Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

Posts

Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#1

Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I finally saw the PBS show about Samurai sword making. I hope others saw it too. While I found the subject of Samurai swords to be very interesting, what really blew my mind was about the ancient art of steel making in Japan.

Made by hand with ancient methods a handful of Japanese still have the skills to make and form steel of virtual perfection. Steel of the highest quality is required for swords. The layering and laborious forming techniques are used to form the blades.

Of course, where this hit home for me was with Japanese tools. I know that some Japanese masters make excellent tools. But after seeing that show I have new found respect for the tools made by hand by the master Japanese craftsmen. I now understand why they can cost what they do and why they can be superior tools.

If you get a chance to see the show I highly recommend it.

Tom

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#2

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

Tony - Memphis

>Yeah, I saw it too. I had heard about it and was glad it was on again. Really enjoyed the show. Very fascinating. What a rich history. I work with a fellow from Japan. He has a lot of his uncle's tools. His uncle was a carpenter. He mentioned something the other dya about old tools....something along the lines of "There are no "good" old tools around, because if they were good, they were used so much that there ain't much left!" ....or something like that. He said his uncles chisels are mostly stubs now.

Tony

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#3

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

Hank Knight

>Tom,

I agree, that was a wonderful show. I appreciate the Japanese steel making tradition all the more knowing how many of the old techniques and methods world wide have been lost through the ages. It's nice to know that we can still own fine tools made in the old tradition. I thought the explanation of how Samurai swords get their curve was particularly interesting. I always assumed they were forged that way. I never suspected that the curve occurred naturally in the process.

Hank

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#4

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

Paul Kierstead

>I was totally blown away by guys working the forge in *white*. Insanity. I too was taken by the bend of the sword; truly fascinating.

My only criticism was that I was left wanting more!

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#5

backwards

Adam Cherubini

>I've seen this show in the past and I hear the hype often. I think the story is 180 degrees backwards. I grant you that this myth is far more interesting than reality. It's also significantly more politically correct. The Japanese have done a great job marketing their inability to make steel into some sort of competitive advantage.

The reality is, Japan never developed the industry to produce homogenous steel in any significant quantities (if at all). They lacked the capitalist infrastructure and raw materials to do so. Consequently, they continued to make steel the way medieval Europeans had for 1000 years. Folding steel isn't an advantage. We don't fold steel to make fighter aircraft parts. Folding steel is what one must do when one hasn't developed the ability to produce homogenous steel (like cast steel). All they were doing was making shear steel out of blister steel.

By the late 19th and early 20th century, Japan's medieval steel production was severely limiting the progress of that nation. Japan was so reliant on superior Western steel they invaded China for her raw materials. Perhaps to maintain Japan's dependance on US goods, perhaps for humanitarian or political reasons, the US government place a trade embargo upon the Japanese government on oil and steel. Japan, likely feeling their economic security was at risk, responded with their "preemptive counter-strike" on Pearl Harbor.

I greatly admire the tradition, culture, and perseverance of Japanese sword making. But I find the claim that the Japanese alone were able to produce what others were not, or that their resulting steel was somehow different or special, or possessed mythical, mystical or inscrutable mechanical properties, simply not factual. The reality is, every cast steel chisel produced in Sheffield at the end of the 18th c, and throughout the 19th c was comprised of vastly superior steel.

Adam

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#6

Re: backwards

paul womack

>All they were doing was making shear steel out of blister steel.

I think it's quite important to note that they were doing this very well...

BugBear

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#7

Re: backwards

Paul Kierstead

>Folding steel isn't an advantage. We don't fold steel to make fighter aircraft parts. Folding steel is what one must do when one hasn't developed the ability to produce homogenous steel (like cast steel). All they were doing was making shear steel out of blister steel.

I'm disinclined to argue the facts, since clearly you are much better educated on the topic then I (considering your other profession, I hope so anyway!), but your logic is poor.

Let us say (I'm not claiming truth, just following the logic) that folded steel did, indeed, make the absolute best steel (not that such a thing exists, but...). Let us also say that the process was not amicable to large scale production by largely moderately skilled workers, but instead could only be reliably made by a master. Let's say that the only way to check the quality was by a master user of the steel. Now lets say we could make large quantities of extremely good steel, that was easy to verify, consistent, had lots of material available (probably due to it being very refined, so source of material didn't matter much) and did require large numbers of highly skilled individuals, which may be in short supply or fickle. Which would you build a plane out of? Clearly "quality" of the steel is not the sole determining factor; in fact, for a plane, probably having a steel that performs to close tolerances is, I would surmise, much more important that "quality". In fact, in modern manufacturing, Quality Assurance is typically related to repeatability, not the usefulness of the final product.

Is, possibly, sheer steel superior to cast steel for a sword edge?

Note I am not claiming Japanese swords are superior; I do know they are very very good for the style of fighting the Japanese engaged in, but subjective analysis is extremely difficult due wildly varying requirements and judging criteria. Sort of like planes.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#8

Ugh!

Paul Kierstead

>" did NOT require large numbers of highly skilled individuals"

for the large scale production.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#9

Clarification.

Paul Kierstead

>"Which one would you build a plane out of" refers to aircraft, whereas the last plane reference was to the sort which wrecks wood.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#10

Re: backwards

Hank Knight

>Adam,

I agree with most everything you say and I particularly agree with your historical analysis. I disagree with your comment that 19th century Sheffield steel was (is) superior to the steel the Japanese made by hand. The industrial revolution made the large scale production of consistently high quality steel possible and that gave the West a huge economic avantage over non-industrilaized countries. I would argue, however, that the best handmade steel to come out of the Japanese tradition was at least as good as the best cast steel made in Sheffield. The Japanese couldn't make the good stuff by the ton and the quality was variable, as with any manual process; but I'll put the steel in a top quality Samurai sword or a modern Imai chisel up against anything produced in 19th Century Sheffield, or today, for that matter - except for the modern limited production exotics. Moreover, from my personal perspective, there is something to be said in today's world for the romantic appeal of the traditional craftsman turning out high quality, beautiful steel tools in a small shop. I much prefer that image to the image of chisel making in a smokestack foundry. I would think you, of all people, would enjoy the romance of the Japanese hand-crafted tradition.

Hank

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#11

Re: backwards

joel

>In the 19th and 20th century Japan imported very high end tool steels for use in toolmaking (don't know about swordmaking) from both England and Sweden. Obviously they also made their own stuff but the imported tool steels were also prized.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#12

Sheffield steel superior

Adam Cherubini

>Hank,

Homogenous steel is a huge advantage over laminating. I'm just talking about mech properties. And you're right- one of the things I love about the Japanese is their adherence and reverence for tradition. So this may sound contradictory; I think its possible the Japanese can make superior tools with inferior steel. But when you compare steels and steel production methodologies, that's where they are behind.

Adam

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#13

All I know is......

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>....watching a 150 year old man stoke a white hot fire for 3 days without a moment of sleep and via ancient methods produce a quality of steel that impresses even the steel experts at Lehigh University is pretty impressive to me!

Tom

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#14

Re: All I know is...... *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, to me, too. For even more info, check out the The Craft of the Japanese Sword by Leon Kapp et al.

Pam


The Craft of the Japanese Sword

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#15

Re: backwards

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Hank, are you claiming that an Imai chisel is made from traditional folded steel that is made by a craftsman "by hand"? That the steel itself is made the same way a sword was made in Japan centuries ago? I think there is a big difference between making the chisel and making the steel.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#16

Lehigh University

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Thomas, your talking about experts at Lehigh brings back memories for me. In the fall of 1969 I took a metallurgy course at Lehigh. The teacher was Japanese. He spoke English so poorly that if you didn't read the chapter you had no idea what he was talking about. As far as I know he didn't say anything about Japanese steel. I did not know about Japanese tools until about four years later. It would have been interesting to ask him about such things.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#17

Re: backwards

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Tamahagane is very difficult and expensive to obtain, so it's unlikely that contemporary commercial Japanese chisels are made of it; but if you're very lucky and very rich, you can obtain tamahagane saws made by Yataiki, last I heard they were $20,000 each.

Would be a good question for Soatoz, Iida-san, etc.

pam

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#18

"lining" versus "laminating"

Adam Cherubini

>Maybe there's some (purposeful) confusion between "lining", laminating a piece of steel to wrought iron or low carbon steel as a way of saving the cost or use of steel, and "laminating" non-homogenous steel to make a more homogenous product.

Personally, I prefer "lined" steel blades (I've called them laminated in the past because they are indeed laminated). Forge welding steel to a softer material makes for a blade that is easier to sharpen. Legend has it, there are some vibration or impact reducing properties due to the difference in Young's modulii. I don't know of any western chisel makers still doing this. The Japanese chisels are certainly lined and that is indeed an advantage in my book.

The lamination of Samurai swords was done because sword makers were making their own blister steel. Blister steel is made with a wrought iron bar, placed in a sort of kiln (or forge), and packed with carbon. The kiln heats up to 3000F and the iron absorbs some carbon and becomes steel.

The problem with blister steel is that it is steel only on the outside and remains iron in the center. And teh diistribution of carbon is inconsistent. By continually forging that into thinner and thinner layers and welding the layers together, you can minimize the effect of the non-homogenous metal. That's what Japan's great sword smiths did.

There may be people still doing this. They certainly did this a few years ago in Colonial Williamsburg. I would doubt anyone is doing this on a production basis. It would be very expensive and it remains structurally inferior to the leaf springs at my nearby metal scrap yard.

Adam

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#19

Re: All I know is......

Adam Cherubini

>You used the term "virtual perfection" to describe ancient Japanese steel. That may be hyperbole on your part, but I'm sure I've heard others say the same things having seen those PBS specials about Japan's living treasures.

I love the whole idea of having people as national treasures instead of buildings or battlefields like we have. And I love Japan so much, I studied Kendo to learn to speak Japanese, and learn to appreciate the religion and traditions of this fabulous culture.

I just think some of the romantic imagery has spilled into the world of engineering and it shouldn't have. I don't believe Japanese knives, chisels or plane irons are anything like Japanese swords and that's a good thing. Japanese swords aren't as great as we have been led to believe. If there's a mystical steel out there, it's not a samurai sword or damascus sword from the second crusade, it's Bill Tindall's CPM-3V! It's amazingly clean, abrasion resistant, fine grained, and strong.

Adam

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#20

Comparing CPM 3V with forged high carbon steel

wilbur

>Do you have data to support that CPM 3V is really superior to the high carbon forged steels used in Japanese swords?

There is a paper that analyzed the properties of high carbon forged steels, and it seems to me that in many ways, CPM 3V comes up short in comparison. The paper shows some very interesting properties of forged high carbon steel. You can get very fine grain due to the forging process, with grain particles of less than 1 micron. The grains are very evenly distributed from the forging process. Both of these properties will lead to the steel being able to take a very fine edge with sharpening. The steel can be made very hard, with an RC of up to 64. The ductility of this steel is also very high.

On the other hand, from the technical information on CPM 3V that I could find in many ways CPM 3V does not meet the characteristics of forged high carbon steel. The grain size of CPM 3V seems to go down to 2 microns or so, which although is very small, is larger than the grain size of forged high carbon steel. The RC for CPM 3V seems to be about 60, so it's not as hard as forged high carbon steel. Certainly the powdered nature of this steel allows for very even grain distribution, and it also has a high ductility.

I wasn't able to find any data on abrasion resistance between the two steels that I could directly compare, but it seems to me that harder steels certainly will be more abrasion resistant, and that the finer grain will lead to less chip failure.

Obviously, CPM 3V has a cost advantage over forged high carbon steel.

Now, it certainly seems to me that many things can go wrong in the forging process for high carbon steel, leading to a steel sample that is not as hard as you want, or with carbide particles that are larger than you want, which will lead to brittleness, a tendency to chip fracture, and less abrasion resistance. But from a technical standpoint, it seems to me that if you do the forging correctly, forged high carbon steel has some advantages over CPM 3V in terms of sharpness and hardness. A direct comparison is needed to settle the toughness question.

As far as the benefits of lamination, this paper shows that lamination greatly increases impact resistance compared to homogenous steels. In fact, the lamination of the forged high carbon steel with low carbon steel resulted in an impact resistance that is better than what is specified for CPM 3V.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#21

Chris Scholz

Makes me think our blades are way to inexpensive.

Chris Scholz

>

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#22

Metalurgy Merry Go round

Adam Cherubini

>I know this is a subject that interests you, Wilbur, and I think that's great. The problem with it is that it's really complicated, and like French, it gets more complicated the more you learn.

The first paper is really talking about Ultra High Carbon Steel. UHCS is defined as steels with an excess of 1% carbon. For those playing along in our home edition, 1095 (W-1) is .95% carbon. Eutectoid steel is 1077 (O-1), .77% C. The added carbon does increase the Rc hardness but doesn't necessarily improve cutting ability. Rc hardness is a measure of the matrix. It doesn't accurately predict the ability of a steel to cut something hard. CPM gets its properties by holding really hard particles in a fairly soft matrix.

Grain size is sorta unrelated to the alloy. I can change the grain size in the forging process. But that's an inexact science. CPM is nice because the grain you start out with is the grain you end up with unless you screw up the heat treat.

The last paper that talked about lamination actually includes a quote comparing japanese swords with shear steel used to make scythes. It didn't really talk so much about the Japanese sword lamination as modern laminates with good clean materials and "lining". I've used Aluminum- aluminum composites and ceramic aluminum composites which were pretty cool. But this isn't similar to what the Japanese sword makers were doing.

Let me just sum up this way- What the Japanese sword makers did is try to bake a cake without a measuring cup, without controlling what ingredients went in, and without a mixer. They baked what they had, it came out vanilla in some spots, chocolate in others and there were bits of egg shells and old boots. Then they crumbled it up and stuck it back together. They had no alternative. Modern cakes have precisely controlled ingredients and when we bite into them, we don't find any surprises. Guys can say they like the old ways, and that's fine. But it's not a better cake.

As to CPM, I don't have any. Like you, Wilbur (and many others) I'm still more comfortable using high carbon steel. I don't much care for D2 or A-2 either. But my mind is open. CPM is not an alloy, its a method of making a steel that has real advantages to woodworkers. The price of steel is on the rise world wide so it may be sometime before LN is shipping CPM tools. But I predict that day will come.

osakini shitsureshimasu

Adam

P.S. You thought I was kidding about learning japanese didn't you! Actually, the only things I can say include apologies, "please forgive me for standing in your way" "I'm terribly sorry my head got in the way of your boken" "my feet are so large they left you no choice but to step on them" sumimasen

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#23

Re: backwards

ThomD

>No disrespect, but I think there is a lot of loose thinking in your remarks and we are only going to get closer to the truth with a little tighter analysis. Which between the barbs, might on a good day, be what follows.

"I've seen this show in the past and I hear the hype often." I think the story is 180 degrees backwards. I grant you that this myth is far more interesting than reality."

You haven't really said anything yet, but if you go back to the 19th century people from the west who casually came across Japanese craftsmen where struck by the efficacy of the tools. One commentator noted their apparent crudeness, and yet how much better the skills and results appeared to be than he was used to form his own country. This is a period that is more or less pre-hype as far as there being any interest in Japanese tools as a thing to be remarked on, over here. Most of the hype, and some of it has been hype has come from American merchants.

"It's also significantly more politically correct."

This subject has been around a lot longer than the term or concerns in question.

"The Japanese have done a great job marketing their inability to make steel into some sort of competitive advantage."

Can you show one example of a Japanese doing this, I have never come across it myself.

"The reality is, Japan never developed the industry to produce homogenous steel in any significant quantities (if at all)."

That has little to do with anything. Woodwork as a hand tool enterprise was seeing the writing on the wall by the time any of that capitalist infrastructure was in place. And while there would have been differences in capability of the west with Japan even earlier, as history shows, it really wasn't evident in the quality of the steel. I think a lot of the worlds craftsmen had no desire to go in the direction you ascribe, it's the kind of rear view mirror history, that I don't even see recognizable attitudes in my parents generation, let along hundreds of years prior. People of the industrial age wanted bridges of steel, woodworking tools were of no concern.

"They lacked the capitalist infrastructure and raw materials to do so."

They lacked that to produce plastics, yet even so I am not sure you could convince even customers today that boxwood combs are inferior to plastic ones.

"Consequently, they continued to make steel the way medieval Europeans had for 1000 years."

I doubt they had any contact with medieval Europeans...

"Folding steel isn't an advantage. We don't fold steel to make fighter aircraft parts."

We don't wrap the handles of fighter pilot controls in silk either, but I'm not going to say that was a bad choice for swords. These are just ridiculous analogies.

"Folding steel is what one must do when one hasn't developed the ability to produce homogenous steel (like cast steel)."

It is continued to this day. I will grant there are areas of advantage and areas of disadvantage. Damascus shotgun barrels are a little risky. But there is also the rule of mixture, wherein a composite takes on the attributes of their parts, not to mention their method of assembly. We can make foams that are homogenous, we can also make syntactic foams out of hollow bead like particles mixed into setting plastics, etc... The more options the better.

"All they were doing was making shear steel out of blister steel."

Or to capture the essence of the whole enterprise they were making sharp steel sticks out of dull ones.

"By the late 19th and early 20th century, Japan's medieval steel production was severely limiting the progress of that nation. Japan was so reliant on superior Western steel they invaded China for her raw materials."

That would be the period after the sword was outlawed, modern military methods were being introduced at the point of a... pencil, maybe. Not exactly the period of greatest relevance for the technology in question.

"I greatly admire the tradition, culture, and perseverance of Japanese sword making. But I find the claim that the Japanese alone were able to produce what others were not,"

Agreed, on the one hand it is ridiculous today we have Americans making steel and swords etc... On the other hand they have an utterly specific culture, nobody built swords as they did, or fought as they did. It is far from clear that their methods were better. I know of only one duel between a euro and a samurai, and the euro ran the Sam. through in the blink of an eye. It is generally considered that the thrust is more deadly than the slash. There is a lot of slashing in the Japanese style, the sword suits the style. They would have remained far happier if global competition had never put them on a path that eliminated their whole reason for existence.

" or that their resulting steel was somehow different or special, or possessed mythical, mystical or inscrutable mechanical properties, simply not factual."

Yes, there is a tautology in action. Old Glory probably doesn't mean much to a samurai either. On the other hand if you have only seen a punch, some judo does get your attention, and this is a country with a lot of judo, of sorts.

"The reality is, every cast steel chisel produced in Sheffield at the end of the 18th c, and throughout the 19th c was comprised of vastly superior steel."

Sheffield was in the process of serving a world wide audience, the average swordmaker, a lord, a clan? For either enterprise to cross over in any relevant detail could only occur by gross error.

"...vastly superior steel."

It would be interesting to know whether a real steel person would feel that. I mean Sheffield is the kind of place where good things happen when the amount of chromium added to a batch of steel is missed by a large order of magnitude. Still one wonders if they would have been so readily dismissive of such obvious art. The kind of art that has been seized by just about every person to ever come near it.

But it all depends on what characteristics in steel or the culture of steel you are looking for. The Japanese enterprise with swords was not designed to produce a battleship's weight of them. It was designed to satisfy extremely powerful lords who lived or died by their swords, and who had no problem spreading the live or die action among their subjects.

Imperial Japan may have run up against it's limitations, but of one thing there is no doubt: It could have taken Williamsburg in any fight or woodworking contest that might have been specified on a fair basis. Anyone who's touchstones are in places like Williamsburg should have a far greater respect for what Japan had on the go. One of the interesting features of Japan was it's intentional isolation from the outside world. America was the kind of place that would import tools. Different model.

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#24

Re: Metalurgy Merry Go round

Dean Lapinel

>Adam,

Nice posts! I just recently learned a bit of what you wrote about from a forging forum. Your statements are completely consistent with the forging experts that I hold in high regard.

Dean

Re: Samurai Swords/Japanese Steel

#25

Re: Sheffield steel superior

ThomD

>I;m kinda lost on what is being folded, laminated, or what is homogenous. All those adjectives could be used to describe parts of a japanese blade, but if we are talking about lamination as one typically sees in a japanese chisel, then I would point out:

"Homogenous steel is a huge advantage over laminating."

It is extremely comon in the modern tool business to have just such lamination for many of the same reasons A carbide saw blade router blade, metal lathe tool, etc. Economy is part of the reason, but heat, impact resistance, ease of sharpening and cutting power all play in.

Even stuff like spades, knives with seperate handles, kitchen scissors with steel/plastic blades, etc share the same desire to mix materials with certain advantages with materials that have other advantages. The examples of laminated, bonded, etc... tools may actually outnumber the stuff that is monolythic.

In fact where the mono stuff is involved it is often used where cheapness is the determinative factor. Cold chisels or high speed lathe tools come to mind. It's not that a HSS lathe tool isn't great, it is, but it can be made of solid material because that material for a piece that will last a good long time is only $1.25.