Re: want a better chisel, buy better steel
ThomD
>We have the advantage of both the latest scientific methods, and whatever remains known or seems to have been rediscovered in the old world. On the slightly scientific front, stuff like FWW laboratory tests etc... still mostly come out with hand made and forged chisels on top. Over 30 years I have never seen a chisel test on performance that was won by anything other than a Japanese blade. Rarely are the testers even particularly competent woodworkers, they still couldn't avoid the glaringly obvious. I would point out that in some cases the wining chisel was a hand made better quality item, and in some cases the winner, or second place was taken by a lower quality Japanese chisel quite possibly made largely by mechanized processes and industrial heat treating methods.
The white and blue paper steels are basically tool steels in paper protective wrappers like O1 is sold in. In some cases, even better tools are made out of home made steels. Again what is winning out is the craftsmanship not a specific method of doing things. I have yet to see anything out there that compares to Japanese hand tools, it's the people behind the product, not some artificial criterion like hand forged or not.
An important part of the craftsmanship is the craftsmanship of the target market craftsman, as well as the maker. Japan has remnants of the original crafts of both toolmaking and woodworking, that remain intact. This raises the standard of play. In 30 years there has been a huge improvement in the quality of tools people are making here. If one looks at texts form the 70s, they were full of info on how to scab together a decent kit of tools. By and large the hobby woodworker was at a fairly low level even ten years ago. In the same 30 years the clients of the average Japanese tool maker would have been everything from existing living treasures, to folks who on day one of their apprenticeships were in a more enriching environment than the luckiest of us is in for more than a few days at a time. Of course their tools are better, but it isn't really whether the smith is hitting it with a hand held hammer or a power hammer that counts, for the most part.
There are a few myths in the thread so far:
"Now up front let it be said that there isn't much true handforging of individual blades going on. Anywhere. How could there be? The smith has to make a living unless he was born into money, and if he was born into money, he wouldn't be a smith. So, like John Henry, smithing has by and large lost out to machine methods. Cause how many smiths can get $200 a piece for their blades?"
Not if one is talking about filling Wal-Mart's shelves. There are thousands of very active smiths of very good skill level out there these days, and I can't think of a time when the realities of the craft have been as striped bare for all to see as they are today. Most of the action is in knife making where you can get 100 bucks an inch or a lot more. Still most are amateurs to some extent.
" 'Better' meaning that for comparable toughness and sharpenability, the smithed chisel will hold its edge better."
I don't see much evidence of this. Normally smiths have to also work in other criterion like durability in combat to make a case for a forging. However where it can mater is in the closeness with which a smith can work materials. Once it becomes a mass produced need and a mass produced solution, we don't need hand work anymore. I get frustrated when folks like us, nominally hand craftsmen, don't understand how a craft works. You want a plastic cafeteria chair, I can't beat a factory price. There are certain kinds of needs a charimaker alone can meet. Same deal with tools. Forging can be a very efficient way to work materials though. Rougly I would compare it to busting out wood, nothing is faster than spliting a log, riving, etc... Same thing with moving around metal. Plane blades are an easy one to make out of flat stock, but some other pieces are clearly easier to forge.
"Why do I think it is likely that the top smiths can beat professional heat treating? The reason is that the smith is guided by phase changes he can see occurring in the steel, as they happen, whereas the professional heat treater has the steel on a program which is established by the clock and by thermostats (if this isn't so, someone please correct me). F'rinstance, the smith can see the hot steel shrink slightly and change color in the orange zone as it transforms into austenite with a different crystal lattice. By responding real-time to phase changes in the steel, the smith is can shrink grain size, use higher carbon concentrations (think 'more carbides'), and manage his carbide distribution so as to optimize edge holding, toughness, and sharpenability of the steel forging."
I would tend to put this down in the myth department myself. Some of the stuff good smiths know how to do is process related where going along a particular path allows them to get somewhere a good heat treating cycle gets to automatically. I have recipees for heat treating that basically get you your hardness despite the fact it is hard to do the soak properly in an open flame. Where the smith does great work is by being close to the requirement and being relentless in testing to ensure he is getting the particular results he wants. I enjoy reading Ed Fowler's stuff because as a western rancher he has a real idea of what he personally wants in a knife, and he has been unterly relentless in getting it, and taking it to new levels. Though his objective is somewhat personal. His quest is similar to what John Alexander has tried to do with fitted wooden seating in ladder rungs.
"Any opinions or evidence one way or the other on smithing vs. professional heat treating?"
Toolmaking smiths are professional heat treaters!!
"hammer refine the steel and very effectively control grain size"
If we are in the area of "packing" here that appears to be contrary to what science tells us about steel, and many/most smiths don't seem to feel the need to cling to that. There are things smiths can do to reduce grain size through heat treating, and other choices.
"I think it is hard to evaluate the performance of these tools without respect to the user's techniques, both sharpening and using. A smooth and deft technique is easier on the tool than a clumsy one. The needs of an 18th century cabinetmaker or joiner were different than that of a hobbyist today, and I think that is reflected in the steels."
+10, I would just add that wood has quite a bit to do with it also. There is a correlation between the tools and the wood available in quality and species at a given time.
"Why would one want to believe that carbon steel of 1850 would be the best alloy for making a chisel ever discovered?"
I'm with you on that to an extent, but:
- Steels aren't always discovered, they may well be crafted for the intended use, then it becomes easier to believe they are better, when handled by experts, than something we may have today.
- So much modern stuff is crap, and may explain why the cross slide on a 100 year old lathe doesn't snap in half like it's replacement today. I'm starting to worry where our structural steel is coming from. I don't think 19th century gun barrel steel is better than the modern stuff, we care about guns. If you can find me a modern steel that is designed for making chisels alone on a similar scale to the ones we press into service...
"I know that the better alloy will win over better heat treatment of carbon steel."
That isn't always the case today. Lots of knives remain made in simple carbon steels, are better regarded as such, and that is even with the popularity of stainless to contend with. There are some non-performance reasons for this, but performance is also a part of it.
"This has been the case with knives and it is the case with chisels and plane irons."
Not universally so. There are a lot of serious users out there who don't agree. No way you are flogging the alphabet soup to the Japanese classically trained guys. Adam, crushingly, wants softer steel! These are common responses in the knife biz also.
"If you can bury a 25 degree mortise chisel in oak with a dead blow hammer and pry out chips without fear"
Then you're obviously a newbie (speaking of the person in the image)
"Chisel steel is easy to spec out... comes back flat."
You would have to admit though that this approach is glaringly obvious. To some extent this kind of approach works for wood turning... Just isn't working for me on the other wall of the office. I would tend to agree that there has to be a use for even "better" steels, it just doesn't seem to be all that important.
An example of a different sort is bicycles. Bikes made of chromo tubing remain popular, even in forms that would scandalize a traditionalist. Super materials like carbon should have taken over long ago, but they can't and probably won't for many reasons. Similar issue in golf club shafts. Sometimes the obvious answer is just wrong. However Carbon has been dominant in sports like fishing for decades. In archery where both bows and arrows seem obvious candidates for carbon, it is used most widely only on the harder to make and more easily broken arrows. The world is a complicated place.
"This approach lacks the glamor of shade trees and forges or oriental mumbo jumbo so I appreciate it isn't for everyone."
These kinds of comments tend to devalue input, and open up to dismissal for reasons that I imagine would be as unfair as they would be unflattering. Talking about oriental mumbo jumbo would probably strike them as rich when we are far more prone to idle talk than they are.
There are certainly Japanese tools that are made for the tourist trade as I like to call it, but there are also a large range of very impressive, "real" tools. I really have difficulty understanding how anyone who is a serious craftsperson could fail to see it. It is a long way from saying that to saying everyone should use them. I have a lot of Japanese tools, but I don't really know if they have advanced my personal cause that much. They almost become an end in themselves. But that is wholly different than saying they aren't good tools, or worse. At the end of the day, I want to make things that excel in function and beauty, and I can see it when others achieve that end.
"He thought that 18th century woodworkers were able to handle a more delicate tool and that the thick irons of the 19th century reflected a waning of craftsmanship"
I don't know about that, though I have often felt the same way about infill planes...