Re: This reminds me... long
Thom D
>When you think about who the leaders in the woodworking community are, as measured by name recognition, they aren't largely woodworkers, but people who have written about woodworking, do seminars, etc... Another group are those who do detailed reviews of products, a good opportunity to parade superior knowledge. Over time this can lead to an activity where what people who follow the media actually want to do it write (boards), teach (boards clubs friends etc...), review, etc... The last thing anyone wants to do is the hard manual labor.
I noticed this in knifemaking when I started to hang out to pick up stuff to turn to making woodworking tools. There are a lot of articles in magazines that compare knives, often by beating the heck out of them in various torture tests. Normally stuff that you would never do to a knife if you were a serious user, any more than you would test your jointer plane by using it to drive heavy metal stakes. But at some level the torture tests prove something... So what happens? There is a whole consumer culture out there devoted to buying knives and reducing them to scrap. One of the things I enjoy about being a craftsman is a greater sense of respect for the things people make. It discomforts me to just see people breaking stuff.
Anyway, it would be logical for people who hang out in woodworking magazines, to develop a desire to do real professional woodwork, you know, test all the different planes out there and return the ones you don't like. Just like the pros. And just as the knife makers are stuck doing warrantee business for people bent on destroying their products, tool manufacturers are going to be stuck with people who want to kick tires. They started it.



