Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

Posts

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#51

Re: Pencil marks

Edward S

Ok, stripped table today, wow i love my new Bosch ROS. I am wondering if it might be better to put a thin coat of shellac down, then do the #'s and lines? then a couple more coats. need some more input on this?

also, what about my Purdy bristle brush that i used before and spread all the contaminants around with, can i still use it, or should i trash it?

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#52

Re: Pencil marks

David Yoho

I am wondering if it might be better to put a thin coat of shellac down, then do the #'s and lines? then a couple more coats.

That would probably work just fine.

Also, what about my Purdy bristle brush that i used before and spread all the contaminants around with, can i still use it, or should i trash it?

I think to be on the safe side I'd go with a new brush.

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#53

Re: Pencil marks

Edward S

thanks for your help David! i have been learning alot from you guys here! sorry to say but i will probably be starting another thread in the next week or two. I bought another shuffleboard, it is a beautiful 22ft. American shuffleboard, it is all original, just needs refinishing. But the board on this one has just been resurfaced with epoxy.

I also just wanted to say i cant believe i have been using my square porter cable sander. This new Bosch RO is so nice to work with!

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#54

Re: Pencil marks

Edward S

ok, i bought a quart of oil based Zar poly. I did not cut it down with thinner, i applied straight from the can. It was real thick so i guess that was a mistake! The fish eyes look gone now, but see alot of dust and few bubbles, is this normal? I cleaned with tack cloth before i applied!

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#55

Re: Pencil marks

Edward S

i cant freakin believe it!! I have a couple little fish eyes!! I scrubbed this table with a solvent, sprayed 3 damn coats of shellac!! wtf

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#56

Dust and bubbles

David Yoho

It's normal. The bubbles should go away as the wet finish levels and dries. The dust is another matter. Once it's dry if it feels rough to your hand use the 600 wet/dry paper technique I explained earlier. Then wipe it down and apply the next coat. I would think two brushed on coats would be plenty, given there is already a base coating of the shellac.

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#57

Re: Dust and bubbles

Edward S

ok, im going to sand tomorrow to give plenty of time to dry. Do you think i should thin the poly? its pretty darn thick! Hoping maybe that will cover over the fisheye better.

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#58

Re: Dust and bubbles

Edward S

or should i sand, and apply another can of Zinsser dewax shellac??

I just cant believe i had fisheye after all that! This shuffleboard table is really pissing me off!!

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#59

Re: Dust and bubbles

Edward S

dont know too much about shellac, but now im wondering if i can spot spray on the infected area??

anyone? I have a few sprays left.

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#60

Try This

David Yoho

Yes, you can spot spray if you want. It might help and can't hurt.

I was going to suggest you thin your second coat. I would also think adding some fish eye reducer (or whatever it's called) to your poly might help too. Since you have done this before, you probably have a feel for how much to add.

All you can do is give these suggestions a try and see what happens. Now you know why finishers dread silicone contamination.

The only shuffleboard table I've been around (beach rental house last year) they used some type of fine sand or something like that to make to pieces glide down the board. I wouldn't think there was any silicone in that stuff.

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#61

Question for Ellis/Moderator?

Barry Irby

This has be a wonderful thread. A new person getting good advice form some long time contributors. One of the best things about Wood Central. Wish I had some real experience to contribute.

The Question? Is this the longest thread ever? (I need a wider monitor.)

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#62

Re: Question for Ellis/Moderator?

Edward S

sorry for this long thread Barry! But as you have read, im a noob at this stuff and learning from you guys! Anyway the powder your referring to David, yes there is silicone in that stuff. There is also a spray that is used on the board before the powder is applied.

anyway the fisheye reducer did not work before, so dont know now. think i will sand, clean, spray some shellac on infected area, and reapply some thinned poly.

will keep you updated, i am just so frustrated!

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#63

Second Coat

David Yoho

That sounds like a plan. However, on the previous attempt you were applying the poly right on top of the contaminated surface without the aid of anything to seal it. The difference this time is the shellac, which sounds like it has helped to a great degree. So, why not add a little fisheye reducer to your poly. It can't hurt but it might help.

To review - sand, wipe down, spray shellac on affected spots, apply second coat of thinned poly with the fisheye reducer.

Report back with your results. Hopefully they're good. It sounded like even though you experienced the fisheye spots, they were less and smaller than before.

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#64

Re: Question for Ellis/Moderator?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Yea, Barry, I think so too....I was looking for the end under my desk....it got soooo long.....

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#65

Re: Second Coat

Edward S

sorry for pissing guys off on this board for the long thread. but remember i am a noob and you guys are my teachers, i am very happy to have you help me!!

anyway I finally dont see anymore fisheye, after sanding, spot spraying with shellac, the contamination looks to be gone.

Now i am getting near the end of poly application. My final question in this thread is this.

How do i go about sanding the last application? Do i start with 320 and work my way up to like 500,800,1200? Do i sand in circles?

Also when im done should i get a good rubbing compound and buff?

then paste wax?

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#66

I think you misinterpreted a posting

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Some of us are in awe of this odyssey not annoyed by it. Your stamina is to be commended.

What you have just spent days working on a poor place to practice and learn smoothing and rub-out. My suggestion is to put a few coats of finish on a test piece and become proficient there.


I have limited experience with high gloss finishes. While it may not look bright in the picture this top is a mirror. The last I did was as follows:

about 360 (may have been 400) grit wet/dry paper with water lubricant. Pumice and oil on a felt pad, rotten stone and oil on a felt pad. This is a traditional procedure. Now days many use a polishing compound from the auto body shop store.

On lathe turned pens and pencils I have used the sequence 600, 1000, 1500, 2000, wax to get a bright finish.

If you luck out and find someone that does bright finishes regularly they will have a more modern and likely better procedure.

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#67

Re: Second Coat

David Yoho

Edward, I didn't read it as anyone being mad about how long the thread is/was. What I got was appreciation for how a new guy can get good advice here on this message board and NOT be made to feel stupid for asking. I also got that several regulars were curious if the thread was the longest one ever. It's very unusual for a thread to go even half as long. There's nothing wrong with anything you posted. It's all good.

I can't remember if you mentioned what you wanted the final finish to look like. I also don't remember if you said what sheen the poly was that you were using. If this board is to be used, I think I'd go one way, but if it's for "looking at" I'd go another. If it's a user, I think a clear gloss would be less desirable since it would show scratches for use. I think either a satin or semi-gloss would be better.

As for final sanding, I stand by what I already mentioned and has always worked for me - very light hand sanding with a piece of 600 wet/dry (any direction is fine) and follow it with a coat of paste wax and buff. This goes for any sheen. It's simple, effective, and costs less than using all the higher grit papers and polishes you asked about. These materials and techniques are usually employed by pro shops and can be useful in giving wood finishes the "shine", much like the look of today's automotive finishes. However, I think there's a time for it and I think you would be better served to experiment with it after you have a few more finishing miles under your belt. There's so much more to finishing and getting a great finish than applying coats of polyurethane. A better understanding of finish chemistry and experience working with other finishes will pave the way for you to better understand all I have just said. Nothing wrong with polyurethane - I started there and probably most others too. You'll learn that there are so much better finish choices awaiting you to explore. Be prepared - the building or refinishing is one thing but the finishing is where it's at and a totally new skill to master.

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#68

Depends on what you mean by buffing

Dick Coers

First off, there is a big difference between dry and cured. Finishes can feel dry in 24 hours, but aren't cured hard for a week. Maybe more. Hand buffing can be done in a couple of days, power buffing MUST be done after it is cured. Poly takes a long time to cure, I would wait at least two weeks before power buffing, and then take it easy. Just saying rubbing compound is generalizing a huge number of products. Generally speaking, rubbing compound is a course product that you can actually feel the grit and has limited use. I've never used it on wood. Polishing compound is a more accurate term. Go to an local automotive paint store and talk to someone there. 20 years ago, I used 3M Finesse-It and a wool pad. Now they have foam pads and even better products. Any final sanding depends on what the finish looks and feel like before you start. If you have brush marks, orange peel, dust specks, then start with 320 or 400. I prefer mineral spirits to water for wet sanding. Generally a rigid sanding block is recommended, but if you didn't block sand before the finish, don't use one on the finish. Don't change the grit until you have an equal sheen over the entire piece. A shiny spot is still low. Then move up till it is starting to shine, then start with the polishing compounds. You might consider using Abralon after the initial flat sanding. They have a range of cushioned abrasive pads, that when used with mineral spirits and a power sander, can give you a really nice finish. Maybe good enough that you don't need the compounds. Just don't get in hurry. If the finish balls up a little on the paper as you sand, stop, it's not cured!

The length of the post emphasizes that learning to finish is a complicated process. It takes years to learn, but much shorter if you can find a mentor. 10 mentors on a forum adds even more complexity!

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#69

Re: Second Coat

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't know of a better finish for this application than urethane varnish. It's both hard and tough.......if you get the right kind of it. The urethane name tells how the polymer is hooked together but nothing about the properties of what is being hooked together and how the result will wear.

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#70

Amen.....but

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

one can learn on a practice piece and this student seems to be highly motivated.

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#71

Re: Question for Ellis/Moderator?

Edward S

well, the poly is clear gloss, and hoping this is my final coat, might need another though, there were a couple low spots from previous stripping.

Also David, you stated nothing wrong with poly, arent i using the correct finish for this shuffleboard to be used? I was under impression that lacquer was not used anymore because it cracks easily.

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#72

To Bill's and your point...

David Yoho

Yes, I agree with the choice of polyurethane in this instance. Don't get me wrong, there are jobs that are perfect for polyurethane and it's a good finish. What I meant in my earlier reply was more about not thinking of it as the only choice -- just like having only one hammer and using it on every nail you come across.

The other thing I was trying to say was if you were going to go through all the additional effort and expense of finer grit abrasives and compounds to get to a "piano" finish, it would be better saved for a nicer finish than poly. If you are using clear gloss for all the coats, you should end up with a nice enough high gloss look from the finish alone.

If you are bound to enhance the look of the clear gloss anyway, then do as Dick said and give the finish plenty of time to cure first. The other issue that could affect the outcome besides cure might be amount of finish built so it doesn't get "sanded" through.

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#73

Re: Amen.....but

Edward S

ok, board is looking good, this may be my last coat of poly! i had several low spots, so this last time i sanded with my orbital sander and 220 grit, after cleaning and applying last coat of poly, it looks pretty good. So i guess i will sand again with 320, then 500, and 1500, i have these in stock.

how do i use the paste wax? just like waxing a car, let haze then wipe off?

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#74

Wax on - wax off

David Yoho

Actually, you don't HAVE to wax it. It should have a glossy shine by itself. However, if it's wax you want, then apply it, let it haze, and rub it off with a soft cloth. The reason you might want to avoid the wax is it will show finger prints and smears from touching. Remember - the wax doesn't dry.

Re: refinishing vintage Shuffleboard table

#75

Re: Wax on - wax off

Edward S

David, i do know a paste wax is used on shuffleboards i guess to help pucks glide? there is a polish, a glaze, then silicone spray, then the powder which has silicone in it.

anyway, i was told carnauba wax is the good stuff, others have stated to use johnson's paste wax.