Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Posts

Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#1

Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Dan Collins

>I'm looking to get a low angle jack plane. I have narrowed it down to Veriatas (189.00) or Lie-Nielson (225.00). The materials and sizes appear to be the same. Am I just paying extra for the Lie-Nielson name or is there an identifiable difference in performance, durability, etc?? Thanks for any imput. Dan

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#2

Better duck!

Jerry Nicholson

>This could be another one of those long threads! Kind of like Mac vs PC, Porter Cable vs DeWalt, bevel up vs bevel down, K&E vs Post, etc.

Jerry

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#3

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Bruce Mack

>I own the L-N and cannot compare it to the Veritas. It is a tool I take out just to experience the magic of putting a shine on a scrap of 2x4, whispy shaving after shaving. I can't imagine better.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#4

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>I saw something recently (may even have been here on Wood Central) that seems relevant:

"One is like a shiny silver dollar coin and the other is like a crisp new dollar bill. One's a little more solid than the other and one's easier to fold into your wallet. They are different but both have the same value."

I can't remember who said it and that particular post was about comparing two top-quality table saw fences, but it probably applies just as much to the planes you've asked about.

regards

Angus Barclay

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#5

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Michael Brady

>T. Lie-Nielsen said one time that the LA jack was the best tool he makes. I wouldn't argue that. It is surprisingly versatile, and easy to adjust and use. I was also able to try it before I bought it because retailers and the ww shows(Chicago)have samples to use. Never saw an LV anywhere but in their catalog, so you have to buy before you try unless you live in Ottawa. People around here say they like the LVLA, too; but get as many opinions as you can and read the other threads about related topics. It never hurts to buy the best that you can afford, and that certainly applies to hand tools.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#6

The reviews I've read...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>...put the Veritas ahead of the LN for a number of reasons. The lower price is just icing on the cake...

I don't own the LN, but I do have the Veritas, and if you would force me to keep only one plane, this would be the one. Can't imagine anything better...

DC

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#7

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Mick Foley

>Dan -

I've got the LN low angle jack - it is a great plane. I've never used the Veritas low angle jack, so I can't comment on the differences.

I will say, however, that I have a varitey of both LN and Veritas planes and without exception, they are all great. Service from both companies is fantasitc.

The truth here is that you are picking between two winners. If money is a key concern, go for the Veritas. Otherwise, look at the features, read the responces and choose. You really can't lose.

Mick

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#8

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

mikew

>Take this for what's it is worth--I don't own either. Just used both is all. Probably I have used the LV more.

I don't think you'll find a performance difference.

Many have personal appearance preferences and those with strong feelings in this regard invariably select the LN line of planes.

There is also the issue raised as regards the difference in tote design and the angle of the tote.

Others point to the adjustablility of the LV as superior to the LN. I personally don't spend a lot of time adjusting planes, so I don't know how much an issue that is for me, but the LV adjusters do work very well.

Having handled and used both, I give the nod to LN for a more traditional appearance and a feel to the tote which is similar to my other Stanleyesque planes. I do own the LV low angle smoother and do not find it uncomfortable to use.

I sold off many of my metal planes last year. And I will probably purchase some in the not too distant future. The planes on my list to buy to replace them are the LV BU Smoother and BU Jack and the LN 5 1/2 and 5 1/4.

Take care, Mike

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#9

Comparsions of the top-end...

Paul Kierstead

>... are invariably not terribly helpful. Really. Both are extremely good and perform fantastically. Any review which finds a quantifiable difference almost invariably make demands or push the limits of planing to the point of irrelevance and even then differences in technique, etc. might make your results different. In either case, at these levels of quality if the one of the two fails to perform, it is a almost certainly the operator, not the plane.. Go with your gut (and possibly your wallet if it is an issue) and you won't go wrong.

And, worse comes to worse, use if for a while and if you don't like it, sell it; both retain their values well.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#10

two choices, toss a coin or ...

Ian Neuhaus

>Dan

I own the Lie-Nielsen and it's one of my favourites.

In answer to your question about discernable differences?

all I can say is that it comes down to asethics and how the plane feels in your hands. None of us can use the plane for you nor make decisions on asethics for you. All we can do is give you our opinion.

Place a picture of both planes on the fridge or somewhere else you see regularly and let your heart (not your wallet) be the ultimate judge.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#11

Tough question

HC Sakman @ Victoria, BC

>I have both planes.

They are very close to each other in every aspect, though I give slight edge to LV for the following reasons:

*LV is wider and heavier. It seems to help to deal with some certain grain/wood that LN tears. (Both blades were ground at the same 27 degrees.) These circumstances are not very common, only for very demanding woods. Wide blade also allows better skewing when necessary.

*LV is cheaper, if that matters.

*I love the mouth stop screw in LV, as well as the lower mushroom knob.

*LV has lateral adj. though, that does not really a big deal to me personally. LV's tote does not look highly attractive but comfortable.

I like the look of LN. It has a better visual appeal.

Ultimately, boils down to personal preference. You can't really go wrong with either one.

Chico...

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#12

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>Hi dan,

I have handled both planes. I own the LN and was leant the LV to play with. I like the LN even though it doesn't have the lateral adjuster.

I like it for the following reasons:

-> tote is more comfy in my hands

-> the sole and toe plate are dead flat on my LN with no light.

I like the idea of the LV louth stop screw but don't like where they put the brass screw

Just my opinion

Dan Clermont

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#13

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Alice Frampton, UK

>Hi Dan,

Talk about walking in where angels fear to tread...

Regarding your comment "The materials and sizes appear to be the same.". Go back and look again. 'cos they're not. I think all the differences have been covered by other respondees to this thread, but summing up have a look at; length, width, weight, position of mouth, mouth adjustment, blade adjustment and handle design. All those have an effect on how a plane will feel and work when you use it, above and beyond that there are the aesthetic considerations of materials, shape and so forth. Try and narrow down what aspects are most important to you and buy accordingly. I have both and know which I prefer, but even then there are aspects of the other I like better! Either way you'll get an excellent tool for the money.

Cheers, Alf

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#14

Re: price...

paul womack

>*LV is cheaper, if that matters.

OTOH, If price doesn't matter I'm sure that Mr Marcou would enjoy making you a LA jack...

BugBear

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#15

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Mark Nowicki

>Get both, use them for 30 days, keep the one you prefer, return the other.

Regards

Mark Nowicki

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#16

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

paul womack

>-> the sole and toe plate are dead flat on my LN with no light.

How bad was the LV's sole?

BugBear

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#17

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>Hi Paul,

It was out enough for my friend to take it back cause he was unhappy with it.

I did take pictures comparing the two soles but refuse to post them as I thnk it may create a very negative thread

You and I have been down this raod before and know that getting a true measurment out of how "out of flat" a sole may be is very difficult to measure without plotting it on a piece of gear you and I don't own.

LV has a good return policy which makes them a good company.

Personally I am not a Bevel Up fan so I wouldn't buy the LV or LN again. I don't use my LN much except for shooting

Just my Opinion,

Dan Clermont

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#18

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>Sounds like a great idea but it isn't fair to the manufacturer as they then have to sell of the used plane as "used" stock

Cheers

Dan Clermont

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#19

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Vijay

>I went through the same decision making process and chose the LV. While both make fine planes, I chose the LV due to the fact that it can accept the different blades that you can buy come pre-ground to the 38 deg and 50 degree bevel in addition to the the 25 deg that is standard.

Of course you can buy extra blades for the LN and grind them yourself to the higher angles. But the one thing where the flexibility of the LV is that you can use these same blades on their bevel up jointer and their smoother.

Having said all this if you are going to buy only one plane you cant go wrong with either. They are both great planes.

Vijay

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#20

Re: Agree with Dan 100%

paul womack

>I'd call that an abuse of a "friendly" returns policy.

BugBear

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#21

Me, too, abusive consumer behavior

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#22

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Greg Sloop, Portland Oregon

>I went looking for my past posts on this subject, but frankly I can't find the one I want. (BTW: Google searches WC a lot better than WC searches WC...)

I got the LN 62 some time ago. I really loved it. Very nice plane, but I did have some peeves about it.

When LV started selling the 62.5 I used a friend's 62.5 for a few weeks, and decided to sell my LN on the bay and get a LV. That I did, and I've been very, very happy with the LV version.

Here are some comments I've made in that transition.

"The adjuster is much finer, IMHO, than the LN62. I also always feel there's just a bit too much lash in the LN, and that it's not fine enough in pitch. The LV62 adjuster I keep liking more and more. I'm not much of a guy to use the lateral adjust, thus it's mostly wasted on me - but if you can't sharpen your irons straight or like a lateral adjust, the LV has a very nice one."

"One pet peeve on the LN is the iron cap. The LN uses a simple brass screw with a bit of a point on it. What I've experienced is that unless you crank it down quite hard, it will often come loose. Often you won't notice until the iron starts to chatter. Then you check the cap and find it's way loose. Tighten and the chatter goes away. This isn't a huge problem, but it can be annoying.

The solution to the above problem is to crank the iron cap down. But when you do, you can't make any projection adjustments - the iron is just being held too tightly to make any adjustments. Now, perhaps that's as designed, and I'm a moron, but I don't think that's the case.

(You can often find a happy medium where you don't get a loose cap iron and can still adjust projection, but it can be hard. More than occasionally, I find I'm unsuccessful and the cap iron is either too tight to allow projection adjust or too loose to stay firm, and it works its way out.)

The LV has a similar cap, but it's longer - which gives more of a fulcrum and the brass screw has a "foot" on it. (I don't know what else to call it. Perhaps some pictures later...) The cap doesn't come loose, and with a moderate tightness on the iron cap, you can still easily adjust projection of the iron without fussing with the tightness of the lever cap, both before and after. "

"The little screw that keeps the adjustable foot from banging into your sharpened iron is very nice. However, when taking a fine cut with the mouth wide open - not something one would often do - the shaving often gets caught behind/underneath the screw and stops up the mouth. This is easily fixed by closing the mouth down. I'm not sure how it will work when taking a thick shaving with the mouth wide open it may still occur - I've not tried it. I suppose you could always take the screw out if you found it annoying on a regular basis."

Update note to the above. If you don't leave the screw all the way out, it doesn't catch shavings. Run it in against the foot when you're taking thin shavings and it doesn't catch the wispy ones any more. (If I wasn't so dim, I'm sure it wouldn't have taken Rob Lee to let me know to do this. I asked via email and he was very gracious to tell me *I* was borked, not the plane. *grin* [Actually Rob was very diplomatic as usual.])

"The front adjustable shoe on the LV adjusts very nicely. I think the LV that I have slides more easily and freely than the LN.

The LN does have the cam ring to help adjust the shoe, and the LV doesn't. Given how freely the LV slides, it isn't a problem at all. However, if the LV one was a bit stickier, it could be a problem. (If the LV engineering/manufacturing QC is good, I don't expect this to be a problem.) [Update: I've not heard of anyone complaining about this, so LV apears to be doing well here.]

The better feel and heft make it easy to get full length shavings - it seems easier to power through a full cut. The finer adjustment also helps, as you can more easily/quickly pick exactly how thick a cut you want to take"

I prefer the longer toe on the LV version. It's quite handy when you're touching up short pieces. This is a very substantial issue for me.

----

A few further comments.

These apply when you look at the "set" of planes from LV and LN as a group.

LN: 62, 164, Jointer

LV: 62.5 Heavy smoother, Jointer

As has been noted, the irons on the LV serious of bevel up planes all transfer between all the three of that series. *Heavy* smoother (not the smaller one), 62.5 and jointer. Since I have at least two angles for each plane, that save a bundle since I'm not required to have two irons for each plane. If I choose to have two each, I have more irons to run through before I have to sharpen again.

The LN 164 smoother has an annying attachment to the blade for adjustment purposes. To sharpen you have to take it off, and will have to transfer to another blade if you only have one. Minor irritation, but significant, at least to me.

The LV jointer has an adjustable mouth, the LN does not.

===============

Given all the above, and given the advantages of a "set" of planes, IMO, the very clear advantage is to LV - at least from a utilitarian view.

One last item. Some people have more of a fetish relationship with their planes than I do, and don't care for the "look" of LV. If that's a problem for you, then look carefully and see if you don't mind the LV stuff. Frankly I don't much care what they look like anyway, but I don't think they look half bad anyway.

Also, as has been mentioned, some don't care for the LV tote. Myself, being the oaf I am, I guess, can't tell any real difference betwixt the two. But you might.

If I were to try something, I'd buy the LV and see if you liked it. If not, send it back. I suspect you will.

Cheers,

Greg

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#23

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielsen

Marc in Luxembourg

>I don't agree. LN hones every bevel you want for no extra charge. So this ain't an argument. And honing a microbevel takes only some minutes.

I thought about the same on changing blades and bought #4,5 #6 and #7. All the same blade. But ask how many times I did change? Never! Meanwhile I came to think better have one tool for one purpose. That works great and makes you go on much faster and easier.

Indeed one could imagine buying the two planes and writing a review ;-) But in fact the idea doesn't seem to be that strange. You could use one for smoothing and the other for coarse work.

Marc

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#24

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Dan, where are you located. Perhaps some of us with the planes are nearby and you can just try one out. I have the LV LA Jack, and I took a gamble on buying without having tried it. I have been completely impressed with it's quality. But, I'd have loved the chance to try some planes before buying them. I was worried about the tote on the LV, but I haven't had any problem, even with 1/2 hour to 1 hour planing sessions.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#25

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Mark Nowicki

>I don't think I will go out on the limb if I assume that Lee Valley or Lie Nielsen or any other well run company know how many returns they can expect during their business year, and their prices reflect that possibility. I will even venture a guess that most companies with clearly stated return policies have a reserve account set up for tax purposes.

In any case why is abuse to use a "return for any reason guarantee" if you find a reason?

Regards

Mark Nowicki