Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Looking for a finishing protocol

Posts

Looking for a finishing protocol

#1

Alan Young

Looking for a finishing protocol

Alan Young

I am working with a client on a Farmhouse Table design. We are trying to finalize the finished look. The top will be made from Hickory and get a poly finish, the base will be Poplar painted white.


The goal for the base- legs and apron- is a look that leans more towards the rustic-ie not a gloss white. The desire is that if the table gets nicked and bumped-that "damage" won't stick out like a sore thumb rather blend in with the general look and feel. We want something between a thorough distressed look and a gloss white....any suggestions on a finish protocol for this base?

Thanks

-Alan

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#2

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

john Veerkamp

I like the look of milk paint under satin poly for the look you're describing. You could also do a base coat of cream or tan and then after the coat of white, scuff it on the edges & wear points for and old look. Then protect with the satin poly.

Onr approach.

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#3

Ditto On The Milk Paint

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I'd not get too involved with the "wear point" distressing although you might consider several corner "dings" on the lower part of the legs.

I'd also suggest some mild cream-on-white glazing before you apply a top coat. You'll give a slight pop to the profiles plus imply age and wear that way.

For a top coat, since I dislike flattened finish coats, I suggest a gloss waterborne poly like General's Enduro Clear Poly, then kill the gloss to semi or satin with synthetic wool. I believe the waterbornes will stay more flexible over time than will oil-based poly, so they won't be as likely to chip from a real ding.

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#4

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

larry in nw ohio

Alan If you want the disstressed look, just give me the time and place and I`ll bring my 81/4 grandchildren, I almost forgot going to have another grandchild, over and they`ll distress it for you no charge. :D Larry

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#5

Re: Ditto On The Milk Paint

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

+1 on the general water based finishes.

I have been using their HP poly for a few years now and I really like how it performs. It takes about month to develop its full hardness, like almost all finishes, but once it is cured it is very abrasion resistant and as you would expect it holds up very well to liquids. I use the gloss formula and then knock it down with steel wool and hit it with a coat of wax and it looks just like buffed out lacquer.

An odd schedule I have been using a lot is to apply a coat of an oil based finish and before it has a chance to dry I brush on a coat of Generals water based HP poly. It sounds really crazy but it works exceptionally well, but you will have to try it with your particular brands of finish to test for compatibility. I stumbled on this schedule when I did a bunch of samples and for samples I didn't care if the finish was prone to de-lamination I was just after how they would look. As the project came close to finish time I got jammed up time wise so before I called the client to postpone delivery so I could allow the oil finish to core before applying the water based top coat I checked the sample to see how well it had adhered when applied wet on wet. Low and behold when I tried to de-laminate the water based finish it would actually pull the oil finish and some wood fibers up.

The advantage of this schedule is that the oil pops the grain and it also seals the wood. By following with several coats of the general HP poly I can build the finish quickly and have something that is very tough, wears well and is easy to repair but with the oil underneath it looks great and I didn't have to hassle with raised grain from the water based finish. I’ve used this schedule on tables, chairs and drawers and have not received a call back in the 3 or 4 years I have been using it.

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#6

Grain Pop

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hi Robin,

You can get the same grain-pop and adhesion with a coat of dewaxed shellac rather than oil. What ever works for you. :)

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#7

Alan Young

Ok- Looks like Milk Paint is the avenue

Alan Young

What about prep and Priming? Does Milk paint require a primer?

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#8

Re: Ok- Looks like Milk Paint is the avenue

Nat Robison

Not sure on the primer but one of the big woodworking magazines had an article in the last few years on milk paint.....maybe you can find it in print or online. I believe you have to do several coats and it doesn't look great about 3 coats on it. This Old House put in a kitchen island in one of the recent projects that was milk painted on the bottom (green, I believe) and coated with poly after that.

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#9

FWW Milk Paint article *LINK*

mdclor

Alan,

If you are a member of FWW, you will be able to use the link below. Otherwise, the article was in issue #199, July/August 2008.

HTH,

Merle


FWW Milk Paint article

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#10

Alan....a question about the base.....

roger lance

sorry that I do not have a finishing suggestion for you, but I wanted to ask you about the base design for that table....I plan to make a dining room table about 42"x72" to seat 6 people and I want to use that same table leg design you are using in terms of the legs being attached only to the aprons and no other structure.....this gives all people at the table no interference with their feet, knees, etc.....but is this type of leg structure solid and reliable over time???.....or prone to problems???.....what do I need to be aware of in making a base like this???.....thanks for your insight.

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#11

It is typical table construction

Bill Tindall

The best education in furniture design is to be found in antique shops. By in large designs that hold up will make it to the antique shop after a hundred years or so. Legs and an apron is the only design I ever see in a dining table. You may want to consider making it an extension table to be more versatile.

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#12

Not Alan but.....

David Yoho

You will see any number of methods of joining the legs to the aprons if you look at enough tables. By far the strongest joint is still the mortise and tenon for this application. Add pegs on the inside and the tenons will never work loose.

Albeit small, the base I'm currently building for a cherry jewelry armoire employs M&T and should hold far after I'm gone.


Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#13

A difference of opinion on pinning

Bill Tindall

I believe pinning was invented when clamps were less available, ie. 1720. Pinning was used to pull the joint together in the absence of "bar" clamps, something I rarely see in inventory descriptions of Period shops.

The pin provides no significant strength to the glued joint. I haven't done the calculation but I would not be surprised to find the shear strength of the glue is greater than the pin wood. The pin holds a failed joint together, for better or worse, and there is a better and worse to be considered.

There is no reason that the glue in a well prepared M&T on a table will ever fail. The mechanical stress in the joint is borne by the wood. The glue simply holds the M&T in place, a function the pins redundantly provide.

Nothing wrong with pins, but the effort would be better spent on more precise M&T.

Nice legs, BTW. I wish I was more talented at creating sculptured legs.

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#14

Additionally.....

Bill Tindall

If the legs are more dainty then I add corner bracing to absorb some of the racking force on the leg. There may not be sufficient wood in a dainty leg to rely solely on the remaining wood strength after the mortise is cut.

Re: Looking for a finishing protocol

#15

Leo Cuellar

Re: A difference of opinion on pinning

Leo Cuellar

In a properly fitted pinned joint the glue is a superfluity.