Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Does time exist? (OT)

Posts

Does time exist? (OT)

#1

Moses Yoder

Does time exist? (OT)

Moses Yoder

I am having an argument with a friend about time. I say time does not exist. He says it does because scientists say so. What do you think? If time existed, time travel would be possible; since it doesn't, time travel is not possible. I guess the topic is not religious or political.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#2

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My impression from a little reading of popular treatments of physics is that you're raising a set of questions that has the physicists themselves arguing.

I think your logic depends on the assumption that time is a dimension, like physical dimensions, which permit movement in any direction within the dimension. If it exists but is not a dimension, then there's no particular reason why time travel should exist.

Pins or tails first? And what's first, in the context of your argument? :)

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#3

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Chuck in Mtl.

Time does exist because we can quantify it but it is a lot like gravity in that it can vary depending on the circumstances. On earth if a man weighs 200 lbs he will weigh 6 times less on the moon so the force of gravity varies....Einstein said that gravity affects time...an airplane circling at a high altitude with a precision clock will register several seconds less than a similar clock running on earth. So time is a quantity...a 4th dimension after the usual 3 dimensions.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#4

How Do You Tell

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

if it's "Time" rather than just your measuring device (the clock) that is effected by gravity? Since gravity, as a physical force, effects any matter in some ratio to its center, whether it's a mechanical clock or one based on, say, atomic decay, the same physical force will apply to its cause and effect.

Do we measure time or merely create devices to measure intervals of a convenient construct we call time?

Is, for instance, the slowing of the airplane (or spacecraft) clock actually a measurement of the force of gravity?

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#5

You been chewyin any wild wood weeds?


Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#6

Better Question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Did he bring enough for everybody?

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#7

No. Time does not exist

RobCarr

Time is simply our perception of a universe that flows from order to chaos... there's a good book on the subject, written relevantly recently, can't think of the title, but if I do I'll post it.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#8

Moses Yoder

Re: No. Time does not exist

Moses Yoder

If you could find that book title, I would greatly appreciate it. I am of the same persuasion as you concerning time, and have been arguing it for years to my wife's chagrin. She loves movies like "The Prince of Persia" where the main character finds a dagger that turns time back 2 or 3 minutes. Imagine the consequences. I challenge anyone to go back in time 1 second and prove it.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#9

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Clementine

Not intending to make a religious thing out of this, but I find this statement intriguing:

"For all substance that is not God is creature; and all that is not creature is God."

Augustine, On the Trinity 1.6.

I'd say time is a created thing, so it exists.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#10

Re: No. Time does not exist

Chuck in Mtl.

yet is does exist and is a quantifiable entity....like a persons weight or air pressure. You simply need to readjust your thinking to imagine the fourth dimension....what is known as time.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#11

Re: No. Time does not exist

Barry Irby

The Book is A Brief History of Time by Stephan Hawking available on Amazon for less than $13. I have not read it nor have any idea what it is actually about.

I can travel through time, but in only one direction, Forward, one day at a time.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#12

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Craig Daymon

I think your question is weak. You're not presenting anything. In what way are you stating that time does not exist? Certainly time, like weight, length, volume and many other things, are human constraints to explain things. You could just as easily say that weight does not exist. (Probably some folks struggling with diets would be happy to believe this.)

I remember proposing to some friends of mine the idea that all "moments" exist together and it is a survival defense mechanism of ours that we can only perceive these "moments" in a linear fashion, time. Otherwise, it might prove difficult for us to make it through our day. (Sorry, day another time reference.) This was proposed more to think about how it might be possible for some people might be able to perceive the future. For example, from what I've read, the mind frequently suffers misfires that would generate hallucinations. Chemicals in the brain prevent this. LSD shuts down the production of these chemicals and allows those misfires to be perceived. Perhaps there is a drug that would unlock our ability to see the future (and the past), though tailoring it to focus on what we are interested in might prove much more challenging. Just a thought exercise.

Now, with respect to time travel. Certainly if you dismiss time, really just a coordinate that allows us to catalog an event, we must first discuss what would be time travel in your newly defined perception of the universe. Keep in mind that the universe is expanding and we are spinning, around on our axis, around the sun and, in our solar system, around our galaxy (maybe more specifically, the black hole at its center). So basically, time travel as we typically think about it involves a substantial calculation to pinpoint "where" we want to arrive and not just "when". Even if we believe that everything is at this moment, it does not that mean that we cannot find a way to displace ourselves to the required location and interact with that moment, thereby creating the equivalent of time travel in an existence where no "time" exists.

So that's my ramble on the subject, but in order to give a real answer to your question we need more information on your new, time-free, perception of the universe to know within what context you see time as an unnecessary parameter. (Though, it has certainly proved relevant in many equations, even if it has been proven not to be constant, along - or inversely - with length.)

-Craig

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#13

Re: No. Time does not exist

Craig Daymon

I have the one with pictures, "The Illustrated A Brief History Of Time".

I'm not sure if my copy includes the corrections as some of Hawking's original ideas were disproved, possibly by Hawking, I don't remember. Though, I think those are things toward the end of the book and I can't say that I've finished it. (Nor have I attempted to prove/disprove everything - anything - in the book.)

-Craig

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#14

Ask me later!


Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#15

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

mdclor

If time does not exist, how do you explain running out of it when making Christmas presents? :)

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#16

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Jesse Cloud

I think the OT postings get a lot more interesting on these long cold winter nights...

I read somewhere that time is the one thing everybody has the same amount of, and no one can buy more.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#17

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Asking if time exists is like asking if a mile or inch exists. Time as we know it is just another measurement used by man to quantify something. Time is the measurement of an observation that events occur with X between them - just as a mile is an observation of the spacing between objects we perceive. We really know very little about anything including gravity - time - space - electricity. All we really have are "postulates" that have been observed, then observed by someone else and then we agree that we accept that as real. For instance if the earth happened to wander into another galaxy or universe with different "rules" gravity could be 1/2 or reversed to what we know. Electricity might flow in what we now call insulators. Time might "pass" (the space between events) much faster or slower than we currently accept as "normal". We humans don't really know what causes gravity, electricity, or obviously time. I really think we are as far from understanding the real basis of things as an ant is from understanding Physics (as little as we know of it). When I was a lad I was taught space was a Vacuum empty of any object/matter. Now in order to justify some of the Astrological measurements - "Black matter" - objects/item we can't measure or perceive except as it acts on objects we do see - is believed to be most of the matter in the universe. That really makes us look kind of silly - that we can't even tell the most abundant material in the Universe is something we can even tell is there!

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#18

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

A simple example of time existence is the GPS guidance system.

Not far from the US master clock in Bolder Colorado there is a USAF station whose only purpose is to keep the clocks on board the GPS satellites synchronized. Several times a day this station sends clock corrections to the satellites. Due to the velocity of the satellites the clocks on the satellites will slow down down due to Mr. Einstein and the theory of relativity. IF the clocks slow down, all the navigation systems will be wrong. Do you want your plane to land in Lake Michigan instead of O'Hara .

This is not some absurd argument like how many angles can dance on the hear of a pin. If they were baptists, they wouldn't be dancing anyway. We are talking demonstrated science.

Are we all running out of things to do?

Ken

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#19

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Paul Leuba

Very interesting discussion.

The scientific method bases our understanding of the world around us on what we observe.

I believe the question is not so much "does time exixt?", but rather "is time a fundamental property?"

Time certainly exsts, even if it is as described above, our method for measuring the an interval between the occurence of events. But, is time a fundamental property of the universe like the strong nuclear force, the weak nuclear force, or electromagnetism? My sense is that it is not fundamental, and I feel that way for a couple of reasons. First time has the properties of a fixed vector, e.g. a quantity that moves in only one direction. No one has observed time moving in any direction other than into the future. Second, this same vector property seems to indicate that time is not really a dimension in the way that we understand dimensions. Dimensions of space take on vector properties in infinite directions.

It seems tha time is a measuring capability that we have developed to record differences in the state of systems we observe.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#20

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

frank ashmore

Yes its already tomorrow in Australia.That solves the time travel question also

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#21

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Larry in NW ohio

Time has to exist, how else would we be able to tell when our wives are late getting back from shopping. But we love them no matter. Larry

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#22

Don't Know but...

Don Orr

...I sure could use more of it in a "day". Anybody have any to spare?

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#23

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

JMOHNIKE

According to H.G. Well and Rod Serling time travel is possible, so it must exist. However when I am in my shop, time does not exist and I am divorced from reality and the rest of the world.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#24

Lee Grindinger

The argument...

Lee Grindinger

The argument goes like this, time is how we describe cyclical change. If change stops time stops. So, the concept of time as an absolute is erroneous but the concept of change is not, unless all movement stops. Because change takes place at different speeds in different environments it means that time is not static, but relative. The fact that there is change implies that time does does exist, but as a part of our fabric dependent on the world in which it's encumbered.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#25

Depends on your definition

Alex Grigoriev

What's your definition of time that makes time non-existing?

Does distance exist? Does light exist? If we define one second of time as interval between two moments while the light travels 300000 km, then we can measure time. Does it exist now as a physical concept? We can also measure time based on fundamental frequencies of waves generated by certain atoms, like cesium. This is an atomic clock. If the atomic clock is put on a satellite, it will be off because of effects of general and special relativity. A GPS you may be using these days has to adjust itself because of that. Time doesn't move with the same pace for different observers. See "twins paradox", for example.

What else doesn't exist? particle-wave dualism? Quantum mechanics? Einstein didn't believe to quantum theory ("God doesn't play dice"), even though his work on photoemission laid very importans basis to it. But to understand semiconductors, magnetoresistive effects (used in your hard drive's read heads), and superconductivity you need to use quantum theory.