Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

John Henry versus the steam hammer

Posts

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#26

Schadenfreude

Adam Cherubini

>You're right that was toned down a lot. I originally wrote "had he been carried away by swarm of Tennessee's killer mosquitoes then eaten alive in a bog near the University of Alabama..."

Adam

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#27

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

Todd Hughes

>The advantage a hand made and tempered blade has over a machine made or factory one is that it gets individual attention to what it needs.

...Is easy if you are making one blade at a time to temper it so that it has a very hard cutting edge while leaving the rest of the blade soft...this is not easy to do if you are heat treating batches of a couple dozen blades all together in some heat treating oven.

....Also if you are selling blades to who knows who you don't know how they are going to be used so you have to comprimise. Beleive me if the chisels you bought at the home depot were as hard as some Japanese hand made one they would be returned in groves by unhappy buyers that snapped them off opening paint cans. So they are made for the avarage wood worker and quality suffers.

I think it is a mistake to believe that the blacksmith art is somehow diminished now, I think rather just the opersite. There are plenty of blacksmiths today that are as good or better as any that ever lived, just like wood workers. It really isn't a lost art like many think.

After saying all this I really don't think for practical putposes a hand forged blade is all that special in itself, certainly don't believe half the hype that people that make such things will tell you.Same as a laminated blade. A hand forged blade can be made very well but also can be junk, same as a machine made one.

I also think that probably most of the so called hand forged chisels and plane blades you see are not really hand forged as I would think of it, IE forged out by hand...but rather are knocked out with power hammers and heat treated in ovens etc. and marketed as hand forged....Todd

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#28

Re: I remain waiting to be convinced

Larry Williams

>Well Bill, I've watched your work with magic bullet steels with interest and some amusement.

There seems to be two approaches to eliminating dull tools being a barrier to woodworking. One approach is to learn to sharpen and the other is to find some magic bullet that makes sharpening much less frequent.

Learning to sharpen turns sharpening into an easy, quick task that's of little consequence or significance in terms of time and effort. The quest for the magic bullet steel, however, further elevates the barrier of sharpening by making it more difficult, more tedious and more complicated. It literally takes me as long to walk the ten or so steps to my sharpening area and return as I spend at the sharpening bench when sharpening a chisel. It's an insignificant and completely non-memorable task and I wish I could make the rest of my work as quick and easy. Help me out here Bill, I'm having some trouble getting my mind around what the big issue is around sharpening a chisel.

I must admit being amused by irony of your journey. It may be unfair but when I read your posts I see a person who started out to reduce time spent at a task he hadn't yet mastered. In your effort to avoid sharpening you spent so much time doing it you've become a resident expert in sharpening. Now that you can sharpen, I often wonder what your views would be if you went back to normal good steel and sharpening methods.

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#29

let me clarify.......'cause you missed the beginng

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>In the beginning I owned a set of blue handled chisels and one massive ergonomically flawed Two Cherries mortise chisel. The blue handles gave me hand cramps when dovetailing (handle too heavy and blade too long) and their edges crumbled when used for striking. I lived with the edge retention but the hand cramps was intolerable. The ergonomics of the Two Cherries invited improvement which came in the form of regressing to old fashioned handles.

Skipping over the details of the decision process I arrived at the decision to make chisels that suited me (and it turned out to have been a successful decision). At the time I knew nothing about how to make a chisel, or steel, but I approached the task as I do most tasks and researched the topics. Information on how to make a chisel came from folks on Badger Pond. I called Crucible Products and asked about buying metal for the chisels. When I told them what properties I wanted- optimum hardness and toughness- they told me to buy CPM 3V. The annealed working properties of 3V are exceptionally favorable, the cost is not excessive and knife makers were having exceptional success with this alloy. There was no advantage to making chisels from a carbon steel and potential advantages for making chisels from 3V. The metal decision was therefore straightforward. For the same effort and cost I got the advantages of a better performing steel. I don't see any flaw in the decisions that led to a set of 3V chisels that stay on the bench while an assortment of blue handles, Sorby, Two Cherries, Japanese and one Swan are somewhere in a drawer.

While we were at it, for little additional effort or expense some lathe tools and plane irons were fabricated (at the time I was into making wood planes and still use the block planes as they sit in the hand nicely).

The whole effort turned out well. The whole set of chisels cost less than my one Japanese chisels and they perform better than anything I could afford to buy and they may well perform as well or better than any exotically fabricated metal. The plane irons and lathe tools were also a pleasant surprise.

The bottom line is that I arrived where I am at because for essentially the same cost and effort I could fabricate tools that suited me from what was judged by experts (tech staff at the steel company) to be the best material for the product- chisels.

I am a transparent person with no hidden agendas, more motivated by frugality than laziness. My motivation in informing others about this effort is three fold. Foremost, I want to show that it is easy to cheaply make your own chisels and that they will perform well, if not superior. Second, there are many steels other than carbon steel. I would like to motivate others to try them. I think it is naive to assume that there can't be something better than whatever best once was. Third, I like challenging myths and folklore. When I asked the experts on Badger Pond if tool steels would make good woodworking tools I was told they would not take an edge. Some mumbo jumbo about grain size and the like and optimization for high heat. Steve Elliot put this myth to rest to my satisfaction.

The fact that this effort has attracted criticism is bothersome and I don't understand it. I would like to inspire curiosity not amusement. I'm not trying to sell anything. When I posted information about the lathe tools on the Turning Forum I was ferociously attacked. I don't go there any more. I made tools that would have cost tens of dollars for less than ten. Not my loss if they don't want to hear about it.

I won't deal with sharpening in this post other than to say that what I have arrived at is cheapest and fastest of anything I have seen. These seem to be desirable attributes worth consideration. For those not settled on a method they should consider it. Some have and like it. Others persist in thinking that just because it involves diamonds it must be too exotic.

Recall Wiley's post involved whether this or than forging of carbon steel produced a superior product. My horse in the race was to suggest that a better alloy might produce a better product than better pounding of carbon steel. I remain convinced that it is a thought worth considering.

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#30

I got run over by a sheep!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Two black eyes and a several cuts. But it hasn't dissuaded me from advocating consideration of new products and processes in wood working.

In spite of their PR agent sheep are not gentle animals.

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#31

Re: let me clarify.......'cause you missed the beg

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Bill,

I have read numerous posts of yours. Always informative and easy to read.

I don't understand why people attack when someone is only attempting to share their knowledge. Could it be that the attacker (s) know they are less knowledgable and are trying to compensate for their own inferiorities?

I've never made a chisel, but if I ever do, I know who consult.

Thanks for sharing,

Marv

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#32

nice...

Victor Parisian

>

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#34

Re: let me clarify.......'cause you missed the beg

wilbur

>Hi Bill,

I'd like to turn your question on its head for a minute. You said, "When I told [Crucible Products] what properties I wanted- optimum hardness and toughness- they told me to buy CPM 3V."

If I'm not mistaken, Crucible Products is ultimately the only place to get CPM 3V, so the recommendation is not entirely unexpected. So exactly why is CPM 3V better than forged high carbon steel (carbon content >1%) for chisels? What is it about CPM 3V that gives it better hardness and/or toughness?

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#35

Yes, Wilbur

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#36

Baaa ran over yewwww!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Sorry couldn't stop thinking of the movie babe.....

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#37

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Stephen,

I would love to hear more stories about your apprenticeship days with the European journeymen. I think the German traditions are really remarkable. I was fortunate enough to receive a copy (and translation) of Josef Greber's book on The History of the Woodworking Plane, and there are very sophisticated planes dating back into the 1500's. I suppose those planes evolved out of the Roman days, so who knows how far back they really go. But the traditions are old there. How did those guys get to Utah? Were they POW's who stayed, or did they come after the war?

I think many would be highly interested to hear your evaluation of the Galoot-Tools laminated iron. Perhaps Chris Scholz could provide useful technical details on the manufacture of those irons, as his knowledge goes very deep.

Wiley

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#38

Larry, can you post that

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>photo of the old Dutch plane with the very fine-grained blade? Do you have an approximate date on that plane?

Wiley

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#39

let me tell you why

r payne

>I am not at all interested in modern high alloy steels.

Let me start by saying I forge and find myself forging more and more of my own hand tools. I don't particularly enjoy grinding, I find it tedious. I also do my own heat treat in the forge. That does limit me to the steels that are readily workable to low alloy or carbon steels.

The problem with alloy steels for the most part is the large carbides that remain after heat treating. Those carbides prevent a truely finely honed edge below an inclusive angle of around 15-17 degrees. Now while I don't regularly sharpen most chisels to that fine (unless I'm paring with it), I have that option with a properly hardened carbon steel. Carbon steel also has a resistance to breaking that is often comprimised by the alloying elements. The way to offset that brittleness is to reduce the hardness.

While you may be satisifed with 3V, I will stick to carbon steels for tools (from my research, M2 and maybe M4 might work better, but I'd have to grind those [I have a piece of M2 that has been waiting to be ground on for going on 2 years now]).

Of course another factor is I don't like the way diamonds sharpen. I do have some diamond lapping paste I like but don't care for any of the diamond sharpeners I've tried. And carbon steel is easy to sharpen.

ron

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#40

My situation is different

Steve Elliott

>I'm a professional cabinetmaker and have worked in more than a dozen shops over the past thirty years. I like edge tools and learned to sharpen early in my career.

I've never worked in a shop where the management liked to see me sharpen. Some shops didn't want to see me using hand tools at all, and over the years I've acquired the habit of sweeping up plane shavings promptly to remove evidence of hand tool use.

All my sharpening is done at home, on my own time. I NEVER want someone else trying to hurry me up or tell my what is good enough.

Under these conditions edge retention becomes much more important. I've found that CPM 3V is well suited to my needs and have learned to sharpen it almost as quickly as carbon steel.

I don't advocate use of 3V for most hand tool users, whose needs are quite different from mine. Their time may well be better spent learning skills other than the sharpening of high-alloy steel. Not that sharpening 3V is hard to learn, but good grinding is the key. Very little honing is needed after an accurate grind.

It was Bill Tindall who got me started on 3V although I had already bought another alloy called CPM 10V in a quest for better edge retention. I like the fact that I can fabricate a blade to just the specs I want, have it heat treated for a reasonable amount, and end up with a premium blade of my own making. I'd never be able to learn the forging skills necessary to do that.

There is a great deal of satisfaction in making a tool myself, especially when I know I'll be making more and learning from the experience.

There's plenty of room for different work styles and interests. I don't see much point in trying to tell others what they should choose.

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#41

Re: I am a market of one

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Adam,

Very much looking forward to your entry into the chisel market! Did you model yours after a particular maker or time period?

Much of your post revolves around the sharpening characteristics of chisels. I have a question, and I apologize if you have covered this in previous publications: If you're working at the bench, do you resharpen many times quickly on the fly as you work? Or do you wait til you have a handful of dull chisels and then go sharpen? I'm betting it's the former, and that when you stop work for the day, you have a handful of sharp chisels.

You need someone more qualified than me to evaluate your chisels! However, I am qualified to buy I think.

Wiley

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#43

A coworker of mine and I used

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>to start conversations about work in progress as we left for the day with, "If I get run over by a Mack truck..."

Not sure why we were picking on Mack drivers - for one thing, Peterbilts are WAY more common in California - I think it just fit the rhythm better.

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#44

You've picked it quite well, Wilbur

Andrew F in Australia

>As well, Wilbur, cooling rate affects strength by playing with a transformation that occurs in the steel around about 720C (no, not quenching, the cooling rate to produce the equilibrium structure.)

I've rarely seen this in any technical articles, although it affects toughness. This is because it's very hard to control.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#45

Re: Schadenfreude

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Well, I certainly like the original better, much more imaginative. :)

Pam

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#46

:)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#47

Size and shape first, then sharpenability

Adam Cherubini

>Wiley,

These chisels were made for me personally, so I started by focusing on the characteristics that support my work and technique. I'll describe these things in detail when the tools hit the proverbial street.

They are 18th c English patterns. They are made of high carbon steel. High carbon steel is capable of achieving very high Rockwell hardnesses. I have had some trouble with edge chipping with the hardest of my specimens. But I've learned that one can prevent edge chipping or reduce it by honing to a fine polish and of course grinding a favorable edge shape. I feel this is an aspect all of us know about but sometimes forget in these discussions. One could (and should) optimize the edge geometry of each steel to achieve its best performance. It's not really fair to take a group of chisels, grind them all the same and then compare their performance.

For me, I think the big advantage in using high carbon steel, especially over a truly superior steel like CPM-3V, is that I can custom heat treat each different blade. In my shop, the 1" chisel never sees the tip pressure that the 1/2" chisel does. And by this logic, you'd think the 1/4" would need to be even harder than the 1/2" but it doesn't. I guess it has something to do with the size of the wood grain.

I recall an old chisel article in FWW. It was reprinted in the "Best of Hand tools" book. The author compared various chisels and concluded with something like- "the steel means nothing if the handle isn't comfortable. So pick the chisel that best fits your hand." (that's not a direct quote). I guess I'm not far from that point of view.

Adam

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#48

on the merits of thin, and a way to get it

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You said, "So, specing steel for a chisel may be easy, but forming that tool to be useful is more difficult. As we can see, there are those of us who can not find one in the current market."

Indeed , this fact is what got us into making chisels and it is easy. Mostly by accident, I made my chisels slightly over 1/8" thickness (steel is often sold somewhat over nominal thickness to accommodate post heat treat refining). Again, mostly by luck, the 3V turned out to be a spring steel. At Rc 60 it can be bent and not break so there is no limit on how thin one can make a chisel. I have become quite fond of the light weight of these thin chisels.

I can see the attraction of forging a tool, except many people would not take the time to learn to do it just to make some chisels. The alternative is to buy annealed bar stock and saw and grind the shapes one wants. The 3V is exceptionally soft in its annealed state and way easier to saw, mill and grind than O-1. Hence, it is a simple matter to fabricate what ever shape one wants, not much different than shaping wood.

The toughness of 3V popped up in other ways. When honing, the wire edge is astonishingly tenacious. It usually stays around till I get to 1 micron where it finally becomes so thin it literally floats away. If one fails to be rid of it the tool can appear dull after honing. However, for a lathe scraper this property is a significant advantage, something the detractors on the turning forum failed to grasp. A turned up edge on a 3v tool is similarly tenacious, and does it ever cut, and last.

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#49

Re: let me clarify.......'cause you missed the beg

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I think Larry has a good analysis of your history, Bill. Handles too long, crumbling edges, cramped hands, too much time sharpening, these are all problems of the beginner. I am interested in what you are doing, but it does seem that you set out years ago to remedy beginner's problems. As a long time worker, I have different problems. Tools designed to withstand the abuse of amateurs, tools designed to be used on a grinder (I haven't used a grinder in decades), thick and clumsy, feeling gummy on the stone. I don't need so much toughness if I am not abusing the tool. And I could certainly sacrifice hardness if it meant that I could get an exquisite edge even more easily.

Re: John Henry versus the steam hammer

#50

It's actually a British plane

Larry Williams

>This plane is British and I can't read the extremely faint maker's mark. It has the features, especially the heel of an 18th Century style smooth plane. The iron is by Frederick Stones who Don McConnell's information lists in business at least as early as 1817. It's interesting that the iron is also marked "Sheer Steel," which is the steel that was common before cast steel. Here's a photo of the plane:


img