to guide their decision. Metallurgy is too complicated and too misleading to be of use to us."
It's just the long way around. One may enjoy the view, or find local customs odd.
"Japanese chisels clearly outperform others in edge holding tests. But the exact reason for their performance is not at all all clear."
A lot of it has nothing to do with the steel in them, which is why one Swedish maker made a close copy years back, of the form.
"It's certainly not as simple as their choice of materials, or technique of lining hard steel to soft."
Nor is it independent of it since the planes are even "simpler" And the edges still have a big impact.
"I suspect the differences between chisels have much more to do with the intentions and values of their makers and the amount of labor that can be put into the finished product."
Doubtless, though even mass produced replaceable edge razors, or Japanese carbide router bits turn out better. In the later case you can get all kinds of unlikely arguments about carbide size making this impossible.
One thing that is extraordinary is that the performance difference is still there. I keep in mind that:
a) old every day tools were pretty good, and if I never saw another Japanese tool, my output wouldn't change.
b) tools when the modern thing started where crap, in the late 70s. Stuff we can routinely buy today, and it just works, we had to make or modify to get something (or use old tools though that was kinda a parallel line, maybe because the makers weren't buying ads.
c) The Japanese tools are still better. Hotley isn't better, LN isn't better, etc... There isn't any reason why the "gap" can't be narrowed, in fact it has been narrowed, but not by so much that the difference doesn't remain noticeable.
At some point this argument will go on and the gap may have disappeared, perhaps the Japanese biz will die out, or the domestic business will catch up.