Re: what?
Grant in Iowa
Edward,
I'll let Bill guide your finishing process, as he knows his stuff. I do want to address the sanding method though.
On a shuffleboard, you need as flat a surface as you can achieve. Random orbital flat is not flat enough for serious play. If this is how you sanded it, you may need to start over. To that end, I'd consider making a large "sanding block" of something very flat , such as a piece of 3/4" MDF (Medium Density Fiberboard). Cut a piece of MDF as wide as your sandpaper sheets, and maybe twice as long. Alternatively, you can buy 12"x12" pieces of stone tile (not ceramic, as they aren't flat) at a home center. Then glue your sandpaper to the surface using 3m spray adhesive such as 3m 77 spray or rubber cement so the paper can be replaced without destroying your sanding block. Wrap the leading and trailing edge up around the edges of the sanding block to help keep it in place. You might find it will go easier with cheap hardware store handles affixed to the back of the MDF platen. If you try this, you will almost immediately find that what you thought was flat is NOT. Far better to discover this now than after you have invited friends over for a game.
So you will then need to do a good bit of sanding to get the surface flat. Buy the big pack of sandpaper, and in several grits from about 80 through 220 or so. Don't skip a grit, as that just wastes time and finish quality. One additional note is that a good shuffleboard has adjusters on the underside of the board. These serve to help control the crown on the board, which is the left to right flatness as one looks at the board from one end. I would release any pressure on these prior to flattening the board. Once you get it flat, acclimated to the space in which it will live, then re-tension these to achieve the final left/ right flatness desired.
Once you get it flat, and go back to applying a finish, let the finish sluff over the edges slightly, as this can easily be fixed after the final coat by using a sanding block along the edge. Waiting until after the final coat will help keep the edge square. Otherwise it will tend to develop a rounded lower area along each edge. Your finish will also need flattened, depending on how much you apply. Some boards have up to 1/4" of finish applied to them. As Bill said, use fine paper such as 280 or 320 grit for flattening the finish. Maybe do something like 500 grit after the final coat and then apply a paste wax before you sprinkle on the dance wax for play.
Good luck on your project.
Grant in Iowa