Here's the iron logo
Larry Williams
>Frederick Stone's mark on the iron:
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Here's the iron logo
Larry Williams
>Frederick Stone's mark on the iron:
an alternative route to "these" chiesls
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>First, I do understand that there can be motivation to have a tool that replicates exactly a classic tool. To get there you obtained forging expertise. The rest of this message is for those that would like a chisel like in your picture but for whatever reason forging is out of the question.
It would be a simple task, with operations familiar to all woodworkers, to saw and grind a chisel from annealed bar stock that would replicate the one shown in the picture, except.....The bolster and tang would need some modification to make this portion of the chisel easy to fabricate. As a result this part of the chisel would look different but there would be no difference in performance or feel in the hand.
Annealed bar stock is available in any alloy of one's choosing and even our near by small town has a heat treater. Or the steel can be mailed off for hardening at almost insignificant cost. Bottom line, you don't need to know much or have much money to be able to make a chisel shaped instead of forged.
Unless one is replicating vintage sharpening techniques (oil and ARK stones) there is no more effort to sharpen a Rc60 chisel than one softer so the need to uniquely harden chisels in a set should not be important to most chisel users, presuming one is already using water stones, optimum sand paper or some format of diamonds. I can tell if I am sharpening a Stanley plane iron (the easiest to abrade) vs 3V but there is no difference in time in my hands.
You are right on that feel in the hand is THE most important factor. Forging or otherwise shaping by grinding and sawing is a way any of us can have a chisel to perfectly suit our tastes. The simple classic shapes feel best in my hand which leaves me suspicious that many modern handles were designed by the marketing department.
The whole iron
Larry Williams
>Here's the iron. I wanted to see what the sheer steel was like but the iron was badly pitted. I spent quite a while flattening the face of the iron and working working my way past most of the pitting. I checked the steel as I went for any indications of problems like inclusions, impurities or color change. I didn't see anything like that. My impression is that the steel was very good and probably the finest grained steel I've worked with.
steel selection
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I am glad that you got the point that 3v was a recommendation from one source. I have tried to encourage others to explore other steels. One of my main points is that there may be something better and it won't get found if everyone is convinced that there can't be something better than forged carbon steel, O-1, A2 or 3V for that matter.
I can't answer part of your question. I don't know why a particle steel with the composition of 3V has the properties it has. 3V is a particle steel and that imparts some properties. It has vanadium and vanadium carbide is extremely abrasion resistant(hence high wear). And that is the end of my metallurgy knowledge.
The two outstanding properties of this steel is its toughness at high hardness, and abrasion(wear) resistance, the latter being of little importance to a chisel and of considerable importance to a plane iron. At a Rockwell hardness of 60 this steel can be bent without breaking. This attribute makes ideal chisel edges- they don't crumble or chip.
need advice
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>What advice would you offer a beginner that purchased a set of "blue handles" and came to realize that their chisels and chiseling needed improvement?
Re: steel selection
wilbur
>Hi Bill,
If you take a look at the article that I linked to above, there's some interesting information about the properties of forged ultrahigh carbon steels, such as the ones used in Japanese chisels.
First, I need to be clear that we're talking about a carbon content of 1% to 2%. The paper refers to this as "ultrahigh carbon steel", and the reason that this is important is that many tools that are made of "high carbon steel" can have a carbon content of 0.5% or so and up.
The paper shows some very interesting properties of forged ultrahigh carbon steel. You can get very fine grain due to the forging process, with grain particles of less than 1 micron. The grains are very evenly distributed from the forging process. Both of these properties will lead to the steel being able to take a very fine edge with sharpening. The steel can be made very hard, with an RC of up to 64. The ductility of this steel is also very high.
The reason that I go into this is that although CPM 3V is a very good steel for this application, from the technical information I could find in many ways it does not meet the characteristics of forged ultrahigh carbon steel. The grain size of CPM 3v seems to go down to 2 microns or so, which although is very small, is larger than the grain size of forged ultrahigh carbon steel. The RC for CPM 3v seems to be about 60, so it's not as hard as forged ultrahigh carbon steel. Certainly the powdered nature of this steel allows for very even grain distribution, and it it also has a high ductility.
I wasn't able to find any data on abrasion resistance between the two steels that I could directly compare, but it seems to me that harder steels certainly will be more abrasion resistant, and that the finer grain will lead to less chip failure.
Obviously, CPM 3V has a cost advantage over forged ultrahigh carbon steel.
Now, it certainly seems to me that many things can go wrong in the forging process for ultrahigh carbon steel, leading to a steel sample that is not as hard as you want, or with carbide particles that are larger than you want, which will lead to brittleness, a tendency to chip fracture, and less abrasion resistance. But from a technical standpoint, it seems to me that if you do the forging correctly, forged ultrahigh carbon steel has at least some advantages over CPM 3V in terms of sharpness and hardness. A direct comparison is needed to settle the toughness question.
This also would explain much of the "oriental mumbo jumbo" that you referred to in a post above. Why would an old Japanese blacksmith be able to turn out such incredibly hard, sharp, and tough tools (or samurai swords back in the day)? Because he knew what to do to plain old carbon steel to get it that way. He may not know why forging works, or how the molecular properties of forged ultrahigh carbon steel leads to its operating characteristics, but he could do it. This also explains the importance of technique and skill, and why one brand of Japanese chisel is prone to chipping while another brand has no problems, or why one blacksmith will get consistently better results than another, much like why my results with finishes probably will never equal yours. :@)
In any case, based on this information, I don't know that one can conclude that a modern steel alloy can a priori be thought to be superior to older steels just because it's newer. In this case, it looks like the older steel had better specs than we might have thought.
interesting information- reference?
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I found the information you provided most interesting. Do you have a reference to the original article? I have access to a library that can get it for me.
I don't think grain structure has to be a limitation in sharpening. Steve Elliot's seminal work on sharpening has shown that all the tool steels he investigated could be sharpened to an equivalent degree. I have an electron microscope picture with sharpening scratches going through a carbide grain, suggesting the grains can be abraded along with the matrix to form the edge.
Re: interesting information- reference? *LINK*
wilbur
>I had posted the link to the article above, but here it is again.
Grain structure may not be a limitation in sharpening, but thinking about this, it could limit your choice of sharpening methods, if you are relying on the sharpening process to fracture the carbide grains. Perhaps that is why you need to use diamonds with your CPM 3V chisels. My guess is that even though you can sharpen through a carbide, as it were, the larger carbide particles would be accompanied by an increase in chipping failures.
How forging can improve carbon steel properties
Re: need advice
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>I have one Marples blue chip chisel from 1983, not a favorite, but adequate. I think these chisels were designed to be sharpened with Arkansas stones and get slightly better performance from these stones. I would use fairly heavy pressure on the stones (especially wider chisels)and a clean strop afterward.
There are a several things one can do to preserve an edge. Avoid prying. Prying creates tremendous leverage crosswise on an edge. The finer the edge, the more delicate it is. Likewise avoid scraping with the chisel. Avoid biting off too big a chunk at one time. Don't hit too hard. If you see the edge as something delicate, you will treat it better and think smoothness and finesse rather than brute force. All edge tools benefit when you have this viewpoint.
Also...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA
>I raised the bevel on mine to 30 deg. Never had a problem with them after that.
Bill, Ye Pitiable & Bumbling Philistine!
David Barnett - SW Florida
>Beginner's problems
Amuse hierophant yet hones
Magick Bullet Steels.
Re: need advice
Bob Demers
>Quote
I have one Marples blue chip chisel from 1983, not a favorite, but adequate. I think these chisels were designed to be sharpened with Arkansas stones and get slightly better performance from these stones unquote
In my numerous chisels arsenal, i have a complete Marples Record blue handle chisel set from 1/8 to 2 in, 10 in all (could never find the elusive 7/8 out of production for years)
Anyway, I really like these chisels, these are my everyday chisels, they are all polished to a high degree from many years of using.
I got my first one in the mid 70s. Rarely suffer from edge chipping, but if and when I do, I simply raise the bevel edge slightly, just a micro bevel does it. The point is, just like with carving chisels I just tweak the bevel angle as needed for the work at hand. Which is why by the way traditional English carving chisels such as Henry Taylor only come with a basic grind to show you the approximate bevel angle, carvers would then finish grinding the bevel to their method of work or the hardness of wood they were carving.
My point therefore is this: before blaming your chisel or the steel, try adapting your chisel bevel to your work. Its quick and easy, I do it routinely, don't really care what is my exact angle, just the one that work...
There is nothing wrong with blue handle chiseld, they are inexpensive, sharpen to a very sharp edge quickly, take a highly polished sheen and their edges will survived when used properly (care and bevel angle)
Bob, who seem to be attracted to chisels, like to planes, saws, and, and :-)
Re: Bill, Ye Pitiable & Bumbling Philistine!
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Hi Folks,
Amen, David.
Just wanted to say a couple things that only glancingly touch on the original topic. I had the good fortune to strike up an acquaintance with Bill Tindall a few years back, don't remember about what. I had the even better fortune to be associated with Bill, Phil Smith, Bruce Thornton (the third member of the Tennessee Three), and Steve Elliott--when they all collaborated to make a run of CPM 3V plane blades that are branded 'ELLIOTT'. Those Elliott blades are magnificent. I have them on 4 planes, including three of Konrad's. Particle 3V wasn't a big jump for me, because Bill had already introduced me to grinding and diamond sharpening to use on some other HSS steel I had.
But high carbon is like navy blue--it is never going out of style. High alloy is pretty much limited to bench planes and chisels--you can't make anything out of wood with just those two tool categories.
And in reality, we're still on the bleeding edge of diamond sharpening. In 5 to 10 years, there'll be full-capability systems that parallel oil stones and ceramic stones (like Shapton). That's why I think that CPM 3V has a future, but A2 is a dead-end, for reasons given by Dean Jansa. Karnak predicts: In 10 years, there'll still be high carbon, but 3V will have overtaken A2 because there'll be a standard sharpening system for high alloy. [Karnak also predicts that there'll be 20-degree bevel up, and 12-degree bevel-up will be a memory, but that's another jihad.]
But for me....I love high carbon steel best, and natural stones. If somebody actually did come up with a chisel or plane blade you didn't need to sharpen, ever, and it was always dead-on sharp forever--I wouldn't buy it. I love to sharpen. I take 5 seconds and sharpen my dovetail chisels as I'm paring to the scribe lines. The chisels are re-sharpened before they think about being dull, and so they're never dull. It's part of the rhythm. Who doesn't like to sharpen?
I like the edge that natural stones put on steel. In my hands, diamond tears up hard Japanese steel, at meshes higher than about 1/2 micron. It's really hard on it. It works well on O1, but even there, I prefer to use natural stones--the edge is more refined. And I just have to have those Clark & Williams planes. Period.
So where does this end up? Just this: We're all gonna do what we want to do for any reason we choose, or for reasons we can't even remember any more, or for no reason at all. What we do is our choice.
Bill Tindall has offered a choice that, as Adam said, we wouldn't even know about if the big mosquitoes had carried Bill down to Alabama and ate him up. I'm forever indebted to him for the email instruction and online tutorials he did on grinding and grindstones, plus the fabulous particle 3V adventure. Here's the thing--Bill is totally competent at what he undertakes. Even when he's a beginner at something, by the time he gets done researching everything and methodically mastering the details, the result doesn't look like a beginner result. He doesn't believe in miracles; he pays the price to do it right.
Well, Bill's on his path and I'm on mine, and sometimes our paths cross and sometimes they don't. For instance, why doesn't Bill want to edge joint by hand? Is he nuts--that's about 1/4 of the fun in all woodworking. Well, he doesn't want to. But then, he probably thinks I'm nuts to throw money at Japanese chisels and water stones. We choose different things, and don't make any apologies about it. But when Bill offers us a choice, it's a choice that he has mastered the details of, it is real, and you can do it too.
Wiley
Re: Bill, Ye Pitiable & Bumbling Philistine!
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>had to go to the THICK dictionary for hierophant.
Also
Dan Donaldson
>The handles are not too hard to get off so that you can make a wooden one. For me, the blue handles are too heavy. I prefer a lighter one for a different balance. I took the handle off from one of mine and made a wooden one for it, which improved the balance significantly for me.
Thanks, Wiley
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>Thank you, Wiley. This is not the first time you have given us a thoughtful post which has put ideas and people in perspective. I would go easy on the predictions, though. Wood Central may still have a pretty good archive around 2018.
Re: need advice
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Marple performance is highly dependent on the batch you bought. If fairly contemporary, probably not so great. If older, probably pretty good. I don't think you can generalize even on a single brand.
Pam
Re: It's actually a British plane
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Larry,
Thank you very much. Imagine what the world was like when that plane and blade were made! They managed to do very well.
Have you used that plane/blade combination? How does the blade hold up? And how does it sharpen--large burr right away, or smallish burr?
I am constantly amazed at how blades of that era perform. I'm thinking of some Jo. Fuller ogees and astragal, I. Lindenberger thumbnail, and Wetherell Chatham dado and square ovolo, and you can make a good many feet of hardwood moulding before they start acting dull. Then when you sharpen, they put up a spirited defense. And you would expect the English blades of the day to be better, if anything (I think).
I might add, I've been extremely lucky, lucky beyond imagining, to be receiving assistance from an outstanding metallurgist (well known to tool folks). It augurs well for the blade examination project, so I'm looking forward to examining these old blades under a good scope, with someone who knows their stuff looking over my shoulder--so the project just may yield some interesting results.
Thanks again--that blade has a lot of charisma. And the plane looks perfectly sound, at first glance.
Wiley
Re: I remain waiting to be convinced
ThomD
>"It seems the application of these hand forged products is for things like swords and knives, items where the aura of the process of fabricating the item can become more important to its owner than the item's performance."
That is hugely ignorant, and I don't say that in any insulting way. You just have to know how wrong you are, and you seem to have no idea whatsoever. The knife and sword field is so testing obssessed that historically they used to have the right in Japan to kill people to test the swords, passers by, not to mention criminals etc... THis got way out of hand in WWII. BUt in the modern world the books are all stuff like the "high performance knife". It's so bad, some idiots are actually buying art knives and subjecting them to demolition derbys, because the younger folks may never skin a deer, maybe, but read endless tests in mags. Tests are more real to them than real uses. On the combat front swords are banned some places and not others, but certainly large knives are in use or, hoped for use, in everything from self-defence, to Iraq, to hunting hogs with knives only. And there are a lot of people who want to be as accurate as possible in the old martial world as far as skills and gear is concerned. They aren't satisfied with toy swords.
There is another area whcih is the chef, and slaughterhoouse trade, hunting guides, skilled users over a long period softer knives seem prefered. In a production situation there may not be an option of shrapening on a particular set-up that was custom matched to a particualr knife. Or in a wilderness or survival situation.
I'm not so much into the knife world, as into it as a window for the issues that affect us, they are 30 years ahead of us. If you were to take all the big american names in tools, how many would it be LV, LN... Help me... Meanwhile there are thousands of Knifemakers in business let alone playing in their home shops.
"I have great faith in the ability of business to find and utilize superior technology."
Like MDF.
I would say in our field the faith is misplaced. The larger companies blew the deal for 50 or 100 years, totally bankrupt junk. And the early guys around in the '70 had to rebuilt it. prior to those times the industrial concerns had their chance and they blew it.
If someone can show me that this steel is being used in the Phoenix mars lander or some such industrial application demanding the highest performance materials I will concede that indeed there isn't a better modern alternative alloy."
That's were you go wrong. This is not modern industry, that's the corded and cordeless, and CNC folk. We are the hand tool users. Everything we use was long since invented when The Hughes built their first drill. I'm not drilling rock for oil, wave when you get to mars to do your woodwork. The design science is that any time you remove a completely spurious requirement, that arose only due to someone elses needs, you open up opportunities in other areas: If I don't need a tool that cuts for the rest of my life, maybe I can make the tool I want (or some other craftsman will) that fits my purpose before you have finished grinding the tool I don't want that lasts for ever. Even in industry human design is a factor, and this craft is more art than industry.
But lets also be frank about something else. Every new techno development is also designed to bind someone to a particular supplier. All of a sudden bracksmiths who used to rig the drills are out of business and Hughes gets it all. Not a problem in industry, or really anywhere if the product is good enough. I don't, however, want to Walmart my tools I want a lot of stuff to be offered in reasonable formats, I don't want any super steel to corner a particular market, though it could happen. I think of muzzleloading rifles that once looked like historical copies. They are now a new product of our age. We could come back and find a totally different more modern craft at some point. The people might be motivated by all kinds of different things than we are. It can all happen. In a way Japanese tools were like that, because they were out of the culture when we first got to them in the 70s. Could just have easily been Rali planes and Miller falls art deco. But for now the tool biz is diverse and traditional.
"But if the only market for this steel is in products where the story of how it is made becomes the main selling point, then I remain skeptical"
I don't know any such particular tools myself? What story specifically? Isn't this just what your tools are to the same measure. You have a story. Alphabet soup steel, the steel that came after all the steel had gone. Cando, knowhow. That's attractive to a lot of people even as it is almost totally irrelevant to the world of woodworking as we know. In the creation of the average master level Highboy out there. is the shapeneing of a few chisels The Story? Everyone should have a story.
"that there isn't a modern steel with equivalent performance. "
It probably is a modern steel with the equivalent performance. See your story doesn't even hold up on the details. It pretty much all comes in rust proof packets for our stuff. Hitachi makes it for something or other. ANd your prefered steel isn't made for our use exclusively. We are all just feeding at the smorgasborg in accordance with our prefereces,
"The argument that these hand forged steels are too expensive for industrial application won't hold water. If the performance is there this hand forging would be done in 3rd world countries. In fact it would seem to be an ideal industry for such countries if there was a market."
I don't use hand forged japanese tools in my 5 metal lathe, mills etc... I use the 1 dollar chips and they grind and cut well. But still I get this pervasive vibe that if something you could call "industrial" were happening in say Texas, that would automatically vault them to the head of the line where designing snow shovels was concerend. I bought a decent shovel this year from HD. I had this cheap black plastic one that lasted for ever. The new one was a more brittle red platic, and didn't last out the season. Still walmarts a big industry, and those folks in Benton know what a Canadian winter calls for, like nobody's business...
"Keep in mind here that the discussion is not whether hand forged carbon steel is better than generic carbon steel; I agree it may not be. Rather, can the performance of hand forged carbon steel be matched or exceeded by modern alloys which seem to have displaced these hand forged materials in all but some specialized consumer markets."
I'm with you on the argument. Guys cutting dovetails in wood, or talking about it, is a very specialized consumer market, if you ask me.
I agree with you Bill, and Adam that something could without a doubt be made that is "better". The problem is consolidating it in such a way that it is worth doing. An example would be planes. If you want to talk about rational markets etc... what is with this simultanious existence of every known plane type at one time? We can't even swamp out the crap design, let along gain concensus on the materials.
Another argument would be why don't we all have replaceable blade tools. Anything you can do in hunks might be better done in absolutely nasty hard bits that could be inserted into planes and chisels. Industrial enough for you? (Though I feel I have to mention these superior and harder materials are not prefered in most smaller shops machine one reason is they requre a niagary falls of coolant compared to HSS. Crushing isn't it.) We have Ralli which is a superior design for most things. Lots of Japanese tools also, Some industrial tools for chippies use insert tech.
Once we get stuff really ugly and standardized is anyone going to attach a cord to this stuff? Because planely, most hand tools have long since outlived their practicality. So how much of this rational market do you want? As far as MDF?
Isn't the point whether the quest is moving inward to a single point of fixed interest, or it is wandering outward in accordance with individual desires?
Re: Bill, Ye Pitiable & Bumbling Philistine!
Parisian, VL
>The depths of knowledge on this message board never seizes to amaze me.
(btw: What happened to I before E except after C here?)
I enjoy good writing/word-smithing.
I'm off to feed the geese and check security at the shop.
Victor in Hot and Humid Houston