Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Does time exist? (OT)

Posts

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#26

Why do you think time travel would be possible?

John in NM

It does not follow, in my view, that the possibility of time travel is a consequence of the existence of time.

Our various conceptualizations of time may be flawed, but that does not rule out its existence outside of our own self awareness.

The whole subject reminds me of some hippie kid asking Richard Feynman about the possibility of an anti-gravity device, and was a bit non-plussed when Feynman explained how the average chair fit the bill.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#27

Leo Cuellar

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Leo Cuellar

Well, a different paradigm. I've heard people say that time is money. No money = no time. Would that make a credit card into a time machine? Do bill collectors then become time cops, saving us all from chaos? :D

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#28

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Philip Duffy

The real question is; Does Moses exist? Pictures don't prove anything, just that a picture exists in the ether world and is transferred to a monitor and thence to paper. I know this because I am, or be, or something. Philip

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#30

The problem with the argument...

John in NM

There are contexts in which time is not relative - nuclear decay for example, or for all practical purposes when referencing the speed of light.

The trouble is that these sorts of discussions never seem to clearly distinguish between some highly abstract and theorectical constructions and practical reality, and never seem to stand up to logical analysis.

The whole thing reminds me of alchemy, long on desire and short on understanding.

It has made for some entertaining movies however.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#31

Moses Yoder

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Moses Yoder

Certainly clocks exist, I am not arguing that. They mark out a 24 hour day, which is aproximately the amount of time it takes the earth to rotate once. A year is the time it takes the earth to rotate the sun once. So at some point will come the moment in time we have all decided is December 25, 2011. Having that sort of system is handy to put everyone on the same page. But it is not based on anything concrete.

Weight is based on gravity. Gravity is invisible, and yet has been proven in numerous ways to exist. We have found ways to defy gravity, which include zero gravity machines. We have also found ways to make ourselves weigh less, including liposuction. If there was a concrete item we could point to as time we would have already learned how to travel though it. However, there is no such thing as time, therefore time travel is impossible.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#32

Moses Yoder

Re: Why do you think time travel would be possible

Moses Yoder

I would be very interested in a demonstration of time travel using the average chair as the mechanism.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#33

Moses Yoder

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Moses Yoder

Actually that is a good question. The therory that "I think, therefore I am" is flawed. You might be nothing more than a script in a computer program which is making you think you are thinking. I have faith that I exist, but I will never know for sure.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#34

Lee Grindinger

Actually, you're making the argument for me

Lee Grindinger

The fact that time is steady relative to a particular set of events, nuclear decay to use your example, is exactly my point. Nuclear decay is change at a steady pace, measurable and consistent. If all change stops time stops. If nothing moves at any level time does not exist. Time only exists because things change. Change slows as one nears the speed of light therefore time is relative to change. Time is only absolute relative to a very particular set of circumstances.

Now, in the pursuit of the 'god particle' physicists are postulating as many as 11 dimensions, 4 of which we know if you accept time as a dimension. One powerful reason to research this theory is that it would explain the presence of and existence of matter and the ever changing amount of matter/energy in our 4 dimensional universe, imagine a black hole or wormhole as a path to another dimension through which matter/energy flows.

String theory, will you take the blue pill or will you take the red pill? :)

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#35

Welcome to non-sequitur theater

John in NM

That would indeed be an interesting demonstration. I won't be holding my breath til it comes about though :D

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#36

I had no intention of doing so...

John in NM

I'm afraid I don't really find your two posts consistent with one another, but such is the nature of this sort of discussion.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#37

Zero gravity machines?

John in NM

I'd actually considered using gravity and our in-ability to negate it as an analogy for how time could exist without our being able to travel through it at will.

Please note I'm making a distinction between negating the force of gravity and sucessfully resisting it (ie- the chair). Various free fall systems do not negate gravity either, neither do manipulations of electro-magnetic fields or anything else that produces thrust - they all merely use one force to resist another.

At the moment, I believe anti-gravity is still the stuff of fantasy and fiction, just like time travel.

I'm finding it increasingly difficult to take any of this discussion seriously :D

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#38

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Joe W

I think time travel is possible. It's just one way. :)

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#39

Spinoza said :

Yonak

If you threw a stone into the air, and it achieved consciousness, it would believe it was flying of it's own free will.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#40

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you can measure change - and it's possible to do so - doesn't change imply movement through something we call time?

Our decision to use seconds/minutes/hours is a matter of laying a digital template on a flow; but we do that in lots of areas, like measuring gallons per minute of stream flow.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#41

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

Tom MacGregor

Time is relative. The more relatives that show up for Christmas the slower time goes by.

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#42

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

eliot d

I like the one where the guy asks the rabbi,"Do I exist?" and the rabbi answers, "Who's asking?"

Re: Does time exist? (OT)

#43

Re: Welcome to non-sequitur theater

Mike L

You can add ad hominem ("hippy kid") to the theater's playbill.