Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

Posts

Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#1

Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

Barry Irby

I posted questions about the Highland Wood Turner's blade over on the Turning forum, now for the ones about the Wood Slicer.

A few weeks ago I bought two of each, Wood Slicer and "bowl Blank". Put the Wood slicer on the bandsaw (14" Delta with riser) and gave it a spin. Saw some twelve inch wide spalted maple. (about ten linear feet) And some Ash that was eight inches wide. Maybe 20 LF. Probably a total of well under a hundred LF total on the Blade. Removed it and Installed the Bowl Blank blade. Used that for two or three days and tried to reinstall the Wood Slicer. Somehow there was so much drift I could not get my Kreg fence to skew far enough to work. Struggled with it for about half an hour, gave up and put the spare one on. It worked fine and it was obvious the first one had been dulled. Sawed less than fifty LF of cherry and Osage and it started to wander and ruined a couple of pieces. These were clean quarter sawn boards.

These blades were approaching thirty dollars. I find less than a hundred LF to be a poor return on that investment. Am I out of line?

Ahh! the bandsaw, the tool I love to hate.

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#2

Ellis Walentine

I would like to hear Highland's response

Ellis Walentine

When a blade drifts excessively, it means that one side of the blade has been dulled and/or the set reduced on that side. What are the chances that you hit a rock or something hard in your bowl blank or one of your resaw boards that could have damaged the teeth on that side of the blade? Osage orange itself is pretty hard on tools. Maybe that had something to do with it.

Why not ask the technical staff at Highland to explain or to at least tell you what kind of longevity to expect from their blades. The Wood Slicer blade consistently gets high marks from our members and visitors, so I guess the kind of wear you describe isn't a common problem. From my limited experience with that blade, it is a thin band with a small set to the teeth, so a relatively small unbalancing of that set could cause the blade to drift. Less set also limits the width of the kerf and hence the turning radius of the blade, so you could conceivably put damaging pressure on one side of the blade if you try to saw a tighter radius than you should, especially in abrasive or very dense stock such as osage orange.

Just guessing here. I'd check with Highland and see if they have any cutting guidelines you're supposed to follow with this blade.

Ellis

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#3

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again? *LINK*

del schisler

I used to use the wood slicer blade for yrs. Now i use a blade from this company and it will out cut the wood slicer. The difference is on this blade from suppersaw cut is it has deepper gullet's and may be bigger teeth i didn't get that close or measure but you can see depper gullet's tho. I set blade drift and it stay's put. You may try one and see ?? They are around the same price. You have to call the company they don't put a price on the web page .Tell what wood's you will be sawing . here is the web page I belive you posted a page a while back and i think i posted this web page ?? i don't work for this co but the product is very good.


http://www.supercutbandsaw.com/

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#4

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

Keith Newton

How powerful is your motor? If you are underpowered, cutting too slow, this is really hard on blades that can't take a chip of large enough size to take the heat out with it.

Wet chip buildup on the tires can affect drift.

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#5

Check the tires?

John in NM

I've had excessive pitch buildup (local pine, awful stuff!) cause drift, similar to the wet chips that Keith mentions. Other than that I'd look at the blade for uneven wear as Ellis suggests. Blade ought to last longer than that and wear evenly when it does dull noticeably.

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#6

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

Larry in nw ohio

Again Barry I told Del about the other Co. and I do not put down the woodslicer blade, it a great blade, but I think this other blade would be better. One thing I`ve noticed is that it gives a rougher cut. If you look at them and for what you are cutting I would suggest the "Woodsaver Carbide Resaw" and believe it or not it cost just a couple dollars more than the woodslicer. But if I were you I would call Highland and tell them just what you did and they may send you a new blade. Good Luck Barry. Larry

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#7

Well, I felt bad about....

Barry Irby

bad mouthing the Wood Slicer Blade. I know it gets high marks here and I really am a fan of Highland Hardware and I have sent them an E-Mail.

Perhaps my expectations are too high. I, probably unfairly< compair the bandsaw to my other stainonary tools. My TS is a forty year old Rockwell/Delta contrators saw. I have done some upgrades such as machined pulleys and link belt and the Beis fence and a WWII blade. It does exaclty what I expect. It rips well enough that in many cases I can glue up with out jointing if I choose. It maintains its settings and accuracy. I can shage the blade in aobut two minutes.

I ahve a Delta 14" American made bandsaw. Added a riser block, An Itturra Spring, A carter bades tension release, Carter Roller Guides (anothter sore point) and dust collection. I got the Duginski book and tuned it within a hair of its life. I want it to resaw a board at about an 1/8" and sand it to a 1/10". Consistently. Bought the "best" blade. The balde seems to last minutes and saws feet of lumber befre it goes south. I expected hours and yards. Expected the blade to cost me pennies per linear foot sawed and I am close to a buck a foot.

The only "abuse" the balde got whlie on the saw is that we my son sawed a piece of heart pine about two feet long and two inches thick. The wonderful thing about roller guides is the lower ones take that gummy saw dust adn pressing ringt onto the blade. Who knew a bandsaw blade could get so coated in a minute? So, We took the woodslicer off and cleaned it with CMT blade cleaner. Cleaned the wheels and the guides and put the Bowl Blank blade on for some rough cutting. That's wehn I discovered its really a half inch blade.

I am not happy with any of this. The Carter roller guides are a dissapointemnt. I thoguht they woudl be easy to adjust. Not So. I thoguht you would loosen a locking screw and turn an adjustment knob and tighten the locking screw. Nope. Loosen the locking screw with one of sevral allen wrenschs and they slide. You fiddle them to wharere you want them and try to keep them still while you tighted the locking screw. Never get it right on the first second or third try. Fiddle with the upper guides and you have to reset the lower guides. The absence of a reliable and accurate scew for a latteral movement worsenes the design. And I see now that the lower rollers inhently roll the sawdust onto the blade. Thinking aobut going back to Cool blocks on the lower set.

Takes thirty or forty minutes to change the blade. Makes the experinece so painful that you tend to use whatever blade is on the machine for the job at hand, so I can't leave the "good" blade on there. I don't mind so much tradhing a ten dollar blade but its more painful to trash a $30 one.

If my expectations are out of line I will not ask Highland Hardware for a replacement. So what are your expectiaons? If you were resawing Walnut(?) 8" wide, how much would you expect to cu befroe repalcing the blade?

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#8

Re: Well, I felt bad about....

Keith Newton

Did I miss where you mentioned motor HP?

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#9

Re: Well, I felt bad about....

Howard Acheson

A few years ago Fine Woodworking did a review and test of band saw guide mechanisms for 14" band saws. Carter or other large diameter guides were their third place choice. The Bandrollers were judged OK when primarily used for resawing. FWW overall choice was the inexpensive Cool Blocks. They provided the most support for the blade and were the easiest to adjust. Also, they did not damage the blade if the blade mis-tracked nor were the guides themselves seriously damaged.

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#10

Re: Well, I felt bad about....

Howard Norman

I have an American made 14" Delta bandsaw with Cool Blocks. I have never had any complaint with that setup. I don't recall when I installed Cool Blocks, maybe ten to fifteen years ago.

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#11

Re: Well, I felt bad about....

Larry in nw ohio

A lot of years ago I bought some Cool blocks, that is what they were called, that are ceramic, and I think they did the best so far for guides on my 12" American made Craftsman. Larry

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#12

My Cool Blocks Are

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Made from white oak. I've been using them for 20 years or more. As they wear, you sand them square again, and re-insert. They are very effective, and you can't beat the cost.

George

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#13

Band got behind roller guide's ???

del schisler

you said you have the roller guides. By chance did the band get behing the rollor and flatten the teeth ?? Just a thought i bet that is what happen. If the band is wondering on the wheels It should only take around maybe ten min to change and set up botton guides and top guides for a different band??

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#14

That is the reason .....

Bill Tindall

I get my blades at the saw shop for $10 a piece. It wasn't me that recommended spending $30 on a blade.

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#15

Re: My Cool Blocks Are

Joseph Mulherin

I used to buy the cool blocks from Shopsmith, but in the last 2yrs I have used some hardwood and cut them to fit the blocks housings. Also make them longer so I can just sand the facesw smooth again and reset into the Bandsaw blocks.... and they are very cheap to make and have always...if they get too short just make some newer ones...no costs.

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#16

Re: Well, I felt bad about....

Barry Irby

The motor is 1 hp. I have spent more than the BS cost up grading it, but I have considered a 2 hp motor. But then I would have to upgrade the switch.

The blade starts to wander before we bog down the saw. How would a bigger motor help?

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#17

Re: That is the reason .....

Barry Irby

You are right Bill. I read an article in FWW that recommended "cheap" blades and I used them for years. Ordered the exact ones in the article. I may have learned that was the way to go. As usual I may be over thinking this.

I had band rollers from Iturra. They had tiny little ball bearings in them that would fit through the standard guide on the saw. They wore out pretty quickly Those tiny bearings are only good for so many rev's. I also had Cool blocks. Then decided to try the ball bearing rollers. I like the back bearing on them. The blade is tangential to the blade and it rolls like a car tire. On the original set up the blade ran against the side of the bearing. Cutting wet wood for turning blanks lead to the bottom bearing seizing and the blade wore a groove into it. Wonder if I can get better bearings?

I am thinking of going back to the cool blocks if I can find replacement bearings for the thrust bearings.

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#18

Re: Well, I felt bad about....

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Sorry to hear about your woes. I have been using woodslicer blades for a couple of years now and tend to leave one on the saw all the time unless I am going to be cutting alot or bark or something that has a good chance of hitting metal. I often get 3 months or more out of a blade. Since I mill my own wood and I mill everything at +2" thich I end up resawing a lot or my wood, I should add that I rarely resaw boards wider than 8". None the less I use my bandsaw more than any other tool in my shop.

My old band saw had roller guides that I fabricated. Mine were a bit easier to adjust but no mater how I adjusted them I always had problems when cutting wet wood. Pretty much exactly what you described with the bearings pressing the wood onto the blade.

My current bandsaw is an 18" Craftsman badged Parks and it has phenolic blade guides which have been just fine and do not gum up the blade as badly when cutting green wood, but the blade still gets gunked up.

A few years ago the was talk over on the OWWM forum about blade guides and someone used an optical thermometer to measure the differences in different types of blade guides on the the same saw. The results surprised many becase there really was very ittle difference across the board. Solid metal blocks are just as good as cool blocks or roller guides. At one shop I worked at one of the lower guides on a saw cracked in a way that it could no longer be used. a new one was ordered but was on back order so we cut a block of wood to fit and it workd just fine. The set screw made an indentation that would have caused problems if we had ever needed to re adjust it for wear but short term it was every bit as acurate.

If you cut a lot of wet wood one mod you can do to your saw which can help a lot is to mount a brass brush below the lower guides to clean the blade before it touches the lower wheel. I worked on one saw that had a brush mounted that you loosened with a wing nut so you could adjut the guides and then swing the brush in to the back of the blade so it cleaned both sides without touching the teeth. I always liked that set up.

One of the more abusive things to do with a bandsaw is to resaw wet wood. the saw dust needs to be cleared or the heat will cause the lignin soften and make it stick to the blade. The wood slicer is not the apropriate blade to use for resawing wet wood. I rarely resaw wet wood any more, but when I did I used to get get a bi metal 1/2" three tooth/inch blade with a deep gullet and 2x the normal amount of set. The extra set gave more room to clear the swarf without over heating the blade.

Robin

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#19

Re: That is the reason ..... *LINK*

John in NM

There should be a number on the bearing, the ones on mine are standard and readily available. I bought some extra's from vxb.com... I think my thrust bearings are 6202's or something similar.

Thrust bearings just plain wear out, it's the dust more than anything. I just keep spares on hand and change them when needed. Best guide system I ever used was on an Italian saw, the guides were these hardened steel disks that ran in bronze bearings. Worked really well and lasted maybe 5 years under intermittent pro shop use. Side disks never wore out, it was the thrust disk that we had to replace now and then.


bearings

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#20

At 10", you have 20 ~ 30 teeth in the cut.

Keith Newton

All cutting 90º, which is a lot like using your finest TS cabinet blade at full depth for a rip in hard wood. Do I need to spell the difference in power needed for that?

Most saw blades need to take a certain size chip in order for the chip to take the heat of the cut out with it. When the feed rate is too slow due to lack of power, and the chip too small, blades suffer.

I replaced the 5 hp motor that came with my 100 year old Defiance 36" about 10 years ago, after having used it for 20, to a 7.5 hp. I was thrilled at the difference it made. Of course my blade speed is up there around 60 mph. and is referred to as a high speed band-saw.

After making the change, it occurred to me to look up the some other comparable saws. Tannowitz puts a 10 hp on theirs, but they will cut 24" of height, and mine only goes to 16".

Baker is a popular re-saw for industry shops, and 20 hp is the norm on theirs.

If I put the same blade on my saw that you are using on yours, I could probably cut the same speed @ 10" depth as your saw will cut 1.5". The blade will be a lot happier and last longer on my saw.

Im sure that if you search, you can find a chart showing number of teeth in cut / power / kerf width/ band speed / tooth configuration / feed rate / wood density.

I'm kinda like Tim the Tool-guy. I want all the power I need when I want it. Your son doesn't have an old Harley sitting around not being used does he? What about the wife's car?

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#21

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

Jesse Cloud

Interesting thread! I'm not gonna take sides. What interests me is that every time a bandsaw issue comes up, we get completely different and contradictory advice from some really smart people. I think we are all just trying to find a way to make a poorly designed tool do a job. If there was a really good way, we probably wouldn't keep seeing threads like this.

I think the bandsaw is ripe for re-invention. It is tempermental, undependable, hard to tune, lousy on dust control. We spend darn near the cost of the saw itself (for 14 inchers) trying to tune the thing up to a point where it is useful. I have heard that the really expensive big ones do a better job, but I have seen some that really stink.

I hope some clever engineer out there wants to get rich and will spend some time rethinking this dog of a tool.

Thanks Barry, for starting this - I agree, there ought to be a way to make a bandsaw (or something else that can do curves and resaws) that works as dependably as a table saw - for a price we can afford!

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#22

Ceramic Bearings, Barry?

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Evening Barry,

I replaced the upper thrust bearing on my Jet 14 incher several years ago because the original equipment became grooved with use. The bottom bearing was uneffected and remained in place. The top ceramic bearing has yet to groove, and if it does, its a simple matter to rotate it so it presents a flat surface to bear on the blade's back. I am very pleased. The original bearings wore out frequently, and cost a heck of a lot more than the ceramac versions. I believe I bought them from Rockler in a set of two for around $15.00.

George

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#23

"Cool Blocks" are .....

Howard Acheson

.... a patented proprietary guide made with a phenolic resin.

Maybe in the past, ceramic blocks could use "Cool Blocks" name but they certainly couldn't now.

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#24

I Owe an apology to Highland Hardware

Barry Irby

It turns out my son put the bandsaw blades away when they came in and when we decided to put one of the bowl blank blades on the saw, he got "it" off the shelf and handed it to me. I didn't know they had a tag on them and the one he gave me did not. Turns out it was the last locally made blade I had and he did not notice the difference either. This explains why it was a half inch blade. I just went and looked, thanks to somebody mentioning the tag. Yup, I still have both of them on the shelf. So that explains that and I need to withdraw any complaint I might have about the Wood Turner Blade until I actually try them.

No wonder the blade will not cut as tight a circle as a three eighth inch blade, it was actually a half inch blade.

My apologies to Highland Hardware.

I found the Ceramic thrust bearings at Hartville tools. Could not find them at Rockler. I am seriously thinking of changing the bottom guide back to the Cool Blocks with a ceramic thrust bearing. Seems like it would be better for cutting wet wood. No bearings to seize or press crud onto the blade.

Re: Resawing Bandsaw questions again?

#25

Now that you've set the record straight

Bruce, a MN Galoot

let us know how the Woodslicer works in your resaw efforts. Inquiring minds and all that...