Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Posts

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#51

Re: This reminds me... long

Thom D


>When you think about who the leaders in the woodworking community are, as measured by name recognition, they aren't largely woodworkers, but people who have written about woodworking, do seminars, etc... Another group are those who do detailed reviews of products, a good opportunity to parade superior knowledge. Over time this can lead to an activity where what people who follow the media actually want to do it write (boards), teach (boards clubs friends etc...), review, etc... The last thing anyone wants to do is the hard manual labor.

I noticed this in knifemaking when I started to hang out to pick up stuff to turn to making woodworking tools. There are a lot of articles in magazines that compare knives, often by beating the heck out of them in various torture tests. Normally stuff that you would never do to a knife if you were a serious user, any more than you would test your jointer plane by using it to drive heavy metal stakes. But at some level the torture tests prove something... So what happens? There is a whole consumer culture out there devoted to buying knives and reducing them to scrap. One of the things I enjoy about being a craftsman is a greater sense of respect for the things people make. It discomforts me to just see people breaking stuff.

Anyway, it would be logical for people who hang out in woodworking magazines, to develop a desire to do real professional woodwork, you know, test all the different planes out there and return the ones you don't like. Just like the pros. And just as the knife makers are stuck doing warrantee business for people bent on destroying their products, tool manufacturers are going to be stuck with people who want to kick tires. They started it.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#52

Delivered Price: $201 LV and $210 LN

Todd Stock


>The LV is $189 plus $12 shipping, for $201; the LN is $210 with shipping included from FTJ. The real difference is $9, or about 5%. With that price difference, buy the tool that has the features you want.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#53

A good point...

John in NM


>"...it would be logical for people who hang out in woodworking magazines, to develop a desire to do real professional woodwork, you know, test all the different planes out there and return the ones you don't like. Just like the pros."

I'm not sure which pros you are refering to, I'm assuming professional writers and reviewers, as thats the only case that seems to make sense.

Though this behavior is certainly understandable, it still does not justify the exploitation of generous return policies. Anyone who appreciates the companies in question offering such generous policies should not exploit them or encourage others to do so, as I seriously doubt that the companies' intent is to encourage this sort of abuse. I would imagine that manufacturers encourage reviewing in magazines and online (not an attempt to re-open that nasty discussion) in part to help potential customers make up their minds without having to take in a bunch of slightly used returns. I suspect that the generousity of these companies would disappear if everyone started engaging in the practise of home testing and then returning the "losers".

John

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#54

Maybe an opportunity;-)

Dan Donaldson


>Something to think about: How about a vendor having some stock (used or returns that are good items) that you could get to try out. They could have customers put up enough money up front that they don't lose, and if you decide you like it, you could then return it for a new one and pay the price difference. The returned one could be used for the next customer.

There would have to be some consideration if the customer damages it, but this would be better than purchasing something with the intent to return it.

Probably more trouble than it is worth, but it might work.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#55

Re: Maybe an opportunity;-)

Ted Shuck, Centennial, CO


>I seem to remember one vendor doing this with chisels. He would send out some number of 1/2" chisels by different makers for the prospective buyer to try. Some portion of the cost of the trial could then be applied to purchasing the new chisels. This looked like a very good idea to me, although I never took advantage of it.

Ted

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#56

Tools for working wood did that...

John in NM


>With chisels as Ted mentions below. I almost mentioned it, but I wasn't sure if Joel was still doing that or why he stopped if not. Sounded like a good idea, though I could imagine why vendors might not be wild about doing it. One of the knife forums I've seen does something similar, though I can't claim to know all the details. If there's enough interest, one member buys a knife and then they send it to each participant in turn to try out for a week or however long is agreed upon. I can't remember now how they end up paying for the thing, but it all seemed pretty equitable.

John

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#57

Re: Tools for working wood did that...

joel -( tools for working wood)


>Yes we did it for awhile. We stopped it for two reasons:

We couldn't see a correlation between tester chisels and the final selection of the customer.

We shipped the chisels our sharp and ready to use and got them back dull. Which means that at the time when I was the only person here who could sharpen I needed to sharpen all the time. I didn't have the time.

So we got rid of the program. We still have the samples sitting in a bin here and we let people try them out when they visit the store.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#58

Re: A good point...

Thom D


>If there is any truth in my observation, then the companies are years ahead of me. And they are designing their marketing with this reality in mind. And that reality would be that they are basically in the entertainment business. And the suppliers are just going to have to fit into whatever kind of behavior actually primes the pump.

On the other hand if the Lee Valleys of the world are really and truly in the workman supply business then they are up against the unlimited satisfaction guarantee of places like Princess Auto, heaven help them.

This kind of thread is understandable: It's the business of producing blue collar tools for white collar workers who think in terms of contracts, codes of ethics, and economics 101. It's a rational hard boiled world of tough minded tool users, and darn the guy who pushes the unit of production up one cent. How many "Gs" in cognitive dissonance. A good many judging by the number of catalogs I get in the mail.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#59

Re: Maybe an opportunity;-)

Thom D


>Very fair point if the issue was people actually taking test drives to see which tool was really best, for some profoundly practical reason.

My point (sorry to belabor it) is that maybe the nature of the game is changing. I can think of thousands of examples in other activities that have gone through a shift. Many moons ago mountain climbing stopped being about "getting to the top". And even getting to the top was the slenderest of practical justifications. Few people doing this stuff are driven by practical considerations, which inevitably leads to their being increasingly affected by marketing, the practical stuff is local. It's very rare that local influences, like spouses, wake up and say "honey, you should buy a whole stock of tools that will never pay for themselves and spend all your time in the basement". And you don't grow a business by depending on people growing up in a household where that wass normal behabviour.

Marketing works in unexpected ways. For instance there is some dynamic to why fashion moved to heroine chic, or that comedy moves to ever more harsh jokes. It's not that people are inherently dirty minded, it might be the opposite: I have heard all the decent jokes already. In woodworking there are certain articles that bring together the needs of the magazine the advertisers and the consumers. Stuff like tests. After a while the tests are more real than conventional woodworking. Getting a few chisels to test drive is one thing, that's treating you as a consumer. You have to get the fresh boxes to play reviewer. And it's not that anyone consciously gets up in the morning and decides to play at anything. It's a just a pattern out there with a lot of dollars behind it.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#60

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Thom D


>I hope he is leaving them in a bin outside a Toronto store.