Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

Posts

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#51

Re: I question the lack of relevant data *LINK*

Phil Smith

>Rc 64 is well above the recommended working range of CPM 3V. Can't imagine why you would need a Rc of 64 for typically woodworking. But if you do then the steel of choice would be M4.

That being said the iron that stays in my LN 4 1/2 smoother is a custom made iron made from CPM M4 hardened to Rc of 64. Why did I harden to Rc 64 - because I could and seemed like a good thing to do at the time. I was trying to squeeze last bit of performance out of the steel and Rc 64 is within the working range of the steel. If I were doing it over would harden to Rc 60 to 62.

This steel is significantly more wear resistant to abrasives than CPM 3V and way more resistant than either O1 or A2. How do I know about abrasive resistance. 1. Cost to have back of 4 irons surface ground flat was way more $ for the M4 than I paid for CPM 3V. 2. Polishing the backs of the irons was significantly slower than for any other iron I have polished. I have chisels/plane iron ranging in steels ranging from S7, Japanese, 01, A2, CPM 3V and these M4 plane irons. From memory it took 2 to 3 times as long for the M4 using diamond powder on a cast iron plate as it did for the 3V. 3. This is the iron that stays in the smoother and no I don't sharpen very often.

Link below is for recommended Rc hardness for various steels.


http://www.crucibleservice.com/products/metalForming/formingBending/workingHard.cfm

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#52

Top Hardness for CPM 3V

Steve Elliott

>According to the current data sheet for 3V the as-quenched hardness after being austenitized at 2050 deg F (the highest shown) is Rc63. The highest hardness after tempering is Rc61.

I had one blade heat treated using the manufacturer's recommendation for "the best combination of toughness and wear resistance" which gives a hardness of Rc59. That blade did not hold an edge as well as the blades at Rc61.

For what it's worth, the exact heat treating schedule I use is no longer listed on the Crucible Steel data sheet, although it was on Issue 1 of the data sheet. This calls for austinitizing at 1950 F and tempering at 950 F. The final hardness is Rc61, although the heat treater says there is variation of about +/- 1 in tested hardness of blades treated using any schedule.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#53

prying failure in chisels

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>To "pick a nit" what mortise chisels do is pry

I don't pry with my mortise chisels. If things are going well, they chop at a very deep angle; but the prying is saved for special bottom clearing tools.

Pam

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#54

Optimum for CPM 3V

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The knife makers have come to the same conclusion. A 3V hardness of 61-62 is optimum for their edges. 3V is tough enough to hold up at this hardness.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#55

I disagree

Adam Cherubini

>"It seems that one can't mention Japanese toolmaking without also bringing in terms like "romanticism", "hype", "myth", and "oriental mumbo-jumbo", all of which have been used on this forum in this context."

And I grant you that some of that sounds like racism. But from my perspective, Japanese chisel manufacturers and dealers have benefitted for too long by misleading woodworkers about their products. If you are looking for someone to be angry with, aim your frustration at them. Thomas isn't the only woodworker who has been misled by their inferences that Japanese chisels are somehow similar to samurai swords. They are not. Google "chisel Japanese samurai sword" and you'll find many many woodworkers are similarly misled.

One of the problems appears to be that we (ThomD specifically) are confused about the difference between a "lined" tool which is hard steel "laminated" to soft, and "shear" steel which is blister steel folded over and "laminated" or forge welded together. These are not similar processes and they can result in very different tools. Clearly manufacturers are benefitting from not parsing out the differences and allowing woodworkers to confuse the two.

Then there's the whole "white steel" "blue steel" thing. Are these different materials? Is there really no AISI designation for these? If it's 1095, why not just call it 1095? I think the answer is that Japanese chisel merchants are lining their pockets with the hype, myth and mumbo-jumbo. That's not racism, it's business and it's being conducted at our expense.

Adam

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#56

How I read what they said

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Adam and all,

I read Thomas' original post to say that he believed that advanced forging skill is still alive in Japan. Not that Tasai or Imai or Funahiro are forging blades from raw steel ingot out of a tatara. I agree with you that some--not all-- Japanese tool dealers do engage in hype, and show the smiths' wives wielding the large hammer. However, they are clear that the steel in the blades is Hitachi white steel or blue steel. I provided a link in this thread to the definition of those steels. You expressed displeasure that Hitachi is not using AISI designations--why?

Thom was only confused about your terminology, where early in the thread you were using the term 'laminated' when you meant 'folded', and then coined the new word 'lined' to clarify what you meant. It was confusing.

Wilbur does not want to be upset with anyone. Dr. Pan cited some data which to him were on point; he was trying to take the argument beyond the loaded words into rational territory; you dismissed his data as being irrelevant; he then tried to pull you back to his data in a calm but direct way--and you deflected that by saying he should go be upset somewhere else. Fair?

I found your essay to be wonderfully provocative (it caused me to do much looking up of things), with many original and valid insights.

Wiley

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#57

forward *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

Adam's remarkable post got me to searching. Here's an interesting piece I came across, particularly in light of the nuclear power revival proceeding in the world. See link.

Short version: Japan Steel is the only outfit in the world able to make a monolithic pour of a nuclear containment vessel. They also make high-end swords in a shack off the side. This is the same company that poured the 18" naval gun barrels for the battleship Yamato, which was sunk by US Navy aircraft in 1945, so their expertise goes back a ways.

Wiley


600-Ton single-pour nuclear containment vessel

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#58

This raises an important point

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I was going to add some levity to this discussion by making a picture of my mortise chisel sitting in the mortise waiting for the chips to spontaneously fly out without prying (snicker)....but I resisted to make a more serious point. How we work and fight, seems to be a product of tools and weapons. I had an interesting discussion with a blade expert last night, the woodworking relevant results of which I will post later. He claimed the style of Japanese sword fighting was a result of the properties of the sword steel- namely what it could and could not stand up to. Bashing Renaissance Fair style was not its strong suite. (Presumably the Europeans fought this way as reenacted at these fairs?) He claimed the swords would bend and the edge would chip if handled improperly in combat so the combat was adjusted to accommodate the steel. They would not, in spite of what I have been told with great authority by some traders of Japanese swords, cut a gun barrel through with a stoke. These sorts of claims are the "mumbo jumbo" I refer to.

But to the point, I most definitely pry with a mortise chisel. When I am done chopping (and prying) the bottom of the mortise is done. I delight in the snap the chips make as the grain shears at the bottom of the mortise. I mortise the way I do because the tool enables me to do so. A chisel made of less tough steel would undoubtedly break at the tip the way I use one. As slow as I am at anything I can not claim my technique is superior or that someone else should buy new steel to enable them to use this technique.

It is common for chisels to be sharpened at what ever angle holds up. There have been discussions of steepening the angle on LV chisels to accommodate the inferior toughness of A2 (vs the best carbon steel), and more discussions of not hollow grinding Japanese chisels so as to not weaken the edge. In the end when the technique is adjusted to the tool at hand, by in large one way seems to be equivalent to another in terms of getting the job done.

Here is my thought for the day.........The bottom line is that every experienced woodworker thinks their steel is best because their technique has been optimized to accommodate the properties of their tool, something Warren alluded to way up the lines of this post, or maybe it was another. So what is the "best" steel is only relevant in the context of the details of how the tool will be used.

That said I need to get back to wacking out dovetails in the oak trunk. I broke a jar of butyl cellosolve and I'm waiting for the shop to air out. I hate the smell of that stuff(I know, shouldn't store solvent in glass)

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#59

OT: "if they had old chevy truck springs..."

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>We own two ladderback chairs and one rocker with footstool, given us as wedding and congrats-on-new-baby presents by older friends a long time ago now (celebrating 37 years of marriage this weekend). Hickory chairs, with woven hickory bark seats. The son of our friends told us that, when they visited the maker once, he took them out back to look at the great new material he'd found for weaving seats, way better than the hickory bark: plastic crate strapping.

Romance sometimes requires a little distance from the actual production.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#60

"I sort of collect old Japanese swords..."

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>That means you've only got 2-300, right, Todd? If you were really collecting, instead of just sort of collecting, I imagine the count would exceed 1,000.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#61

data interpretation

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The data quoted in these posts is grain size and hardness, neither of which by itself predicts performance. That fact that some steel can be hardened to RcXX is but half the story if the application also demands toughness. Carbon steel can be taken to the high 60's but it is so brittle as to be useless in a cutlery application. Similarly, small grain size by itself does not predict an ability to obtain or hold a refined edge.

I make a case in a post below that "best" is only relevant in the context of the details of the application.

I'll post later how carbon steel does well in competitive performance events where edge sharpness and durability are important but that modern steels are winning and Japanese style cutlery is not competitive.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#62

Re: data interpretation

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill,

Did you mean to reply to my post? I was not arguing the data, or arguing about Japanese chisels. Am very happy to let people use whatever tools suit them, and you'll notice I don't proselytize. I don't think it matters very much what tools anyone uses. Eventually, we get good with what we have, or we don't.

I was just trying for enough civility, so that data can be discussed.

Wiley

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#63

Re: This raises an important point

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Here is my thought for the day.........The bottom line is that every experienced woodworker thinks their steel is best because their technique has been optimized to accommodate the properties of their tool, something Warren alluded to way up the lines of this post, or maybe it was another. So what is the "best" steel is only relevant in the context of the details of how the tool will be used.


That one gets my goat...

So an experienced woodworker optimizes his/her work towards a given steel type, because they don't know about other types that could be better suited to their work. Don't you find that limitating?

We're talking steel types, sharpening methods, time and money, etc. In the end, if someone doesn't search for ways to get better performing tools (with everything that goes with that) we might as well turn back to bronze tools...

DC

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#64

Re: I disagree

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Adam, Adam, your post reminds me of a couple of friends who, whenever anyone disagrees with their positions accuse the offender of having been brainwashed, of being confused, and other insulting things.

Pam

PS I'm not sure more than one of these people is a friend anymore.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#65

Re: This raises an important point

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I think we probably don't know all the ramifications of using the tools we buy until after some use; but I've discovered that some processes I've picked up to at least partially accommodate my tools are actually superior to other processes even when using other styles of tools, in that they're faster, result in better, more precise joinery, etc.

Now you may like the sound of prying out a chip, but to me it sounds like something breaking, usually the wood. I don't like to break wood, rather convince it to do what I want with grace and aplomb. :)

Pam

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#66

Re: This raises an important point

Paul Kierstead

>We're talking steel types, sharpening methods, time and money, etc. In the end, if someone doesn't search for ways to get better performing tools (with everything that goes with that) we might as well turn back to bronze tools...

Taken to the extreme, as you have, it is true. But on the other hand, putting large investment of effort for a 5% improvement could be equally foolish, depending on the frequency you use the tool. Actually, even a 20% improvement may not be worth a significant effort if the tool is used infrequently or if the 20% doesn't mean much (eg, if it only takes 10 seconds to sharpen, even a lot of sharpenings don't help much if you reduce this to 8 seconds, percentages notwithstanding).

Just saying there are two sides to the optimization coin is all.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#67

yes to both your points.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Dennis and Paul, you are both right. The improvement to an established woodworker resulting from a new material or method- be it diamond, 3V, or whatever- may be too small to bother with, or involve an unacceptable cost.

That accepted, they should not use their position as respected professionals to dismiss or discourage the investigation of new materials or methods, or dismiss the possibility that there can be an improvement ( my personal "goat getter").

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#68

Metallurgy of Swords and Chisels (long and boring)

Adam Cherubini

>Wilbur linked us to a few sources. I'm not sure if anybody read them. I did and dismissed them. But I think I did it too abruptly and disrespectfully. Sorry Wilbur. I'm skipping the CPM debate, and focusing in on Japanese Swords and their relationship to woodworking tools. I think that's the heart of the matter here.

The paper Wilbur linked appears to have been published recently by two fellows working with US government grant money at the Lawrence Livermore Labs in the University of California.

LAMINATE STRUCTURE

The section on Japanese swords is not long but includes some interesting offerings. They seemed to refute the notion of the Japanese swords retaining evidence of laminate structure. I suspect you could discern layers of more and less carbon in the blade's cross section. This gets very complicated, very quickly, but here's what they said about it:

"to produce the high-carbon part of the blade, the steel was subjected to multiple folding operations; this has given rise to the erroneous concept that the swords contain millions of discrete layers."

Their belief is that the final product is more like a modern Japanese (lined) chisel; A laminate of two parts. The author quotes one source saying:

"Tylecote goes as far as to say, "There is essentially no difference in principle between a scythe [made from shear steel], and a Japanese sword."

I understand why they are saying this. It has to do with how we think about and analyze composite structures. We analyze them as separate entities. When the outer layer is stretched and undergoes plastic or elastic deformation, load transfers through the weaker bond (matrix) to the next stronger layer. This is the way wood works, btw. The advantage of the composite is you can access strength of the main material, and elasticity of the matrix. From an engineering perspective, it's important to discern the different elements that make up the composite. With a Japanese sword its possible the layers are so close together that they all strain together, functioning as one. I don't know this for a fact, but it would explain why the authors are saying what they are saying.

CARBON CONTENT

The authors gave "before forging" and "after forging" data on Carbon content for the Japanese sword steel. They didn't make it clear to me how they knew the "before" state. Wilbur said he thought the swords were "Ultra High Carbon Steel" as some Japanese chisels are. To be fair, I thought they were too. I just didn't think that the laminated Blister steel was similar to modern homogenous steel.

UHCS is defined as steel with an excess of 1% Carbon. More carbon makes steel capable of achieving higher hardness. But he and I missed this gem:

"The Japanese sword's external sheath has a similar carbon content (i.e., it can be hypereutectoid, about 0.8-1%C)"

This sounds very similar to 1095, which according to the SAE and AISI specs can have carbon content from .90-1.03%

Hitachi makes steel with Carbon content of up to 1.4%. They grade the resulting material into .1% grades. So theoretically you could buy 1.4% or 1.3% or 1.2% C steel from Hitachi. And I think that some chisel manufacturers are doing just that. But don't forget that forging steel causes a reduction in carbon (called decarburization). This is local effect that grinding would remove.

The authors suggest that the material Japanese sword makers started with was 1.6-1.8% C. This gibes with what Williamsburg came up with when they made blister steel a few years ago. The many folds of a japanese sword certainly would have made the blister steel more homogenous, but it would have reduced the carbon (in a good way) throughout the blade. The problem is that Carbon is a not a good indicator of real world performance.

IMPACT TOUGHNESS

Here's what they said in the paper about impact toughness of true laminates:

"The dramatic improvement in the impact properties of the laminated composite is a result of notch blunting by extensive delaminations that occur on either side of the

initial crack direction in all samples."

Keep in mind, they are saying the Japanese sword is not a laminate in the sense that the steel is folded. They are saying it's a laminate like a Japanese chisel is a laminate. They believe Japanese swords had wrought iron cores, so this data doesn't really apply. And delamination is a bad thing in a chisel. And this is really not speaking to the type of structure we're dealing with (either the sword or the chisel).

MATERIALS TESTING

I've seen many specimen tests and conducted a few myself. Materials testing is generally performed to get gross mechanical properties of a sample. You don't use a materials test to ascertain if a lower control arm of an SUV can withstand a 6" deep pot hole. For that, we generally build several control arms and test them on pot holes (for example). This is not the same as a subjective test. It's just a recognition, won through experience, that the real world is more complicated than a notched sample in a load cell. To this end, tests of chisels have been done and are worthy of our attention.

REAL WORLD TESTING

The only way to know for sure who makes a good chisel is to test them in a real world application. FWW tested chisels by pounding them into red oak (FWW #139). The top 3 were all Japanese models. #4 was Hirsch which corroborates what many of us have found ourselves empirically. Interestingly, the top 3 chisels were all very hard, all in excess of 62 RcC. Aside from these, Rc hardness was no indicator of performance. (#1 was 64, #2 was 67, #15 was 63) This tells me that Rc hardness is not a good measure of performance of a chisel.

Carbon content and grain size also doesn't seem to be good indicators of performance in the real world. An earlier FWW article reprinted in "FWW on Hand Tools" listed carbon content and grain sizes for leading chisels. Marples chisels (which I think many regard as junky) had 1.18% Carbon, the highest in the sample. Hirsch had the finest grain. Neither were chosen as top performers.

METALLURGY MERRY GO ROUND

I think woodworkers should avoid discussion of metallurgy. It's not well understood and in the best of cases doesn't provide meaningful guidance on how to purchase, use, or sharpen a chisel or plane iron. Misunderstandings of even basic principles (like what heat treating is, what a critical temperature is, or at what temperature a steel goes non-magnetic) are so prevalent, that we may end up worse off for the discussion. I've found that modern blacksmiths and among the worst offenders. I think it's very telling that these folks can make very good blades without understanding the steel phase diagram.

MY ADVICE

When it comes to choosing a chisel, I think woodworkers are better served listening to their friends, or trusting their own hands to guide their decision. Metallurgy is too complicated and too misleading to be of use to us. Japanese chisels clearly outperform others in edge holding tests. But the exact reason for their performance is not at all all clear. It's certainly not as simple as their choice of materials, or technique of lining hard steel to soft. I suspect the differences between chisels have much more to do with the intentions and values of their makers and the amount of labor that can be put into the finished product.

Adam

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#69

Wonderful post!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Adam, thank you so much for taking the time and thought, and sharing of your expertise, to prepare this detailed post. The interpretation of some findings of the Stanford study are especially valuable, because it's difficult for non-experts to understand what these technical studies mean, even though we may understand the words. It is the real-world translation that is so valuable.

Wiley

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#70

I Agree Completely. Thank You, Adam.

Hank Knight

>

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#71

Re: Metallurgy of Swords and Chisels (long and bor

wilbur

>Thanks for the input Adam. I'm not looking to be upset, as Wiley said. I'm glad you see where I'm coming from, and be assured that I see where you're coming from as well.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#72

Re: I disagree

Charles

>Well said.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#73

Re: chipping failure in chisels- summary of a stud

ThomD

>"To "pick a nit" what mortise chisels do is pry"

Not in my shop they don't, and even in most shops prying is what people do when they fail to release the chips. The new foot mortising machine I got takes this in interesting direction because it seems capable of making a motise without any prying and with minimal sequensing, and with purely vertical motion. There is a lateral motion but it is the opposite of a pry it's just bevel driven as in any chisel cut. There is nothing earth shatering about this for me, but it is incable of prying, while I might be cheating.

"and was more ergonomically favorable than the Two Cherries."

That just seems like such a low standard.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#74

Re: Metallurgy of Swords and Chisels (long and bor

ThomD

>"REAL WORLD TESTING

The only way to know for sure who makes a good chisel is to test them in a real world application. FWW tested chisels by pounding them into red oak (FWW #139). The top 3 were all Japanese models. #4 was Hirsch which corroborates what many of us have found ourselves empirically. Interestingly, the top 3 chisels were all very hard, all in excess of 62 RcC. Aside from these, Rc hardness was no indicator of performance. (#1 was 64, #2 was 67, #15 was 63) This tells me that Rc hardness is not a good measure of performance of a chisel."

This was not a real world test though, it was a test with all the usual problems. For instance Japanese chisels are not designed for red oak; using a consistent (and subjective) sharpening routine is like feeding every car the same gas regardless) The largest whoopsie to me was that the deformation standard appeared to be out by an order of magnitude or two.

I don't remember exactly but their erosion standard seemed to measure an area and penetration (or some such), and then string them out in a linear fashion when what was being measured was exponential. It sounded sorta like saying the 22 is half as powerful as the 45, because it has only half the diameter, while it's an area and height issue, and a whole lot more to boot. In this case it was an area and penenetration issue. Just seemed like their ranking was good and their order of mag was bad. My gut was that a square was closer to reality than a directly linear variance.

"METALLURGY MERRY GO ROUND

I think woodworkers should avoid discussion of metallurgy."

My sister got her PHD in stats from Oxford doing stuff for CM/US steel in Pittsburgh. As I remember it there are a lot of things you don't want to know about what they don't/didn't know about welds in nuke plants. So right, I imagine nobody is actually saying anything that makes any sense here, and should they start "nobody" will understand it.

"Misunderstandings of even basic principles (like what heat treating is, what a critical temperature is, or at what temperature a steel goes non-magnetic) are so prevalent, that we may end up worse off for the discussion."

Yeah all that stuff is impenetrable Houdini stuff unless you need to make something you can't buy, and just go through the motions. Frying sausages is more difficult.

"I've found that modern blacksmiths and among the worst offenders."

I think that is extremely unlikely unless you mean the guys who shape steel rods into flowers, and even then most of those guys have scary shop skills, make hugely more stuff than the average woodworker etc... Here it's "send me the catalog", those guys just make the tools from found junk.

"I think it's very telling that these folks can make very good blades without understanding the steel phase diagram."

Did you understand what that was when this thread started. That stuff is in blade magi all the time. The only reason to understand it is if you want a graphic treatment of something you can learn from reading the label on the steel, or just enjoy that kind of thing. Sorta like taking a verbal set of directions, reading a map, or using your car's GPS. Plenty of guys can do all three. A lot of guys do or used to use scrap, so to some extent it wasn't diagramed, and they had to wing it. Makes sense, right?

"MY ADVICE

When it comes to choosing a chisel, I think woodworkers are better served listening to their friends, or trusting their own hands to guide their decision. Metallurgy is too complicated and too misleading to be of use to us."

It's just the long way around. One may enjoy the view, or find local customs odd.

"Japanese chisels clearly outperform others in edge holding tests. But the exact reason for their performance is not at all all clear."

A lot of it has nothing to do with the steel in them, which is why one Swedish maker made a close copy years back, of the form.

"It's certainly not as simple as their choice of materials, or technique of lining hard steel to soft."

Nor is it independent of it since the planes are even "simpler" And the edges still have a big impact.

"I suspect the differences between chisels have much more to do with the intentions and values of their makers and the amount of labor that can be put into the finished product."

Doubtless, though even mass produced replaceable edge razors, or Japanese carbide router bits turn out better. In the later case you can get all kinds of unlikely arguments about carbide size making this impossible.

One thing that is extraordinary is that the performance difference is still there. I keep in mind that:

a) old every day tools were pretty good, and if I never saw another Japanese tool, my output wouldn't change.

b) tools when the modern thing started where crap, in the late 70s. Stuff we can routinely buy today, and it just works, we had to make or modify to get something (or use old tools though that was kinda a parallel line, maybe because the makers weren't buying ads.

c) The Japanese tools are still better. Hotley isn't better, LN isn't better, etc... There isn't any reason why the "gap" can't be narrowed, in fact it has been narrowed, but not by so much that the difference doesn't remain noticeable.

At some point this argument will go on and the gap may have disappeared, perhaps the Japanese biz will die out, or the domestic business will catch up.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#75

Re: I disagree

ThomD

>"One of the problems appears to be that we (ThomD specifically) are confused about the difference between a "lined" tool which is hard steel "laminated" to soft, and "shear" steel which is blister steel folded over and "laminated" or forge welded together. These are not similar processes and they can result in very different tools. Clearly manufacturers are benefitting from not parsing out the differences and allowing woodworkers to confuse the two."

I'm not confused by it, I'm merely resistant to a whole new nomenclature, nice try at twisting that around. I should probably let the whole sword thing go. I don't really care how they were made, etc... As related to tools. I own a lot of Japanese tools and none of them are sword steel, so what is the issue for tool buyers generally? On the other hand you have said, to be kind, some questionable things about swords, Adam, and I guess I thought you were reaching out. :)

"Then there's the whole "white steel" "blue steel" thing. Are these different materials?"

These are the colours of the paper the steels are packed in. You can buy these steels if you want, they aren't expensive. You might be missing just a little bit of basic info. Did you ever build that forge we talked about, by the way?

White #1 1.2-1.3%, Mn 0.2-0.3%

Blue #1 1.2-1.3%, Mn 0.2-0.3% , Cr 0.3-0.5%, W 1.5-2.0%

Super Blue: C 1.4-1.5%, Mn 0.2-0.3%, Cr 0.3-0.5%, W 2.0-2.5%, Mo 0.3-0.5%, V 0.3-0.5%

"I think the answer is that Japanese chisel merchants are lining their pockets with the hype, myth and mumbo-jumbo. That's not racism, it's business and it's being conducted at our expense."

Caveat Emptor. In the modern world of 24 hour marketing these concerns seem quaint. Though, you are correct, there has been unscrupulous marketing, or worse in the 80s. That isn't limited to Japanese tools, though, in the tool sector. That's the sales pitch, no logical inference can be drawn to the tools. I would compare it to the marketing of Twinkies vs. green tea. The spiritual aspect of green tea, or even health aspects are getting oversold at the moment, while Twinkies are oversold as... food. You probably have to be a sucker to buy into either, but again, it's that order of magnitude thing.