Re: vacuum pumps, my take
Grant in Iowa
Here's why I went with the venturi setup.
I wanted to be able to control the pressure. It is not only the glue pressure I wanted control over, but I wanted to be able to keep from destroying a minimally built form if I got in to more complex part making. It was (at the time) about $160 or so to get to that level of control with even a small electric diaphragm pump. I wasn't considering lab surplus, which may have been a mistake.
I already had my compressor, and find that I wouldn't want a shop without one having had it available for a decade now. Too much can be done easier with it. So I didn't consider the compressor an added cost. My shop is not simply a fine woodworking shop, it is also a carpentry shop, mixed media shop, as well as a maintenance shop for vehicles and machinery. Grinders, welders, impact tools, air nailers, nibblers, etc. In fact, I have come to realize that my compressor is perhaps too small at this point.
Bill makes a good point in that it makes little difference how long it takes to pull the vacuum on a part. He's right on many glue up types, such as laminating a veneered panel, etc. It may not, however, be correct when thinking about some types of epoxies. I am fond of bent lamination glue ups like the water skis. It can take one person nearly half an hour to apply the glue to the laminations, place it on the form, add the wax paper to protect the bag, add the screen, slide everything in the bag, seal the bag, and begin pulling the vacuum. So for large parts, it can matter significantly how long it will take to get the part under vacuum.
I built the 3.2 CFM V2 unit because I wanted to not have to upgrade later on if I wanted to do some crazy big stuff. I bought the 4'x8' bag for the same reason.
Also, as I was an amateur at vacuum bagging, there were several unknowns. Since it was the best value at a volume that could pull down a large bag reasonably quickly, it was what I chose. I don't regret the decision.
Now I am getting in to lathe work, and I can use the system for clamping parts on the lathe at times. Doing that can require more volume capacity due to the leak possibility and cost of failure.
We all have different methods, budgets, existing equipment and so on. Do what you will with what you have and enjoy it. There are waaaaay more than one way to do a task in woodworking. I would not be so quick to dismiss the solutions of others based on my own needs.
Regards,
Grant in Iowa
Grant in Iowa