Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Posts

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#26

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Paul M. in San Diego

>So you feel justified in amortizing your indecision at my expense? These costs are distributed across all customers. I don't appreciate higher costs because you want to collect several toys before you decide which to keep and return the rest.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#27

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Mark Nowicki

>Actually, Paul, I am saving you money. I have several Lee Valley items that I should have returned but I couldn't be bothered. The answer to your question is yes.

Regards

Mark Nowicki

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#28

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Rob Lee

>Hi -

Yes and no....

As part of the manufacturing operation - we do reject product that's 100% usable... and everyone bears that cost.

When working with cast iron, it's impossible to have 100% yield .... there ARE voids and porosity in the castings... grains of sand come loose when pouring etc. .... since a pinhole void is deemed unacceptable by the marketplace, those products get scrapped.

In some products, you can end up scrapping 5% of more of your production... and it's not the value of the casting that's at issue - it's the machine time you've sunk into it by the time the void reveals itself...

Now - the clothing industry does operate the way you describe.... they budget for a return rate... and even build it into their forecasting system as a time shifted "receipt"....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#29

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>HI Rob,

Is the metal in these planes re-used or are they simply scrapped?

In todays marketplace of excalating metal prices I hope you are re-using them

Cheers

Dan Clermont

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#30

Re: It's called chraftsmanship

Thom D

>It is possible to do returns so that they look brand new. I mean if you are acting in good faith and something just turns out to be crap.

I bought this set a japanese chisels I flattened all the blades sharpened them, I didn't hit them with a hammer, or not hard enough to show. They just weren't that great So I dulled them slightly replaced the 0/90 scratch pattern on the back, re-did the lacquer coating and returned them looking exactly as they had looked when I first bought them. Whoever owns them must think that brand has the flattest backs of any Japanese chisels ever sold.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#31

Let's use common sense Paul

HC Sakman @ Victoria, BC

>Hi Paul,

The difference in these two planes is $50+ change, not $1000 or even $500! That's why I said "if that matters", because $50 is irrelevant to some, but can break a deal for other.

Chico...

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#32

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Thom D

>I bought both jack planes and really prefer the LN. LN's are much nicer finished, and they seem stronger in the handles. I haven't bought either of the smoothers. I was told by Rob Cossman not to buy the LN LA jointer because the mouth wasn't adjustible so I waited for the LV. I bought the LV and I really liked having it in the shop until I cooled off and realized it wouldn't do anything significant my jointer wouldn't, so back it went.

So in general I like the LN for quality and finish, but the LV for features on the jointer, When you get to their non-LA planes there are some major feature differences and it's a whole other deal.

Some of my LVs have made me rush out to make or buy replacement blades. They may have that sorted out, but no LN has ever begged for a new blade, and that's from their carbon stock.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#33

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>Thom D states:

"Some of my LVs have made me rush out to make or buy replacement blades. They may have that sorted out, but no LN has ever begged for a new blade, and that's from their carbon stock."

---------------------------------------------------------------------

What kind of issues were you having with the blades? Could it be a difference between the LN's being A2 Cryogenically treated vs the LV A2 which was not Cryogenically treated? Some state (and I believe it to be true) that a LA plane with a blade ground to 38 degrees requires more sharpenings as the edge wear is greater.

When I tested the LV's I didn't have any problems with edge retention. I know someone who had problems with edge retention years ago but that was before LV really got into Bench planes

Cheers

Dan Clermont

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#34

True....

John in NM

>You are justified in returning a perfectly good product if the manufacturer or vendor defines their return policy that way.

The point is, just don't expect others with a perhaps more rigdid sense of fairness to clap you on the back and say "what a great idea". Retailers will often also factor inventory "shrinkage" into their budgets, but does this justify shoplifting?

John

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#35

Conclusions ??

Dan Collins

>Thanks for all the imput. It is really helpful. I guess I'm leaning towards the Veritas, although the LN does look nice. Appearance is not a big issue for me. Your comments did raise one more issue though. My general feeling is the blade is probably the most important feature since it does the dirty work. I know virtually nothing about metal. I was thinking that since both blades were "A2", they would be the same, but now I am wondering if being Cryogenically treated (LN) is a big deal. By the way, I live in Janesville, WI, but I really don't expect anyone to invite me over for a test run. Thanks again for your comments.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#36

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Rob Lee

>Dan -

We recycle everything possible ....all metals, coolants etc.

Rob

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#37

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Deirdre Saoirse Moen

>I think the only way to tell is to use one of each kind of plane to see which one feels better for you. They are somewhat optimized for different workbench heights. I tend to work high (and often seated), so the LN seems to work better for me.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#38

I think that is worth a whole 'nother thread

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>I can't say for sure. It is one of those extra steps that makes the LN more expensive IMO. Hock also Cyrogenically treats their blades if I remember correctly

Cheers

Dan Clermont

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#39

Re: Conclusions ??

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Hey, you're more than welcome to swing by, I'm only a couple of states away. If you find yourself on the eastern side of PA, feel free to look me up.

And now I can say I know somebody in WI.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#40

Re: Tough question

John Horobin

>I think that the problem with LV planes is not in the function - they are excellent but in the styling. I just prefer the LN planes to look at. If LV got their styling right they would be unbeatable.

Just my opinion. I've used both and both are excellent to use.

John

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#41

I am so confused....

HC Sakman @ Victoria, BC

>Please elaborate on this quote:

" I tend to work high (and often seated), so the LN seems to work better for me."

I am in total lost. Is this a suggestion, opinion or statement? If it's any one of the three, how is one of these two planes "works better for you" ?

Chico...

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#42

Price???

John Hoffman

>Hi Dan, the price difference is not real so to speak. If you didn't like the LN you could turn around and ebay it for almost what you paid, as in real close. I have found that the better I like the tool, esthetics, "feel" et al, the more pleasure I get from it, and really what is all this about if it is not about pleasure.

Treat yourself well and don't even consider the $ difference. I prefer the LN tools.

Regards

JH

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#43

Re: I am so confused....

Deirdre Saoirse Moen

>Other people have said that for higher benches, LNs worked better for them, where for lower benches, LV worked better. I don't know the real differences other than having used both for about an hour (different planes, granted) before I made my choice. That said, I only have one plane that's either, and it's an LN.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#44

Re: I am so confused....

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.-Let's Go Oilers!

>Hi,

I have never heard that,,,,I thought my height in relation to the bench height and the working zone (power zone) was what defined the effective height to work within...I have not heard that one plane works better in the way you have described it...Am I missing something??

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#45

Re: I am so confused....

Deirdre Saoirse Moen

>I'm just sayin' some people found one or the other more comfortable given their bench height. I didn't do a scientific study, nor (offhand) can I remember where I read the thread on same (quite possibly woodnet).

In my case, LN felt more comfortable in my hand as well, though I could be happy with either.

Aesthetically, I prefer the LN as well.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#46

Re: I am so confused....

mikew

>The handle angles are different, with the LV more upright than the LN/Stanleyesque planes.

As concerns the arm/wrist, it would argue for the LV needed a higher bench, the LN a lower one.

This isn't much/any different in principle than saw handle hangs. The hang of a handle in relation to the workpiece makes for less/more fatigue in sawing, which often translates to efficiency.

As well, the lateral/vertical force is applied differently. A handle with a forward lean transfers X percent of the force required to plane downward into the work. A more upright handle applies force further torwards the toe of the plane.

But all this is on-paper. How each works for the individual, their stance they are accustom to [more bent at the waist or not], wrist cocked and or to what degree, type of arm motion, etc, all affect planing efficiency with a given plane style.

Have fun, Mike

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#47

Re: I am so confused....

Deirdre Saoirse Moen

>"As concerns the arm/wrist, it would argue for the LV needed a higher bench, the LN a lower one."

I thought of that later that I probably had it backwards for MOST people, but I seem to just be backwards, period (especially today, which has been a demoralizing day on many counts).

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#48

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Thom D


>I have LV brand planes going back, seems like 20 years, but the ones I am refering to were the high angle smoother and the block plane. I have one of their A2 replacement blade in one of my ECE planes and it seems to be doing great. I think I got that one because A2 doesn't mind having some heavy grinding done to it, I think I pared down the 2" blade to 1.875".

I have a bunch of LN panes mostly purchased from LV before they re-entered the plane market, and right from the beegining they got the blades right. I think it's part of the LN creed that they won't release sub-standard blades. They take the blade seriously where a lot of people back then did not seem to see the blade as all that important, "but look at this great adjuster". LNs are the only western planes I own where I haven't had to toss all the blades. The blades are improving, but I'm currently running home made blades in some of my planes, and I think it's pretty incredible one can get a perfromance improvement off home made steel. There are some smiths who can milk a lot out of O1, but I'm not one of them, just following standrd heat treating proceedures can get one higher performance.

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#49

Re: Conclusions ??

Greg Sloop, Portland Oregon


>My brother in law is just up the road from you, literally. (Evansville)

Unf. he's not a wood-worker, so no joy there.

Since I've had both the LN and the LV, I'll note here that I noticed no difference in edge retention between the two.

IMO, these differences are VERY small if they exist at all.

Cheers,

Greg

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

#50

Re: Veritas Plane vs. Lie-Nielson

Thom D


>Well it's hardly indecisive, he knows he wants to try both right up front. Compare that to the people who don't buy either, require national marketing campaigns to decide what they want, or local service, or lots of input from key executives on every known board, or lots of reviews and videos, or buy the wrong plane then poison the waters with their dissatisfaction,... Look it could probably be worse...