Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

Posts

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#51

Good points

John in NM

The only time I had to worry about air flow in pulling a vacuum was when I was degassing resin with a 3 minute gel time. I mixed the resin before degassing since I had a pump that would do 17 cfm and I only needed a rough vacuum (a bit more than bagging needs). Took about 10 seconds :D

For most adhesives used in bagging, airflow rates shouldn't make much of a difference.

We run lab pumps for days on end, most of them are designed for it - can't speak for diaphragm pumps though, I've never used one of those.

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#52

Re: vacuum pumps

William Duffield

All else being equal, the surplus lab vacuum pump is probably the best method. The reason a compressor and Venturi are often recommended is that most wood shops, especially those that serve double duty as a garage, already have a compressor, and the Venturi itself "can't fail" because it has zero moving parts (if you disregard the air, and all the connected plumbing). If you also do wood turning and have a vacuum chuck, it often includes a Venturi in the kit, so you may be able to take out another bird with the same rock.

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#53

Ellis Walentine

No substitute for experience

Ellis Walentine

Adam, I'm so glad to have WoodCentral to provide such a wealth of experience for us all, but like most people, I've learned most of what I know by trial and error, just doing my best to get the job done and stay afloat.

This talk about vacuum setups takes me back to my first homemade vacuum bag, literally forty years ago. I had some job that required a curved veneered panel, several of them actually, so I went to a flea market and bought an old cow-milker pump. I think it was about 1/2 HP. I had a big 4x8 assembly table in my shop that I drilled for a little 1/4" copper pipe fitting and stuck the pump under the table, hooked up to this new vacuum port. I couldn't afford a fancy vacuum bag, so I went to the local cheapo upholstery shop and bought several yards of their thick clear-vinyl that people used to cover their sofas with in those days. I cut a piece of the vinyl large enough to drape over my panels and lay on the table all around them. Then I used thick double-faced foam tape to stick the vinyl to the table. Believe it or not, this rig did the trick. There was a lot of leakage as you might expect, so the little pump had to run almost continuously for hours on end. I made money on the job and it was off to the next adventure. The pump eventually burned out, but by then I had a bag system and a killer big set of screw-type veneer presses that I could veneer pieces up to about 12' long and three feet wide. I broke all the leaf springs on my pickup truck hauling those bad boys back to my shop.

Thanks for the memories.

Ellis

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#54

Adam of Oakland

yep

Adam of Oakland

Hi William - ya, and I thought long and hard about the fact that having a single machine (air compressor) able to do two different kinds of jobs (spraying, and vac-bagging). I like having machines that serve multiple purposes if I have to make room for them in my barn.

The conundrum i found myself in is that i don't presently have an air compressor. If i were to get one, i'd probably not want anything larger than a pancake or one step up. For larger projects, I was concerned about the insufficiency of using a small compressor for the job. So I caved and am getting a vacuum pump from joe-veneer guy. plus one of his bags.

I know I could have done this more efficiently money-wise but my day job kind of takes up a lot of my time. :\

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#55

Adam of Oakland

you know it's serious when...

Adam of Oakland

...the veneer press breaks your truck's leaf springs!

Thanks for sharing the memories Ellis...

today, i don't posses the resourcefulness that you had starting out, but i'm hoping some of it rubs off while I post progress on this thread.

I'll resume when I get my own vac-bagging kit sorted out here, day job calls!

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#56

Re: Shopvac and epoxies

TomD

Here I am vaccing a 4'x24' panel with regular boat building epoxy, visqueen and bubble wrap. Shopvacs are very capable for vac bagging, but not for lumpy veneers I normally use the rotary vane pump. I agree with most of Bill's points though I don't personally use diaphram pumps. We would just run the pumps on a timer, and let them go. A large volume of air moved and a leaky bag can be a given in certain cases, when parts get so large that even a two speed two stage is slow. Rec woodworkers were late to the party on vac bagging, and in many cases use glues that require major pressure, and like a neat and pleasant workspace. This has lead to some cool Rolls Royce systems, but simple works in a lot of circumstances, also.

[im]https://farm6.staticflickr.com/5803/20580894781_9ef21da720_z.jpg" border="0" alt="">

Let me know if the photo didn't work due to privacy settings or something. I find Flickr very non-intuative so I hope this worked.

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#57

Adam of Oakland

^^img above

Adam of Oakland

Thanks Tom , yeah that looks pretty boss!


Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#58

Re: vacuum pumps, my take

Grant in Iowa

Here's why I went with the venturi setup.

I wanted to be able to control the pressure. It is not only the glue pressure I wanted control over, but I wanted to be able to keep from destroying a minimally built form if I got in to more complex part making. It was (at the time) about $160 or so to get to that level of control with even a small electric diaphragm pump. I wasn't considering lab surplus, which may have been a mistake.

I already had my compressor, and find that I wouldn't want a shop without one having had it available for a decade now. Too much can be done easier with it. So I didn't consider the compressor an added cost. My shop is not simply a fine woodworking shop, it is also a carpentry shop, mixed media shop, as well as a maintenance shop for vehicles and machinery. Grinders, welders, impact tools, air nailers, nibblers, etc. In fact, I have come to realize that my compressor is perhaps too small at this point.

Bill makes a good point in that it makes little difference how long it takes to pull the vacuum on a part. He's right on many glue up types, such as laminating a veneered panel, etc. It may not, however, be correct when thinking about some types of epoxies. I am fond of bent lamination glue ups like the water skis. It can take one person nearly half an hour to apply the glue to the laminations, place it on the form, add the wax paper to protect the bag, add the screen, slide everything in the bag, seal the bag, and begin pulling the vacuum. So for large parts, it can matter significantly how long it will take to get the part under vacuum.

I built the 3.2 CFM V2 unit because I wanted to not have to upgrade later on if I wanted to do some crazy big stuff. I bought the 4'x8' bag for the same reason.

Also, as I was an amateur at vacuum bagging, there were several unknowns. Since it was the best value at a volume that could pull down a large bag reasonably quickly, it was what I chose. I don't regret the decision.

Now I am getting in to lathe work, and I can use the system for clamping parts on the lathe at times. Doing that can require more volume capacity due to the leak possibility and cost of failure.

We all have different methods, budgets, existing equipment and so on. Do what you will with what you have and enjoy it. There are waaaaay more than one way to do a task in woodworking. I would not be so quick to dismiss the solutions of others based on my own needs.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Grant in Iowa

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#59

One point...

John in NM

You can control the degree of vacuum (and thus the pressure differential between that vacuum and atmosphere) with any type of pump. Just a question of a vacuum switch to turn off the pump and an isolating valve of some kind.

There is nothing wrong with a venturi system if that's what you want to do. If you already have a big compressor like yours (I have one of those too), it's probably the cheapest way to start out as you can make the venturi yourself. I find them inefficient, but then I also find air sanders inefficient for the same reason :D If I were doing a couple of quick projects or just wanted to experiment, I would certainly consider a venturi as an intro set up. For long term use, a good lab pump is what I would find.

One guy around here (WC that is, I've forgotten who it is) uses the inlet of a piston air compressor to pull a vacuum. It works up to a point - about half atmosphere if I remember right. That first half is really about all you need for bag veneering gentle curves. Something like your water skis generally need more than that.

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#60

Re: yep

William Duffield

As someone pointed out above, with a vacuum bag, you can easily develop a ton of pressure per square foot. That's somewhere on the order of magnitude of driving a pick-up truck over your assembly. If you are planning to put the veneer, the substrate and the ribs inside the bag, it is very easy to collapse and crush the structure. That's not usually a problem with something like water skis that are solid, but you might have problems with the wide spacing and rather unsubstantial structure of your ribs.

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#61

Controlling vacuum

John K Jordan

>You can control the degree of vacuum ...

The vacuum systems I've researched and the design Joe Woodworker provides (and the one I'm building) control the vacuum with a vacuum controller, a check valve, a reservoir, and at least for a lathe chuck, a bleeder valve. Also, I consider his MAC valve and sub-reservior design a good one.

http://www.joewoodworker.com/veneering/EVS/concept.htm

He has a nice writeup about how and why these work together.

http://www.joewoodworker.com/veneering/EVS/what-and-why.htm

JKJ

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#62

Re: ^^img above

TomD

Gee, thanks for the correcting those scripts. Pilot error there, that was not the fail I was expecting...

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#63

Re: Double bag er

TomD

In the case I illustrated, there was only 4 psi I think it was, or maybe even two. The form had the ply over it and the shape was just gravity. The overall pressure as you say William was still a lot for forms every 2 feet, a few stringers, and nothing between the forms other than the part. At two psi it would work out to 27k pounds. one option is to bag the whole form and one pressure, and bag the laminate at another. Maybe 4 psi is enough for the global shaping, and the higher levels are there for the laminate itself

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#64

Probably depends on the pump...

John in NM

The pumps I've used all had no problem starting with a vacuum on one side already. All the lab pumps were rotary vane, not sure about the veneer pump used years ago in the wood shop I worked for. That one just had a vacuum switch for regulating as I recall, and since it did not loose vacuum when turned off I'm assuming it was a diaphragm pump.

JWW's site is a good one, though I tend to find that his solutions are overly complex for the task. Some people like that complexity though, so I'm not knocking it so much as keeping it in perspective.

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#65

Re:  w frame&panel curved in depth and profil

TomD

Great shop and project. When splitting out to kerfs like that I would hold the chisel bevel down. I ran into some Japanese carpenters at one point who suggested I do more of my work bevel down. So I keep the options in mind as I go.

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#66

Re: Controlling vacuum

John McGaw

I've built one from that design and it works quite well (even though I somehow got the two halves of the main reservoir 1/2" different in length). I modified the overall mounting and layout quite a bit and mounted the vacuum switch inside the on/off switch box for neatness but the 'schematic' of the piping and components are the same. I used one his cheaper pumps but it works fine for my purposes.

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#67

Adam of Oakland

ribs in my structure are too wide apart

Adam of Oakland

Hi Guys, Well I got set up with a rather nice bag system from JoeWW and managed to run a small test on some offcut veneer using the urea formaldehyde unibond 800. Never used this glue before so it was good practice.

I did a trial run with my smaller panel in the bag, sitting on top of asheet of 3/4 ply. I trimmed the veneer to have a small overhang of about 1/8 or so on it's substrate. breether mesh along the top as per JoeWW advice. feeling like i did this whole panel making process backwards, but oh well. next time.

William, you are right, there wasn't enough structure under the substrate to keep it from deflecting once a full 25 atmosphere was indicated on the pump. I could tell just by holding a straight edge along the length of the panel.

However, this sagging is almost nonexistent at 10 atm. given how strongly the assembly seemed to be holding at this lower output, I figure I will just go with that when it comes time to do this for reals. thoughts?


Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#68

Re: ribs in my structure are too wide apart

Jesse Cloud

Yikes, ten seems pretty low. I draw 19 way up in the mountains here. Never heard of anyone running 10. Hopefully, someone who knows the physics and chemistry here will pipe in.

Is there some way you can temporarily beef up the ribs? Maybe add some ribs in a way you can remove them later (nails, screws, etc...)?

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#69

Re: ribs in my structure are too wide apart

Barry Irby

Any way you can put just the panel in the bag and allow the bag to wrap around and conform to the ribs on the back side? Isn't the panel already the shape you wanted?

Or, can you install supports under the panel that are the same shape as the ribs? Styrofoam maybe?

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#70

Re: ribs in my structure are too wide apart

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If it will spring back, pull it down to squeeze the glue out and then release some pressure and hold until the blue sets.

With your small veneer overhang tape the veneer in place with blue painter tape or masking tape so it can't skid. Pull the tape SLOWLY off, perpendicular to the grain, or the grain may lift.

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#71

Results are everything

John in NM

I suspect you'll be fine at 10" Hg - the reading where there is minimal deflection - if the test part comes out the right shape and seems sound.

What you are doing when pulling a vacuum is removing the air molecules. They have weight just like the water in a pond does, but we don't notice the air around us any more than the fish notice the water. If you can remove most of the air from the bag, the air outside the bag pushes down at roughly 12-13 psi, thanks to gravity pulling on the gas molecules that make up the outside air.

Full atmospheric pressure at sea level is 14.7 psi, but you can never get a full vacuum for a variety of reasons, the vapor permeability of the bag probably being the foremost for our purposes.

At 10" Hg, you're getting to 5 psi or so, which is about the minimum that should work - based on hearsay (that guy I mentioned before who uses a junk air compressor as a vacuum pump). You're still going to get better results than forming with clamps I think - forms for that have to be pretty massive by comparison to vacuum bagging.

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#72

Re: ribs in my structure are too wide apart

William Duffield

10 atm.??? You mean 10 psi, right? The maximum you can develop is one atmosphere inside a vacuum bag.

What is important here is that you realize that a total structural collapse is possible, and that you can control your vacuum and stop increasing it before catastrophe.The first time I saw a photo of this type of failure, I was really surprised by how much total force a vacuum can develop, and I didn't forget it. I can't give any numbers, but the structure that collapsed was already had twice the strength I figured it needed, but they needed twice as much as they had. I paid a lot of attention after that to supporting setups that worked. I also decided that bent laminations, whenever possible, were more to my liking.

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#73

Adam of Oakland

Correction: units are inches Hg

Adam of Oakland

Sorry, I should have paid attention, the meter on my vacuum pump is "in Hg" so my usage of "Atm" was totally off base.

I agree with you that my substructure is inadequate to hold up to that kind of force for 3 hours as the glue sets.

I'll either have to add reinforcing ribs to the underside, or try consolidating the layup using 10"-15" Hg.

it seems like an awful lot of pressure to be able to bend 2 layers laminated 1/4 plywood around a curve at 25"Hg. My thought was that this is more than enough and that backing down to a level where such deformations don't occur might still be strong enough.

Anyway, thanks for the input, fellas

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#74

Re: ribs in my structure are too wide apart

TomD

If you put the lams in the bag and then used secondary weight to hold them over your form you would get a lot more clamping pressure on your lams. Not only is your part being distorted, but while you are crushing your mold, the back side of the lams is not getting even pressure. Either the mold provides that, or you need to ensure the bag is on both sides of the lams.

Re: help w frame&panel curved in depth and profile

#75

Re: Correction: units are inches Hg

William Duffield

1 psi is approximately 2 inches of Mercury (inHg) or approximately 69 millibars.